Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give people second hand gifts

230 replies

GADDay · 06/11/2022 09:31

Please be honest. Is this a really crap thing to do.

The gifts are good quality, in exceptional condition and if bought new, would cost £100's.

I would prefer to receive repurposed or second hand. So a bit biased.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RobertaFirmino · 09/11/2022 15:08

@Sn0tnose I like the cut of your jib!

stuntbubbles · 09/11/2022 13:16

@Sn0tnose 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Sn0tnose · 09/11/2022 12:37

GADDay · 09/11/2022 05:45

Gosh this got ugly.

Clearly the Greta Thunbergs amongst us must be middle class idiots. That somehow giving a shit is just a bit of naval gazing bullshit. Well fuck that. I live my life as well as I can with as little impact as possible.

The alternative is worse. Doing fuck all because you can't be arsed, because second hand things give you the 'ick'.

Shame on you for your passive aggressive refusal to see what is right in front of us and your refusal to wake up to what we face. We are fucked because that crap/shit/icky stiff goes somewhere when you put it in the bin. Landfill. We don't need fucking Greta Thunberg to tell us that. Why some people think they are above others beggars belief and then when called on it turn around and tell people that do actually give a shot thay they are nasty middle class lefty greenies.

I started this thread with the best of intentions. The poll tells me what I need to know. For the other 30% - you rock on just living with your heads in the sand.

@GADDay Buckle up then, because I’m quite happy to argue with you too.

You have spectacularly missed the point I was making. I mean, not just a little bit, but to the extent that I’m wondering whether you actually read any of what I wrote. I was asked to justify why I personally wouldn’t want second hand gifts. I think I’ve explained myself quite clearly. If you think it’s just a case of having the ick then I’m not going to waste either of our time by trying to explain it yet again. I’ll just accept that you don’t have any understanding of OCD type conditions. You asked for honesty, which I think I gave you. If I’d realised you just wanted an echo chamber with lots of pats on the back for being so environmentally aware, I would have just scrolled on.

I do give a huge shit about the environment. Not just because I have much loved young nieces, nephews and God children who are going to have to grow up with the effects of climate change but because I have medical conditions that mean when it gets to extreme temperatures I struggle to catch my breath and have to go to work huffing and puffing like I smoke 20 Marlboro for breakfast. I do think we’re fucked because our governments aren’t matching the efforts of people like you, who commit to buying nothing new. If you disagree and think that they are doing enough to turn things around, then it’s not me who has her head in the sand.

I live in a one bedroom flat. I’m on pre payment meters so my gas and electricity usage has been closely monitored and often rationed for years. I don’t have children. I don’t drive. I walk as many places as I can and rely on public transport for the rest. I don’t go abroad so no flights or ferry journeys. I’ve never smoked. My clothes are mended until they can’t be mended anymore, at which point they either become indoor clothes or cleaning rags. My shoes are re heeled and re-soled until they are beyond repair. I don’t have a washing machine because it died after years of being repaired and I’m still saving up to replace it, so I use my mum’s. No tumble drier. My furniture was new when I bought it thirty odd years ago, but it won’t be replaced until it falls apart beyond repair. I live near lots of farms so it’s often cheaper for me to buy food locally than Dutch apples or Cuban melons, so I’ve done what I can to reduce the air miles on my food. My food waste all goes into my mum’s compost bin and I eat a lot of what she grows. My council is very strict on recycling. I can’t remember the last time I filled up an entire black bag for landfill. I don’t buy anything unless I need it and it gets used until it’s falling apart. Admittedly, not just because of the environment but, like millions of others, because we have to stretch our money as far as we can. Please do explain to me where you think I’m slacking and what more I could possibly do to reduce my carbon footprint. I’m genuinely interested.

I don’t think I’m better than anyone else, for any reason. I’m not looking down on you for what you’re trying to do. What I thoroughly object to, however, is being patronised and lectured about not having any understanding of what we face because I don’t want second hand crap, by people sat in their big three bedroom houses, with a couple of cars sat on the drive and their lap tops flicking between the Air B&B they’ve just booked in a dying village in Cornwall, and their long haul flight bookings to sunnier climes, while their cleaner runs herself ragged picking up Barbie dolls and hoovering up after the family Cockerdoodlepoo, DH texts to remind them to marinade the beef in time for dinner and they congratulate themselves for snapping up a second hand, barely worn pair of Jojo Maman Bebe wellingtons for their DC. In fact, it fucks me right off.

And nobody has called anyone a nasty middle class lefty greeny. I did call someone a name I perhaps shouldn’t have, but that name had nothing to do with their class, their politics or their efforts to do their bit for the environment.

BlueWalnut · 09/11/2022 07:58

The simplest way around all of this is to agree not to exchange gifts between adults. I make nice dinners for my parents and they look after my house when I’m away, so we help one another but we haven’t exchanged gifts in a long time.

GADDay · 09/11/2022 05:45

Gosh this got ugly.

Clearly the Greta Thunbergs amongst us must be middle class idiots. That somehow giving a shit is just a bit of naval gazing bullshit. Well fuck that. I live my life as well as I can with as little impact as possible.

The alternative is worse. Doing fuck all because you can't be arsed, because second hand things give you the 'ick'.

Shame on you for your passive aggressive refusal to see what is right in front of us and your refusal to wake up to what we face. We are fucked because that crap/shit/icky stiff goes somewhere when you put it in the bin. Landfill. We don't need fucking Greta Thunberg to tell us that. Why some people think they are above others beggars belief and then when called on it turn around and tell people that do actually give a shot thay they are nasty middle class lefty greenies.

I started this thread with the best of intentions. The poll tells me what I need to know. For the other 30% - you rock on just living with your heads in the sand.

OP posts:
Greenginghamdress · 08/11/2022 14:36

If it looks new, in good condition, and you think they would like it then it's completely fine.
I don't like it when the things look obviously old though, I'd prefer people to say they weren't giving gifts.
For my partners birthday, BIL gave him some vegan truffles, they had expired. When he opened the box they had melted and reformed, plus a bottle of beer that had obviously been in their fridge for years. Scruffy IMO.

Needmorelego · 08/11/2022 14:30

@Sn0tnose I understand why you don't want secondhand hand. Hope everything else with you is ok 💐

GenerationSuper · 08/11/2022 14:08

As a pp has said, this thread is relating to second hand gifts, not flea ridden carpets or filthy second hand underwear. I appreciate that growing up with these things must have been extremely difficult, I didn't grow up in particularly amazing circumstances myself but I don't shoehorn that into conversations that aren't even relevant.

Wow. @Sn0tnose shared her views on the topic of second hand gifts adding her personal angle to this thread, which was brave, so no shoehorning here, why ever you would say that but you did shoehorn a bit here yourself 😂.

Sn0tnose · 08/11/2022 14:04

alfreddo82 · 08/11/2022 13:45

@Sn0tnose

Ach give yourself peace.

My comment wasn't actually aimed at you, I was referring to previous threads on MN where posters have looked down on second hand books, but my original comment still stands.

As a pp has said, this thread is relating to second hand gifts, not flea ridden carpets or filthy second hand underwear. I appreciate that growing up with these things must have been extremely difficult, I didn't grow up in particularly amazing circumstances myself but I don't shoehorn that into conversations that aren't even relevant.

If you say it wasn’t aimed at me, then ok. I don’t have a particular memory about threads on second hand books. Or scarves, come to that. So I maintain that it wasn’t an unreasonable assumption that you may have been referring to me when I said I’d want to chuck a book in the bin.

I didn’t shoehorn anything anywhere. The OP asked what people thought about second hand gifts. I said I thought it would depend on who the recipient was. If it was me, I wouldn’t want it. I then got asked to justify myself by more than one poster. I’m perfectly fucking aware the OP wasn’t proposing to buy anyone a flea ridden carpet so don’t ‘ach’ me.

Titsflyingsouth · 08/11/2022 13:51

If it was something I really loved/wanted in good condition (eg an interesting book, a silky scarf, a leather handbag, craft supplies etc) then I'd be delighted.

But it's some tut that I'm not remotely interested in - random crappy smellies, some ornament with 'Live, Laugh Love' written on it etc then I honestly would rather you didn't bother.

alfreddo82 · 08/11/2022 13:45

@Sn0tnose

Ach give yourself peace.

My comment wasn't actually aimed at you, I was referring to previous threads on MN where posters have looked down on second hand books, but my original comment still stands.

As a pp has said, this thread is relating to second hand gifts, not flea ridden carpets or filthy second hand underwear. I appreciate that growing up with these things must have been extremely difficult, I didn't grow up in particularly amazing circumstances myself but I don't shoehorn that into conversations that aren't even relevant.

Sn0tnose · 08/11/2022 13:22

Needmorelego · 08/11/2022 12:49

@Sn0tnose also I personally buy things secondhand not because it's secondhand - but because I want that particular thing and if it's there in front of me in a charity shop I will get it.
I don't go seeking out secondhand stuff to be all environmentaly friendly etc. I just buy something because I want it.

And I get that too. I could see someone wearing a secondhand outfit and think they look fantastic. There is no part of me that is judging them or their stuff. I don’t think that I’m better than them because my cheap clothes are somehow better than their good quality second hand stuff. It’s just something that I would never do.

Sn0tnose · 08/11/2022 13:18

@Needmorelego

The thing is this thread is about gifts. Not secondhand hand clothes and old carpets.
Gifts such as a particular book someone wants to read, or a toy that can only be found secondhand because they don't make it anymore or a toy that was an unwanted gift and has been donated to a charity shop still sealed and unused or a vintage item (like an old camera). Yep, totally get that. My whole point throughout this thread has been that the giver needs to know the person they’re buying for. My experiences with second hand stuff means that I don’t see the difference between nasty old rubbish and unwanted gifts that someone like the OP has found at a bargain price and wants to pass on. I still have that same sense of ‘I don’t want it’. I don’t see something as vintage. I just see it as really, really old cast offs.

You don't have to answer this if you don't want to because it's your business not mine but I am curious about things like do you allow your children to accept prizes at a school raffle? For example I belong to a hobby group. Lego based (my user name probably gives that away). We as a group sometimes donate brand new sets as donations for raffles.
So a set would go from person who stores them - to me - to the school - stored by someone from the PTA - to the raffle winner.
Would your allow your children to have that prize?
What makes that different to person who stores the set - gives it to someone as a gift who already has it - they donate to a charity shop - someone buys it - gives to your child because they love Lego?
It’s easy for me to answer that because I don’t have children. But, if I’m being brutally honest, I wouldn’t buy a raffle ticket in the first place. Or if I did, it would be as a donation. My DH is a Star Wars lego fan. He loves it. He doesn’t buy second hand sets because he has the patience of a saint and knows it makes me really uncomfortable. My brother (who obviously grew up the same as me) isn’t like this and is fine with second hand. I do childcare for him and he bought some second hand stair gates for me. I went out and bought new ones so I didn’t have to have them. I’m not under the impression that things I buy in a shop are made in sterile conditions and are untouched by human hands. But that’s the thing; it’s not rational.

Needmorelego · 08/11/2022 12:49

@Sn0tnose also I personally buy things secondhand not because it's secondhand - but because I want that particular thing and if it's there in front of me in a charity shop I will get it.
I don't go seeking out secondhand stuff to be all environmentaly friendly etc. I just buy something because I want it.

Needmorelego · 08/11/2022 12:46

@Sn0tnose you obviously have issues over this and I understand. I hope I am not insulting or upsetting you in any way. The thing is this thread is about gifts. Not secondhand hand clothes and old carpets.
Gifts such as a particular book someone wants to read, or a toy that can only be found secondhand because they don't make it anymore or a toy that was an unwanted gift and has been donated to a charity shop still sealed and unused or a vintage item (like an old camera).
I wouldn't give secondhand clothes as a Christmas gift unless it was a very specific vintage designer thing that the person has asked for.
You don't have to answer this if you don't want to because it's your business not mine but I am curious about things like do you allow your children to accept prizes at a school raffle? For example I belong to a hobby group. Lego based (my user name probably gives that away). We as a group sometimes donate brand new sets as donations for raffles.
So a set would go from person who stores them - to me - to the school - stored by someone from the PTA - to the raffle winner.
Would your allow your children to have that prize?
What makes that different to person who stores the set - gives it to someone as a gift who already has it - they donate to a charity shop - someone buys it - gives to your child because they love Lego?

Athenen0ctua · 08/11/2022 12:46

@GenerationSuper I'm not sure why you are assuming posters are middle class? I'm not, I'm a lone parent on a low wage. I couldn't afford things that we want or need if I insisted on buying new.

I don't think anyone is suggesting giving a book in less than very good condition so I don't know where that came from either.

Sn0tnose · 08/11/2022 12:41

@GenerationSuper Thank you for understanding.

I want to make it very clear that I’m not judging anyone for buying second hand. If you find a bargain then great, good for you. I just refuse to be patronised and looked down on by anyone who thinks they’re Greta Thunberg because they’ve bought something second hand.

GenerationSuper · 08/11/2022 12:34

@Sn0tnose Thanks

Well said. So much ridiculous middle class hypocrisy. One word: privilege. With privilege comes a huge lack of understanding and empathy. Pet causes are just that pet causes, they don't change anything in the greater scheme of things. A book that looks like it's been read in a hot bath by about 50 people is fucking disgusting, if a friend gave that to me as a gift, I'd wonder about their why they think this is appropriate.

Sn0tnose · 08/11/2022 12:25

alfreddo82 · 07/11/2022 19:44

I find it absolutely hilarious the number of users on this platform that wax lyrical about climate change and the environment and vilify people like me with 4 children whilst simultaneously boaking at the thought of a second hand book or scarf. It's ridiculous.

Thankfully the popularity of Vinted indicates that a lot of people feel differently.

@alfreddo82 I believe I’m the only poster who has said they’d want to throw a book in the bin, so I’ll respond if I may?

I have never waxed, lyrically or otherwise, about the environment. Personally, I don’t think it matters how many of you buy your Boden from Oxfam; we’re all fucked. Secondly, I’m one of four myself. I don’t care how many kids you have. It doesn’t affect me in the slightest and it’s none of my business. I certainly wouldn’t judge you for it. But if you really want to play a game of ‘let’s compare carbon footprints’ then I’ll happily play. Do start. Although I hope you don’t live in a house, drive or go on holiday?

Lastly, I’m so glad that you find it hilarious that a few of us have got real issues with second hand items. Not through snobbery (I certainly don’t have a pot to pee in) or a desire for ‘pweettty neeeeeeeeeeeewwww things’ as one poster suggested (I mend my clothes and something has to be broken beyond repair before it gets replaced - not because of the environment but because we have to count every penny). But because of a mental health condition or horrible experiences as children that mean we associate second hand stuff with bugs and wearing other people’s old crap that is only fit for the bin. I’m genuinely pleased for you that you see the humour in that. Unfortunately I appear to have misplaced my sense of humour and am struggling to see what you find so funny in other people’s unfortunate experiences. Perhaps you could explain it to me?

There is ridiculousness on this thread. It comes from those posters who sit in their little bubbles, looking down their noses and laughing at people like me, safe in the knowledge that they’re helping save the environment because they’ve bought a scarf from Vinted, sold by another middle class person from a pet free and smoke free home. Safe in the knowledge that they’ll never have to wear a stranger’s knickers or send their DC to school in shoes that are too small because that’s all that was on offer. And if they buy a second or third hand bit of carpet in an attempt to insulate one of their children’s rooms, and it turns out to be hopping with cat fleas, that’s fine because they can simply pay someone to fix the problem.

I’ve had one deletion message already on this thread so I’m trying really hard not to resort to what was described as abusive name calling. But some of you have no idea. None at all. Fucking shame on you.

leatherboundbooks · 08/11/2022 10:27

As many have said there is a big difference between a half used handcream, and old gloopy nail varnish, something the wrong size and suitable for a 90 year old granny or a bobbly jumper and a nice unused handcream, or just unused nailvarnish which might have been a pressie for someone who just doesn't wear it, something in your style and size and a lovely rarely if ever used jumper that fits.
As my parents got older much harder to find anything they wanted or needed. But my Dad was always delighted to get an old rare book he had never seen about one of his interests, mum too if a favorite author she'd not seen before because it was old, and when mum died there were things that had been presents but she had never used them cos no opportu ity, so the charity shop got good unused quality gifts that had never been worn, like the lovely blouse I got her her final Christmas, it got taken out of the packaging and admired and hung up, I k ow how much that cost
Its the thought behind it isn't it and sensitivity to the person's preferences. Myself I'd rather have a carefully chosen second hand present than an expensive bit of tat or something that had just had money but no thought thrown at it.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 08/11/2022 09:45

I can cope with all of that for children.

I can’t deal with wearing a top that’s had someone sweaty armpit on it. It just makes my flesh crawl. I used to lecture textile science.

The smells/body fluid stays on the surface of man made stuff or is absorbed in natural fibres. So it’s still there somehow on what you buy. Children for all the poo/vomit don’t sweat like adults. Mud I’m not bothered about.

00100001 · 08/11/2022 09:36

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 08/11/2022 09:22

Because kids don’t sweat excessively or at all really. Because there’s not going to be adult stuff like semen or whatever that might have landed on there.

They give me the ick. That’s all l can say. Don’t see why l should be attacked for it.

But kids wee, poo and vomit on their clothes, they jump in muddy puddles, roll around in all sorts...

I'm just confused as to why its OK to put your kids in second hand clothes, but not yourself. Just feels like double standard that's all.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 08/11/2022 09:22

00100001 · 07/11/2022 16:37

So why is it ok to dress your kids I. Second hand clothes,bit not to yourself?

Because kids don’t sweat excessively or at all really. Because there’s not going to be adult stuff like semen or whatever that might have landed on there.

They give me the ick. That’s all l can say. Don’t see why l should be attacked for it.

GADDay · 08/11/2022 02:12

An update on the 1 year without buying anything new project.

My children (21, 18, 15) and DH are all on board. We will start on 1st Jan 2023 and finish on 1st January 2024.

The rules will be - nothing new except groceries, medication, personal hygiene and cleaning supplies (we use an environmentally friendly cleaning solution that I just can't live without).

I like fixing things up - so I think the hardest thing to give up will be new paint, brushes, and stuff etc from the hardware store. There are other ways - though, will just be a bit more of an effort.

I also am a bit of a stationery slut so that's going to be tough.

I really think we will be OK for the most part.

OP posts:
alfreddo82 · 07/11/2022 19:44

I find it absolutely hilarious the number of users on this platform that wax lyrical about climate change and the environment and vilify people like me with 4 children whilst simultaneously boaking at the thought of a second hand book or scarf. It's ridiculous.

Thankfully the popularity of Vinted indicates that a lot of people feel differently.