Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think making friends with people who earn less than you is a waste of time

592 replies

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 08:00

Hear me out. We moved to a lovely village a few years ago and I put a lot of effort in trying to make new friends. People who grew up in the area weren't interested as they had their established friendship circles. I met 2 different women through an activity who I hoped I could become good friends with.
Both lived in smaller houses than ours and earned less which didn't matter to me because I enjoyed their company. After a few meet ups, I was dumped. No idea what I did wrong. And it hurt.

Post baby, I have met 3 different amazing mummy friends (they don't know each other) and they think I am wonderful. We meet up regularly with our children and have a brilliant time. They also have part time professional jobs, live in big houses and have similar values.

This got me thinking because I am the same person who was dumped by the two other women. Plus, I have been dumped several times by friends in the past. The move to our current house cost me 3 friends who went cold when they saw the pictures of the house. I was so desperate to hold on to one of those friendships that I spent a year texting her to organise a meet up but she was never free or wouldn't respond.

AIBU to think that trying to make friends with someone who is several levels below you on the economic ladder is generally a waste of time and can only lead to disappointment/heart break?

OP posts:
hesbeingabitofadick · 06/11/2022 12:32

I have met 3 different amazing mummy friends (they don't know each other) and they think I am wonderful.

🙄

Florenz · 06/11/2022 12:32

A woman I used to work with in a call centre is good friends with Tim Rice. It really doesn't matter.

FeelTheRush · 06/11/2022 12:32

shivawn · 06/11/2022 08:03

Yeah I think you're being unreasonable, most of my friends earn a lot less but it's never been an issue at all.

Loving this response

Holidayhomehell · 06/11/2022 12:28

Hi OP,

I actually think you are probably right - I live in a village and looking at friendship groups, you can definitely see the correlation between house sizes / professional status / money. Without a doubt.

I do think though that this is also linked to how people like to spend their time etc - having money, or no money, definitely impacts who you are as a person, your life chances, your life experiences, and your social life. It makes sense that this will then shape friendships. There will be exceptions to this of course. Childhood friendship might continue if you are close enough. But new friendships I think are very much different.

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 12:27

shivawn · 06/11/2022 11:30

I find it baffling that some people are keen to be friends and some decide they want little to do with me.

This isn't baffling at all OP, it's completely normal. Some people are compatible and others aren't.

I seriously doubt your other friends didn't want to be friends because you have a bigger house than them. It's honestly bizarre that you would even jump to that conclusion. Far more likely that it's a personality thing, as they just got to know you better they realised that you weren't well suited as friends, this is completely normal with new friends.

I do agree that this is the most likely explanation. Despite some of the mean posts suggesting that I think everyone is jealous of me, I really do not think that for even a second.

OP posts:
Bentoforthehorde · 06/11/2022 12:26

As ambassador for the working class lowly poor folk I can say it's definitely not you, it's us.
We are intimidated by large houses and fancy decor.
We actually come out in hives if we sit on a sofa made by anyone posher than DFS, it's built in as a class alert system.
So you should definitely stay away from us, we're no good for you.

OwwwMuuuum · 06/11/2022 12:25

Lol. You’ve been very silly to post this. Of course friendships can flourish regardless of difference, whether it’s financial, cultural, whatever.

The comment in the OP about “the same values” stands out to me. What are these values you and your wealthy mummy friends share? Horror at shopping in Aldi? Knowing your Tignes from your Teignmouth? If you’re looking down your nose at people who earn less than you then that’s why people don’t want to be your friend.

I say this with confidence as DH and I have a bigger house and more money than some (not all) of our friends. We use it to welcome, feed and host people - friends old and new, family, work people - from all walks of life and we have a lot of fun. If you’re snotty about it, that’s where the friendship issues come in.

the80sweregreat · 06/11/2022 12:20

I do think that those with money and have had money for many years do tend to forget that not everyone is as fortunate as they are.
Especially those with any inherited wealth

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 12:20

SpongebobHotpants · 06/11/2022 11:25

Just sounds like you were unfortunate enough to have made friends who struggle with feelings of jealousy.

Or you've got it all wrong and you got dumped for an entirely different reason you dont know about.
When DHs friend's sister went through a private baby loss she couldnt cope with being with her friends with young kids, she tried but it was just too much for her to bear and cut them out of her life completely with no explanation. Just saying, there are soooooo many other reasons for the dumping you might not be unaware of.

I have acknowledged in previous posts that previous friends would have ended the friendship for various reasons. I don't for one second think it is all down to jealously. People have busy lives and a lot going on. Just tired of sometimes investing in friendships and it all comes to nothing.

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 12:18

Has your DH had the same experience?

Cornettoninja · 06/11/2022 12:17

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 12:07

I proposed the idea in reaction to being dumped several times. As a form of emotional preservation.

It may never have happened to you but it is hurtful when people stop responding to your messages or no longer want to meet up after after you have invested time and effort in a friendship.

I completely understand that, there aren’t many in existence who haven’t experienced friendship issues at some point.

it comes down to whether you can accept constructive criticism (put aside the outright hostility) or whether you’re just looking to be soothed. I don’t generally get the impression that the more agreeable comments are completely putting the issue to rest for you so maybe there is some value in examining your own prejudices and what you’re projecting so you can avoid it in the future.

limiting your social circle doesn’t resolve your personal insecurities around your experiences and runs the risk of creating more problems when this bleeds out into real life. People have a lot of senses and know when they’re being prejudged, even in the smallest interactions.

Movinghouseatlast · 06/11/2022 12:17

I am the lowest earner of all my friends. I also have the smallest house and a Fiesta when they all drive Audi's and BMW's.

Sparklingbrook · 06/11/2022 12:16

OPis being very selective as to which posts get a thanks and which don’t. 🤔

Lentilweaver · 06/11/2022 12:15

Sorry. Meant to say I am enjoying them more these days than intense friendships

Lentilweaver · 06/11/2022 12:15

OP have you tried meetups? I

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 12:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ as the OP has privacy concerns.

Thank you and noted. You have raised valid points.

OP posts:
Rinoachicken · 06/11/2022 12:13

I am the ‘poor friend’ in my circle. Most of the time it matters not at all, but occasionally the differences will show. For example if they are arranging something during the week (because they all work part time or are SAHM) and I can never join because I work full time. Or when discussions come up about schools and for them it’s all grammar and private. Can feel me feeling left out of the conversation and I just sit there quietly like muppet until the topic has moved on.

CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 12:11

It may never have happened to you but it is hurtful when people stop responding to your messages or no longer want to meet up after after you have invested time and effort in a friendship.

Then think about why it’s happening and what changes you can make.

You’ve said multiple times that you never suggested expensive things - so it’s obviously not about finances.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/11/2022 12:11

A PP observed that it's fine to be the richer friend who is happier to visit the poorer friend, but less pleasant to be the poorer friend.

Very true indeed!

Gwenhwyfar · 06/11/2022 12:10

"And she's extremely generous. So, she tends to offer to pay. It's kind of her, and gives me opportunities to eat in nice restaurants I wouldn't normally go to. I really appreciate that, but I do feel a little sad knowing that my lifestyle is no longer how she chooses to live"

Some people would feel there is a power imbalance there.
Personally, if someone wants to pay for me and they're rich, that's fine by me.

NotQuiteUsual · 06/11/2022 12:10

When I was in a bad place mentally and financially I found it hard to be around friends who were well off. Sitting in their huge, professionally cleaned lounges surrounded by holiday photos hurt. Hearing about their supportive parents who let them stay home while they went to Uni and now watch their children for free while they work hurt too.

Now I'm in a better place these things don't bother me in the same way. I'm still a little sad when I hear about supportive parents, but it's less about the advantages they got from that and more about my own sadness that I don't have that same infallible safety net they do. The holidays and fancy homes don't bother me at all, it gives me a lot of inspiration for styling my own home and I love seeing their children thrive.

Basically I think it's less about financial differences and more about advantages. It does hurt seeing how easier life is for some and if you're not in a place to handle that the friendship couldn't thrive anyway.

Gwenhwyfar · 06/11/2022 12:09

Most of my friends have more money than me. I've also had friends who claimed to have less money (I think in reality were just penny pinchers) who wouldn't go anywhere but Weatherspoons and that was a bit boring.
I have a couple of friends who'll embarrass the group by bringing their own food to cafes that sell food as well. It's more that they're stingy than poor though.
My friends know not to invite me to extremely expensive restaurants though - we go to places we can all afford.
It's also important to be sensitive about things like bill splitting.

notanothertakeaway · 06/11/2022 12:08

A PP observed that it's fine to be the richer friend who is happier to visit the poorer friend, but less pleasant to be the poorer friend

I agree with this

I have a friend who earns less than me. I'm happy to go for walks, eat dinner at home

I have another friend who earns a lot more than me. She prefers to go out for dinner. And she likes to go to expensive places. And she's extremely generous. So, she tends to offer to pay. It's kind of her, and gives me opportunities to eat in nice restaurants I wouldn't normally go to. I really appreciate that, but I do feel a little sad knowing that my lifestyle is no longer how she chooses to live, and it feels like our lives are on different trajectories now

ReneBumsWombats · 06/11/2022 12:08

Raininghard · 06/11/2022 11:57

Yes, of course, if you are in poverty the op maybe considered wealthy. Of course. But in the general scheme of things, I would put good money that she’s not wealthy by most peoples standards. Above average, sure, but that’s it. The house seems to be her big thing. And really important to her. As it makes her look wealthy in her eyes.

But again, the point is that these things are relative.

You don't consider her wealthy, but some people would. And if wealth is going to play a part in the friendship, that perception is what matters. Not where OP falls on the nationwide scale of wealth.

(Which is probably higher than you think. Poverty is more common and more severe than many people realise.)

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 12:07

Cornettoninja · 06/11/2022 11:09

Finding yourself at a point where you are consciously discounting swathes of people as suitable for friendship based on superficial reasons betrays unlikeable traits tbh.

Friendships can’t be forced but analysing in this way and reaching conclusions that make you comfortable with making declarations like ‘I can’t be friends with people economically mismatched’ means you are more comfortable with prejudice than you are with facing your own faults.

it’s easier but its distasteful and it certainly doesn’t match the persona you claim to have.

I proposed the idea in reaction to being dumped several times. As a form of emotional preservation.

It may never have happened to you but it is hurtful when people stop responding to your messages or no longer want to meet up after after you have invested time and effort in a friendship.

OP posts: