Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think making friends with people who earn less than you is a waste of time

592 replies

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 08:00

Hear me out. We moved to a lovely village a few years ago and I put a lot of effort in trying to make new friends. People who grew up in the area weren't interested as they had their established friendship circles. I met 2 different women through an activity who I hoped I could become good friends with.
Both lived in smaller houses than ours and earned less which didn't matter to me because I enjoyed their company. After a few meet ups, I was dumped. No idea what I did wrong. And it hurt.

Post baby, I have met 3 different amazing mummy friends (they don't know each other) and they think I am wonderful. We meet up regularly with our children and have a brilliant time. They also have part time professional jobs, live in big houses and have similar values.

This got me thinking because I am the same person who was dumped by the two other women. Plus, I have been dumped several times by friends in the past. The move to our current house cost me 3 friends who went cold when they saw the pictures of the house. I was so desperate to hold on to one of those friendships that I spent a year texting her to organise a meet up but she was never free or wouldn't respond.

AIBU to think that trying to make friends with someone who is several levels below you on the economic ladder is generally a waste of time and can only lead to disappointment/heart break?

OP posts:
PupInAPram · 06/11/2022 08:56

I can't work out if you're an idiot troll or just a straightforward idiot.

WinterWanders · 06/11/2022 08:56

Maybe they are just busy or have too much going on in their own lives to put efforts and time into new friendships. It could be nothing to do with you. I’m like this, I work very hard with my own business, I’m a single parent. Just keeping up with all this, the non-optional parts of life and keeping the show on the road, take up all my energy. I’d love to have time and energy to invest in friendships but I just don’t.

Tulipomania · 06/11/2022 08:56

In my experience, friendships are usually based on shared common interests and nothing to do with house size or income. Unless that IS your interest, which sounds like it could be with you OP.

Why not try to find out more about what makes women tick rather than comparing their lifestyle with yours? Even if you think you are not being overt about it, it will show, I promise you.

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 08:55

ClocksGoingBackwards · 06/11/2022 08:23

I hear where you’re coming from. It is disingenuous to pretend that things like income levels and housing never have an affect on new friendships. It is natural for humans to be drawn to others who share similarities with them because they’re automatically going to have more to connect over and there is comfort in familiarity.

That said, I have friends all over the income scale, so it’s not inevitable that it’s going to have a big effect in every area of life. I think mummy friendships are more likely to be affected than others because people make those for the benefit of their children as much as their own enjoyment.

I knew my post wouldn't go down well but people completely dismissing my experience trying to make new friends is strange. Thank you for acknowledging that it may play a factor.

OP posts:
Meadowbreeze · 06/11/2022 08:54

I can see this happening tbh and I think people are disingenuous if they say they don't. The reality is, it takes a lot to upkeep friendships in adult life, with a family. It's hard enough spending significant time with your loved ones, let alone new friends. People also really want to be able to relate to their friends and I think maybe the people's you've met have assumed they won't have that with you so they've not bothered to out more effort in. For some, it may have genuinely just been time. It is so hard to keep up adult friendships and maybe that's a big difference between you and them, not the house but how much work you're willing to put it. The house may be a reflection of your situation, you may be able to have some help that saves you time and that attracts a lifestyle those women won't be able to relate to.

It may be a mix of that and a mix of you showing how badly you want a friend. Its like with kids, it's always quite obvious when one is trying to make a friend and not succeeding.
We're social creatures and it hurts to be lonely. I mean that even for an introvert, it's nice to have people sometimes. I feel bad for you, you sound like a lovely person. Village life can be hard and can take long to get used to. Try not to worry too much about it, you'll meet people who you'll reciprocate your friendliness.

Nevermorethis · 06/11/2022 08:54

Leaving aside OPs circumstance, yes it can. Because people tend to want someone who can afford to do the things they want to do. That’s my experience. So yes, I am aware that if I suddenly became really poor my social circles would dwindle. I would lose the friendships which exist at classes I go to, as I could no longer go, and my other friends I would expect to drop off as they got bored of all their contact being house calls or local walks and as I had to keep on turning down their invites to do other stuff.

I actually lived briefly with someone this happened to. She was unemployed for years after losing her job and all her friends had slowly drifted away. I knew someone else who was also unemployed for years and years, and only maintained her friendships by accumulating many tens of thousands of debt which paid for being able to keep on socializing with them.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 06/11/2022 08:54

Do you think you go out of your way to not be showy, but end up being annoyingly patronising instead.

I’ve met the type. Well meaning but pretty insufferable.

Kiwimommyinlondon · 06/11/2022 08:53

QuebecBagnet · 06/11/2022 08:52

So you only earn 55k? Yeah I probably wouldn’t bother being friends with you because you probably couldn’t afford to do the sort of stuff I do.

To be fair to the OP, that post is six years old!

BatshitCrazyWoman · 06/11/2022 08:53

Well, you sound like a charmer.

CookieDoughKid · 06/11/2022 08:53

I also hear where you’re coming from. I agree with previous poster who said it is disingenuous to pretend that things like income levels and housing never have an affect on new friendships. But I do think it's a lot more nuanced. There was a very small hobby group formed with the 6 of us and the group has splintered into two . I am disappointed that certain members don't make an effort any more but totally respect that and I've not raised any issues but it was clear from the start our lifestyles were all very, very different (C level jobs vs being a part time child minder for example). Now I don't care one jot about people's jobs or backgrounds myself but I sometimes don't get return on invites either and I truly think there is a big house effect.

FWIW, I used to get intimidated going into friend's house especially if they were huge and were millionaires(from our private nursery so lots of mixed backgrounds). It takes a little gusto as you think you're not worthy. Mumsnet are often full of confident posters but not everyone is.

Diverseopinions · 06/11/2022 08:52

'have similar values' is an interesting component of the thread, OP. Moral values don't have to be linked to money and class. For instance, covering up your shoulders and knees to honour religious sentiments might be something which very rich and less well off women might do.

I think particularly now, though, that there might be a divide between those thinking and sharing thoughts on how to save fuel, and those saying that they will suck it up and manage. Grafted on to that might be differing views saying, either that the government should do more to manage and off set the crisis and those saying that there is nothing that the government can do and the whole world is affected.

Out of the above can grow beliefs about sharing money around. These can create a sense of having different values.

I'm a big believer in the fact that if you've known hardship as well as comfort you can understand two perspectives. I think a lot of people value the notion of independence and making your way in life, but any kind of hardship or desperation can make you realise that there is a limit to what you can do by your own means to safeguard your future and the family's, and that systemic change will be needed.

Perhaps your different economic position has led you and your former friends to have different political views, too. Even though it's bad manners to talk about money or politics, maybe news items about power cuts, etc, put affordability back on the menu.

RewildingAmbridge · 06/11/2022 08:52

Why won't you address your previous thread where you discuss your income and it's not the huge amount you're portraying

QuebecBagnet · 06/11/2022 08:52

That was a joke btw!

QuebecBagnet · 06/11/2022 08:52

MichaelGovesLeftNostril · 06/11/2022 08:11

So you only earn 55k? Yeah I probably wouldn’t bother being friends with you because you probably couldn’t afford to do the sort of stuff I do.

blippi123 · 06/11/2022 08:51

Your post mentions the size of your house over and over again

Is this all you talk about IRL?

Previous friends probably got fed up of you harping on about it

bakewellbride · 06/11/2022 08:51

I'm a sahm who earns fuck all. Am I not allowed my friends who work part-time then...

RFPO77 · 06/11/2022 08:51

I really don't think it's your big house or professional role that's scaring friends away Tbh 🤷

Christmaspumpkinseeds · 06/11/2022 08:50

I struggle to make friends with some people who are 'several levels below' me but its because we have absolutely nothing in common.

There are others 'several levels below' me that I do get on with because we have things in common and have similar values.

Money/financial status/ the size of my house doesnt come into the equation.

Fluffydiamond · 06/11/2022 08:50

I don't generally give people a survey to fill in before we become friends asking them how much they earn. I earn half what my friend earns. She's a corporate lawyer. Hopefully she not going to dump me!

SkylightSkylight · 06/11/2022 08:49

Sparklingbrook · 06/11/2022 08:03

I don’t know where to start with this. More coffee required I think.

@Sparklingbrook Are your coffee beans hand picked by fairies? If not I think I'm going to have to let this friendship go. Sorry & all that.

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 08:49

TimeForMeToF1y · 06/11/2022 08:19

Do you live in a vlllage? Where I live it's pretty much impossible not to know what someones house is like unless they are a weirdo who won't say which street they live on

Exactly. I live in a small village.

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 06/11/2022 08:49

I really don't think I am patronising

no one ever does. You have to remember that people don’t see you as you see you.

CoffeandTiaMaria · 06/11/2022 08:49

Thank goodness I don’t feel the need to compare myself financially, materially or anything else with others.

Flowersonthewall6 · 06/11/2022 08:49

We have a friendship group where someone lives in a 2 bed terrace upto a 6 bed / 4 bath large house. It’s never really come up in conversation, we are all happy for each other when they get promoted or good things happen. Yes I make jokes the high earner lives in a mansion but that’s about it.

OrangePumpkinLobelia · 06/11/2022 08:48

I do think the OP might have a point. My best friend married a multi millionaire and she has remained down to earth and as far as I can see totally unchanged by it. She has been on the receiving end of a fair bit of envy though and some of our other friends have said things like she is not too big for her boots (she isn't) and so forth. There has been envy and she said once that she had made some friends through toddler groups and when invited them to her DD's 3rd birthday party there was some awe about their house and she was after that completely dropped. In fact one of the husband's commented as he left with sarcasm; 'Thanks for inviting us to your posh house' which she was really embarrrassed and hurt by. So I feel quite sure things like this do happen. She's not a rub it in peoples faces type either. We were out once with a couple of people and someone introduced her to a third person as 'jayne, you know the one in the Big House' and she was mortified and muttered 'Oh it's falling down around our ears and we can't keep up with it' as a kind of apology for living her own life.

So I can see how an obvious disparity might create uncomfortable feelings for someone for whatever reason.