Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To demand my raffle prize?

352 replies

sellmeyours · 06/11/2022 05:27

I bought a load of strips for a charity raffle recently. The raffle was draw at 8pm last night

I won 3 times in a row! Number and price told to me over the 🎤

The organiser then said 'oh let's put that one back since it's your number again Sandra, let's make it fair to everyone else :)'

So she did. I walked up and asked what she was doing? It was my number

She told me to sit back down, it's a charity and isn't fair to keep letting me have the prices

AIBU to want my bloody raffle prize?

I won a spa day and a bottle of champagne. The other price I won was a selection of vouchers! I want it.

OP posts:
Untitledsquatboulder · 06/11/2022 08:22

@Whinge I guess to increase your chances of winning at all. Most people don't buy 4 tickets expecting to walk away w 4 prizes.

MoirasSaggyBundles · 06/11/2022 08:22

Surely the reason you have coloured tickets is because the printers of these books of tickets can only print numbers 001-999 on a single bundle of tickets. If you need more than 999 for a single event, you have other colours to start again from 001. If you use only part of 1 colour, say 700, in a single event, the other 299 are not wasted, because you can use those at the next event and then sell more from 001 in another colour. The difference should colours have absolutely nothing to do with chances of winning, because they should be drawn blind. the colours are simply a practicality and to avoid waste.

CourtneeLuv · 06/11/2022 08:22

Grabby and selfish.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 08:23

red4321 · 06/11/2022 07:01

I'd be letting her know and asking her to fulfill the prize to you or you will raise a small claims against her.

I presume this is said in jest. Because no one in their right mind would take legal action against a charity in these circumstances.

As PP said, by all means, take the first prize and possibly the second. But the third would be poor form, charity or otherwise. Unless there's 30 or more prizes and it's not consecutive (I.e. you win at the beginning and the end, so others have already won plenty of prizes).

We're doing a charity raffle next weekend and we use different colour tickets which helps the picker somewhat (assuming people buy single colour tickets).

That doesn't sound like a true random draw, then. Is that legal?

ReneBumsWombats · 06/11/2022 08:25

CourtneeLuv · 06/11/2022 08:22

Grabby and selfish.

Don't enter lotteries if you don't like how they work. She won fair and square.

Why is it not grabby and selfish to expect extra chances over the number of tickets you bought?

StoppinBy · 06/11/2022 08:25

red4321 · 06/11/2022 07:55

Nevertheless what you are doing is illegal.

Putting our school raffle aside and a genuine question: when I've bought tickets for local charity raffles with different coloured tickets, are they all illegal? Or do you have to put other measures in place around them?

Because, when I think back, I'd say 90% had different coloured tickets. I'm asking out of interest not to point score.

Of course different coloured tickets aren't the issue, it's using the different coloured tickets to pick winners. The draw should be done blind.

If the group in front of me buy the same colour tickets as me and then they win, my tickets (and anyone else who has bought the same colour tickets) being excluded from the next/rest of the draw is ridiculously unreasonable and illogical.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 08:26

red4321 · 06/11/2022 07:23

Absolutely - that's not on and would put people off buying tickets if they know they'll be excluded if someone with a same colour ticket is a winner. Shocking behaviour.

Except there's multiple prizes and only a few colours. And arguably it improves everyone's odds as you're less likely to have three tickets of the same colour clumped together that win prizes (as happened here).

It's an event for school parents supporting a charitable cause and no one has ever mentioned it being shocking and the event has run for over 10 years. Quite a few parents (and teachers) have offered to put their tickets back if they win a prize at all.

I don't think people enter charity raffles run by someone they know (rather than the larger scale commercial types) to clean up on the prizes. It's a donation and if you win a prize, it's a bonus. I don't know anyone who would start kicking off about different coloured tickets for a charity raffle nor take more than one or two prizes.

The point is that there are rules and laws that govern these things. Charities don't get to make up procedures as they see fit.

DeireadhFomhair · 06/11/2022 08:27

red4321 · 06/11/2022 07:55

Nevertheless what you are doing is illegal.

Putting our school raffle aside and a genuine question: when I've bought tickets for local charity raffles with different coloured tickets, are they all illegal? Or do you have to put other measures in place around them?

Because, when I think back, I'd say 90% had different coloured tickets. I'm asking out of interest not to point score.

People aren't saying having different coloured tickets is illegal, it's the fact you said we use different colour tickets which helps the picker somewhat (assuming people buy single colour tickets) that's illegal, the pick should be blind not choosing blue this time because pink won last time. How can you think that's OK?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/11/2022 08:30

ReneBumsWombats · 06/11/2022 07:44

I've never seen "etiquette" which demands you can't win more than X times on a raffle. It being a charity raffle (aren't they usually?) makes no difference. The charity has the same amount of money and in fact it makes more when people decide to buy more tickets to up their odds.

But even if this "etiquette" exists, it's optional and no individual has to abide by it. There are laws around this, for good reason. If you want to be able to rig the results so that it's "fair", don't fundraise by lottery. Do a talent show or something.

And if you're offended at how lotteries work, don't play them. Just donate your money.

Well said.
OP, i hope you contact the organizers.

red4321 · 06/11/2022 08:33

People aren't saying having different coloured tickets is illegal, it's the fact you said we use different colour tickets which helps the picker somewhat (assuming people buy single colour tickets) that's illegal, the pick should be blind not choosing blue this time because pink won last time. How can you think that's OK?

I think you've missed the subsequent posts and replies I've made...

mumda · 06/11/2022 08:33

My friend is very lucky with raffles. But she always puts a good chunk of money in buying tickets. She just stacks the odds in her favour.

The charity has not lost out by one person winning multiple prizes. Reputational damage might mean fewer people buy tickets next time.

Was the raffle drawer a trustee for the charity or just a volunteer?

PeeJayDay · 06/11/2022 08:33

I'd contact the organisers. It's illegal. So is the colour picking thing. Doesn't matter whether it's a school raffle or the national lottery. The same laws apply

Glitterandmud · 06/11/2022 08:34

It's easy to say put a prize back if it's something you don't particularly want though, we're not talking bubble bath here, it's high end prizes. Not their call to make at all.
I would want those prizes too op!

MoirasSaggyBundles · 06/11/2022 08:34

The psychological reason someone might buy a blue ticket or a red one or want a particular number is on the buyer. That psychological reasoning should not be adopted by the drawer of the winning tickets, because it is both illegal and impossible - you cannot account for each and every person's reason for buying a particular colour and you cannot discount that you may be drawing a particular reason for your own psychological reasons. The only thing at play in these types of draws is that the more tickets you buy, the more chances you have of winning. It is completely illogical that in a 500 ticket lottery, with 10 prizes, Jane, who, buys 100 out of the 500, all of which are blue ones, is less likely to win than Mary who buys only 10 tickets but has 10 different colour ones, because the drawer is deliberately drawing different colour tickets for each prize; and choosing a particular colour for each prize category (best, second best etc), which colour hierarchy has not been notified to the buyers in advance.

ElmoNeedsThePotty · 06/11/2022 08:39

StoppinBy · 06/11/2022 07:24

@pastabakeonaplate the draw should be a blind draw where you can't even see what ticket you are drawing out.

I actually am pretty shocked that you think colour coding tickets is a clever and reasonable way to do the draw.

You beat me to it. Surely they should'nt be able to see what colour they are drawing, a bit like when they pull the balls out of a black bag for the World Cup draw.

Georgeskitchen · 06/11/2022 08:40

The woman who.made the decision that you weren't having the prize is the one who should replace it from her own pocket, that way the charity won't suffer.
I would also be making enquiries to the charities commission about the suitability of this person to be involved

WyfOfBathe · 06/11/2022 08:41

YANBU. At the last raffle I was at, one family won at least 5 prizes. By the end, everyone was laughing each time the dad ran up to the stage. There was never any suggestion that he should reject the prizes. They'd bought far more raffle tickets than anyone else so of course their odds were higher. After a decade of termly PTA raffles I've never heard of the "etiquette" of asking for a prize to be redrawn. And even if that was etiquette, it's not up to the charity to impose it.

mam0918 · 06/11/2022 08:42

ComeIntoTheGardenMaud · 06/11/2022 05:39

Decades ago, when I was young, raffle etiquette was that you didn’t take a second prize, but let them draw it again so someone else got a chance.

Say the charity had 5 prizes only sells 10 strips to 4 different people and OP bought 5 of those she has a 50% chance of winning, she PAID for that increased chance and the charity benefited from HER money more than anyone else its not like she is taking all of a freebie.

If you won the lottery but already have savings would you say 'no let someone who doesnt have a chance'?

Do you never play again if you won once?

I if you won Bingo in blackpool when you where 10 can you never play bingo again?

It doesnt have to be fair OP paid and won, to be honest it more unfair that someone who didn't pay as much wins but if thats how it falls fine, its really not fair to increase the cheaper peoples odds of winning by redrawing though.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/11/2022 08:44

It is fair, if it's done properly. Every ticket in the bowl has an equal chance of winning each draw.

What's unfair is rigging the draw, or expecting more chances than you paid for.

CruellaEvilwoman · 06/11/2022 08:45

Definitely was the convention when I grew up to refuse multiple prizes, also for my DH who grew up in a totally different area of the country. It does seem less common now though, although I'm afraid it just shouts 'grabby' to me because that is what I am used to.

WyfOfBathe · 06/11/2022 08:46

red4321 · 06/11/2022 07:01

I'd be letting her know and asking her to fulfill the prize to you or you will raise a small claims against her.

I presume this is said in jest. Because no one in their right mind would take legal action against a charity in these circumstances.

As PP said, by all means, take the first prize and possibly the second. But the third would be poor form, charity or otherwise. Unless there's 30 or more prizes and it's not consecutive (I.e. you win at the beginning and the end, so others have already won plenty of prizes).

We're doing a charity raffle next weekend and we use different colour tickets which helps the picker somewhat (assuming people buy single colour tickets).

Personally I'm not sure I'd announce online that I was planning to break the law

ThinWomansBrain · 06/11/2022 08:47

there's a big difference between the winner choosing to not take the prize and the organiser deciding to give it to someone else!

raffles and lotteries legislation is set out by the gambling commission; raffles don't need a licence as suggested above. Most lotteries do.
It's a charity - YANBU - but I wouldn't pursue the lost prize at this point - but a terse email pointing them in the direction of the legislation, and that it's not a total free for all if they;re selling a raffle ticket compared to asking for a donation.
If it's a local branch of a national charity, make sure that the national organisation is aware - they should be advising their branches on fundraising.

www.gamblingcommission.gov.uk/public-and-players/guide/fundraising-prize-draws-raffles-and-lotteries

Seeingadistance · 06/11/2022 08:53

tulips27 · 06/11/2022 07:44

I've honestly, hand on heart, never heard of this etiquette surrounding raffles. Is that a thing or are people just being supportive in confirming other posters?

It used to be the done thing to decline a prize if you’d already one, but it’s a tradition which seems to have fallen by the wayside. It was an act of generosity really, and entirely the winner’s choice. The person drawing the raffle doesn’t get to decide and would break the rules and laws on raffles.

Interesting point from pp about prizes being issued from biggest to smallest. I hadn’t realised, but of course that’s what always happens. It also means someone who’s already won can decline if their ticket is drawn again, in the knowledge that they’re not going to miss out on the main prize.

mam0918 · 06/11/2022 08:55

All the people 'judging' OP for taking what she BOUGHT fair and square... I hope you know everyone is judging, eye rolling and laughing at your martyr complexes right now.

Being a doormat doesn't make you 'superior' it makes you someone without a basic backbone.

They lied when they told you the 'Meek will inherate the earth'.

ReneBumsWombats · 06/11/2022 08:57

mam0918 · 06/11/2022 08:55

All the people 'judging' OP for taking what she BOUGHT fair and square... I hope you know everyone is judging, eye rolling and laughing at your martyr complexes right now.

Being a doormat doesn't make you 'superior' it makes you someone without a basic backbone.

They lied when they told you the 'Meek will inherate the earth'.

Shh. I want these people in every raffle I enter. More chances than I paid for? Yes please.