Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Called husband an incompetent parent

210 replies

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 13:23

He's stormed out saying he clearly can't do anything right so what's the point trying

Back story, heavily pregnant and feeling every bit of it. Husband went to collect our click and collect order this morning, 3 year old didn't want to go with him, fine. The plan is to go to the beach for a walk for the afternoon so he's getting out then. Spent the morning on the sofa, he was on the floor with Netflix on in the background playing with his toys.

10am Netflix comes up are you still watching, mum guilt kicks in, I say right enough tele let's go do something. Go in the kitchen, get the paints out, cut some potato stamps and we are doing that all fine, not even 5 minutes later he starts complaining he's bored and wants tele back on. I say no we've had 4 hours of tele we're going to do something else, if you don't want to do painting why don't we get something else out and make a few suggestions. He flies off the rails (which in itself is the result of too much screen time!) escalated to the point he scratched my arm and threw a bar stool over which took a chunk out of the wall. I did raise my voice at this and he then threw the paint and made a big mess with it. My husband walked in the door as this was happening and suddenly my son went from angry to hysterically sobbing that mummy made him upset because she shouted (I know I shouldn't of) my husband asked what happened and I explained that we've had hours of tele and he's kicking off because I said no more. He says give them a minute to calm down and go for a shower as I had paint on me.

I come back down from my shower and they are cuddled up on the sofa and he's got tele back on. As I walk in my husband goes right what do you say, toddler says sorry mummy, then my husband says that my son has cleaned up the paint and knows that because he was naughty he doesn't get to go to the beach anymore.

Fucking really? We don't think the logical solution here for a tantrum about screen time was to say because you've behaved in this way, there's no more screen time today and we're all going to go out to the beach. No, we take away the walk, outside in the fresh air, and give him more screen time? I turned the tele off and said you've had enough screens, we're going to the beach. Husband says I'm undermining him, I laugh because it's so ridiculous that this is how he thought he had resolved situation, he says why am I laughing? I say it's incompetent parenting to reward a tantrum about screen time with screen time and take away an outdoor activity as the punishment despite the fact that's a positive thing and is totally unrelated. He kicks off nothing he does is good enough and storms out. Left me with a kicking off child who didn't know what was going on and was just angry all over again about the tele being turned off. Took me an hour to calm him down, another big tantrum in that time and now I'm just exhausted and pissed off.

AIBU? Or is just parenting 101?

OP posts:
Discovereads · 06/11/2022 22:02

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 21:58

Yes. 36 weeks pregnant!
cut her some slack.

I’ve been 36 weeks pregnant, four times. Being pregnant isn’t an excuse to lose your shit like OP did. Especially not after a restful & peaceful morning of 4 hours dozing on the sofa while watching TV while the one and only DC you already have is quietly & nice.y playing with their toys on the floor. Pregnancy is not some sort of golden ticket that excuses everything and anything.

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 21:58

BagOfBollocks · 06/11/2022 14:47

Talking of lazy parenting, did you read the bit where the OP said she had Netflix on for 4 hours?

You're absolutely proving the PP right who said some MNetters can't get their heads around the fact a woman can be in the wrong.

Yes. 36 weeks pregnant!
cut her some slack.

PinkSyCo · 06/11/2022 21:57

I think you are making life easier unnecessarily hard on yourself and your husband and need to chill out. Once baby number 2 comes along you will probably be begging your DS to just sit and watch some tv when he’s mithering you to do arts and crafts.

bumblenbean · 06/11/2022 19:38

I understand your point about him undermining the no tv message and removing the more ‘wholesome’ outdoor activity. But I think the way you reacted and spoke to him was out of order- you actually laughed at him and called him incompetent, and in front of your DS. You were undermining him too!

if you look at it rationally, he came back and immediately de-escalated the situation, sent you off to shower / calm down and recognised your DS needed to apologise and tidy up. Even if putting the tv back on was the wrong message for DS, you mocked and belittled him instead of discussing it with him later and maybe agreeing how to deal with those kind of situations in future. I would’ve been really pissed off with you too. Being called incompetent is really quite a nasty thing to say to your spouse.

3 year olds can be arseholes and I get you’re hormonal but being pregnant doesn’t give you licence to talk to your DH like shit.

Onlyforcake · 06/11/2022 18:29

Incompetent communication between the two of you perhaps.

Justtobeclear · 06/11/2022 18:28

ZeroFuchsGiven · 06/11/2022 15:29

I think the fact he’s 3 and had such a violent tantrum means there’s possibly more going on here

Why does it have to be something more going on? Do you even have kids? 3 year olds can be total arseholes it doesnt mean 'there is more going on' Hes just a 3 year old who was taken away from something he was enjoying, playing with his toys!

Yes I do 3 in fact! I didn’t say there was I said there is possibly. As in a child that is about to have a sibling and his whole routine changing. A mum who is really stressed and he is picking up on it. Those kind of things that can cause a child to act out of character. I haven’t ever experienced a tantrum like the one described - it seems like a highly charged situation from all sides that no one has come out of well.

BogRollBOGOF · 06/11/2022 18:11

While it's poor form and lazy to reinstate the trigger of the tantrum and cancel the walk that the toddler needed, calling him an incompetant parent is too far. The immediate consequence of helping clear up was sensible.

I've done a difficult, heavy pregnancy with a toddler over a long winter. It was bloody hard and so difficult to safely get a toddler out of the house and do anything with him when I couldn't even bend down to him or use a buggy. Don't sweat the small stuff. Excess TV time saved the sanity of both of us. By the time I'd recovered from a crap birth and felt human again it was summer and we managed the TV time back to sensible levels. Getting out when you can is important though and it's important to burn off that physical energy.

caggie3 · 06/11/2022 18:06

Whilst it's not ideal to raise your voice at your kids, I think the majority of parents have gotten to the point of it happening at least once and I think calling it traumatising for the child is a bit OTT!

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 18:01

The suggestion that a three-year-old is cynical, sly and manipulative is really quite disturbing; I've been thinking about it a lot today. It's a really hostile thought for a mother to have.

As to: "the obvious thing to do would of been after sending her for a shower, knowing that the tantrum was about screen time, would of been to explain that because of his behaviour he would not only not have screen time now but he would also not be having any for the remainder of the day but that he could still go to the beach if he apologised and or tidied up"

We are talking about a toddler here, not a teenager. And a toddler who has just been shocked and traumatized by his mother shouting at him. The father was right to soothe him and say he was sorry to mummy; meeting that with another rant about screen time and insults is just nuts.

pumpkinelvis · 06/11/2022 17:49

I agree with you op. Not Going outside for fresh air and exercise shouldn't be a punishment. Most little kids need to get out. Sounds like your dh couldn't be arsed to go out.

I do think he did well to calm dc down though and I do think you were wrong to call him what you did. He should have communicated with you about the consequences he wanted to impose.

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 17:47

Yep, basically this 👆🏻

SchoolQuestionnaire · 06/11/2022 17:44

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

mine would do anything to get what he wanted.

I can see this from your perspective but this is batshit. He’s 3. Do you seriously think he has this level of self awareness? It’s far more likely that he was overtired and enjoying a quiet morning in front of the tv. Yes it’s not ideal, but it isn’t going to hurt him as a one off.

His dad came in and didn’t berate you for causing the situation. He took over to let you get cleaned up, spoke to him and managed to calm him, then got him to tidy up and apologise to you for his behaviour. That’s a great outcome in my book and I can assure you that the 3 year old had no more motive for doing this than daddy had asked him to. He isn’t some naughty genius manipulating things to get what he wants, he’s only three. You may be having a new baby but don’t forget that this one is still little and learning too.

caggie3 · 06/11/2022 17:43

"So what are you suggesting OP should have done instead then?"

To me, if I was the husband here the obvious thing to do would of been after sending her for a shower, knowing that the tantrum was about screen time, would of been to explain that because of his behaviour he would not only not have screen time now but he would also not be having any for the remainder of the day but that he could still go to the beach if he apologised and or tidied up. The husband wasn't that far wrong, he just got the punishments completely the wrong way round which in the process did undermine OP who had said firmly no more screens and did reward the negative behaviour.

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 17:29

OP I am totally with you. Only on mumsnet must you pander to every whim and tantrum of your child’s In case they’re traumatised later in life

So what are you suggesting OP should have done instead then?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 16:30

Imagine the comments if the genders were reversed?

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 16:30

tickticksnooze · 06/11/2022 13:54

I also cannot help but notice that those posters so quick to get the boot in with the op for losing her temper apparently have no words of criticism for the husband losing his temper and storming out the house.

The OP came down to find the mess cleaned up, the child calmed down and having helped clean, and an apology. She then lost her shit, laughed at her husband and tore into him. Called him incompetent.

Husband then lost his temper and left the house rather than argue in front of the DC.

Who had provocation in this situation? Who handled things better? The husband.

LargeHadronCollidHER · 06/11/2022 16:29

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 16:08

Oh I forgot, nobody’s ever allowed to be at the end of their wick and lose their temper.
get a grip.

Except the OPs DH though

As you’ve slated him for being at the end of his wick

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 16:23

I think you were being very unreasonable OP.

The four hours of TV something you wanted while you lay on the sofa and your DC played alone with his toys. But then you lied to your DH and made it sound like the the TV was your DC demanding to watch a show he wanted.

You clearly were incompetent at handling the painting situation, did your DC even want to do the activity? Do you even ask your DC what they’d like to do?

Your DH has a more effective parenting style as he got an enraged child to clean up the mess he made, apologise to you and he’s comforting him when you come down.

You were out of order to turn off the TV and have a go at your DH and call him incompetent. You completely undermined him and mocked him in front of the DC. And your fabrication that the TV in the morning was for your DC and not because you were knackered and couldnt get off the sofa, was purely to give the illusion you are the better parent, when imho you’re not.

The TV was on for 4 hrs because that what you wanted, not what your DC wanted as they played with toys by themselves the entire time. At least your DH seems to listen to your DC and actually care about what the DC wants and needs are.

Topseyt123 · 06/11/2022 16:18

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 14:34

So many comments about getting toddler to apologise and clean up and how good that is, maybe we have very different children but mine would do anything to get what he wanted. Of course he said sorry and wiped up the paint, he wanted TV and was told if he did that then he could have the TV back on but that he wasn't allowed to go to the beach. You can end most tantrums almost instantly if you give them what them want, but sometimes, especially after violence that is not an option because it justifies their behaviour and shows them that it works. That's what I mean by parenting 101. It's just stupidity to me to call that a resolution.

I'd call it a resolution. You got to go for a shower in peace, you came down to a clean floor, paint wiped up and a relatively quiet toddler who apologised to you.

Your DH had been to collect the shopping and came in to find you distressed (understandably) because of your tantrumming child. He took over so that you could go and de-stress.

I personally don't see what was wrong with what he did. He just approached it differently to you. That doesn't make your approach right and his wrong.

You WERE wrong and totally unjustified though to call him incompetent. Remember that because of the situation he walked in on he could easily have turned that one around onto you. You wouldn't have liked that, I am sure and luckily he didn't do it.

I think you need to back down now, and apologise to DH.

Neither of you is incompetent. Toddlers are little gits. Why didn't you just accept the apology, give notice that the telly would be going off again soon, have a breather and a peaceful cup of tea or coffee and then go for a walk. Perhaps even all going. Personally, I wouldn't have cancelled the beach walk because I would have wanted to go myself, and I refuse to punish myself.

Your pregnancy hormones may be meaning that you have made far more of this than you needed to.

melj1213 · 06/11/2022 16:17

YABU - the incompetent parent is not the one who walked into chaos due to the other parents decision of forced fun and no TV, calmed the child down, tided up the paint and mess, gave a punishment and then decided to put on a bit of TV to keep things relaxed and settled until the other parent came and kicked things off again.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 16:15

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 15:50

He is three. He didn't hurt you on purpose. Tantrums happen when toddler have feelings they don't understand and can't control or communicate about. They are involuntary and are not manipulative. And cuddles from parents are not a reward and should not be withheld as a punishment, ever.

In this case, the DH was absolutely right to restore calm and reassure the child that everything was still OK, whilst making him help clear up and prepare an apology. And then OP came in and kicked everything off again. For nothing. It was done and resolved. It must have been upsetting for the little lad.

I completely agree.

Absolutely this. Twice the OP took a peaceful situation and created strife. Why? Because it was her way or the highway.

Arguing like that with the toddler in the room is terrible, as well.

Rosebel · 06/11/2022 16:11

happysundayiguess · 06/11/2022 13:46

Thank you this is where I'm questioning my sanity on this thread. So often on mumsnet you read that the punishment needs to be related to the situation so taking away a walk outdoors instead of screen time

I'm getting berated for leaving the tele on for four hours and in the same breath berated for turning the tv off and trying to do some painting with him!

Arghhhh!

But he didn't want to do painting. From the sound of it he wasn't just watching TV, he was playing as well.
Why you would even attempt to force a 3 year old to do something they don't want to do is beyond me. Why does he have to do something else when he was playing happily?
You were unreasonable to try and force fun on your child, you were incredibly unreasonable to call your husband incompetent after he got your toddler to clean up and apologise.
Sounds like it's all about what you want to do. Go for a walk somewhere else so he's still going out.
Surely your DS has learned if he behaves this way again he'll have to clean up and apologise. That's not a bad thing.

girlmom21 · 06/11/2022 16:10

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 16:08

Oh I forgot, nobody’s ever allowed to be at the end of their wick and lose their temper.
get a grip.

Why would she be at the end of her wick when DS has been good all day until she decided on forced fun?

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 16:08

Oh I forgot, nobody’s ever allowed to be at the end of their wick and lose their temper.
get a grip.

girlmom21 · 06/11/2022 16:07

Peashoots · 06/11/2022 15:53

OP I am totally with you. Only on mumsnet must you pander to every whim and tantrum of your child’s In case they’re traumatised later in life 🙄

your husband rewarded bad behaviour because it made his life easier, end off. Easy to get a kid to say sorry once they’re happy and getting what they want. YANBU.

Her husband walked in to her shouting at a 3 year old and sent her for a shower for space and to calm down.

I bet OP didn't apologise for the shouting...