Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be livid that year 11 DS thinks 4-5 hours/week homework/revision is enough for GCSEs?

756 replies

Hotdaisies22 · 06/11/2022 11:48

DS in year 11. Bright boy but has always been poor at doing homework at home despite being well set up for it at home (quiet desk space etc). Does his homework at homework club after school -Mon - Thurs max 5 hrs week (thats only time homework club room is available at his school). We're having conversations that he now needs to up his game these next few months before GCSEs and start studying /revising at home extra time. Getting massive push back and causing a lot of friction. He thinks what he does is enough and no intention of doing more "at the end of a tiring school day" (he only has a 20 min journey to school). What are other year 11s doing? (I'm trying to have conversation with his school on this but so far they've been rubbish - no reply!)

OP posts:
GoldIsMyChosenMetal · 12/11/2022 10:07

I didn’t do that much, I’d feel school underprepared him if he hasn’t covered the work.

As long as the hours he is doing are productive, I’d say that sounds reasonable.

I wouldn’t worry he’d be “stressed” but if learning for 6 hours it’s hard to take more in, personally.

pointythings · 12/11/2022 09:57

@CaronPoivre I do agree with you, but I don't accept that making your DC work all the hours on top of their school work to the exclusion of all else starting this early in Yr 11 is healthy for the majority. There has to be a balance that includes wellbeing, and paying attention to that is not being indulgent. It's being a good parent.

CaronPoivre · 12/11/2022 09:45

pointythings · 12/11/2022 09:25

@CaronPoivre I don't think anyone is suggesting otherwise, are they? But the fact that you use 'low expectations' to mean 'not wanting law, medicine or the city' speaks volumes. My youngest DC is studying Marine Biology. It's what they have wanted to do since age 11 or so and have worked hard towards. But it doesn't demand AAA* to get in, nor is Oxbridge the gold standard provider. The picture really isn't black and white.

I do agree that it is very difficult when you have a Yr11 who doesn't yet know what they want to do and isn't motivated, because at that point keeping doors open is key, which does mean strong academics and a good work ethic. But not 22 hours a week on top of school.

Low expectations are nothing to do with their career choices - our son chose to not go directly to university and we fully supported that. He did, however have the academic qualifications to do so - we knew it was actually an informed choice rather than ‘dunno, what can I do with a D and an E’?

It’s about ensuring what they do is actually a choice rather than a fall-back because the parents were too indulgent to support maximum achievement. A happy fifteen year old, who is cool, who chills with their friends may find they aren’t the happy, well adjusted, thriving and economically stable thirty year old. Clearly not all children can get exceptionally high A level or IB grades, but they absolutely can be supported to get their best grades.

One of our foster sons couldn’t read when he arrived and went to a special school. He’d been damned by parents who let him do his own thing - that thing involved hanging around, messing with a group in low level criminal activities, smoking and damaging the environment. His achievement wasn’t A levels but it was literacy, numeracy and onto City and Guilds qualifications that has allowed him to set up his own vintage vehicle renovating business. We are as proud of him as our other children.

Nothing to do with being a barrister or doctor - all about what choice actually means for an eighteen year old. Interestingly, few with high grades choose to go into bin collection or become shop assistants long term. I’m sure a few do, but most want the nice things in life and to be comfortable. That requires effort unless you’re born with a silver spoon.

Florenz · 12/11/2022 09:27

A lot of kids would do better in life if they went into a manual trade rather than getting a second rate degree from a second rate university, getting themselves into debt to do so.

pointythings · 12/11/2022 09:25

@CaronPoivre I don't think anyone is suggesting otherwise, are they? But the fact that you use 'low expectations' to mean 'not wanting law, medicine or the city' speaks volumes. My youngest DC is studying Marine Biology. It's what they have wanted to do since age 11 or so and have worked hard towards. But it doesn't demand AAA* to get in, nor is Oxbridge the gold standard provider. The picture really isn't black and white.

I do agree that it is very difficult when you have a Yr11 who doesn't yet know what they want to do and isn't motivated, because at that point keeping doors open is key, which does mean strong academics and a good work ethic. But not 22 hours a week on top of school.

CaronPoivre · 12/11/2022 08:41

pointythings · 11/11/2022 15:34

@Lentilweaver university applications are very competitive, but not everyone 1) needs to go to a top flight uni to become a productive member of society or 2) wants to study those very competitive courses. Society doesn't run exclusively on doctors, lawyers and investment bankment, for which may we be truly thankful.

No but if a child has potential then they should have a choice. That means good academic results. Otherwise we perpetuate the myth that higher professions and the city are only for the independent school, affluent children.

CaronPoivre · 12/11/2022 08:39

Parker231 · 11/11/2022 16:03

From reading this thread there seems to be parents with unrealistic expectations of the results their DC’s will get - it’s not a failure to get a 4 or 5. A levels and Uni are not for everyone and shouldn’t be. If so much revision is needed at GCSE level, A levels are probably not appropriate and an apprenticeship or vocational path would be better for the DC.

How to damn a child with low expectations.

Elwynsmum · 12/11/2022 08:29

I advise mine 10 hours a week on top of school shared between their subjects but make sure you have one day of the weekend properly off and don’t give up your hobbies. (Teacher and private tutor)

FlamencoDance · 12/11/2022 08:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster’s request.

pointythings · 11/11/2022 16:40

@Parker231 I couldn't agree more. When DD1 was doing GCSEs we had a school friend of hers living with us during the week - parents forced to move over the summer before Yr11, school in new area couldn't accommodate friend's options, so we had her live with us so she could carry on her GCSEs. She got a range of 4s and 5s plus very high grades in her BTECs and a 5 in maths. She was the first in her family to pass any GCSEs at all. She worked her bacskde off for them (but also managed to have a life). University was never going to be for her.

Parker231 · 11/11/2022 16:03

From reading this thread there seems to be parents with unrealistic expectations of the results their DC’s will get - it’s not a failure to get a 4 or 5. A levels and Uni are not for everyone and shouldn’t be. If so much revision is needed at GCSE level, A levels are probably not appropriate and an apprenticeship or vocational path would be better for the DC.

pointythings · 11/11/2022 15:41

It's another way in which our education system is problematic - there's no worthwhile and valued vocational pathway and people are forced to specialise early. I'm lucky in that my two both had very precise ideas of what they wanted to do and how to get there and that they were both academically inclined, but it's hard for a lot of young people.

Lentilweaver · 11/11/2022 15:39

pointythings · 11/11/2022 15:34

@Lentilweaver university applications are very competitive, but not everyone 1) needs to go to a top flight uni to become a productive member of society or 2) wants to study those very competitive courses. Society doesn't run exclusively on doctors, lawyers and investment bankment, for which may we be truly thankful.

True. But most 15 year olds don't know what they want to do. That's the problem. I guess you can only move forward with what they don't want to do. That was our approach anyway. But then you can't go back easily.

pointythings · 11/11/2022 15:34

@Lentilweaver university applications are very competitive, but not everyone 1) needs to go to a top flight uni to become a productive member of society or 2) wants to study those very competitive courses. Society doesn't run exclusively on doctors, lawyers and investment bankment, for which may we be truly thankful.

Lentilweaver · 11/11/2022 15:14

If DS had got all As at GCSE and A levels he would have been rejected by all the unis he applied to. As it was, he was still rejected for his top 2 picks. Uni applications have been very competitive lately.

Aleaiactaest · 11/11/2022 15:08

@Parker231 - that sounds like an amazing school for the DC but is it private with all musical and sporting bells & whistles? And teachers who feed perfect GCSE etc notes? Amazing science lab and lots of kids willing to learn and not disruptive in class?
Because in that kind of environment it is much easier to “thrive”, have a great balance etc and still do really well with less work put in.
Not that this applies to the OP DS, but in many comps in England now kids have cover teachers for subjects like Maths/Physics etc and it can be soul destroying, including for very bright talented DC. Who would have thrived in a top independent or grammar but instead end of disengaging or working all hours of the day to plug gaps.

Parker231 · 11/11/2022 10:41

PalmTrees7 · 11/11/2022 10:18

@Aleaiactaest

That sounds fantastic and very much like the DC’s school. The vast majority of DC working extremely hard and trying to get the best grades they are capable of.

The 4 hours a week, GCSEs don’t matter crew are going to find it incredibly difficult in future.

DT’s school’s approach which we supported was four hours a week in a homework club. The school and parents - high achieving international school- supported the students through their GCSE’s and A levels. DT’s got all A’s at GCSE and A level and 1st class degrees. Students went onto study at top universities across the world.
DT’s both completed grade 8 in their instruments and played sport at a high level. I have 100% no interest in them participating in schemes to reward for how many hours of study they completed- a stupid idea imo. If your DC’s need such an excessive amount of study time I think they are on the wrong course.

Aleaiactaest · 11/11/2022 10:28

@PalmTrees7 - I think a hardworking DC is good provided that they also have time to see friends (whether in person/online) and do a bit of a hobby, ideally some exercise or something creative to balance out.
However, a DC driven by fear working all hours is a recipe for disaster. So some teacher friends are worried about this side too.
My own theory is that due to the internet access all kids have they are far too much in the loop on the scare stories in the media, things like Oxbridge bias against grammar schools, med school competition, recession, war etc. So for some of the brightest the motivation is fear and that really is not good for their mental health long term. They are worried about how expensive uni has become etc and really feel the burden to get into a top course of top uni.
To me life is more about working out at a key age where you real passions and talents lie and putting your mind to what you want. If it changes, that is fine but find out who you are and where you would like to go.

My ideal exam DC would be doing about 8-10 hours a week, still fit in 3-4 hours of exercise (ideally with friends) and some reading/drawing or music etc and take proper time off in the holidays to catch up with friends. Take good notes, good quality revision in a calm frame of mind. So basically calmly keeping on top of things but having a good balance. No different for adults. Healthy friendships being the most important thing.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 11/11/2022 10:20

Tbf you don’t don’t take your job home but your is doing 42 hours schooling a week including those five hours

PalmTrees7 · 11/11/2022 10:18

@Aleaiactaest

That sounds fantastic and very much like the DC’s school. The vast majority of DC working extremely hard and trying to get the best grades they are capable of.

The 4 hours a week, GCSEs don’t matter crew are going to find it incredibly difficult in future.

Aleaiactaest · 11/11/2022 09:30

The thread is fascinating.
In my DCs superselective grammar (London area) teachers have actually commented that DCs this year (Year 11, 12, and 13) seem to be working far harder and much more worried than past years about grades. The comments have been made primarily by extra curricular heads because of lack of full engagement in drama, music and sports as compared to pre Covid years. So in this school they have the problem that the DC themselves are so worried about getting top grades they are working extremely hard. Sounds like they will all do incredibly well (in their academic exams, that is). They appear worried about uni places etc and not getting jobs in a recessionary environment. They are worried about GCSE and A levels being harder and they think they need to get top grades so as not to compare too unfavourably to the Covid cohort.
So there is that side too in some schools. I have heard the same from friends who are teachers in the top selective private schools. All grade focus coming from the kids themselves. The teachers being confused why these cohorts as so incredibly academically focussed.

Rainbowandbirdhouse · 11/11/2022 09:20

Meanwhile the DC’s school is running a competition across all year groups with prizes for DC who complete the most hours of revision in the run up to their winter exams/mocks.

I agree with doing revision regularly, but somehow hate this idea. More competition and pressure...and students can technically be 'revising' for hours without getting too much done. The quality of the revision is most important imho.

PalmTrees7 · 11/11/2022 08:35

@Rainbowandbirdhouse

That’s because this thread has become a support group for parents of DC who are not working hard enough.

Meanwhile the DC’s school is running a competition across all year groups with prizes for DC who complete the most hours of revision in the run up to their winter exams/mocks.

GloomyDarkness · 10/11/2022 11:21

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 10/11/2022 10:42

If you were both keyworkers they should absolutely have given you a place, all of ours were accommodated at school. That's not right.

They didn't offer school places past Y8 at DC state school - older than that it was judged they were fine at home even if there was no-one else there for bulk of the day.

It only started to change after a very long time for individuals on case by case bases when it became clear that some GCSE students had no internet access at home or who were deemed vulnerable.

I don't find Silversaxo experiences are that unusual - it was a very mixed experiences with friends and family in other bits of UK - some schools and teachers going above and beyond and others finding it much harder to get going with the new conditions.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 10/11/2022 10:42

If you were both keyworkers they should absolutely have given you a place, all of ours were accommodated at school. That's not right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread