Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be livid that year 11 DS thinks 4-5 hours/week homework/revision is enough for GCSEs?

756 replies

Hotdaisies22 · 06/11/2022 11:48

DS in year 11. Bright boy but has always been poor at doing homework at home despite being well set up for it at home (quiet desk space etc). Does his homework at homework club after school -Mon - Thurs max 5 hrs week (thats only time homework club room is available at his school). We're having conversations that he now needs to up his game these next few months before GCSEs and start studying /revising at home extra time. Getting massive push back and causing a lot of friction. He thinks what he does is enough and no intention of doing more "at the end of a tiring school day" (he only has a 20 min journey to school). What are other year 11s doing? (I'm trying to have conversation with his school on this but so far they've been rubbish - no reply!)

OP posts:
Hobbi · 08/11/2022 12:58

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:49

@Hobbi - you are making false assumptions assuming what my “colleague” is like. She is a single mum and works hard as a secretary in a large law firm. Her boys are mixed race. She definitely feels for her boys it is a question of work put into during their GCSEs

I made no assumptions about your friend. I stated what message her actions conveyed. And my point about those working in the soup kitchen remains, only take your children there to help or bugger off with your poverty porn. And what does the ethnicity of her children have to with anything? What a remarkably unusual thing to say.

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:52

In fact, in many cases, the teenage brain cannot quite understand or fathom consequences/dangers etc. Sometimes you need to show them in a concrete way.

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:49

@Hobbi - you are making false assumptions assuming what my “colleague” is like. She is a single mum and works hard as a secretary in a large law firm. Her boys are mixed race. She definitely feels for her boys it is a question of work put into during their GCSEs

Hobbi · 08/11/2022 12:47

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:43

My colleague has 3 teenage boys. She always tells the story of how she motivated them to work of their own accord.
Firstly, she took them to Canary Wharf and did a tour round her office. She then took them to the car park and showed them all the Porches and Lamborghini’s of the parents. Next she took the DLR to the council houses half way between Canary Wharf and the City. She made them work around there, look at the rubbish, made them walk through many of the estates etc. Then she took them to the City of London, showed them the Royal Exchange. Next she went to Harley Street etc. You see where this is going. She also took them to a soup kitchen etc.
She did the same when it came to schools. She made a point to take them to look round the less prestigious comprehensives, as well as the grammar as well as Eton College. She showed them all the options at an early age and then left it to them. One got a full bursary to Eton College.
Obviously she and her kids are relatively privileged. However, she swears after she showed them the various options properly that they all worked properly. They needed to see for themselves.

People in those circumstances aren't there because of a nominal amount of work they put into their GCSEs. All she did was suggest some people are of less value than others, which is a lovely message. Did she show them the folk working or volunteering in the soup kitchens, or were they similarly failures at life?

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:43

My colleague has 3 teenage boys. She always tells the story of how she motivated them to work of their own accord.
Firstly, she took them to Canary Wharf and did a tour round her office. She then took them to the car park and showed them all the Porches and Lamborghini’s of the parents. Next she took the DLR to the council houses half way between Canary Wharf and the City. She made them work around there, look at the rubbish, made them walk through many of the estates etc. Then she took them to the City of London, showed them the Royal Exchange. Next she went to Harley Street etc. You see where this is going. She also took them to a soup kitchen etc.
She did the same when it came to schools. She made a point to take them to look round the less prestigious comprehensives, as well as the grammar as well as Eton College. She showed them all the options at an early age and then left it to them. One got a full bursary to Eton College.
Obviously she and her kids are relatively privileged. However, she swears after she showed them the various options properly that they all worked properly. They needed to see for themselves.

Katebakescakes · 08/11/2022 11:45

It’s a weird one. I don’t really know how I feel about this situation because I didn’t do much work and did well - let’s be honest GCSEs are easy AF. They’re more about managing time and not being stressed out than anything (which is a life skill in and of itself!) I recently found my old certificates - GCSEs, a levels, undergrad and law school. I think what I personally really needed was a plan. I was all over the place and when shit got hard at a level and I didn’t know what the hell I was doing. I then moved school and had more freedom - not less. Like another poster mentioned this actually motivated me more. I think a serious talk is a good idea. Ask your son what he wants out of life and what he enjoys. How he can maximise this.

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 11:35

I agree there is no point in raising the subject of sacrifices you have made. Though often it is hard to keep mum.

Comefromaway · 08/11/2022 11:31

I made enormous sacrifices to pay for my children's private education. Part way through I realised that for my son it was not working and wasn't worth the mental health issues.

I withdrew him, sent him to a state school, he did the minimum to get through GCSE's then went onto a Btec course he was passionate about. He is currently in his first year at a leading institution for his degree subject but last week seriously considered dropping out as he was offered a contract paying over £2k per month (He turned it down).

sunshinemode · 08/11/2022 11:24

I work in child mental health and I sat listening yesterday to a child telling my co worker that they seriously will consider killing themselves if they don’t do well in their mocks. Yes, exams are important but they are not that important.
This is not the only child I have hard this from.
The fact that OP has made huge sacrifices for private education is a choice they made as a parent and the pressure of that should not be put on their child.
We need to stop placing these huge amounts of pressure on our children, as frustrating as they can be at times, and let them grow.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 08/11/2022 11:11

GCSEs are not difficult, like A levels are, for a bright child who is getting good grades.

But I don't think that applies to the OP's child.

TheMarzipanDildo · 08/11/2022 11:09

Togoodtobeforgotten · 07/11/2022 20:08

You may want to watch a few documentarys about the Chinese education system before you eat your words.

Should we emulate China on everything? Their authoritarian government for example? The worker’s rights abuses? Hmm

“But they do it in xyz” is not a legitimate reason to do it here. 14 hour school days are shocking.

LaDamaDeElche · 08/11/2022 11:05

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 07/11/2022 19:52

Are GCSE's much harder these days than they were in the mid 90's? I didn't do anywhere near that much revision and I got ten with pretty good grades. I just studied at Easter if I remember rightly.

I don't know about the 90s but for a few years they were mostly coursework and modules which you could resit until you passed. All changed now and most are exams at the end of 2 years plus this is the 1st year when exams will be completely back to normal with no concessions since covid started (so I suspect that the experiences of many people on here is irrelevant). Plus I'm not sure that doing bugger all work for GCSE's is good preparation for A levels. I'm all for a happy medium.

Ours were exams at the end of the three year period. No modules and one piece of coursework. I didn't suggest doing bugger all work, just that I got 10 good grades without studying for 5 hours plus a week every week up until my GCSEs. I did study a lot over the Easter holidays. GCSEs are not difficult, like A levels are, for a bright child who is getting good grades.

thesugarbumfairy · 08/11/2022 10:50

I do understand OP - in fact I completely empathise - its the same here. We have what is basically a lazy teen - he is starting to comprehend how important it is - just a little too late as his mocks have already started. He is capable of much more - he just can't be arsed. He wants to be arsed - but isn't.

I would say - your 'sacrifices' are irrelevant for him - you have simply done what a good parent does - puts their child's wellbeing before everything else. It won't register him - maybe ever - that he should be grateful for this - but certainly not in mid-teendom. So whilst in your mind your efforts should be linked to his attitude - it isn't and won't be. I know its exasperating when you've worked your arse off to get him into a good place - but don't put that on him.

I can't really advise - nagging doesn't work I know that - are there any revisions you can help him with? I'm a maths person so I said to DS that I'm happy to sit down for him for half an hour and go through each topic at a time - so he isn't trying to revise by himself which rarely ends well. or starts well actually. I have also offered to help with German (which I don't speak but I can test him) and History which we could have discussions about which might help facts stick in his brain.

Harrysmummy246 · 08/11/2022 10:29

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2022 08:51

If your child wants to do something academic or competitive then yes gcse results do matter. The message they dont is extremely outdated and unhelpful.

But you're saying it depends on what the child wants.....

We don't know what OP's DS wants, only what they want given they're paying for his education.

Harrysmummy246 · 08/11/2022 10:27

Stevie77 · 07/11/2022 22:00

So where/how would you teach effective learning/revision techniques? Trying to instill good habits with Yr 8 child and have looked into study skills but most advice seems to be aimed at undergraduates, which may overwhelm them a bit.

@Stevie77
Now is the time to help your child explore whether for example they prefer written notes, online resources, videos etc, explaining a concept to you, practicing answers. All of which are valid, but all of which suit different people.
Not everyone likes revision cards for example. Personally, I do need to write and colour things as my mind then pictures the 'shape' and can retrieve the answer but lots of people prefer listening to things (doesn't work for me, I listen to loads of podcasts related to my work but don't necessarily remember the content).
Get them used to spending short times focussed on a task then take a break. Make sure they have a good area to work. Try to encourage them to be organised for themself- drove me mad that my tutee would log on to the zoom without his pen and calculator for example.
Make sure they look back over work and look at where it could be improved- biggest value from tests is often reviewing them, working out where you lost marks etc.

And, maybe, find a tutor who can work with them to instil some skills now and help them understand what works for them. (I'm actually much more about that than content for example)

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 10:11

Parker231 · 08/11/2022 09:59

If a student needs to do the amount of homework and revision some posters are insisting on, these students are on the wrong course and should be looking at a lower level qualification. When do they have time for sport and other hobbies? When are they going out with friends? These schools are going to end up with students totally stressed out and not the well rounded individuals we need. You can’t force someone to revise

Revision is quality and not quantity.

Disagree. My DS took his grades in Further Maths (or whatever it is called) from 7 to 9 with quantity. Maths is all about practice anyway IMO. He needed it so he had to. His uni couldnt care less about well rounded individuals. They needed A star A star A at A levels with an A star in FM. He got it. Gave up football in A levels. Thinks it was worth it. Hasnt burnt out.

blueshoes · 08/11/2022 10:04

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 08:58

I think it's going to be a shock for some posters if/ when their DC want to go to uni and they find out the grades required for many competitive courses. Things have changed.

Cmopletely agree.

It is a good thing that fewer posters aim high for their dcs. It reduces the competition for those who do. The academic schools know the drill but others can continue to live in their world where you shouldn't try too hard if you are not naturally clever (or hardworking).

Then you have threads on mn of how to be rich. Well, the easiest way for a lot of people (though not guaranteed of course because personality and luck come into play) is strong academics and a good course in a good university. These are the building blocks but they do require some effort.

Parker231 · 08/11/2022 09:59

If a student needs to do the amount of homework and revision some posters are insisting on, these students are on the wrong course and should be looking at a lower level qualification. When do they have time for sport and other hobbies? When are they going out with friends? These schools are going to end up with students totally stressed out and not the well rounded individuals we need. You can’t force someone to revise

Revision is quality and not quantity.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 08/11/2022 09:51

Things have changed, and you do need good A levels to get into the competitive courses - but my youngest has a girl on her course (Marine Bio) who didn't get the A levels and got in via a Foundation Year. There's also access courses. Some young people mature later than others and for them these alternative routes can work well.

That's true but it costs money and I'd be very pissed off with my DD if she wasn't willing to put in some work for her (free) GCSEs and A levels and then expected me to pay (£3000 at the 6th form she hopes to go to) for an access course for her to go to Uni.

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2022 09:19

There are programs in 6th form only for those with a certain gcse grade point average so the “gcse results don’t matter” advice is unhelpful.

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2022 09:16

Absolutely Dd worked very hard with no prompting from us because she has a goal and is smart. I agree if you have to force a child to revise that path is not right for them anyway.

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 09:14

FlirtyMelons · 08/11/2022 09:03

But if they are having to study for 3-4 hrs a night to pass GCSEs to a good level then they are probably not cut out for those courses. The kids I know getting 8/9s across the board definitely didnt need to as they are the naturally clever kids. DS could have got 9s for all exams with a bit of work every night but he chose to do very little and got 7-9s.

For the kids at the other end sometimes scraping maths/English and not passing many others is not a bad thing as doing L2 vocational course at college in something they are passionate about then moving up that way is the best thing. Often with an extremely successful outcome.

People on MN have a bizarre outlook on life in general. Not everyone's aim is to go to Oxbridge, it also isn't always relevant for people's career choices.

Sure, not everyone's aim is to go to Oxbridge. However even the " lower rung" unis such as LSE, UCL, Durham, Imperial, Kings are asking for very high grades at both GCSE and A levels. It's a lot more competitive than it used to be. When they get there they will meet foreign students who study double the hours the OP mentions and would simply laugh at the idea of 7 to 9 GCSEs being acceptable. They have all 9s or the international equivalent and some have 6 A levels.

If the DC want to do something vocational, fine. Not sure if they can make that choice this early.

All that said, I don't think one can force DC. My DS learnt from watching older DD mess up her A levels- lack of focus- and then be limited in her choice of uni. She regrets it.

pointythings · 08/11/2022 09:08

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 08:58

I think it's going to be a shock for some posters if/ when their DC want to go to uni and they find out the grades required for many competitive courses. Things have changed.

Things have changed, and you do need good A levels to get into the competitive courses - but my youngest has a girl on her course (Marine Bio) who didn't get the A levels and got in via a Foundation Year. There's also access courses. Some young people mature later than others and for them these alternative routes can work well.

FlirtyMelons · 08/11/2022 09:04

TheaBrandt · 08/11/2022 08:51

If your child wants to do something academic or competitive then yes gcse results do matter. The message they dont is extremely outdated and unhelpful.

If they want to do something competitive and don't put in the work then it's not for them surely! If you have to force them it's pointless.

FlirtyMelons · 08/11/2022 09:03

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 08:58

I think it's going to be a shock for some posters if/ when their DC want to go to uni and they find out the grades required for many competitive courses. Things have changed.

But if they are having to study for 3-4 hrs a night to pass GCSEs to a good level then they are probably not cut out for those courses. The kids I know getting 8/9s across the board definitely didnt need to as they are the naturally clever kids. DS could have got 9s for all exams with a bit of work every night but he chose to do very little and got 7-9s.

For the kids at the other end sometimes scraping maths/English and not passing many others is not a bad thing as doing L2 vocational course at college in something they are passionate about then moving up that way is the best thing. Often with an extremely successful outcome.

People on MN have a bizarre outlook on life in general. Not everyone's aim is to go to Oxbridge, it also isn't always relevant for people's career choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread