Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Called husband an incompetent parent

210 replies

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 13:23

He's stormed out saying he clearly can't do anything right so what's the point trying

Back story, heavily pregnant and feeling every bit of it. Husband went to collect our click and collect order this morning, 3 year old didn't want to go with him, fine. The plan is to go to the beach for a walk for the afternoon so he's getting out then. Spent the morning on the sofa, he was on the floor with Netflix on in the background playing with his toys.

10am Netflix comes up are you still watching, mum guilt kicks in, I say right enough tele let's go do something. Go in the kitchen, get the paints out, cut some potato stamps and we are doing that all fine, not even 5 minutes later he starts complaining he's bored and wants tele back on. I say no we've had 4 hours of tele we're going to do something else, if you don't want to do painting why don't we get something else out and make a few suggestions. He flies off the rails (which in itself is the result of too much screen time!) escalated to the point he scratched my arm and threw a bar stool over which took a chunk out of the wall. I did raise my voice at this and he then threw the paint and made a big mess with it. My husband walked in the door as this was happening and suddenly my son went from angry to hysterically sobbing that mummy made him upset because she shouted (I know I shouldn't of) my husband asked what happened and I explained that we've had hours of tele and he's kicking off because I said no more. He says give them a minute to calm down and go for a shower as I had paint on me.

I come back down from my shower and they are cuddled up on the sofa and he's got tele back on. As I walk in my husband goes right what do you say, toddler says sorry mummy, then my husband says that my son has cleaned up the paint and knows that because he was naughty he doesn't get to go to the beach anymore.

Fucking really? We don't think the logical solution here for a tantrum about screen time was to say because you've behaved in this way, there's no more screen time today and we're all going to go out to the beach. No, we take away the walk, outside in the fresh air, and give him more screen time? I turned the tele off and said you've had enough screens, we're going to the beach. Husband says I'm undermining him, I laugh because it's so ridiculous that this is how he thought he had resolved situation, he says why am I laughing? I say it's incompetent parenting to reward a tantrum about screen time with screen time and take away an outdoor activity as the punishment despite the fact that's a positive thing and is totally unrelated. He kicks off nothing he does is good enough and storms out. Left me with a kicking off child who didn't know what was going on and was just angry all over again about the tele being turned off. Took me an hour to calm him down, another big tantrum in that time and now I'm just exhausted and pissed off.

AIBU? Or is just parenting 101?

OP posts:
CocoLux · 06/11/2022 14:48

I feel quite sorry for your DH here.

LabradorFiasco · 06/11/2022 14:48

@ZeroFuchsGiven 🤣 on re-reading, yes that is my bad. Poor DH has taken quite a battering!

diddl · 06/11/2022 14:47

Had anyone actually been watching the telly?

If not.why was it even on?

Is it just put on in the morning?

Why did turning the telly off mean that he had to paint rather than carry on playing with lego?

Why couldn't he have gone to the shop anyway even though he didn't want to?

Loungingstevens · 06/11/2022 14:47

csnt believe the responses you are getting.
of course, it was a ridiculous response from your partner. You went through all that to turn it off. His response to then cancel the beach shows a lack of judgement.
or more accurately, that you have different ideas about what your child needs (ie fresh air, exercise etc)
of course, a whole morning of tv isn’t ideal. But needs must sometimes!

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:47

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 14:45

Yes, I do think it’s immature to storm off.
Yes, the dc calmed down and cleaned up because he was promised the very thing that had caused his tantrum.
OP’s words were not kind but her dh was a lazy parent at best. And cleaning up a mess is normal for parents.
Your boundaries are pretty low.

Talking of lazy parenting, did you read the bit where the OP said she had Netflix on for 4 hours?

You're absolutely proving the PP right who said some MNetters can't get their heads around the fact a woman can be in the wrong.

AnImaginaryCat · 06/11/2022 14:46

I don't think your husband is an incompetent parent because he didn't alleviate your guilt for allowing four hours of screen time.

You husband deescalated what sounds like an out of hand tantrum. He tidied up and got the child to recognise a wrong and to apologise. How he handled the time after all that is his call. Not like he walked in and plonked the child immediately back in front of Netflix.

If you want to limit it, then it might be easier if you make screen time a separate activity than combine it with an activity such as playing by themselves with toys.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 14:46

5128gap · 06/11/2022 14:44

I agree removing the walk was a bad idea.
But, your child had too much screen time because you'd allowed him four hours of it in the morning. It's a bit hard on the other parent to use up all the easy parenting tricks then expect them to deal with problems without the quick fix you availed yourself of all morning.
Either accept your child will be watching TV more than is ideal while you're tired, or if it's that important, be consistent about when he can and can't watch and agree the rules with your husband in advance.

Excellent points.

If I were H I'd spend the afternoon at the pub.

caggie3 · 06/11/2022 14:46

This thread is hilarious.

Heavily pregnant mum leaving a TV on too long, any other thread you'd be told don't bear yourself up over it, it's hard being heavily pregnant with a preschooler.

Heavily pregnant mum turns off TV and tries to do an activity with her child, any other thread it would be good on you for making the effort especially when you don't feel well.

Mum says no more screen time, child kicks off, dad comes home and calms child down by giving him screen time back, any other thread you'd get complete agreement that it is shoddy parenting and just him taking the easy way out and undermining op.

Mum says she's irritated that an activity that gets her child outside in the fresh air was taken away as a punishment instead of something that was related to the punishment, and arguably worse for the child generally such as screen time when he had already had hours worth. Any other thread you'd get complete agreement that screens shouldn't be a reward and that getting a child outside in the fresh air isn't something that should be taken away as a punishment.

BUT you made the mistake of being a heavily pregnant women posting on AIBU, so you're inevitably going to have an absolute pile on about how awful you are Grin

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 14:45

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:35

He returned from picking up the shopping to find their toddler had flown off the rails, scratched his mum's arm, threw a bar stool over which took a chunk out of the wall and then because his mum was shouting at him, he threw paint everywhere.

He calms the toddler, sends OP for a shower, supervises the tidying up, gets toddler to apologise and then storms out because his wife laughed at him and called him an incompetent parent and he feels he can never do anything right.

But yeah, he was immature to storm off 🙄

Yes, I do think it’s immature to storm off.
Yes, the dc calmed down and cleaned up because he was promised the very thing that had caused his tantrum.
OP’s words were not kind but her dh was a lazy parent at best. And cleaning up a mess is normal for parents.
Your boundaries are pretty low.

5128gap · 06/11/2022 14:44

I agree removing the walk was a bad idea.
But, your child had too much screen time because you'd allowed him four hours of it in the morning. It's a bit hard on the other parent to use up all the easy parenting tricks then expect them to deal with problems without the quick fix you availed yourself of all morning.
Either accept your child will be watching TV more than is ideal while you're tired, or if it's that important, be consistent about when he can and can't watch and agree the rules with your husband in advance.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 06/11/2022 14:43

He done well up until the point you both started arguing again.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 06/11/2022 14:42

I think he done well.

You let the DC watch netflix for the entire morning causing the outburst.

TeaAndStrumpets · 06/11/2022 14:42

Lilgamesh2 · 06/11/2022 14:35

Your DH took the easy way out when he let the kid have the telly on as a way to end the tantrum. It was lazy and short term-ist parenting. He undermined you before you undermined him.

Also can't believe the posters on this thread who think that it's fine for a dad to storm out and not bother parenting the toddler because of an argument with his wife. This isn't the 1950s. Dads don't get to walk away from their parental responsibility if their wife dares to disagree with them.

Absolutely. You need to work as a team. Giving in to a tantrum rewards the wrong behaviour. It's a shame your DH doesn't get this.

CaptainMum · 06/11/2022 14:40

The toddler tidied up and apologised. You should all be heading to the beach. More screen time is a ridiculous consequence to the tantrum.

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:38

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

OK, your parenting is far superior to your husband's.

Forcing your toddler to stop happily playing by himself to go and play with you even though he was bored after 5 minutes, was absolutely top class parenting, as was shouting at him when he was throwing a tantrum.

Better now?

LargeHadronCollidHER · 06/11/2022 14:38

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

I’d not bank on your marriage lasting long if you’re this unwilling to accept you’re wrong here

Glitteratitar · 06/11/2022 14:38

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

Seriously OP. Why are you posting here if you just want everyone to agree with you.

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:35

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 14:26

God, how immature is your dh to storm off.
He is an incompetent parent if that’s how he handles a disagreement.

He returned from picking up the shopping to find their toddler had flown off the rails, scratched his mum's arm, threw a bar stool over which took a chunk out of the wall and then because his mum was shouting at him, he threw paint everywhere.

He calms the toddler, sends OP for a shower, supervises the tidying up, gets toddler to apologise and then storms out because his wife laughed at him and called him an incompetent parent and he feels he can never do anything right.

But yeah, he was immature to storm off 🙄

LondonWolf · 06/11/2022 14:35

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:24

"Trying to force a 3 year old to do an activity they don't want to do? W*ho the fuck wants to go for a walk on the beach in November?"
*
My 3 year old. He woke up this morning and asked if we can wear our puddle suits and go for a walk on the beach today. We got caught in the rain on a dog walk one time and the beach on a miserable day is now his idea of the best day ever.

Why don't you just hide this thread OP? Can't be good for you to have to read all this. I'd be long gone 😁

Lilgamesh2 · 06/11/2022 14:35

Your DH took the easy way out when he let the kid have the telly on as a way to end the tantrum. It was lazy and short term-ist parenting. He undermined you before you undermined him.

Also can't believe the posters on this thread who think that it's fine for a dad to storm out and not bother parenting the toddler because of an argument with his wife. This isn't the 1950s. Dads don't get to walk away from their parental responsibility if their wife dares to disagree with them.

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

OP posts:
Ohhmydays · 06/11/2022 14:33

FlounderingFruitcake · 06/11/2022 13:37

You should have spoken to DH out of earshot of DS to make your really very valid point that there had been a lot of screens already and that the walk in the fresh area was needed.Then you could have gone back in together to say 2 more minutes of his programme and then he does get to go to the beach after all since he said sorry and cleaned up the paint. Even though you were right about the TV you handled it terribly, undermined DH and way overreacted.

I agree with this. I think you both undermined each other, you said no more tv(hence the toddler tantrum) hubby turned it back on undermining you. Hubby did a good job getting toddler to clean up and apologise, rewarded him with tv which you turned off, undermining him. I get being heavily pregnant and exhausted with a toddler though, my belly was like 10times the size it usually is and I struggled to stand let alone do anything else but not a good situation loosing it in front of toddler. I know it’s easier said than done, but try to Just hold it in till toddler sleeping n buy then you’ve had time to chill and calm down to talk about it properly.

Foolsandtheirmoney · 06/11/2022 14:33

maplesaucewithbacon · 06/11/2022 14:17

He's stormed out saying he clearly can't do anything right so what's the point trying

What's the point trying? To get better at being an adult and a parent? Does he flounce out like that at work or in hobby groups with his mates when something is too hard or he's criticised and told to buck up? Nah, I bet not.

This is one of these convenient things, seen more often in men, to abdicate having to learn and to do things (better). Pathetic.

So if your husband laughed at your parenting efforts, mocking you then called you a shit parent you'd what? Apologise and promise to do better next time? It was a shit way to treat him and that's putting it lightly really.

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:31

Crunchingleaf · 06/11/2022 14:25

OP said no more screen time and tantrum took place. OP told husband what happened and he gives child more screen time even though OP had already said no.
The husband undermined OP here.
Too much screen time has a negative effect on a child’s behaviour and mood.

Too much screen time has a negative effect on a child’s behaviour and mood.

Did you read the bit where the kid was happily playing with his toys while the screen was on in the background?

LargeHadronCollidHER · 06/11/2022 14:29

So the OP gets to take the easy way out and stick the kid in front of the TV for hours to save herself some effort, yet when her DH does the same (after getting their child to clean up and apologise) he is undermining her?

How many times have I seen on MN people say it’s not undermining when the OP is a woman and is pushing against a ‘rule’ or ‘punishment’ their DH has put in place that makes her life harder.