Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be livid that year 11 DS thinks 4-5 hours/week homework/revision is enough for GCSEs?

756 replies

Hotdaisies22 · 06/11/2022 11:48

DS in year 11. Bright boy but has always been poor at doing homework at home despite being well set up for it at home (quiet desk space etc). Does his homework at homework club after school -Mon - Thurs max 5 hrs week (thats only time homework club room is available at his school). We're having conversations that he now needs to up his game these next few months before GCSEs and start studying /revising at home extra time. Getting massive push back and causing a lot of friction. He thinks what he does is enough and no intention of doing more "at the end of a tiring school day" (he only has a 20 min journey to school). What are other year 11s doing? (I'm trying to have conversation with his school on this but so far they've been rubbish - no reply!)

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 06/11/2022 20:14

theremustonlybeone · 06/11/2022 19:17

Those discussing Oxbridge are fooling themselves. First they do expect a set standard and interview all candidates. Many exceptional state schools now stream DC in sixth form knowing their aspirations are Oxbridge. They are bright and apply under the 'state' umbrella having spent formative years in private school and then moved across. I heard there is a local school in cambridge who have high number going to the university. Hills Road Sixth Form College i believe and they had 69 offers from Oxbridge and it is a 'state' school. They all play the system and pretend they are taking more kids from the state system

This doesn't surprise me.

The state school that I went to had a disproportionate number of Oxbridge entrants per year even back in the 90s. Truth be told it was a school that people paid a premium to attend via housing prices and private tuition topped it up.

My nephew goes there now and is on the Oxbridge track. The children who go there are the kids of accountants, consultants and lawyers.

These things don't happen by chance.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 20:12

theremustonlybeone · 06/11/2022 19:17

Those discussing Oxbridge are fooling themselves. First they do expect a set standard and interview all candidates. Many exceptional state schools now stream DC in sixth form knowing their aspirations are Oxbridge. They are bright and apply under the 'state' umbrella having spent formative years in private school and then moved across. I heard there is a local school in cambridge who have high number going to the university. Hills Road Sixth Form College i believe and they had 69 offers from Oxbridge and it is a 'state' school. They all play the system and pretend they are taking more kids from the state system

Oxford and Cambridge are wise to this. You have to put in UCAS not just your sixth form, but also your college where you took GCSEs. You can’t qualify as a state school widening access candidate if you were in private school for GCSEs.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/11/2022 19:46

They find out far more about themselves by challenging themselves, overcoming barriers and trying new things. Four hours dossing on a sofa or playing CoD doesn’t really offer the same opportunities, does it?

Depends how you look at it. There’s such a thing as fun too. And wasting time. I couldn’t bear a rigid schedule of parental controlled activities. How do you factor their social life and just hanging out with friends in it?

Bogglebrain · 06/11/2022 19:36

@GloomyDarkness @LetYouGo
I don’t disagree with either of you!

I’ve explained to my DC the importance of exams on their future goals/the choices education gives them etc. till I’m blue in the face! My DH and I do support them but ultimately it’s their life and they have to put the effort in.

Katya22 · 06/11/2022 19:20

PalmTrees7 · 06/11/2022 11:54

Of course YANBU. 4 hours a week is nowhere near enough work for most DC to even pass GCSEs, never mind get good grades.

Ime many teenagers (particularly boys) are not able to see the link between hard work in year 11 and long-term opportunities. I would therefore be coming down hard on him and removing all privileges until he is doing 2.5 hours of revision on school nights (ideally 3) and 4 hours a day at weekends.

Time to get strict OP!

Confused My DS did half an hour on weekdays, two hours a day on weekends and got all As and B’s, one A*!
theremustonlybeone · 06/11/2022 19:17

Those discussing Oxbridge are fooling themselves. First they do expect a set standard and interview all candidates. Many exceptional state schools now stream DC in sixth form knowing their aspirations are Oxbridge. They are bright and apply under the 'state' umbrella having spent formative years in private school and then moved across. I heard there is a local school in cambridge who have high number going to the university. Hills Road Sixth Form College i believe and they had 69 offers from Oxbridge and it is a 'state' school. They all play the system and pretend they are taking more kids from the state system

CaronPoivre · 06/11/2022 18:58

PollyEsther · 06/11/2022 16:50

Why wouldn't you, if you've done the 'parenting' and they're still making the wrong choice? These are 15/16 year olds, not 5/6 year olds. You can take a horse to water, but there is absolutely no way to force a 16 year old to study, parenting or no parenting.

Maybe, those of them who (like mine) think they can just coast through with zero effort, need to find out the very hard way, that it just isn't true. College exists, they can retake: often alongside the course they want to do. Failing a GCSE first time round really doesn't ruin anybody's life.

Who said anything about forcing them? Failing a GCSE can ruin lives for a good few years. Educate them so they can make choices as adults, at eighteen. That starts long before GCSEs.

CaronPoivre · 06/11/2022 18:52

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/11/2022 17:04

‘Structured activities from 8.00am to 10.00pm every day sounds like a bloody nightmare and a recipe for disaster. How do they find out anything about themselves in that set up? People need time to breathe.

Oxbridge don’t pick from public schools anymore and don’t look for ‘structured activities’

We have 4 dc between us. I’d say none of the eldest 3 put all their effort into GCSE nor A level, but they had to have a life too. All are employed in competitive high profile jobs.

DD has just started 6 th form. I’ll be allowing her to have a life too.

Breathing can be done perfectly well alongside other activities.

They find out far more about themselves by challenging themselves, overcoming barriers and trying new things. Four hours dossing on a sofa or playing CoD doesn’t really offer the same opportunities, does it?

Oxbridge pick a disproportionate number of children from independent schools still. It’s improving but you still need very high grades regardless of your school. Oxbridge may not be everyone’s choice but without those grades, it’s not going to be a choice, is it?

A life can be lived in many ways. Getting drunk on cider or alcopops in the local park or ‘just chilling’ doesn’t strike me as ‘living life to the full’.

Structured doesn’t mean no time for chosen activities or continual Higher level maths. It means a routine that includes academic, social, physical, community service and artistic activities too. It means avoiding doing absolutely nothing for the majority of their waking hours.

Harrysmummy246 · 06/11/2022 18:45

@pointythings I do too, having supported students in various guises, seen my sister struggle with university pressure (a student in her group did take their own life) and only learnt for myself, how to revise, in my late 30s. I've seen so many school refusing anxious students, in a school known for good results etc.

Just hope to strike the balance later on with DS (he's only 5 now)

pointythings · 06/11/2022 18:28

@Harrysmummy246 I feel very strongly about this. DD2 is now at uni, 2nd year in a STEM subject. Currently sitting at the high end of a 2:1. Am I pushing for her to get a First? Hell, no. Her health has deteriorated to such an extent that she now needs a wheelchair. She has PTSD and anxiety. She doesn't have a diagnosis for her physical symptoms (NHS in a state) but does now have an autism diagnosis. And she's still living independently, achieving and having a life. I want her to enjoy life now, because we don't know what her future is going to hold.

Harrysmummy246 · 06/11/2022 17:48

pointythings · 06/11/2022 17:41

Work smarter, not harder is definitely a thing. My two both had mocks in November, which they revised for but not exhaustively. They got useful feedback on weak points to be worked on, which they duly did. They then had more mocks in February, which they revised much harder for. That was interesting because they both did worse in those. From Easter onwards they were doing 2-3 hours every week night and 3-4 on weekends, with planned days off. They both far exceeded their November mocks grades because their study was planned, targeted and supported by excellent revision classes at school. And they still got to have a life. There's a balance to be had here, there's a need to acknowledge that one size absolutely does not fit all and that excessive pressure is harmful.

THank you @pointythings for showing the middle ground. Success is more than just grades, it's coming out a whole human being at the other end.

AbreathofFrenchair · 06/11/2022 17:45

Wehadabetamax · 06/11/2022 17:31

I agree. Getting home from work to find that my 16 yr old son has taken an overdose was much worse. Luckily after some time in hospital he was ok, but the amount of revision he did, didn't seem too important after that.

How absolutely awful. I hope he's ok now? And you too.

AbreathofFrenchair · 06/11/2022 17:43

PalmTrees7 · 06/11/2022 15:08

Frankly I think there is an infectious sense of delusion on this thread whereby parents whose DC aren’t working are falling over themselves to say how this is fine, they got top grades with no work in 1983 and actually, grades don’t matter anyway as Aunt May’s cousin’s budgie is a billionaire with no GCSEs.

In reality, the DC who work the hardest will be those who earn, and get, the top grades next year. Sorry folks, but 4 hours a week is not going to result in good grades at GCSE for the vast majority. In an ideal world, DC would have the self-discipline to work themselves, but often this isn’t yet present for 15 year old boys. It is therefore our role as parents to step in and implement structure- and yes, that includes a good amount of study time.

I also find the faux outrage at a parent who has paid tens of thousands for their DC to be gift from private education expecting that DC to work hard bizarre. Clearly expecting straight 9s just because you have paid isn’t acceptable if the DC is not capable of that, but asking them to keep their side of the bargain and take advantage of the benefits they’ve been given is surely common sense and normal.

No delusion here at all. My sons on track for high 9s and 1 low 8 for a subject he doesnt like.

Why would I push him to do 22 hours plus revision a week as someone on here is doing when he is already getting the highest he can get? I appreciate the may be the exception.but with his peers, they are all looking at 7s and 8s too and they don't seem to revise either.

Our school are excellent at getting the children to achieve high results and they are exceptional at supporting children who need it to get those grades without burn out too.

It was the OP who made the choice to pay for private education. It just reaffirms the obvious that if a child wants to learn they will and putting them in private education doesn't mean they will all of a sudden start putting the effort in.

If schools aren't satisfied that a full school day, plus an hours homework a night and then 17 hours a week extra work on top of that is not enough them I would be questioning the school not my childs ability

pointythings · 06/11/2022 17:41

Work smarter, not harder is definitely a thing. My two both had mocks in November, which they revised for but not exhaustively. They got useful feedback on weak points to be worked on, which they duly did. They then had more mocks in February, which they revised much harder for. That was interesting because they both did worse in those. From Easter onwards they were doing 2-3 hours every week night and 3-4 on weekends, with planned days off. They both far exceeded their November mocks grades because their study was planned, targeted and supported by excellent revision classes at school. And they still got to have a life. There's a balance to be had here, there's a need to acknowledge that one size absolutely does not fit all and that excessive pressure is harmful.

savehannah · 06/11/2022 17:38

Wow, my DD definitely did less than that and came away with a decent set of grades. Sure she could have done even better with three hours work a night but it wasn't worth ruining our relationship by hassling her more about it.

LBFseBrom · 06/11/2022 17:37

I sincerely hope you don't go on at your son about the sacrifices you have made for his education, there's nothing worse.

Leave him alone, he may surprise you.

Harrysmummy246 · 06/11/2022 17:32

PalmTrees7 · 06/11/2022 17:22

@Harrysmummy246

Ime the ‘quality over quantity’ cliche is often used to justify laziness. 1 hour a day won’t cut it regardless of how ‘high quality’ it is.

My view is that there needs to be a combination of both quality and quantity.

Willful misunderstanding there @PalmTrees7
I didn't even say one hour a day was enough, you've put those words in my mouth.

But i'd take 1 hour quality (i.e. probably broken up into two chunks) of 3 hours enforced time which might just be filled for the sake of filling it. For example, I know that one hour supported learning with a tutor would probably trump 3 hours floundering if unsure. Especially if that tutor also ensures the student is finding out what revision techniques work for them. And if they're actually any good, they'll be advising their students to be balanced and not burn out.

Might be why my last student, predicted 5-6 in maths came out with a 7.....

Wehadabetamax · 06/11/2022 17:31

Theydoyaknow · 06/11/2022 15:32

Nothing worse than your child not achieving the grades they need/are capable of

Believe me, there is a LOT LOT worse than this.

I agree. Getting home from work to find that my 16 yr old son has taken an overdose was much worse. Luckily after some time in hospital he was ok, but the amount of revision he did, didn't seem too important after that.

Ericaequites · 06/11/2022 17:27

I attended a very competitive American private school. At 15/16, 2.5-3 hours of homework per night and 4-5 hours over the weekend . My school explicitly taught study skills. If you want top results, you must work hard. Young people do need one full weekend day off to relax, help in the houdse, see friends, and so on.

PalmTrees7 · 06/11/2022 17:22

@Harrysmummy246

Ime the ‘quality over quantity’ cliche is often used to justify laziness. 1 hour a day won’t cut it regardless of how ‘high quality’ it is.

My view is that there needs to be a combination of both quality and quantity.

Harrysmummy246 · 06/11/2022 17:22

MultiTulip · 06/11/2022 14:42

I was on a Master’s course wjth someone who was used to putting in similar amounts of overwork. By Master’s level she was putting in 70 hour weeks and still having to ask for extensions. She’d never learned to study efficiently, she’d just put in vast amounts of time and kept scraping through until she reached a level she couldn’t cope at. She’d have been useless as an employee because she thought overwork could compensate for everything.

And the more I've tutored, then recently studied for a job- related qualification, the more i realised I didn't know how to revise best for me. So I figured that out at the age of 39 when trying to study whilst also working and having a young child. Sleep was far more valuable to me (and I always look at my tutees and if they look haggard, tell them sleep is more important)

Harrysmummy246 · 06/11/2022 17:17

HauntersGonnaHaunt · 06/11/2022 13:56

That poster couldn't spell laissez-faire correctly. They should have put more hours into their French revision.

Didn't even notice but 😂

This person seems to be equating quantity with quality

FlirtyMelons · 06/11/2022 17:14

A lot of what they do after Xmas will be revision in school anyway so I would just leave them to it. They have to learn to manage things themselves,
babying them does them no favours.

If they are bright GCSEs aren't difficult,
DS1 didn't do loads outside of school but did what he needed to nearer the exams.
His school didn't finish till 2 weeks before exams were over so he did plenty of revision in the school day. He got really good grades.

There are some MN parents who certainly do not reflect any parents I have come across in RL, my DCs were at a private school and most were definitely not as controlling/helicopter as many on here!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/11/2022 17:14

Ime many teenagers (particularly boys) are not able to see the link between hard work in year 11 and long-term opportunities. I would therefore be coming down hard on him and removing all privileges until he is doing 2.5 hours of revision on school nights (ideally 3) and 4 hours a day at weekends.

IME as a secondary teacher who has taught millions of Year 11boys, they suddenly wake up after Christmas and really turn it round. The majority l taught were like this but still came out with a clutch of good GCSE.

So l disagree with your statement based on teaching about 1500 y11 boys over the years.

GreenWasTheColour · 06/11/2022 17:13

There is nothing more ridiculous than the argument of working excessive hours now because 'work won't be 9-5' as a poster upthread said. If we tell our kids their future will be unrelenting, stressful and exhausting so their life now should be unrelenting, stressful and exhausting to prepare them for it then how on earth are we incentivising them?

We shouldn't fetishise presenteeism, long hours and pointless busy-work in the workplace or in school years. Year 11s need smart study skills; not measured in hours but in usefulness. Downtime is vital for knowledge consolidation, retention and deeper thinking skills as well as for mental health. I send my children to private school but in my mind the investment is in the nurturing approach of our chosen school and the small class sizes - I'd be horrified if they were putting pressure on students to work 50hr + weeks. The person who said there is nothing worse than a child not achieving their grades is tragically blinkered and all the academic success in the world can't compensate for such a pitiful (and dangerous) world view. There are countless worse options, some of them explained in the thread.