Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a SAHP why?

162 replies

cattyfranny · 06/11/2022 13:22

Currently I am a SAHM, I am studying at Uni and I volunteer but I don’t have a paid job (I have a 2 yr old home and 7 yr old at school)

When I meet new people they assume that I have been “forced” into this position either because childcare costs are too high or crazily that my DH asked me to stay home! They seem to think it’s unthinkable to choose to be a SAHM 🤷‍♀️

If you are at home with your children, did you willingly choose to do it? Would you prefer to be at work? Why are you a SAHP?

OP posts:
HeraldicBlazoning · 06/11/2022 16:36

Exactly, @SleepingStandingUp . All the faux concern stuff about "leaving yourself vulnerable" or the passive aggressive "I would be SO bored" stuff is just so tiring.

Some people just can't cope with other families making different choices. I could not give two hoots if you return to your high-powered city job at 14 days post partum and work full time. So full time workers, or part time workers, or whatever, should not give two hoots about choices people make to stay at home.

But lots of people think it's entirely acceptable to say that their brain would rot if they didn't go out to work each day, or that women who aren't working are leeches.

TTCBBY3 · 06/11/2022 16:33

SAHM to two toddler DC by choice. Currently ttc DC3 so intend to stay at home a while longer yet. My husband very much supported my decision not to return to work after having DC1 because I hated my job and couldn't stomach the thought of going back. We are very fortunate that DH has a very highly paid job, and I have an "income" through houses that we jointly own and rent out. So I don't feel I am living off DH (not that I'd mind if I was - it's our money at the end of the day). DC both go to nursery 2 days per week which gives me time to myself, I think I'd feel very differently if we had money troubles and I was alone at home with 2 toddlers 5 days a week. I feel incredibly fortunate that I have the best of both worlds, and so do the children. I wouldn't change it for the world! (Neither would my husband, he regularly says he could never do what I do)

SleepingStandingUp · 06/11/2022 16:28

musicviking1 · 06/11/2022 16:25

You sound very bitter

she sounds like she's been on a lot of threads on mn about how awful SAHPs are

Itisbetter · 06/11/2022 16:28

I chose it because it was where I was needed and where I could do the most good.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/11/2022 16:27

I assumed I'd go back to work after mat leave, but ds was born very poorly, was still really poorly at the point of making a decision, actually got poorlier once I decided to leave, and needed a lot of support and medical appts etc. I couldn't have managed to hold down a job.

At the point I could have looked at a term time job (I'd have struggled to get him into childcare with his needs) i got pregnant with twins.
Had them, covid hit.
They're now nearly 3, i left my job 7.5 years ago, and I'll look at a part time job once they're full time.

Controversially, DH only earns a basic wage so we rely on benefit top ups.

I have volunteered for nearly 15 years and have managed to maintain that, and have taken on more responsibility, i also have just started volunteering with my sons hobby, and I'm studying with the OU. DS still has several hospital appts a year, i'm his 121 on school trips and occasionally have to go in and check stuff

musicviking1 · 06/11/2022 16:25

HeraldicBlazoning · 06/11/2022 16:14

Because i want to be a brain-dead, unemployed layabout leeching off my husband, obvs. 😁

You sound very bitter

musicviking1 · 06/11/2022 16:24

Chose it, I had two children very close in age so childcare would have been very expensive and I thought what's the point, I might as well stay home since we can afford it.

spaceshiptrain · 06/11/2022 16:18

HeraldicBlazoning · 06/11/2022 16:14

Because i want to be a brain-dead, unemployed layabout leeching off my husband, obvs. 😁

This is the most baffling thing to me. Being at home with an internet connection and books surely provides far more ample opportunity for learning than what is oftentimes a function-performing role that takes up 8 hours of your day. Every single woman so critical of not working surely is not in a role which stimulates her mind and provides varied things to do each day?

I can learn about absolutely anything without anyone asking me to file a report or clean a floor any time I want, how could I possibly be brain dead?

Beautiful3 · 06/11/2022 16:14

Mine happened because I don't get any support from family. Wrap around care and holiday clubs are too expensive for me. I am enjoying it though.

HeraldicBlazoning · 06/11/2022 16:14

Because i want to be a brain-dead, unemployed layabout leeching off my husband, obvs. 😁

Luredbyapomegranate · 06/11/2022 16:11

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 15:36

I think it’s very selfish to choose to be a SAHP simply because you don’t want to work, if your DP is having to work FT.

Most people don’t choose to be a SAHP just because they don’t want to work though l, so I can see why your friends would be shocked that someone would be ok with staying at home not working all day for years, when your DP was out grafting hard.
If this was the case the best solution would be to both work PT.

@CarefreeMe

well the OP is looking after a 2 year old, and if she wasn’t doing that, she’d be paying someone else to.

Both parents working PT is a great idea, but in practice it’s hard to have a good career PT, so it’s often not practical

SpudleyLass · 06/11/2022 16:10

For now, I'm a SAHP. My 4 year old has ASD and a chromsomal abnormality which means its very unfeasible for both of us to be working.

She is on a reduced timetable so is home by midday.

I've only recently emerged from a depressive episode which has lasted months so I'm not looking for a job right now but we are looking to move in January and I've floated the idea that we swap roles and he stays home with her so I can return to work instead.

All being well, by next September, we can both comfortably work full time, but we shall see.

It has definitely had an impact on my mental health, but I can't say I've regretted staying at home with her.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 06/11/2022 15:58

If this was the case the best solution would be to both work PT.

Not always that simple though. The company that dh works for won't allow reduced hours. They are brilliant in many ways, he's had 4 pay raises at least since March 2020, cost of living bonuses and he's got an excellent benefits package plus he likes his job so that's just not an option for us.

randomsabreuse · 06/11/2022 15:55

Indirect financial (wouldn't gain enough to justify time taken) plus conflict with DH's job and lack of wrap around childcare.

I'm going back to work next month and really looking forward to it.

Lavendersummer · 06/11/2022 15:54

18 year in here. DH had a very demanding job with lots of exams. No family support nearby. His career was a much higher earning than mine.
We looked into me going back after DS two was born - I was on a career break but with travel and childcare costs I would have made a such a small amount it was easier to do babysitting to earn some extra money.
Then we moved abroad as he got a job with a different company. His office was in the english language. I didn’t speak a word of the local language when I arrived. In this country primary school age kids came home at lunch times and 2/3 times week after lunch - no afternoon school.
DH started to do more exams and now much more travelling for work.
And it works for us. I deal with 99% of the kids and home/domestic/school stuff.
He works really hard, can fully concentrate on it and appreciates what work that I do.

Whoopsies · 06/11/2022 15:54

I loved being a sahm. I literally loved every minute of being with my kids when they were that little. I think I'll always look back at those years and think they were some of the best of my life. I've just returned to work as my youngest got his 30hours and a job I love was offered to me. I'm so grateful we could easily afford for me to be at home for that time though.

LittleBeluga · 06/11/2022 15:52

Dacadactyl · 06/11/2022 15:43

Not a SAHM anymore, but i was for the best part of 10 years. I did it because i wouldnt have trusted anyone else to look after my kids (with the possible exception of my mum, but she was too far away and wouldnt have done it anyway)

Also this

LittleBeluga · 06/11/2022 15:51

I've always wanted to be a SAHM. My mum stayed at home, and my early memories with her are irreplaceable. I wanted to give my own children that special time too. When I left my job, everyone was so quick to tell me how foolish I was being and how much I'd hate being at home, how much harder it is etc. But three years in, I can safely say it was the best decision I've ever made. My toddlers are bloody hard work! But I feel nowhere near as worn down and exhausted as I did when I worked, and I didn't even have a demanding job or work long hours. We don't want to have any more children, but I will feel absolutely bereft when they start school and I have to look for employment again.

123sunshine · 06/11/2022 15:50

I chose to be a stay at home mum for the first 7 years, my husband perused his career whilst I gave mine up. I didn’t have children to put them in full time childcare. However my marriage broke down and I began working part time and had to claim tax credits. It was a long hard slog to rebuild my career and upskill, 10 years later I’m doing well and running a successful business. But it was tough for a while having given up my career, whilst my ex husband thrived. If I had my time again, I wouldn’t have given it all up, it leaves woman very vulnerable.

spaceshiptrain · 06/11/2022 15:50

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 15:36

I think it’s very selfish to choose to be a SAHP simply because you don’t want to work, if your DP is having to work FT.

Most people don’t choose to be a SAHP just because they don’t want to work though l, so I can see why your friends would be shocked that someone would be ok with staying at home not working all day for years, when your DP was out grafting hard.
If this was the case the best solution would be to both work PT.

That's interesting, because most of the time the narrative I've seen on here is that it's cruel to ask a woman to give up her career and it's the man who's benefitting from integral respect from the children because children only respect people with capitalist economic value and cannot possibly respect their primary carer.

Your view is far more coherent, but you must realise that this is a situation which would be decided between the two people involved? You can't just choose not to work while your partner works because the working partner would not just say 'okay' and go off to work like a slave as there's no reason why they would have to.

I don't enjoy employment personally but do like earning money and enjoy what I do as it's creative and buildings towards things, but I have literally zero financial responsibility because my husband sees it as his job and likes it that way.

Like I said in my PP, this is a set up that's been done throughout the modern western civilisation and one that is coming back into popularity, and I think it's because it works excellently for all involved.

You might call it regressive, and one can't deny that it is because it harks back to a different time, but at the same time I don't want to progress towards a situation where we both have to work full-time and feel stress and have less time with our child.

Because I'm at home doing everything I am able to provide nutritious cooked meals with a very low food budget, time to shop around, cook from scratch, and give my husband and child a home where they can flourish, as well as myself, and without juggling many things at once in which one thing inevitably gets neglected because of that.

supadupapupascupa · 06/11/2022 15:46

I chose it, I couldn't wait to stay home with the kids. I work part time now but I don't have to. I'm fully qualified in my profession so I always have a B plan to go back to my career. It makes life so much easier to have one of us available at all times.

As it happens had I not chosen it I would have been forced to for over a year due to SEN and no suitable school place anyway.

Dacadactyl · 06/11/2022 15:43

Not a SAHM anymore, but i was for the best part of 10 years. I did it because i wouldnt have trusted anyone else to look after my kids (with the possible exception of my mum, but she was too far away and wouldnt have done it anyway)

Meklk · 06/11/2022 15:43

And it's definitely cheaper. We used to order lots of take aways, simply didn't have a power to cook after 12hrs shifts cleaning rooms.
Now I'm planning every single meal. Looking for sales, offers, etc. Able to go to bakery when they reducing their stuff, yellow stickers, etc.

EssexCat · 06/11/2022 15:43

And surely the danger with both working part time is that BOTH careers and long term prospects are negatively impacted.

EssexCat · 06/11/2022 15:42

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 15:36

I think it’s very selfish to choose to be a SAHP simply because you don’t want to work, if your DP is having to work FT.

Most people don’t choose to be a SAHP just because they don’t want to work though l, so I can see why your friends would be shocked that someone would be ok with staying at home not working all day for years, when your DP was out grafting hard.
If this was the case the best solution would be to both work PT.

I did exactly this when mine were small. My husband bloody loved his job at that point and was more than happy with the situation.

Not selfish in any way. He didn’t have to make any career sacrifices and could work as many hours as he needed (wanted) to without having to worry about the children.

Im back at work now and I know practicality wise he’d prefer I wasn’t! Although as he’s a decent chap and we discuss our decisions he’s happy because I’m happy.