Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give lifts with baby in the car

381 replies

alwaysfrazzled · 06/11/2022 13:11

My baby is four months old and is a nightmare in the car. She screams the place down and always drops her dummy which upsets her even more. If I need to go anywhere in the car I make it short journeys and if I have to go anywhere longer than ten mins I always go with someone else in the back.
Sister in law is in hospital and needs a lift home. She stays a half hour drive away so that's an hour round trip.
She would have to sit in the back with the baby but it won't stop the screaming, on the way home would be a nightmare. I hate driving with constant screaming.
I don't want to do it. Would I be unreasonable to suggest she gets the bus home?
My partner is working away so not home to help. Her mum is on holiday. Nobody else can drive her home. Nightmare.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 06/11/2022 17:03

workingeverysingkeday · 06/11/2022 16:39

This might be controversial but I'd give her some calpol so she sleeps on the journey

Apparently MNHQ no longer delete dangerous medical advice.

It's controversial because it's an outrageous suggestion. You can't medicate a baby so that they sleep without proper advice. That's a disgusting suggestion and I hope you don't have children.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 06/11/2022 17:01

Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 16:57

The comfort of knowing you’ll step out of the hospital to a friendly, familiar face? Be able to get home and have a cuppa with a relative? Not having to sit at a bus stop waiting when you’re obviously unwell enough to be kept in hospital. It’s a bit sad if you really can’t see any way a relative picking you up when you’re ill would bring someone comfort.

So you also expect the OP to hang around and have a cuppa, too, when she has her newborn with her, and children to pick up from school? It's a bit sad if you thing to do to a mother of a newborn, when if SIL wants a friendly face why doesn't she ask her best friend to pick her up, and not expecting this mother of a newborn to inconvenience herself and other road users, for a woman that is well and is being released.

A 'friendly face' might be nice, but when it means you are inconveniencing a mother of a newborn and risking other road users, it is an unacceptable thing to ask. And she is being released from hospital, so she's well now.

thelobsterquadrille · 06/11/2022 17:00

Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 16:57

The comfort of knowing you’ll step out of the hospital to a friendly, familiar face? Be able to get home and have a cuppa with a relative? Not having to sit at a bus stop waiting when you’re obviously unwell enough to be kept in hospital. It’s a bit sad if you really can’t see any way a relative picking you up when you’re ill would bring someone comfort.

Would you really feel comforted knowing you'd forced your SIL to collect you with a screaming baby in the back seat? And then knowing that once you were home and settled, she'd have to do the same journey home again?

Fraaahnces · 06/11/2022 16:59

Since they’re not the sort of family to pitch in to help you, I don’t see why you have been volunteered to drive with a screamy baby. I’d say that it’s simply not possible.

Kanaloa · 06/11/2022 16:57

been and done it. · 06/11/2022 16:37

Not sure much comfort and support would be available with a screaming baby sat next to her. She's having AB infusion.

The comfort of knowing you’ll step out of the hospital to a friendly, familiar face? Be able to get home and have a cuppa with a relative? Not having to sit at a bus stop waiting when you’re obviously unwell enough to be kept in hospital. It’s a bit sad if you really can’t see any way a relative picking you up when you’re ill would bring someone comfort.

girlmom21 · 06/11/2022 16:56

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 16:50

I don't think the baby should go but it's hard to believe there is no neighbor, fellow school mum, or other person available who could watch the infant for a while.

The baby's only 4 months. I wouldn't leave a 4 month old with a random school mom or neighbour.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 06/11/2022 16:56

Theydoyaknow · 06/11/2022 16:50

Would I be unreasonable to suggest she gets the bus home

I think this is what got people's backs up. Had you mentioned taxi, it would not have sounded as bad.

Why? I took a bus home from my 5.5 weeks IV/PIC line antibiotic Sepsis stint in hospital, mine took 1 hour 10 mins (I live rurally), in fact, it never occurred to me not to. Yeah a taxi is more direct, but a well person being released from hospital should be able to take a bus. Even a train.

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/11/2022 16:55

Some places have a bus from the hospital door and some folk live right outside a bus stop (on two occasions in my life, I have lived opposite a bus stop for a bus that goes right into the hospital grounds so its hardly super rare!).

So the bus suggestion MIGHT be perfectly reasonable - or it could be a long walk to the bus stop at either end and thus unreasonable, we don't know.

I think its reasonable to assume that bus is simply shorthand for 'public transport' and if the OP thinks public transport is a reasonable option, then it probably is, up to her SIL if she wants cheap bus or expensive taxi!

And IV antibiotics are given for multiple reasons - I don't know why everyones lept to the assumption of sepsis, but if a patient were still severely ill with sepsis.. they wouldn't be being discharged!

LumpyandBumps · 06/11/2022 16:54

I don’t have time to read every suggestion, but on the off chance it hasn’t been mentioned already, is hospital transport available?
In this area as well as some non emergency ambulances there is a volunteer driver scheme. There is a charge for the driver service, but it is just to cover costs, so much less than a taxi.
Whilst it would be nice if you could help out I don’t blame you for not doing so in your circumstances. I have waited ages in the past when collecting people from hospital.

gogohmm · 06/11/2022 16:52

@JennyNotFromTheBlock

Not everywhere has plentiful taxis trust me! I have to drive dp to the station at 7am tomorrow because there are no taxis at all between 7am and 10am or 2pm and 4pm due to them contracting with the council for sn school runs. By all I mean both of them, small town

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 06/11/2022 16:51

gogohmm · 06/11/2022 16:48

To all those saying get a taxi, you don't know where they live. Here taxi's are rarer than hens teeth - you need to book weeks ahead and they still cancel on you. Mostly neighbours help neighbours out with hospital runs, airport drops etc because it's got to the point that it's simply not viable to get a taxi, before even considering the cost (and we have poor public transport eg nothing to the hospitals at all)

OP would have said something, it's clear SIL is not where you are. Regardless, it is still not OP's responsibility to put her baby's health at risk and risk her life and other road users lives, with SIL can call a taxi, or get a bus, or train, or get her best friend to pick her up. So many alternatives that ask for a mother of a newborn to risk lives.

Theydoyaknow · 06/11/2022 16:50

Would I be unreasonable to suggest she gets the bus home

I think this is what got people's backs up. Had you mentioned taxi, it would not have sounded as bad.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 16:50

I don't think the baby should go but it's hard to believe there is no neighbor, fellow school mum, or other person available who could watch the infant for a while.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 06/11/2022 16:50

gogohmm · 06/11/2022 16:44

If you sil needs a lift just forewarn her, perhaps if she sat in the back it might help calm your dc down. She's asked you because she needs help

SIL doesn't 'need help' @gogohmm is well enough she is being released from hospital, and can call a taxi like everyone else released from hospital does. OP, the baby's own mother, tried sitting in the back, she said so if you read her replies on here. It did not help. SIL needs to stop being so selfish she is putting out a mother and 4 month old newborn baby, and call a taxi. It's really that simple.

billy1966 · 06/11/2022 16:48

alwaysfrazzled · 06/11/2022 16:36

@girlmom21 no. It's not.
I have mentioned all this to my health visitor who has suggested she will grow out of it and will get better when she's forward facing but she can't be forward facing yet. Please stop hounding me to seek medical advice. I know my baby to know when she's ill. She hates the car. That's it. I do not refuse to help my baby.
All this seems blown totally out of proportion all over giving my sil a lift home from hospital.

Should have mentioned that my son grew out of it and slowly increased the time he could stand, about an hour as a one year old.
We adapted.

Best of luck.

gogohmm · 06/11/2022 16:48

To all those saying get a taxi, you don't know where they live. Here taxi's are rarer than hens teeth - you need to book weeks ahead and they still cancel on you. Mostly neighbours help neighbours out with hospital runs, airport drops etc because it's got to the point that it's simply not viable to get a taxi, before even considering the cost (and we have poor public transport eg nothing to the hospitals at all)

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 06/11/2022 16:47

Tonkerbea · 06/11/2022 16:43

Don't blame you OP, some bonkers replies on this thread. Including those who think a baby should be distressed for an hour because a grown woman would rather not get a cab.

think a baby should be distressed for an hour because a grown woman would rather not get a cab.

Exactly. I know AIBU is bonkers at the best of times. But some of the comments must be from CFing chancers themselves as they are so batshit crazy. Anyone that suggests a mother with a 4 month old newborn baby puts the baby through that, through no gain for them, and risk themselves and other road users, for a lazy CFing chancer who can't phone a taxi like every other person released from hospital does (I took a bus that took 1 hour 10 mins to get home, never occurred to me to ask anyone to put themselves out for me) is not on planet reality.

gogohmm · 06/11/2022 16:44

If you sil needs a lift just forewarn her, perhaps if she sat in the back it might help calm your dc down. She's asked you because she needs help

Tonkerbea · 06/11/2022 16:43

Don't blame you OP, some bonkers replies on this thread. Including those who think a baby should be distressed for an hour because a grown woman would rather not get a cab.

MrNook · 06/11/2022 16:43

alwaysfrazzled · 06/11/2022 16:36

@girlmom21 no. It's not.
I have mentioned all this to my health visitor who has suggested she will grow out of it and will get better when she's forward facing but she can't be forward facing yet. Please stop hounding me to seek medical advice. I know my baby to know when she's ill. She hates the car. That's it. I do not refuse to help my baby.
All this seems blown totally out of proportion all over giving my sil a lift home from hospital.

Agreed OP.

My DD would scream and scream until she was sick in the car until she was about 11 months, I had to avoid car journeys it was awful so no I don't think YABU to not pick up your sister, you don't want to put your DD through that stress unnecessarily. She can get a taxi home.

been and done it. · 06/11/2022 16:43

Rather than going on at the OP why can't SIL arrange a lift with her friends/neighbours

alwaysfrazzled · 06/11/2022 16:42

I'm coming off this thread now. Someone suggests I dose my child up with calpol to give someone a lift home from hospital.
In what world is that ok!? Jesus.

Thank you to all who were helpful and supportive. I am ok with being told I'm unreasonable but the abuse from others saying things like 'poor kids' and calling me selfish and nasty things...had enough.

OP posts:
workingeverysingkeday · 06/11/2022 16:39

This might be controversial but I'd give her some calpol so she sleeps on the journey

girlmom21 · 06/11/2022 16:39

alwaysfrazzled · 06/11/2022 16:36

@girlmom21 no. It's not.
I have mentioned all this to my health visitor who has suggested she will grow out of it and will get better when she's forward facing but she can't be forward facing yet. Please stop hounding me to seek medical advice. I know my baby to know when she's ill. She hates the car. That's it. I do not refuse to help my baby.
All this seems blown totally out of proportion all over giving my sil a lift home from hospital.

I'm not hounding you. I was responding to another poster. At 13:21 you insisted you weren't going to the doctor because it's only in the car. Your health visitor isn't necessarily correct, considering the older child has to take medication for such short journeys.

Car journeys shouldn't be so horrendous for the whole family. If they were my children I'd be looking for other causes, but they're not my children.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 06/11/2022 16:39

@alwaysfrazzled You know you can't do this, and in fact, it would be wrong of you to do it and make your baby upset and risk other road users. You can't do it. Don't try to justify yourself to the ignorant vipers on here who are trying to talk you into risky dangerous behaviour for a healthy CFer who is being released from hospital and can sit in a taxi.

Swipe left for the next trending thread