Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Called husband an incompetent parent

210 replies

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 13:23

He's stormed out saying he clearly can't do anything right so what's the point trying

Back story, heavily pregnant and feeling every bit of it. Husband went to collect our click and collect order this morning, 3 year old didn't want to go with him, fine. The plan is to go to the beach for a walk for the afternoon so he's getting out then. Spent the morning on the sofa, he was on the floor with Netflix on in the background playing with his toys.

10am Netflix comes up are you still watching, mum guilt kicks in, I say right enough tele let's go do something. Go in the kitchen, get the paints out, cut some potato stamps and we are doing that all fine, not even 5 minutes later he starts complaining he's bored and wants tele back on. I say no we've had 4 hours of tele we're going to do something else, if you don't want to do painting why don't we get something else out and make a few suggestions. He flies off the rails (which in itself is the result of too much screen time!) escalated to the point he scratched my arm and threw a bar stool over which took a chunk out of the wall. I did raise my voice at this and he then threw the paint and made a big mess with it. My husband walked in the door as this was happening and suddenly my son went from angry to hysterically sobbing that mummy made him upset because she shouted (I know I shouldn't of) my husband asked what happened and I explained that we've had hours of tele and he's kicking off because I said no more. He says give them a minute to calm down and go for a shower as I had paint on me.

I come back down from my shower and they are cuddled up on the sofa and he's got tele back on. As I walk in my husband goes right what do you say, toddler says sorry mummy, then my husband says that my son has cleaned up the paint and knows that because he was naughty he doesn't get to go to the beach anymore.

Fucking really? We don't think the logical solution here for a tantrum about screen time was to say because you've behaved in this way, there's no more screen time today and we're all going to go out to the beach. No, we take away the walk, outside in the fresh air, and give him more screen time? I turned the tele off and said you've had enough screens, we're going to the beach. Husband says I'm undermining him, I laugh because it's so ridiculous that this is how he thought he had resolved situation, he says why am I laughing? I say it's incompetent parenting to reward a tantrum about screen time with screen time and take away an outdoor activity as the punishment despite the fact that's a positive thing and is totally unrelated. He kicks off nothing he does is good enough and storms out. Left me with a kicking off child who didn't know what was going on and was just angry all over again about the tele being turned off. Took me an hour to calm him down, another big tantrum in that time and now I'm just exhausted and pissed off.

AIBU? Or is just parenting 101?

OP posts:
Conkersareback · 06/11/2022 16:05

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 15:53

OP I am totally with you. Only on mumsnet must you pander to every whim and tantrum of your child’s In case they’re traumatised later in life 🙄

your husband rewarded bad behaviour because it made his life easier, end off. Easy to get a kid to say sorry once they’re happy and getting what they want. YANBU.

Yeah what he should've done was tell op to sort it out, not told her to go for a shower, that would've been the much easier option.

WeeblesWibbleWobble · 06/11/2022 15:57

In the nicest possible way.
Sometimes you have to pick your battles. Especially when you have a baby and a threenager.

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 15:53

OP I am totally with you. Only on mumsnet must you pander to every whim and tantrum of your child’s In case they’re traumatised later in life 🙄

your husband rewarded bad behaviour because it made his life easier, end off. Easy to get a kid to say sorry once they’re happy and getting what they want. YANBU.

LizzieSiddal · 06/11/2022 15:53

I think the fact he’s 3 and had such a violent tantrum means there’s possibly more going on here

Absolute rubbish!

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 15:50

He is three. He didn't hurt you on purpose. Tantrums happen when toddler have feelings they don't understand and can't control or communicate about. They are involuntary and are not manipulative. And cuddles from parents are not a reward and should not be withheld as a punishment, ever.

In this case, the DH was absolutely right to restore calm and reassure the child that everything was still OK, whilst making him help clear up and prepare an apology. And then OP came in and kicked everything off again. For nothing. It was done and resolved. It must have been upsetting for the little lad.

I completely agree.

TruestRepairman · 06/11/2022 15:48

He hurts me and trashes the kitchen and gets his way and a cuddle with daddy and learns exactly what to do next time I turn the tele off

He is three. He didn't hurt you on purpose. Tantrums happen when toddler have feelings they don't understand and can't control or communicate about. They are involuntary and are not manipulative. And cuddles from parents are not a reward and should not be withheld as a punishment, ever.

In this case, the DH was absolutely right to restore calm and reassure the child that everything was still OK, whilst making him help clear up and prepare an apology. And then OP came in and kicked everything off again. For nothing. It was done and resolved. It must have been upsetting for the little lad.

I don't wish to add to any pile-on, and I think it's really sweet that your little boy woke up and remembered a lovely day in the rain and wanted to recreate it. That is so cute.

Holding onto resentments and thinking along the lines of "Why should he get that? He was bad and will learn to be bad to get what he wants!" is misguided and not helpful.

I don't think having the TV on in the background whilst playing is bad. I definitely used Cbeebies for this when my kids were little. It's definitely not as if he was glued to an iPad for four hours.

Conkersareback · 06/11/2022 15:35

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:24

"Trying to force a 3 year old to do an activity they don't want to do? W*ho the fuck wants to go for a walk on the beach in November?"
*
My 3 year old. He woke up this morning and asked if we can wear our puddle suits and go for a walk on the beach today. We got caught in the rain on a dog walk one time and the beach on a miserable day is now his idea of the best day ever.

he says why am I laughing? I say it's incompetent parenting to reward a tantrum about screen time with screen time and take away an outdoor activity as the punishment

But it is a punishment, it's the thing your DS most wanted!

YABVU

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 15:32

BellePeppa · 06/11/2022 14:52

Yup.🙃

Agreeing with someone who's being a twat, doesn't make you less of a twat you know 🙄

No499 · 06/11/2022 15:31

I'm sorry, I think you massively overreacted and owe your DH an apology.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 06/11/2022 15:29

I think the fact he’s 3 and had such a violent tantrum means there’s possibly more going on here

Why does it have to be something more going on? Do you even have kids? 3 year olds can be total arseholes it doesnt mean 'there is more going on' Hes just a 3 year old who was taken away from something he was enjoying, playing with his toys!

Sundaya · 06/11/2022 15:28

YANBU. Your husband did the opposite of what was appropriate.

girlmom21 · 06/11/2022 15:24

caggie3 · 06/11/2022 14:49

"Talking of lazy parenting, did you read the bit where the OP said she had Netflix on for 4 hours?"

Have you ever been 36 weeks pregnant with a toddler?! The rules don't apply - it's survival Grin

It's the same as not being pregnant with a toddler, apart from everything happens a bit slower.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 06/11/2022 15:23

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:35

He returned from picking up the shopping to find their toddler had flown off the rails, scratched his mum's arm, threw a bar stool over which took a chunk out of the wall and then because his mum was shouting at him, he threw paint everywhere.

He calms the toddler, sends OP for a shower, supervises the tidying up, gets toddler to apologise and then storms out because his wife laughed at him and called him an incompetent parent and he feels he can never do anything right.

But yeah, he was immature to storm off 🙄

I actually feel kind of sorry for him. He came back home from a short trip to the shops (assuming as he was just picking up a click and collect) to find the calm home environment has turned into a complete cluster fuck and he's the incompetent one.

I dread to imagine what I'd say if someone had the nerve to pass their ineptitude off as mine.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 06/11/2022 15:15

LabradorFiasco · 06/11/2022 14:14

In my opinion you both did good and bad things.

Your bad: 4 hours of TV; having an argument in front of DS; undermining DH.
Your good: stopping the TV and trying to do constructive activities; having a good idea about how to handle the situation (ie no more TV, going to beach).
His bad: taking 4 hours to get the shopping; using more screen time as a resolution to a tantrum about screen time.
His good: prioritising you getting a shower/out of the stressful situation; clearing up with DS; getting DS to apologise.

Next time, as PP said, you just need to have a discussion outside of DS’ earshot to decide exactly what you will do. In this case, it should have been before the shower.

Basically you did all the right things but in a disjointed way. I can understand why DH feels hurt. I can also understand why you are knackered and at the end of your tether.

I don't think he took 4 hours to do the shopping.

Justtobeclear · 06/11/2022 15:04

I think the fact he’s 3 and had such a violent tantrum means there’s possibly more going on here. I don’t think in this situation your DH is incompetent or lazy - he did what was required to calm him. I understand why he removed the walk if it was something your son had asked for and wanted to do. in your situation I would’ve said something along the lines of “I agree dh, where shall we go instead?” then agree somewhere you/dh enjoy. Show him that he loses the privilege of choice. Putting the tv back on and having a cuddle is moving on from the situation and continuing the day - appropriate for his age as continuing to “punish” him will prolong the stress for everyone.

Confusion101 · 06/11/2022 15:01

Wonder*

Confusion101 · 06/11/2022 15:01

Once again I was why a poster posted in AIBU when they point blank refuse to be told they are being unreasonable!

Can you not appreciate that you got some peace and quiet in the shower and came back down to a calm toddler, a cleaned kitchen and an apology? That is good going!

Yes, in hindsight, perhaps DH could've acted differently (I wouldn't necessarily use the word "better") but that could've been a discussion instead of you being a bitch to him. If I acted like that to my DP he would react the same way and probably not help again in that situation! You said DS was really looking forward to the beach so removing that was a punishment!

itsjustnotok · 06/11/2022 14:58

Tbh OP it sounds like it’s your way or the high way. Yep being pregnant is exhausting. So you decided that DS could watch TV to enable yourself a break. The you decided that despite the fact you will be going to the beach, TV time is over. Yes your toddler had a moment but your DP cleaned up and expected an apology. Does DS like the beach? If so then that is still a consequence, the issue is it’s not your consequence. Your DP calmed down the situation, i personally think you need to take a step back. Your DP is allowed to determine a consequence, maybe next time talk to him about expectations so that you’re on the same page. It doesn’t sound like he intended to piss you off but you’re taking it personally and then insulted him because you didn’t like the way he dealt with it because it wasn’t what you would do.

Christmaslover2022 · 06/11/2022 14:56

Child probably shouldn't be watching that much tv in one go and if I were you, I'd start by teaching the child how to play so you don't rely on screen time.
Also I do think you should have discussed this and child shouldn't have ended up watching TV again but your husband thought he was doing the right thing. He's probably thinking well its alright for you to use the TV so you can sit on the sofa so why can't he do that? Children NEED to play in and outside so I'd still get out and maybe discuss the reasons why.

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 14:55

YABU

He’s a toddler, you’re acting like he’s a grown adult.

Your DH was almost spot on - he let you remove yourself from the situation, explained to toddler that his behaviour was unacceptable, made him clean up and apologise and showed him that because he has behaved appropriately that he now gets to watch some TV - it’s better to rule with a carrot, than a stick.

What I agree with you on is that he shouldn’t have been stopped from going to the beach - that punishment doesn’t fit with the crime and was way too far in the future.

But ultimately you are at fault here - you allowed 4 hours of TV in the first place, then got annoyed because DH allowed some and then you caused an argument with your DH in front of DS.

I would apologise to DH and explain how you think stoping him from going to the beach was the wrong thing to do but you appreciate what he did do and in hindsight you can see he handled it better than you did.

I think DS probably needs to get out of the house so I would say to DS because you’ve behaved so well for the rest of the day that we can still go to the beach.

Conkersareback · 06/11/2022 14:53

But how did the tele billing on in the background equate to too much tele time?

Why not just turn it off and let DS carry on playing?

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 06/11/2022 14:53

You let him watch TV for four hours, shouted at him, and wound him up so much he threw things.

Your husband calmed him down, got it all cleaned up, and got him to apologise.

And you think HE'S the incompetent parent?

BellePeppa · 06/11/2022 14:52

arethereanyleftatall · 06/11/2022 13:43

Could 'have'. Please, please, please 🙏🏿

Yup.🙃

caggie3 · 06/11/2022 14:49

"Talking of lazy parenting, did you read the bit where the OP said she had Netflix on for 4 hours?"

Have you ever been 36 weeks pregnant with a toddler?! The rules don't apply - it's survival Grin

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 14:49

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

Sounds like you value control over harmony. Good luck with that.