Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be livid that year 11 DS thinks 4-5 hours/week homework/revision is enough for GCSEs?

756 replies

Hotdaisies22 · 06/11/2022 11:48

DS in year 11. Bright boy but has always been poor at doing homework at home despite being well set up for it at home (quiet desk space etc). Does his homework at homework club after school -Mon - Thurs max 5 hrs week (thats only time homework club room is available at his school). We're having conversations that he now needs to up his game these next few months before GCSEs and start studying /revising at home extra time. Getting massive push back and causing a lot of friction. He thinks what he does is enough and no intention of doing more "at the end of a tiring school day" (he only has a 20 min journey to school). What are other year 11s doing? (I'm trying to have conversation with his school on this but so far they've been rubbish - no reply!)

OP posts:
PeekAtYou · 06/11/2022 12:33

Yabu

Firstly, he needs to peak in May/June next year.

Secondly, is homework club a good use of his time ? My kids would have chatted with their friends and would have been more efficient at home.

Thirdly, Yabu thinking that revising longer means better results. If revision quality is poor, the amount of time sat at his desk won't help even if he did 6 hours a day.

HelenWick · 06/11/2022 12:33

It depends what he has been doing all year.It's November! Neither of my 2 did any work until March/April then it was minimal. They got all 7-9s. A Level is a different ball game though.
Out of interest - those who do 20 hours a week for GCSE what do they do at A Level? The same? Or does it become overwhleming

nomoreflyingducks · 06/11/2022 12:33

Most state schools (in this area at least) do a 6.5 hr day so mon-thurs he's doing a 7.5hr day...not far off the average working day. At least when you are working you get paid. I think it's hard to keep motivated when the reward seems so far away and not guaranteed. I think he's doing okay myself. But if you want him to do more work, what incentives are you offering?

lifeturnsonadime · 06/11/2022 12:32

@Hotdaisies22

From a practical point of view have you tried approaching this a different way?

Achieving top grades is lovely but is not necessarily the be all and end all. Perhaps talk to him about what he wants to do next, is it A-Levels? What are the entry requirements that he actually needs to get to the next point?

That will, hopefully, help him focus on what he actually needs to do.

A focus on the number of hour of study 'to do his best' can be a bit overwhelming especially over 9/10 subjects.

TumbleFryer · 06/11/2022 12:32

PalmTrees7 · 06/11/2022 11:54

Of course YANBU. 4 hours a week is nowhere near enough work for most DC to even pass GCSEs, never mind get good grades.

Ime many teenagers (particularly boys) are not able to see the link between hard work in year 11 and long-term opportunities. I would therefore be coming down hard on him and removing all privileges until he is doing 2.5 hours of revision on school nights (ideally 3) and 4 hours a day at weekends.

Time to get strict OP!

I’m not sure if your being serious or not. An hour a day is plenty for a bright child. I certainly didn’t do more than that when I was at school and I got straight As.

Holidayhomehell · 06/11/2022 12:32

5 hours is a lot for a young person I feel. However, if you are worried try speaking to school again and see what they advise.

I feel that young people should be able to pass their exams in school through working hard in school, completing their homework
and some revision. Any more is madness.

toastfiend · 06/11/2022 12:32

PalmTrees7 · 06/11/2022 11:54

Of course YANBU. 4 hours a week is nowhere near enough work for most DC to even pass GCSEs, never mind get good grades.

Ime many teenagers (particularly boys) are not able to see the link between hard work in year 11 and long-term opportunities. I would therefore be coming down hard on him and removing all privileges until he is doing 2.5 hours of revision on school nights (ideally 3) and 4 hours a day at weekends.

Time to get strict OP!

This is a hugely binary way of looking at things. Different people need different levels of revision and most won't need as much as you suggest unless there are other needs that require a high level of ongoing support. I certainly didn't do as much as OP's DS for my GCSEs and I achieved all As and A*s. I was at boardinf school so no parents breathing down my neck, learning to motivate oneselfand assess your own learning needs is also a valuable life skill. Similarly for uni, I had a life outside of revision when finals were coming up, and still achieved a 2.1. Sure, I might have got a First if I'd worked harder, but I also had an amazing time, made friends for life, and gained a huge amount of confidence and other life skills that have taken me further in my career than a First would have done.

The schedule you are suggesting is totally unrealistic, doesn't allow the poor boy any chance of a life outside of GCSE revision and is a recipe for creating wider problems. I went to a highly academic, highly competitive school where a lot of the kids were required to work like this by their parents. The prevalence of anorexia, anxiety, and other mental health problems was high, and primarily among those with parents like you. Most of them didn't do any better than those of us with "normal" working schedules, and in fact, several did worse because by the time they reached examination time they were mentally and physically exhausted.

RagzRebooted · 06/11/2022 12:32

I probably did 5 hours for my entire year 11. DS1 did maybe 2 hours a week homework and barely any revision, same for DS2 who is currently year 11. They have the time and space, but I'm not forcing them to do anything it's their responsibility and they understand the consequences.

However, they're all bright enough to get 6/7s without trying and they aren't bothered about getting more. DS1 got enough to get into A levels which he is now putting a lot more work into because he knows he needs good grades for uni. He will probably get As and Bs, but could and may well get A stars if he decides it's worth the effort.

DS2 wants to do forestry and they only need GCSE at 5 and above for that, he will easily manage that without revision. No desire to go to uni, he wants to work at 18.

Littlewhitecat · 06/11/2022 12:31

This is going to sound harsh but you need to look at your definition of bright. Your son is at a fee paying school but is predicted 4s in some subjects? My DD did less work than you are describing and got all 7s 8s and 9s. If she had worked harder she would have done better but it was more than good enough and importantly she was happy. If he's as bright as you think he is then I'd be talking to his school about his predicted grades and why they aren't so great. Also you made the decision to send him to a fee paying school not him - he doesn't owe you your perceived sacrifice.

Fairislefandango · 06/11/2022 12:31

The reformed GCSEs have more content, and most have no coursework or controlled assessments. All exams are terminal and can't be re-sat like the old modular system.

Quite a few posters probably did their exams before modular and coursework were a thing, or did subjects where coursework wasn't involved. I certainly did!

jellybe · 06/11/2022 12:31

Is that 4/5 hours on top of his homework or all the school work he is doing? If it is extra on top of what is being set by school I think you'll be fine. If it is all the work he is doing each week then yes I think he needs to be doing more.

Can you put some sort of incentive to go with getting good grades? It is hard at that age to see the point of working hard without any tangible reward - which grades aren't when you are 16.

Also, does he know how to revise? It is a skill that is more than just reading your notes, can be hard to study if you don't know how if that makes sense.

RobertaFirmino · 06/11/2022 12:30

I am reminded of an old colleague who came into work one morning complaining her DD got a B in her Maths GCSE. This wasn't good enough apparently. Her DD killed herself not long after. Please don't be that woman, please.

pointythings · 06/11/2022 12:29

@Hotdaisies22 I understand how powerless you must be feeling, but you can't force your son to study - because it will achieve nothing. If he ends up having to learn a really hard lesson, you will all have to accept that. There are other paths than the standard A-levels >> University.

taliaG · 06/11/2022 12:28

School is really tiring, because you're learning news things all day, thinking really hard, pushing your brain at the boundary of its ability. You do get to a point where your brain is just full and doing any more is not productive.

Ice he is submitting all the required coursework, finishing the homework that has been set, I'd say that's enough until a month or 2 before the exams when he should come up with a revision plan, flash cards, practice exams etc.

Blueink · 06/11/2022 12:28

YABU to be ‘livid’. The school day is tiring, they are still dealing with the Covid fall out, including extended school hours in some cases. Well-being is more important and it seems like he’s going to school and keeping up with homework, more than many.

Hotdaisies22 · 06/11/2022 12:27

Reigatecastle "I think you need to find a hobby (or a job, if you don't have one) so you spend less time fussing". How patronising! I work full time (more than FT actually) in a demanding job and don't have time for 'hobbies' or 'fussing' I can assure you.

To those saying 'I didn't work and got top grades or my DCs didn't do much and got top grades' - that's great, you/your DCs are obviously very clever! My DS is predicted mostly low grades on current trajectory so its very different.
I'm not expecting him to be doing lots of revison now in November, I'm expecting him to acknowledge that he'll need to up his game in coming months. His refusal to acknowledge that and to think zero revison/study outside the few hours midweek at homework club is going to be enough right through to exams to get him good grades is what prompted me to post today.

OP posts:
pointythings · 06/11/2022 12:27

@lifeturnsonadime I couldn't agree with you more. If he needs that much work, the school isn't doing its job. If a Yr11 student needs 22+ hours of extra work to get the grades, the school is a complete failure. My DD2 got her grades despite having lost her father the year before, suffering from fibromyalgia and losing her grandmother 2 weeks before the exams started - she's bright but not genius material and she absolutely didn't work those kinds of hours; it would not have been possible for her to do that without ending up in hospital. GCSEs have toughened up over the years, but for a child who is genuinely bright and is at a good school they are perfectly achievable without basically working another full school week on top of the existing one. And that includes getting high grades.

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 12:26

YABU

He’s doing an hour a day ON TOP of the 5 hours he’s doing as normal at school.

When he gets home he needs a break.

If he’s predicted a 5 in English there is no way he’d get an 8 or 9 no matter how hard he studies.

So instead of making himself ill with stress it’s better to accept that he’s going to get around a 5 and keep doing what he’s doing.

I get that it’s frustrating for you, especially if you know he can do better but it sounds like he’s already doing a lot more than most students which is great!

Does he know what subject he wants to study after this and are there minimum grade requirements?
As this is the only thing that will encourage him to study more.

Itsabitnotcold · 06/11/2022 12:25

It's plenty. Parents being on your back while not knowing anything about what you're actually doing causes so much stress and is probably making it harder for him to find the motivation to revise. Just let him manage it himself.

CarPoor · 06/11/2022 12:25

Bearing in mind that most children will start getting a job in Yr 11, that will likely take up one weekend day or an evening or two. Plus extracurriculars like sport or music. They've also got to have time to actually enjoy being a teenager ans socialise. These things will be equally beneficial if not more in the long run than just good grades.

Doing hours a day of revision for a year at 15/16 is excessive and they will burnout. Yes they will need to up the work as it comes to February/March time.

bewarethetides · 06/11/2022 12:24

OP, I strongly suggest you make an appointment with your son's form tutor to (a) see where your son is now, and (b) discuss how much 'extra' revision time is sensible and appropriate for him. Roughly an extra hour a day for revision, not homework, will likely be the answer, so yes, strongly suspect you are expecting too much, unless your son didn't do anything for the last 4 years...

Florenz · 06/11/2022 12:24

Tell him that he is competing against all the other 16 year olds in the country. What kind of job does he want in the future? Does he think all other kids his age are only doing an hour a night, 4 nights a week?

LindaEllen · 06/11/2022 12:23

You're 'livid' that you have a son who attends a homework club (which I assume isn't compulsory) and wants/expects to be able to chill when at home? Really?

As long as he's keeping up with his work and getting consistently good grades in homework/mocks, what's the problem? If he's attending an hour a night homework club he must only be getting in gone 4, then having his dinner, then how much time is actually left before he has to have a shower and go to bed?

I'd encourage a little work at the weekends, perhaps two hours each morning, but for goodness sake, the time will come during A Levels and uni if he goes when he's tied to his desk - GCSEs aren't the time for that.

NoodleSnow · 06/11/2022 12:23

It’s not 4-5 hours a week. It’s 4-5 hours a week on top of a full school day. Lots of their lessons will be revision/consolidating what they know. I think the school day + 1hr is a reasonable amount of time to expect them to be working.
If the school sends them on study leave early before the start of exams, it might be time now to start introducing the idea that keeping up with school day + 1 hour during study leave would be a good goal, but if he’s getting the work done I don’t see any reason to do more at the moment.

AllTheOtherNamesWereTaken · 06/11/2022 12:22

I virtually did any revision and didn't get anything below a B. I'm not super smart but listened (as well as messing about a bit with my mates) and did my required work. He should definitely cram what he can closer to the time and will hard at his coursework but I really don't think it's necessary to be revising this far away from exams