Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be livid that year 11 DS thinks 4-5 hours/week homework/revision is enough for GCSEs?

756 replies

Hotdaisies22 · 06/11/2022 11:48

DS in year 11. Bright boy but has always been poor at doing homework at home despite being well set up for it at home (quiet desk space etc). Does his homework at homework club after school -Mon - Thurs max 5 hrs week (thats only time homework club room is available at his school). We're having conversations that he now needs to up his game these next few months before GCSEs and start studying /revising at home extra time. Getting massive push back and causing a lot of friction. He thinks what he does is enough and no intention of doing more "at the end of a tiring school day" (he only has a 20 min journey to school). What are other year 11s doing? (I'm trying to have conversation with his school on this but so far they've been rubbish - no reply!)

OP posts:
Aleaiactaest · 09/11/2022 09:19

“Their view is that they have made enormous sacrifices in many cases to give their DC a better life and lack of effort won’t be accepted.

That may be acceptable thinking in someone from their background, but I would call it emotional blackmail.”

I used to think like that when my DC were little. However, I have now seen these types of DC grow up and thrive on all levels. I remembering think a Chinese mum in my DC1’s Year 1 class was crazy for making her 5 year old do 1 hour of work every evening after after school club finishing at 6pm. She used to say that is just how it is done, they need to learn to sit early and just get into good habits. He wasn’t the brightest kid but got into a top grammar school and now doing incredibly well, zero mental health issues, he wasn’t allowed online much either.
Another time I witnessed an Indian mum in KS1 confront the teacher in front of me on why her DC was not in the top extension group in state primary. I would have been mortified to do similar. Again, said DC doing incredibly well. Sometimes high expectations followed by a supportive background do work. Both these mums worked full time by the way in gruelling jobs. They model the work ethic themselves and tolerate no lesser I guess. They still find time to sit with their DC in the evenings and on weekends to support homework/revision. Frankly, I do not know how they do it.

The reality is that there are plenty of DC in the UK today who are willing and able to put in hours and hours and I think many of them will be filling the top jobs.

Lentilweaver · 09/11/2022 09:18

FourTeaFallOut · 09/11/2022 09:13

Oh, behold, the pious and honourable trope of the hard working immigrant parent come to chastise the lazy common garden native parent 🙄

Don't you feel a little embarrassed to wave an arm over the word immigrant as if they are all the same - with the same style of parenting?

Because my DH is an immigrant, and fyi he didn't make many sacrifices to come here, and he's quite happy to let our high achieving son build his own homework and revision schedule. You know, almost like he sees a responsibility raise a whole human and not just a crop of grades.

No, I don't actually. I also don't recall saying that mine is the only way to parent or that we are all the same or made the same sacrifices. If you read my posts, we were pretty relaxed with older DC. Didn't work out so well and she now has to rethink all her career choices. Regrets not focusing actually. Younger DC decided to learn from that.

Anyway, you do you.

FourTeaFallOut · 09/11/2022 09:13

Oh, behold, the pious and honourable trope of the hard working immigrant parent come to chastise the lazy common garden native parent 🙄

Don't you feel a little embarrassed to wave an arm over the word immigrant as if they are all the same - with the same style of parenting?

Because my DH is an immigrant, and fyi he didn't make many sacrifices to come here, and he's quite happy to let our high achieving son build his own homework and revision schedule. You know, almost like he sees a responsibility raise a whole human and not just a crop of grades.

pointythings · 09/11/2022 09:08

Their view is that they have made enormous sacrifices in many cases to give their DC a better life and lack of effort won’t be accepted.

That may be acceptable thinking in someone from their background, but I would call it emotional blackmail.

@Hotdaisies22 I think if your DS isn't open to doing more work later on then you do have a genuine problem and I suspect the path towards resolving it is to start working out what he's interested in and what he wants to do next. Which is difficult if he's feeling a bit rudderless. Good luck.

PalmTrees7 · 09/11/2022 08:19

Interestingly a lot of the parents at DS’s school are from immigrant backgrounds. I was telling some of them about the view that 4 hours a week was sufficient work for year 11 and they were in disbelief.

Their view is that they have made enormous sacrifices in many cases to give their DC a better life and lack of effort won’t be accepted.

Many of their year 5 and 6 DC were doing more work than some on this thread have advised for year 11. Doesn’t seem to do them any harm!

PalmTrees7 · 09/11/2022 08:09

@Lentilweaver

Interestingly

DogInATent · 09/11/2022 07:55

There are some really helpful suggestions and advice in the thread which we can try with him. He has no idea what he wants to do next btw. Probably not A levels.
I'm curious what experiences he's getting outside of school and schoolwork. Particularly if he doesn't want to do A-levels.

What does he do apart from homework?

Lentilweaver · 09/11/2022 07:54

If I come across too much as a tigermum on these threads it is because I am first gen immigrant from a v poor country with no social security, as is DH. No generational wealth, no family in the UK, no UK education. We had to really start from scratch and fight our way up. This colours our thinking. Our DC have an easier road but still not easy.

OP, I feel for you and don't think you are being unreasonable. Solutions though are harder.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 09/11/2022 07:51

YABU. All he will do is tire himself out and give a poor performance in school. He probably has no idea what to revise or how to revise anyway. Seneca premium is pricy but a good way to ensure he is revising only the stuff he needs to.

DD1 worked every day of the year except for Christmas and birthdays, DD2 did the bare minimum and their grades are not that different. Let him have a childhood.

Katebakescakes · 09/11/2022 07:50

You should have sent him to a state school and let him fend for himself 😝

PalmTrees7 · 09/11/2022 07:46

Interestingly I was at a parents’ session at DS1’s school last night. A big focus was on revision and what DC need to be doing- the head said 95% of year 11 are doing at least the school’s minimum expectation of 3 hours on school nights and 5 hours a day at weekends.

This is backed up by checks carried out by teachers on revision materials. He also said that on average in other schools, year 11 are doing 3 hours in school nights and 3 hours a day at weekends.

Virtually all parents I spoke to were happy the school was setting high expectations and were enforcing these at home.

I think the idea some have on this thread that no year 11s are doing any work and that GCSEs don’t matter is for the birds.

Wigglywoman · 09/11/2022 07:12

Wigglywoman · 09/11/2022 07:12

This is disgusting. Imagine ‘touring’ people worse off than yourself to tell your kids they don’t wanna be like them 🤢

This was meant to be in reply to the person who’s friend did this, not OP

Wigglywoman · 09/11/2022 07:12

This is disgusting. Imagine ‘touring’ people worse off than yourself to tell your kids they don’t wanna be like them 🤢

Hotdaisies22 · 09/11/2022 00:30

Thanks for various responses even though some people ignored some things I'd already said. I'm NOT expecting him to revise in November, I had a conversation with him about doing more LATER. He thinks that is not needed - hence this post to find out what others do and vent a bit. Maybe the word 'livid' was too strong although I do feel cross inside at times given I'm working my arse off and most of my salary goes on his fees and if left to his own devices, he'd just be playing games and watching tik tok etc for 5 hours an evening and do no work at all (he doesn't as we limit screen time). I'd feel the same if he was still going to his previous non fee paying school of course - I'd still want him to try his best and do the necessary work for a few months before exams whilst being mindful of pressure and mental health - I have friends who have sons who have struggled on that front so I'm well aware of the issues.

At the moment DS doesn't do any revision, his 4- 5 hours at homework club is on 'set' homework (realise some of it may be 'revision' set by teachers). His school say 10 - 11 hours 'homework' a week. Homework club after school is compulsory for him (sort of!) because we pick him up afterwards and won;t pick him up earlier! He does actually do work at the club. He was doing zero homework at home previously before his school started homework club. He does zero school work at weekends. He does not have a part time job. He has a short school commute (leaves home 8.20ish). Does almost nothing in terms of household jobs. He does have hobbies he does including music, he does do informal sport (not pressured competive sport), he does see friends. He is not being tipped over the edge with hothousing pressure by us - far from it. We have a good relationship, we chat lots, we have a laugh. We are not the 'high pressure' parents some have suggested in this thread. He wanted to try the local private school his last few years, we didn't push him into it because we are trying to pressure him or 'buy' top performance of 'all 8/9s' type student (of which there are lots on MN it seems!) we know thats not him and thats fine. He has loads of amazing attributes and skills and we are regularly praising those. We did it because he was a year behind having done little for most of year 9 in lockdown (I mean nothing - his school wasn't doing any 'live' lessons and he had over 40 pieces of outstanding work by summer term). He also had friendship issues as his best friend had left the school. We are very supportive with him and we do offer carrots to encourage him.
There are some really helpful suggestions and advice in the thread which we can try with him. He has no idea what he wants to do next btw. Probably not A levels.

OP posts:
marktayloruk · 08/11/2022 22:32

Mocks currently in some schools- I was supposed to be an invigilator.

Jumpinjackkflash · 08/11/2022 20:29

As exams get closer most schools have finished the curriculum and spend all day revising for a number of months. My sons school recommended only doing a max of 20 mins of 2 subjects per evening to prevent burnout. I think they receive enough pressure at school without the same at home! It's counter productive

kc431 · 08/11/2022 20:19

LOL because working 60 hour weeks and driving a Lambo somehow makes you superior to those poor fuckers on council estates? That person sounds like a wanky prick. My dad’s ex wife tried to give me a similar lecture about how I should be motivated by money and seek the opportunities with more money. It doesn’t work, just like how you can’t force someone to be tall or straight. If you’re not motivated by materialistic bollocks then you don’t have to bust your guts doing 70 hour weeks in pointless “elite” jobs, and can enjoy your life instead.

kc431 · 08/11/2022 20:05

I’m sorry but this is bonkers. I revised the night before my GCSEs and week before for A levels, I got As/A*s and got into a good uni. Pulled my finger out at uni (still not more than 40 hrs a week tho) and got a 1st, but there’s people from my course with 3rds/2.2s that earn way more than me now.

At the end of the day, you want to end up in a job you enjoy, and people who are motivated by status/money never seem to grasp that. Say you make your (average sounding) son revise 50hrs a week and get high grades above his natural skill level. Is that so you can push him into some degree course that you want him to do? He’ll have to work super long hours to scrape a 2.1 and will likely have a breakdown, and not enjoy his job either. You can’t give someone YOUR aspirations and motivation - it has to come from them.

I love my job and find it interesting (data science). Could I earn much more in investment banking or law? Sure, but I don’t want to work more than 40 hours a week and do more boring work, just to have more money. I kind of saw GCSEs the same. I COULD work like crazy to get 12A*s - or I could have a life, go to Topshop, sit on MSN, drink in the park sometimes and get some As/Bs too.

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 20:03

My colleague is originally from Slovakia her ex from a Carribean Island. They are both from working class backgrounds, no family wealth whatsoever, but she is very smart. 1 of her DC is now at Oxford following grammar, the youngest on a full bursary to one of the most famous private schools in the world. She sent them all to
Kumon etc from an early age. Her methods seem to work.
She is now doing some sort of night school to become a trainee solicitor. She had her first child at 19.
I am pretty sure her DC will do really well, whatever her methods. Her stories are funny- I do sometimes wonder if she is exaggerating a bit. They are all Mensa members too now. She told me verbal and non verbal reasoning is entirely coachable, nothing to do with inherent IQ. She also fed her kids lots of strange vitamins.

Katebakescakes · 08/11/2022 19:56

Same with law school. Also…part of a lot of career paths is being able to calm the fuck down and maintain your cool. Not turn yourself into a nervous wreck because you’re surviving on zero sleep and crying in the library. Which admittedly, I have actually done 😂.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 08/11/2022 19:55

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:43

My colleague has 3 teenage boys. She always tells the story of how she motivated them to work of their own accord.
Firstly, she took them to Canary Wharf and did a tour round her office. She then took them to the car park and showed them all the Porches and Lamborghini’s of the parents. Next she took the DLR to the council houses half way between Canary Wharf and the City. She made them work around there, look at the rubbish, made them walk through many of the estates etc. Then she took them to the City of London, showed them the Royal Exchange. Next she went to Harley Street etc. You see where this is going. She also took them to a soup kitchen etc.
She did the same when it came to schools. She made a point to take them to look round the less prestigious comprehensives, as well as the grammar as well as Eton College. She showed them all the options at an early age and then left it to them. One got a full bursary to Eton College.
Obviously she and her kids are relatively privileged. However, she swears after she showed them the various options properly that they all worked properly. They needed to see for themselves.

How revolting.

l think the people working in the soup kitchens were doing a more important job than the tossers driving Lamborghinis.

Who on earth wants to drive a penis extension round?

Katebakescakes · 08/11/2022 19:51

Aleaiactaest · 08/11/2022 12:43

My colleague has 3 teenage boys. She always tells the story of how she motivated them to work of their own accord.
Firstly, she took them to Canary Wharf and did a tour round her office. She then took them to the car park and showed them all the Porches and Lamborghini’s of the parents. Next she took the DLR to the council houses half way between Canary Wharf and the City. She made them work around there, look at the rubbish, made them walk through many of the estates etc. Then she took them to the City of London, showed them the Royal Exchange. Next she went to Harley Street etc. You see where this is going. She also took them to a soup kitchen etc.
She did the same when it came to schools. She made a point to take them to look round the less prestigious comprehensives, as well as the grammar as well as Eton College. She showed them all the options at an early age and then left it to them. One got a full bursary to Eton College.
Obviously she and her kids are relatively privileged. However, she swears after she showed them the various options properly that they all worked properly. They needed to see for themselves.

Your colleague sounds horrendous. What a stupid thing to do. Is it somehow suggesting that people living in council estates with “rubbish” everywhere somehow deserve it. The myth is that if you work extremely hard you’ll be able to escape poverty and live a glorious life full of riches and joy. The reality is that the average salary in the uk is under 30k and in london it’s about 41k. That’s not a lot. The Majority of people earning over 100k are usually people who have not just made good choices but have HAD good choices to make.

neurosensitive · 08/11/2022 19:43

You are being unreasonable. I got my GCSE's without revising and I am a university graduate now with 20 years work experience. Your son is doing 5 hours a week and has good boundaries using home to relax (except when you are nagging him) and school to work in. The school probably haven't replied as they probably have more important things to worry about than a bright year 11 boy who attends homework club every day.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 08/11/2022 17:51

justasking111 · 08/11/2022 16:50

Yes they work to live, yet moan when they're passed over for promotion or laid off 😁

People can still want promotion without killing themselves for their employer.

Hate all that presenteeism/long hours culture. It benefits no one.

justasking111 · 08/11/2022 17:35

pointythings · 08/11/2022 17:22

Some do. Some don't. Not everyone wants the high stress high pay track. Job satisfaction matters. You're coming off as very judgemental.

It's the companies that maybe judgemental. Me I like the easy life 😂