Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a SAHP why?

162 replies

cattyfranny · 06/11/2022 13:22

Currently I am a SAHM, I am studying at Uni and I volunteer but I don’t have a paid job (I have a 2 yr old home and 7 yr old at school)

When I meet new people they assume that I have been “forced” into this position either because childcare costs are too high or crazily that my DH asked me to stay home! They seem to think it’s unthinkable to choose to be a SAHM 🤷‍♀️

If you are at home with your children, did you willingly choose to do it? Would you prefer to be at work? Why are you a SAHP?

OP posts:
Highfivemum · 06/11/2022 18:59

I consider myself to be very lucky to be able to be a SAHM. Love it, I will return to teaching once my youngest DC starts school but at the moment I am enjoying every moment of it

dollyblack · 06/11/2022 18:57

I was for a few years. DH worked away, no family/support, nursery is extortionate, SEN kids. I didn’t have a career path. Being at home actually really boosted my confidence. I started freelance WFH then started my own business.Was nice to have those early years at home.

sorbet5 · 06/11/2022 18:54

Topgub - my DH is not me and I don't need him to be. We are different people. I don't understand your argument. How would me working mean he was a better parent?

Norriscolesbag · 06/11/2022 18:53

Let’s be real- there are different types due to circumstances. Having toddlers (especially more than one), children with special needs… it’s not the same at all as someone who has kids at school with plenty of money. To be honest I have three autistic children, the youngest are 4 and 2. Work is a million times easier than trying to entertain the youngest two together ever was.

JennasCrustyHandbag · 06/11/2022 18:49

I didn't choose it but am incredibly happy I did it. I had a year maternity leave with Ds, returned to work for 6 months then Dh was offered a job in a better location, more opportunities for work, much closer to family and I could walk into the same job I had. Turned out my not so great health massively improved when we moved and I was sorting out unpacking the house and getting Ds into a new nursery. So not juggling work and childcare removed a lot of stress and I felt so much better.

We had a talk, we said we would try it for 6 months as I was concerned about the financial side, about how I would feel not earning money. That was 18 years ago. Went on to have Ds2. My deteriorating health means I can never work, not even part time. On bad days I can just be bed ridden and Dh worked from home to be able to do school runs.

I am lucky to have my own car and access to all monies. Financially we are incredibly comfortable, have lovely holidays and a nice house. Didn't stop people telling me about lunch time jobs going in school or suggesting I should take up tutoring or some such nonsense. I have enjoyed it, enjoyed the house stuff too, made it work for the family.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 06/11/2022 18:47

I did choose to be a SAHM but I also really didn't have much choice in the end anyway.

I adopted after 10 years of TTC and after 20 years of working up to management level in banking.

Reasons why I chose to be a SAHM :

My job was not one that could be done part time ( employer said business needs meant they would insist on full time or a downgraded position) and I also knew it would be too tough to combine the full time job with parenting due to the long hours expected.

Cost of childcare was also a huge factor as I'd have needed a live in Nanny.

We could easily afford to live on one salary.

Husband in similar style of job so same issues for him.

Reason why I had to be a SAHM anyway : we were matched with a baby and the adoption agency stipulated I'd have to be. SAHM as that's what they had promised birth mother when she relinquished him.

After 10 years of TTC and 20 years of working I was ready to commit to being a SAHM

I never went back to work. My DC are now 14 and 17 and the youngest has a chronic condition which requires lots of hospital treatment and medical appointments so working around her needs would still be difficult.

I'm 52 now - DH and I now looking forward to his retirement so we can enjoy some more time together.

OhIdoLike2bBesideTheSeaside · 06/11/2022 18:44

I'd love to be but we simply cannot afford it unfortunately

DramaAlpaca · 06/11/2022 18:41

I was a SAHM for 9 years when my 3 DC were small. DH earned a lot more and we could just about manage on one salary, plus both of us felt it was best for the children. I was perfectly happy to be at home, they were very happy years. It was always the plan that I'd go back to work so I returned part time when my youngest started school and full time when he started secondary, by which time I was delighted to go back. I've no regrets, I'm glad I was able to do it.

NCFT0922 · 06/11/2022 18:40

Absolutely love it. We run businesses so I’m not completely free from some work but, for the most part, my time is my own.

Choose it because I can. I don’t need to work and don’t know anyone who would choose that life if they had a fully financially secure future.

1stTimeMama · 06/11/2022 18:37

Me being a SAHM was one of the first decisions we made after finding out I was pregnant, which was a huge thing for my now husband to take on as we'd only been together 3 months. I've always appreciated it so much.
We then chose to home educate, so I've been a SAHM for 13yrs now. I didn't want to pay other people to be with my children, I wanted to raise them, be with them, enjoy them and not miss out on anything. We have such a relaxed, laid back lifestyle and we're all happy, which is what is most important.

spaceshiptrain · 06/11/2022 18:34

FortSalem86 · 06/11/2022 18:32

I didn't breastfeed but still have a very strong bond. Mine prefer me to their dad. 😂
I don't deny the strong bond between a mother and child however I think father's need the chance to bond. If that means being the SAHP at some points so be it.

Mu husband works very long hours and our child's bond with him is beautiful to witness. She absolutely adores him.

All this point scoring is a daily occurrence on here.

The very reason my husband is able to bond so well though is because we are both entirely stress-free given we take on single roles. The stability that the traditional family brings is invaluable.

You can achieve it whilst both working I'm sure, and if you can hats off but I wouldn't want to be under such constant stress.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 18:32

When you stop denying that sex-based roles make lots of sense, are comfortable and work best for the children, you are so much happier aren't you?

🤢🤢🤢

FortSalem86 · 06/11/2022 18:32

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 06/11/2022 18:27

I'm guessing you're responding to me, @FortSalem86 , as I made the comment about being the best person to care for my DC, over and above everyone else.

In actual fact, the breasts were pretty important - I breastfed both of mine till 3.5, and DD, in particular, was a very high needs baby who for quite some time could only be calmed and soothed with breastfeeding.

But also, whilst I realise it's an unpopular opinion and one that makes people quite angry, I do think the bond between a mother and her baby is special and irreplaceable. You literally grow them inside you. They share your immune system. Your heartbeat is one the first sounds they hear. They know your voice before they even meet you. In fact they know you before they even meet you.

All a baby wants, all it needs, is its mother. In situations where that isn't possible, other caregivers can and do make wonderful, wonderful parents - I'm not saying otherwise. But a willing and happy mum, that's the gold standard. We do mothers and children a disservice by pretending otherwise.

I didn't breastfeed but still have a very strong bond. Mine prefer me to their dad. 😂
I don't deny the strong bond between a mother and child however I think father's need the chance to bond. If that means being the SAHP at some points so be it.

Feysriana · 06/11/2022 18:31

SAHM here. Chose it because I did not feel I could be both an excellent mother and an excellent employee, not at the same time anyway, and I wasn’t willing to be less than that.

When children were young it was bliss. Adored it, best years of my life. Loved playgroups etc. When the youngest turned around age 9, things changed. I’d gone from being their goddess to being a cleaner/cook. DH’s career had meanwhile rocketed skywards since I became SAHM (and took care of everything that wasn’t his job), and now he and I have so much less in common than we used to, it worries me. But there is no point trying to get a job again now after 15 years out of workplace when DH is on very high income, I’d probably be contributing 5% of household income and still have the same issues at home.

Most women I know are now back at work, so the lovely lunches and coffees seem to be over. Don’t know what to do with myself.

Would I recommend being a SAHM? For the early years absolutely, but I stayed with it too long.

MassiveSalad22 · 06/11/2022 18:30

Many reasons, one being that I am one of millions of people who wouldn’t work if they didn’t need to. Sooooo many other fantastic ways to spend your time 😃😃

Kids are 7, 5 and 6 months.

DH works abroad a fair amount (probably on average a couple of weeks every other month). Life would be soooooo much more complicated and stressful if I had to literally work around that along with doing 100% of the childcare and cooking and house stuff while he’s away. Also while he’s away it’s always then that someone gets ill or something in the house breaks, typical! So if I had to work too….. no.

In order to make any kind of good money I’d need to retrain probably - I had DC1 in my ‘wtf am I doing with my life’ phase so haven’t had a career yet, just jobs.

My life is sooooo full with mainly stuff I choose to do and stuff that is fun. So I’d be mad to change that right now! I have a lot of savings in my name, plus a gem of a DH, so I’m not worried, but of course I realise shit can hit the fan.

I have a list of places to volunteer when youngest is at nursery in a couple of years, and when she’s at school I’ll get a job. Just using my time now to try and figure out WHAT job! Absolutely loving my SAHM years and not sure this isn’t my peak tbh! Absolutely in my element.

spaceshiptrain · 06/11/2022 18:29

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 06/11/2022 18:27

I'm guessing you're responding to me, @FortSalem86 , as I made the comment about being the best person to care for my DC, over and above everyone else.

In actual fact, the breasts were pretty important - I breastfed both of mine till 3.5, and DD, in particular, was a very high needs baby who for quite some time could only be calmed and soothed with breastfeeding.

But also, whilst I realise it's an unpopular opinion and one that makes people quite angry, I do think the bond between a mother and her baby is special and irreplaceable. You literally grow them inside you. They share your immune system. Your heartbeat is one the first sounds they hear. They know your voice before they even meet you. In fact they know you before they even meet you.

All a baby wants, all it needs, is its mother. In situations where that isn't possible, other caregivers can and do make wonderful, wonderful parents - I'm not saying otherwise. But a willing and happy mum, that's the gold standard. We do mothers and children a disservice by pretending otherwise.

You're right but there's a trend to deny this. Nesting is real. Nurturing dispositions are real and most often belong to mothers.

Hunger gatherers are real and women and men have had sex-based roles in families and communities since the dawn of man.

Evolution means these traits will remain. It's just facetiousness that makes people ask about stay at homes dads.

It's not chance or social conditioning that mums nurture children and fathers breadwin.

When you stop denying that sex-based roles make lots of sense, are comfortable and work best for the children, you are so much happier aren't you?

Topgub · 06/11/2022 18:28

SleepingStandingUp · 06/11/2022 18:25

she's clearly said she thinks she has more to offer the kids than he does

Is she?

That's not how I read it.it read to me as questioning why any woman works instead of 'raising' their child(ren)

But she's not asking her oh that.

Funnily enough

SleepingStandingUp · 06/11/2022 18:27

AlwaysLatte · 06/11/2022 17:56

We felt strongly that we wanted to look after them ourselves, and both were willing to be SAHPs, or work, but after discussion we both agreed that I'd be a SAHM (although by the time #2 came along we were both SAHPs). It's been brilliant being able to do it and both be at school assemblies, parents eves etc.

you said you're both SAHP so did you both give up work and survive on benefits in order to both voluntarily be at home? Or you've come into money so don't need to, been forced into it for care reasons etc?

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 06/11/2022 18:27

I'm guessing you're responding to me, @FortSalem86 , as I made the comment about being the best person to care for my DC, over and above everyone else.

In actual fact, the breasts were pretty important - I breastfed both of mine till 3.5, and DD, in particular, was a very high needs baby who for quite some time could only be calmed and soothed with breastfeeding.

But also, whilst I realise it's an unpopular opinion and one that makes people quite angry, I do think the bond between a mother and her baby is special and irreplaceable. You literally grow them inside you. They share your immune system. Your heartbeat is one the first sounds they hear. They know your voice before they even meet you. In fact they know you before they even meet you.

All a baby wants, all it needs, is its mother. In situations where that isn't possible, other caregivers can and do make wonderful, wonderful parents - I'm not saying otherwise. But a willing and happy mum, that's the gold standard. We do mothers and children a disservice by pretending otherwise.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/11/2022 18:25

Topgub · 06/11/2022 18:23

@sorbet5

Why was your oh ok you to getting the joy of his kids and not him?

Did he not mind missing the joy?

she's clearly said she thinks she has more to offer the kids than he does

SleepingStandingUp · 06/11/2022 18:24

Babyroobs · 06/11/2022 14:53

You aren't a sahm if you are a full time student ?

OP doesn't say full time , she says student. I'm a student, but i study evenings distance learning when DC are in bed. Rest of the time i'm looking after them. I'm a SAHP far more than a student.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 18:23

@sorbet5

Why was your oh ok you to getting the joy of his kids and not him?

Did he not mind missing the joy?

sorbet5 · 06/11/2022 18:21

I am a SAHM because we can afford it without any noticeable impact on our lifestyle and mainly, I felt I had more to offer my kids then anyone else. 15 years now and never regretted it. For me, the question would be reframed as 'why WOULD pay another woman to get the joy of your kids if you don't have to.?"

ShallowHalWantsAGal · 06/11/2022 18:14

I just thought you were complimenting our swimming skills 😁

FortSalem86 · 06/11/2022 18:13

FortSalem86 · 06/11/2022 18:05

I can't find the post now but , other than having breaststroke, why are you and not your DH considered the best person to look after your children? Why not dad?

Breasts not breaststroke. 😏

Swipe left for the next trending thread