Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not trust a single mechanic

32 replies

Hyggemama · 06/11/2022 07:25

Prepared to be flamed for generalising a whole profession. I’m sure there are excellent mechanics out there of course, but I still haven’t found a single one. I have had cars damaged by mechanics, paid hundreds for replacement parts and fittings that then fail within a few months.
A mechanic did unauthorised work on one vehicle and then claimed I had to pay him otherwise I was “stealing” - I’d specifically told him I’d need to have an estimate first.
I had a car get 7 advisories on one MOT, then 1 advisory the following year - without any work having been done. Most recently a mechanic took my vehicle for MOT then has added £72 onto the fee (again unagreed) for taking a look at it after it failed, then telling me there was nothing he could do to fix it.
I keep trying different garages because I don’t trust them and they all seem as bad as each other. Surely an industry that are relying that much on blind faith should be regulated in some way? The costs are so high, not to mention that a mistake could be fatal on the road. I’ve tried word of mouth and that hasn’t helped either. I live in a rural area and a lot of people I speak to have some sort of family link to their mechanic, so I wonder if that’s why they don’t seem to struggle with them. Any advice on how to find one I can trust?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lovelypidgeon · 07/11/2022 09:53

I know what you mean OP

For years we used a local mechanic who was great. Tried using the same garage after he retired and one of his staff took it on and I was told that my car failed the MOT as apparently the exhaust was worn out beyond repair but that as I was such a valued customer he'd be willing to squeeze me in later in the week and sort it for £££££. I pointed out that the same garage had fitted an new exhaust a couple of months ago so surely there would be some sort of parts warranty if it was really that worn out. He agreed to check it out again and amazingly all that was needed was a new clip. Rather counter productive for them really as I won't trust that garage again.

OldTinHat · 07/11/2022 09:53

I bought a 2009 used car last year, one owner from new and it had always been looked after by the same independent garage. I thought that as they knew the car, I'd take it there for its MOT. They were great! I think they were pleased not to have lost a car.

PeloFondo · 07/11/2022 09:41

I use a local garage that was recommended by a lot of people and he's really good and reliable
It probably helps I work for a dealership so it's no good trying to blind me with technical stuff!

AnonWeeMouse · 07/11/2022 09:40

Because cars go wrong for all sorts of reasons. It's not as straightforward as saying "well, they repaired X six months ago and it's gone again

I don't think that way, it's another reason why I would take it for a second pair of eyes to look instead of assuming the first place fitted it wrong.

thelobsterquadrille · 06/11/2022 16:09

The amount of times someone has work done for an MOT for it to fail after a few months and they return it to the place that did the repair.

Because cars go wrong for all sorts of reasons. It's not as straightforward as saying "well, they repaired X six months ago and it's gone again, so it must be dodgy/a scam". You need to think about things like:

How many miles has the car done since the MOT?
Is it driven regularly or does it spend most of the time sat on a driveway?
Is the driver a good driver, or does the car get bumped/scraped/knocked regularly?
Is it used to carry loads of heavy things which can impact on how smooth/easy it is to drive?
What kind of roads is it driven on? Smooth, well-maintained roads or bumpy country roads full of potholes which can do hidden damage?
Does the driver live somewhere coastal which can cause extra damage due to the salty air/salt water?

And some cars are just old and battered and will have lots of issues because, well, they don't last forever and at some point, it makes more sense to scrap them and buy something else.

RedAppleGirl · 06/11/2022 15:58

AnonWeeMouse · 06/11/2022 11:36

Good for you, you have one you trust, great.

But, if your mechanic missed something, you've no second or third pair of eyes that may see what your single mechanic missed.

The amount of times someone has work done for an MOT for it to fail after a few months and they return it to the place that did the repair.
Take it elsewhere and they'll spot what the repairers missed.

The problem is, vehicles often have multiple faults or its likely a fault develops soon after. It's the way, with products that have moving parts.
The customer incorrectly assumes it's the garage setting them up or ripping them off.
Any business must charge enough to make a profit.

Hellsmovie · 06/11/2022 12:07

UnstableCarHouse · 06/11/2022 08:57

I generally go for one of the big brands, Halfords, Kwik Fit, the main dealership. Not saying they’re any better but at least there’s a head office to moan to if I’m unhappy (which I never have been).

You trust quick fit????

You must have more money than sense .

I have 2 garages I trust 100%.

My suggestion is if you dont trust the mechanic learn to do bits yourself

AnonWeeMouse · 06/11/2022 11:36

SoupDragon · 06/11/2022 10:11

I'll be using the same mechanic over and over as I trust this lot not to rip me off. What odd advice.

Good for you, you have one you trust, great.

But, if your mechanic missed something, you've no second or third pair of eyes that may see what your single mechanic missed.

The amount of times someone has work done for an MOT for it to fail after a few months and they return it to the place that did the repair.
Take it elsewhere and they'll spot what the repairers missed.

XAQ · 06/11/2022 10:18

I used to feel like this for year until I found my current mechanic. Small independent place, they are great. They do lovely small things too like replacing fob battery and not charging for it. Last MOT he told me the tyres were on the way out but because of my low milage to wait till the next MOT to change them.

Ask on your local FB pages.

SoupDragon · 06/11/2022 10:11

AnonWeeMouse · 06/11/2022 10:03

Always go through the Good Garages Scheme website, always always always.
Don't use the same mechanic over and over for services and MOTs

I'll be using the same mechanic over and over as I trust this lot not to rip me off. What odd advice.

AnonWeeMouse · 06/11/2022 10:03

Always go through the Good Garages Scheme website, always always always.
Don't use the same mechanic over and over for services and MOTs

WishfulWanda · 06/11/2022 09:57

Our car was in a hit and run two years ago. Ever since then, when we drive straight, the wheel goes slightly to the left. We’ve taken it back to the same garage three times but they insist that there’s ‘nothing wrong’ 🙄 🙄 Funny how it was fine before some cow bag drove into us…

ASmallCat · 06/11/2022 09:47

Related to my mechanic so no probs trusting him (at DVA right now waiting on MOT!)

But yes, if I had to take it elsewhere I’d be worried.

Nephew has taken me through some troubleshooting so I can have a better idea and diy but it’s great to have a reliable & trustworthy mechanic when needed.

L1ttledrummergirl · 06/11/2022 09:38

We've had some dodgy dealings with garages- the most memorable 20+ years ago when kwikfit refused to release my car to me saying it would cost ££££ which I didn't have available. I was a teenage girl and they were disgraceful.
After fil spoke to them by phone, I was able to drive the car "home", went round the corner to Halfords and they fixed it for a couple of hundred pounds. They were also amazingly reassuring and supportive.

We now use 2 garages, one we started using as we have a friend who manages it and we trust him, but they only do routine repairs, for anything more in depth they send us to a garage that they trust and I couldn't be more relieved that we found them. They are amazing.

Ask people you know for recommendations.

uhtredsonofuhtred1 · 06/11/2022 09:37

I know exactly what you mean! It takes me ages to find one that I'm able to trust. After I moved to where I am now, I used to travel 90 miles back to my home town for anything car related as I trusted them not to rip me off.

When I first moved to the previous town I knew exactly what was wrong with my car and thought I'd test out all the local garages by not letting on I knew which part needed replacing. It was a £25 part and quick labour (less than an hour). I got told anything between £800-£250!! One garage even said I needed the full suspension all round replacing! Then I went to the now trusted one and they were totally honest, offered me a couple of price range options with no pressure.

SoupDragon · 06/11/2022 09:37

I know what you mean. I also feel that being a woman is an invitation to be ripped off by some garages.

Luckily I found a reliable one through personal recommendations and they've been excellent.

bigblueyonder · 06/11/2022 09:30

You have to look for them but they do exist. I tend to stay away from main dealerships and there are a lot of dodgy garages out there. Try and use one from the good garage scheme www.goodgaragescheme.com or ask for recommendations.

A clean car will get a better service than a dirty one.

Kabbalah · 06/11/2022 09:27

pointythings · 06/11/2022 09:24

I think you've been very unlucky. I've been with the same place (main dealership) for years and they have been excellent. A few years ago I had a problem with my brakes, it turned out that they hadn't spotted the discs needed replacing. And because they had not spotted it, they replaced them for free.

But you pay main dealer prices at £175 an hour plus VAT and spares are marketed up too. OK I guess if you can afford it.

autienotnaughty · 06/11/2022 09:25

Yes I used a garage near me they kept the car the whole day even though the work was only an hour it was £90 for labour!! They rang and said the part would be £25 so I agreed to fitting. Turned out it was 2parts they were £35 each plus vat. Entire bill was nearly £200 !!!

pointythings · 06/11/2022 09:24

I think you've been very unlucky. I've been with the same place (main dealership) for years and they have been excellent. A few years ago I had a problem with my brakes, it turned out that they hadn't spotted the discs needed replacing. And because they had not spotted it, they replaced them for free.

Kabbalah · 06/11/2022 09:24

There’s a lot you can do yourself. I do all my own spannering and I’m a mother of three who works for the NHS. Currently restoring a 1948 Rolls Royce.

Ariela · 06/11/2022 09:23

I think you need to teach yourself the basics of how to check over your car and find issues that need doing before it's dire, and to fix the simpler ones yourself.
You can generally find videos on YouTube of how to check your car over and even specifics for your make and sometimes even model of car.
Simple things like check the oil level, water and windscreen wash, do your own tyre pressures, check and change windscreen wipers, check your tyres for wear, check your lights and brakes and how to change any failed bulbs.
For any MOT /service it is polite to thoroughly wash your car inside and out and use a hose to wash off underneath as best you can. A clean car shows a sign of a cared for car, and your mechanic will appreciate it - we had a bulb blow between leaving our yard and the MOT station and rather than fail or charge extra the guy threw a free bulb in because it was the last of 3 immaculately presented vehicles for MOT = clean underneath and inside and easy to check everything.
Then I'd ask locally on Facebook for recommendations for a mechanic - they tend to be quite precious/competitive about reputation locally to me.

Loachworks · 06/11/2022 09:21

As a woman I hate garages and car dealerships. I've never met one who didn't try to speak over me to DH.

CruelAndUnusualParenting · 06/11/2022 09:18

I've mostly been lucky, but when my wife had a Volvo 480 the Volvo dealers were terrible. I currently use a local garage that everyone in the village knows for my Ford and an independent specialist in town for my wife's Peugeot. The specialist I found on Google and the Google reviews were really good. They solved a timing issue that the local garage couldn't deal with and the service matched up with the reviews, so they get repeat business from me.

MadameDe · 06/11/2022 09:15

Where I am the garages are quite good. One of them I found through the AA, so maybe check the AA website. However, if I need a builder or anything done in my house, I'm scaling the walls with anxiety. I had one builder and tried to detract from his own incompetence by blaming it on the electrics - I felt really ripped off. Nowadays I only let people into my house who are from registered companies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread