Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a SAHP why?

162 replies

cattyfranny · 06/11/2022 13:22

Currently I am a SAHM, I am studying at Uni and I volunteer but I don’t have a paid job (I have a 2 yr old home and 7 yr old at school)

When I meet new people they assume that I have been “forced” into this position either because childcare costs are too high or crazily that my DH asked me to stay home! They seem to think it’s unthinkable to choose to be a SAHM 🤷‍♀️

If you are at home with your children, did you willingly choose to do it? Would you prefer to be at work? Why are you a SAHP?

OP posts:
ShallowHalWantsAGal · 06/11/2022 18:11

FortSalem86 · 06/11/2022 18:05

I can't find the post now but , other than having breaststroke, why are you and not your DH considered the best person to look after your children? Why not dad?

I don't know which post you mean, but for us it makes sense for me to be at home. We met young and had to travel about for dh's work. I had to take whatever I could get in terms of work when we moved. That, plus dh just generally being more blessed in the brains department than I am, meant that his earning potential is a lot higher than mine. Working full time as I have been, my salary was about a third of his. That's part of the reason I get to be at home and retrain - so I can contribute more in the long term. But in the short term it also means I get to be at home more for him and the kids which will be lovely for all of us (I hope)!

Mumoffairy · 06/11/2022 18:07

I chose it and i love it. Both my kids are in school now and i have no intentions of going back. I feel very lucky, that i have this option.
I always find so much to do with volunteer work, our pets, household, driving kids around, hobbies etc. And i have lots of sahm friends i can hang out with anytime i want.
it really is the best life.
DH doesnt get it! Hes always glad when the weekend is over and he can head back to work. He finds it hard work with our kids and couldnt do it all day long. I actually really enjoy it, even when its hard sometimes.

But i guess its a good thing that he wouldnt wanna do it. We both get to do what we prefer and nobody feels resentful.

FortSalem86 · 06/11/2022 18:05

I can't find the post now but , other than having breaststroke, why are you and not your DH considered the best person to look after your children? Why not dad?

AlwaysLatte · 06/11/2022 17:56

We felt strongly that we wanted to look after them ourselves, and both were willing to be SAHPs, or work, but after discussion we both agreed that I'd be a SAHM (although by the time #2 came along we were both SAHPs). It's been brilliant being able to do it and both be at school assemblies, parents eves etc.

DarkKarmaIlama · 06/11/2022 17:55

@SchoolQuestionnaire

Yes I did this too. Many of my friends who remained at work did so whilst coasting in certain jobs that remained quite family friendly and haven’t actually progressed all that much like you would expect. That’s not a problem and it may suit them but what I am trying to say is careers can often stall even if the mother remains at work. I’ve known people to take a good few years out, retrain in nursing and then surpass their friends career wise who remained in work.

LargeglassofRosePlease · 06/11/2022 17:53

I went part time with both my D.C. but the past year I have had to be a SAHM as I have the worst mental health and am falling apart, so not able to work.
It’s a bit shit to be honest. I would not wish poor mental health on anyone. I feel really unwell. And so scared of how it makes me feel 😢

SchoolQuestionnaire · 06/11/2022 17:50

I wanted to be home with my kids and drop them off and pick them up from school. Luckily my dh wanted the same and earned enough that I could.

I did retrain during the last couple of years at home but I didn’t plan that when I gave up
work, it just made sense as the kids got older and needed me less to make a plan to return to work.

mondaytosunday · 06/11/2022 17:45

After I had my second the daycare costs would have been more than my take home pay. I was in my early 40s so had been working for 20 years so was happy to stop. My husband was a high earner.

Usernamen · 06/11/2022 17:38

I never come across SAHPs in real life as I live in London where you need two salaries to be able to afford to breathe, it seems. I literally don’t know a single one. So it’s nice to get that perspective on MN.

Hatemymiddlename · 06/11/2022 17:37

Yes and loved it. Went back to work part time when my youngest started school.

Tittyfilarious81 · 06/11/2022 17:33

I'm a sahm ,we chose it ,I love it and it is what is best for our family .

Apusskidonot · 06/11/2022 17:29

Various reasons.
It's worked well for our circumstances, although I didn't really expect it to be as long term as it has been. I think I'm at the stage where I'm unemployed rather than a SAHM although I'm not actively job seeking which tends to confuse people.

I don't think I've met anyone in RL who really cares why I'm a SAHM though. If anyone has then they haven't said it to me.

Chickpea17 · 06/11/2022 17:26

Well I didn't mean to offend anyone. I only answered the Question from my reason not everyone else's

Dachshund · 06/11/2022 17:20

I was fortunate to be able to choose it but tbh our lifestyle would not have possible if we had had to pay through the nose for private childcare as there were no nursery spaces (lived in overcrowded london area)

Now DD2 is going to school next year and I will be going back - DH and I work for ourselves so I have been part time on and off anyway - but in total I will have been a SAHM for 8 years. Loved it. Not every moment mind, but I don’t enjoy working in general and I adored being with my children when they were small. It has been some of the most precious years of my life

Unglamorousgranny · 06/11/2022 17:17

@CarefreeMe it's not selfish at all. It's what works best for the family. In my case my dh was the higher earner with more prospects. It would have been selfish of me to potentially harm his career by asking him to go part time.
Also, do you not think us sahm work? We don't all sit around watching This Morning, Loose Women etc. There's the housework, child care, shopping, cooking etc. This doesn't all get done by itself while the husbands/partners are grafting you know!

HeraldicBlazoning · 06/11/2022 17:15

Chickpea17 · 06/11/2022 16:48

I wanted to raise my children not someone else.

That's just as offensive to people who choose to work as the nonsense about brains turning to mush, tbh.

TallulahGosh · 06/11/2022 17:10

I’m a sahm but I didn’t really choose it. It’s complicated. I was long term unemployed before I got pregnant 4 years ago. I have mh problems and other problems that make it really difficult for me to work or study. I am fairly smart but didn’t finish school, get exams or go to college. I was on a special training programme to help get me into employment, then I got pregnant. At the time I even thought I might eventually look for a job after the baby was born but then my mh went to hell and Covid hit a few months after I had dd. We are used to living on my dp’s income so that is not an issue. Looking back, me starting a job and trying to cope with being a ftm was ridiculous and never going to happen. So I’m sort of a sahm by default. DP wfh a lot and does loads at home so I don’t do all the housework etc. Honestly, I don’t think being a sahm is particularly good for me. I’m lonely, isolated, understimulated and exhausted simultaneously and don’t get any time for myself. But I do love spending time with my dd and not having to have her in childcare. Maybe in the future I might try to do another training program or look for supported employment or something.
A big part of my problem with being a sahm is the isolation. There are hardly any baby or toddler groups where I live and most of them it’s women with small babies on mat leave who come in a pair or group/ have no interest in making friends. Lockdown made it more difficult obviously but it’s crap anyway. I tried a group in the library, nobody else turned up. Nobody around here is a sahp, they’re all working. There’s not even any small kids around, they’re all in childcare if they’re not in school. Dd is in preschool and the other kids are picked by either grannies or childminders or parents in cars on their phones etc. Nobody to talk to there even for a few minutes.
I don’t have any friends to meet up with, not close with my family either.
Honestly, I think they’re are very few who choose to be a sahp, can afford to do it comfortably and find lots of enjoyment and fulfilment in it. If so, you are very lucky. I agree with pp that if you are a student and that, I wouldn’t really call that a sahp.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 17:08

@HeraldicBlazoning

As boring as all the sly digs about working meaning children are being neglected

As tiresome as having to listen to the sake old sexist shite

Flowersonthewall6 · 06/11/2022 16:54

I would be a SAHP in a heart beat. We aren’t in the situation so dropped my hours instead as a compromise. But if I had a choice I would be a SAHM.

I think it’s lovely, I enjoyed my mat leave, daily walks and play groups. I was in my element, definitely not for everyone. I’m not the biggest fan of my job, it’s stressful and I’ve lost my passion for it. I wonder if that’s why someone would choose to be a SAHP, it’s the more fulfilling role to take for them?

Chickpea17 · 06/11/2022 16:48

I wanted to raise my children not someone else.

Daisychainsx · 06/11/2022 16:43

I chose it and my baby isn't even here yet! Due in a few months, there were lots of factors that went into my decision. Moved country, needed to do a lot of paperwork etc to convert my qualification, got a totally unrelated job in the meantime, really enjoyed it but got pregnant and was very sick so instead of messing them about (I wasn't entitled to sick leave pay and it was a very small team) I just thanked them and left! My qualification came through about 2 months ago and now I could teach here if I wanted, but I'm 6 months pregnant and just moved into a new house, so im spending my time and effort decorating and making myself at home! I love it and I wouldn't have it any other way. Probably won't go back to teaching until I'm a few kids in and they're all at school!

WeeblesWibbleWobble · 06/11/2022 16:41

When I was a sahm its because i wanted to. I did with my teen. Returned to old Job when they started school.
Hated juggling work, school etc.
I could have quit despite dc being at school but i loved my colleagues and it was a laugh.

When was pregnant with 2nd i quit after maternity. Never returned. Had 3rd who's now nearly 3 and wfh. But as and when i choose. I could do 1 hr a week, 10 or 30. When i want. And works well.
As its like being a sahm with a good salary.

OhmygodDont · 06/11/2022 16:41

If all you can talk about is works gossip I hate to see your marriages when you retire tbh.

TTCBBY3 · 06/11/2022 16:40

HeraldicBlazoning · 06/11/2022 16:36

Exactly, @SleepingStandingUp . All the faux concern stuff about "leaving yourself vulnerable" or the passive aggressive "I would be SO bored" stuff is just so tiring.

Some people just can't cope with other families making different choices. I could not give two hoots if you return to your high-powered city job at 14 days post partum and work full time. So full time workers, or part time workers, or whatever, should not give two hoots about choices people make to stay at home.

But lots of people think it's entirely acceptable to say that their brain would rot if they didn't go out to work each day, or that women who aren't working are leeches.

Absolutely couldn't agree more. I find it unbelievably insulting when people say they hate the idea of being a SAHP because "they'd have nothing to talk to their partner about when they got home from work". Sorry?! Is your only topic of conversation about work? If so, I pity you. My husband & I have a LOT to say to each other at the end of each day, as my day is full enough despite the fact "I don't go to work". Just because I don't sit in an office doesn't mean I don't speak to other adults all day. It's just juvenile and reeks of jealousy.

It's a classic case of good for you, not for me

OhmygodDont · 06/11/2022 16:40

I was at college when we had our first so we were used to one income. Me working minimum wage and needing child care would have put us in a deficit. Back to college second baby, same as above. By the time we had our third we were almost better off than those worrying about having their first and not being able to afford to take 9months leave. Now we have a company and I’m a payee employee. It’s worked out ok but I wouldn’t have had baby two and three without a wedding ring.

Swipe left for the next trending thread