Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think making friends with people who earn less than you is a waste of time

592 replies

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 08:00

Hear me out. We moved to a lovely village a few years ago and I put a lot of effort in trying to make new friends. People who grew up in the area weren't interested as they had their established friendship circles. I met 2 different women through an activity who I hoped I could become good friends with.
Both lived in smaller houses than ours and earned less which didn't matter to me because I enjoyed their company. After a few meet ups, I was dumped. No idea what I did wrong. And it hurt.

Post baby, I have met 3 different amazing mummy friends (they don't know each other) and they think I am wonderful. We meet up regularly with our children and have a brilliant time. They also have part time professional jobs, live in big houses and have similar values.

This got me thinking because I am the same person who was dumped by the two other women. Plus, I have been dumped several times by friends in the past. The move to our current house cost me 3 friends who went cold when they saw the pictures of the house. I was so desperate to hold on to one of those friendships that I spent a year texting her to organise a meet up but she was never free or wouldn't respond.

AIBU to think that trying to make friends with someone who is several levels below you on the economic ladder is generally a waste of time and can only lead to disappointment/heart break?

OP posts:
MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 11:16

Nevermorethis · 06/11/2022 09:38

Only read a bit of the thread, but I’ve noticed that posters who have found themselves being the ‘poor’ friend acknowledge the mental challenge of this, those who are richer are happy and proud to be friends with anyone.
It’s surely not hard to see that it feels a lot better to be the one accommodating cheaper days out for your poor pal, than to be the poor pal having to be accommodated.
Those comfortably off, happy with their poorer friends and stating money makes no difference, may not realise that the poorer friend is less at ease with the situation than them.

This is a valid point. Thank you.

OP posts:
Freddosforall · 06/11/2022 11:14

I don't think it's about cash, but I do think it can be about values. The two people who I didn't keep in touch with from my NCT class were also the 2 wealthiest, and I just didn't feel like I had much in common with them. They were quite material and would spend ages talking about something like a new car, and in turn couldn't really identify with my interests. We just felt very different. Equally, I find it hard to befriend people who left school at 16 and then had a kid, as their life experiences are so different to mine. It's not that I don't want to, I just find it hard to find common ground.

shinynewapple22 · 06/11/2022 11:14

MichaelGovesLeftNostril · 06/11/2022 08:11

The thread you've linked was from 2016.

No idea of the truth of any of it - but a lot can happen/change in 6 years .

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 11:10

LargeHadronCollidHER · 06/11/2022 09:30

YANBU

although many on here are struggling financially so you’ll get flamed

It is pointless making an effort to befriend people in such different financial circumstances to yourself, as you’re always going to struggle with days out, gets awkward around birthdays and Christmas.

Thankfully it’s an issue that seems to be self policing, as most people find friends where they live, and where they live is usually dictated by income etc.

It is sad because I am happy having friends from different social/income levels. I only suggest cheap outings like coffee at a cafe or walks around a park.

It is hurtful being dumped and I posed the question out of a sense of emotional self -preservation.

OP posts:
katseyes7 · 06/11/2022 11:10

I have friends who are millionaires. Some only on paper due to property prices and locations, some seriously minted.
I also have friends who are on benefits. I'm in my 60s and working until l get my state pension.
I'm not friends with my friends for what they have/don't have. I'm friends with them because of the people they are.

Cornettoninja · 06/11/2022 11:09

Finding yourself at a point where you are consciously discounting swathes of people as suitable for friendship based on superficial reasons betrays unlikeable traits tbh.

Friendships can’t be forced but analysing in this way and reaching conclusions that make you comfortable with making declarations like ‘I can’t be friends with people economically mismatched’ means you are more comfortable with prejudice than you are with facing your own faults.

it’s easier but its distasteful and it certainly doesn’t match the persona you claim to have.

DerangedDonut · 06/11/2022 11:09

I read social cues well.

But not glaringly obvious voting stats it seems.

emptythelitterbox · 06/11/2022 11:09

Has your DH had the same experience?

PS5Gamer · 06/11/2022 11:08

I hope this one gets picked up by the newspapers. The comments section will be hilarious.

IsThereAPenOfIt · 06/11/2022 11:07

YANBU OP. Most of my friends have more than me, but I've not been bothered by it. They made different choices to me, and we all are in public sector or arts so noone is hugely money-driven. I spent most of my life in cities too.

However, since moving to this town 5 years ago I have noticed much more envy and competition between people (with exceptions, thankfully). It's partly money, but also any kind of status, influence, prominence or accomplishment, ranging from hobbies to volunteering to education.
I think living in a smaller conurbation means that people are acutely aware of what others are up to and they are all operating in a few limited arenas, whereas back in the city it was like everyone was following such disparate paths it was like comparing apples and oranges.

You have my sympathies, OP.

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 06/11/2022 11:07

I think OP is getting a hard time, because IME some people ARE weird about it if your house is bigger than theirs. My dad gave us a massive sum to buy our house, which is also massive. Long-standing friends came over to visit and there was definitely oddness from some of them. I just kept saying "my dad has been generous, we're very lucky" and laughing at the 'unique' decor left to us by the previous owner. Friends did eventually revert to normal, but it was a noticeable difference for a bit. I imagine new friends with those insecurities could quite easily just have ditched me instead.

Couldyounot · 06/11/2022 11:04

BabyClubYEEAAH · 06/11/2022 08:04

Maybe try living outside of your own asshole and you might find friendships easier.

Marvellous. I'm nicking that 😂

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 11:04

Lily073 · 06/11/2022 09:26

Typo sorry....Are you sure the reason people are behaving like this is not because you live on a housing estate that in their view has ruined their village? Villagers sometimes view developments like those as detrimental to the character of the village and might also consider living on a 'new build estate' as unpleasant

It's an old period house.

OP posts:
AllThatAndMore · 06/11/2022 11:02

One thing I’ve noticed , when I’m with my friends/family on lower incomes , I tend to hold myself back quite a bit. I don’t talk about holidays or new purchases. I don’t suggest doing anything expensive. Unless I’m close with someone , I won’t invite them over.

Part of this comes from a family member (who suffers from low self esteem ) made a comment once about how unrelatable I was . At the time I made the mistake of talking about our home renovations/extension we were getting done . She rents and is on a low income so I can see where she is coming from. I wasn’t trying to show off but the work took a year and it was a huge part of my life .

I find that I can openly talk about these sorts of things with my family and friends on similar incomes and as a result I feel like I can be more of myself .

liveforsummer · 06/11/2022 11:02

I knew my post wouldn't go down well but people completely dismissing my experience trying to make new friends is strange. Thank you for acknowledging that it may play a factor.

Making new friends is indeed hard but many of the pitfalls of friendships with a large income disparity aren't relevant in your case as you say you're frugal anyway. You think of these people as below you, you said it in the OP and although you may not say it out loud it will almost certainly come across. Plus moving and changing life stages can bring many friendships to a natural end anyway. The two that dumped you perhaps they thought they'd give the friendship a go but realised you don't have much in common (could be totally un related to wealth) it takes a while to get to know someone. Perhaps they found coffees and English heritage sites dull

Tillsforthrills · 06/11/2022 11:01

How you came to that conclusion is mind boggling. You sound like a very superficial type which may have something to do with being dropped, people can sense when you feel like you’re better than them because of your house/job/income.

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 11:00

Venetiaparties · 06/11/2022 09:23

There is something truthful in op's post, obviously very old and trusted friends won't care where you live.

We had a modest cottage and a group of baby club friends, dh's career took off and we moved to a large country house. My friends were open about feeling intimidated about my new house, and yes the friendships cooled despite my efforts to reassure them. They didn't feel good enough anymore, and said they felt they had to 'dress up' now when they came. It was odd and hurtful. Definitely their insecurities, as we were just the same as before. Some of the group were great, and we remain close to this day, and the one or two that found it difficult dropped out altogether.

That is sad. It is painful to lose friends. Glad you have some friends who saw you and your DH were still the same person and stuck by you.

OP posts:
CatsEatDogs · 06/11/2022 11:00

Im not saying you’re doing this op.
I had a small group of friends who were much wealthier than me. I really liked them But they would spend a long time talking about things I just couldn’t join in with, long discussions about multiple holidays and all the hotels they’d stayed in. They all seemed to know all the hotels in all the expensive holiday destinations. It ended up making me feel shit as I couldn’t join in and made Me feel like I didn’t fit in. I really don’t think they realised they were doing it, or how it would make me feel, it’s just what was normal to talk about for them.

NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet · 06/11/2022 11:00

"Both live in smaller houses than me and earn less but it didn't matter to me"

Eh?!

How noble of you...

LunaMuffinTop · 06/11/2022 10:59

It’s not the people that your friends with that are the problem it’s you change your attitude and you might find it easier to make and keep friends. Just a thought op.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 10:58

I have friends who earn far more than me and far less. I have had one person earning less be very jealous (they were open that they were being horrible for this reason: apparently I shouldn't ever share my struggles as a disabled lone parent with SEN kids and trauma caused by my ex-H etc because it's insensitive to do so when I have a good job, as if that makes everything ok Confused) but that person was an outlier IME. It's never been an issue with anybody else.

MrsShelby · 06/11/2022 10:57

BeyondMyWits · 06/11/2022 09:22

I can identify with the losing 3 friends when you moved (from their side). I also had a friend who moved to a beautiful village... about 10 miles from me. We used to pop into town for a coffee and a catch up every other week. That stopped when she moved, I always just got invited to hers... no buses, no visits... the friendship died a death . She'd come to mine but then whine that no one came to her... she was the one who moved to a place that no one could get to unless they had a car, and was inconvenient for school runs etc.

Moving can kill friendships for many reasons.

No doubt that moving can kill friendships. I would have been happy to continue with calls and messages and visiting them when I can but they weren't interested.

OP posts:
CarefreeMe · 06/11/2022 10:56

YABU

You have been dumped by multiple friends yet you think the issue is something to do with them - that says a lot about your personality.

Most people would look in the mirror and think about their behaviour and why this keeps happening - but instead you’ve come up with some ridiculous reason about finances, even though you’ve said that finances were never part of the friendship.

Some friendships don’t work.
Adult friendships are very difficult because of time.

I have always been friends with people who are much higher and much lower earners than myself.

There has been issues when they’ve wanted to do something more expensive but I was honest and said I couldn’t afford it.

I am also friends with a SAHM who I’ve had to be honest with and say I don’t have time to meet after work.

I already know that I wouldn’t want to be friends with you because of your personality.

It would have nothing to do with the finances and I suggest if you ever want to make friends, then you start being a little less patronising and think about your behaviour rather than the finances or any other ridiculous reasons.

GiltEdges · 06/11/2022 10:54

Maybe it’s just you. I never felt the need to share pictures of my house with friends 🤷‍♀️

Dinosaurhearmeroar · 06/11/2022 10:53

Jesus. This post! My best friend earns triple what I earn - she’s a corporate lawyer and I’m a secondary school teacher. Not once have I ever thought that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread