Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel rejected by my son?

133 replies

Flippingnora100 · 06/11/2022 02:41

DS is 12 and a lovely, kind, gentle, easygoing kid. We get along really well. I love our family time together. Lately he’s been hanging out at his friend’s house a lot and is always going on sleepovers there. The friend is a nice kid, but is quite indulged (I’m not sure if it’s because he’s an only child). Junk food, sweets, fizzy drinks, no screen time limits, big house, lots of fun stuff eg basketball court, sleepovers all the time with lots of friends etc. The mum is really nice but definitely less strict than me. My son never invites his friends to our house and jumps at any chance to go to his friends’ houses-especially this friend. Plans that start off being at our house seem to always end up at this other kid’s house instead. Today we planned a family pizza movie night and when we arrived to pick DS up, he had just been invited to sleep over and was all excited. I said yes but left feeling a little hurt. I’m happy that he has friends and gets invited to things. I don’t want to guilt trip him, but we had planned to all hang out together tonight. Do I need to let go and accept that this is how it is when kids get closer to their teenage years? Should I talk to him about evening things out and inviting friends here more often?

OP posts:
tulips27 · 06/11/2022 07:20

Does the fifteen minutes include things like Instagram and Whatsapp? If so, even though I agree that we all (not just children) have too much screen time these days ,I think it's excessive because such a large amount of socialising is via these apps he'd be excluded from communicating with friends and it might adversely affect him.

Regularsizedrudy · 06/11/2022 07:15

You’ve been on a screen for over an hour judging by the times of this post.

What can you even DO on a screen in only 15 mins?

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 07:10

And...of op can unclench so her son doesn't feel he can't invites his friends over then the flip side is that maybe this free and easy friend learns to enjoy the more family oriented structure at ops and likes that closer family unit and also becomes their pal?

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 07:08

Lola what harm is some junk food if ops child is eating really well 95% of the time?.

Because she's so strict she's set up this situation where to him nivarna and heaven are at this boy's house.

I am a huge believer in balance and no extreme behaviour.
My parents were very easy and going and relaxed and when I left home all my good friends knew my parents really well, and now my parents are gone it's very special that they remember them.
We were all able to socialise as adults, and enjoy each other company, go on holiday as adults etc.

Op should absolutely make sure there is a limit to sleepovers esp after lots of spur of the moment ones. But if it was me I would couple the ,can we limit the sleepovers to 2 a month however I have decided that you are older now and let's look at screen time again.

Would you like more freedom at home and give him some power and trust! Of course I wouldn't say these things because my DC have balance already. But I think his heart would sing with joy if he was actually asked his opinion on this and come up with some new rules.

Mummyoflittledragon · 06/11/2022 06:59

Like @Puddywoodycat said, I see this as a total lack of trust as well as a lack if respect for your ds. I understand you don’t want no boundaries but there is a happy medium such as no screens after 9.30 pm. If he’s out and about with friends at the weekend, that will naturally curb the amount of time and if you relaxed your control over screen times, you could see how well he does.

At 12, he should be getting some kind of agency over his time and choices. It’s good practice for adulthood and in a few years he will be off to university. The last thing you want is a child, who’s been allowed nothing as these are the ones, who’ve never been taught to self regulate and often go wild.

Have you thought to discuss this with him and ask him how much time he should be allowed on screens, what is a sensible limit on sugar and how he’d see a sleepover playing out?

Itsbeenalongwhile · 06/11/2022 06:59

Cantstandbullshit · 06/11/2022 03:37

Be a parent and put rules and boundaries in place eg sleepovers once a month or something. Not getting now you make plans and they end up with your 12 year old dictating what he ends up doing and you go along with it even though you don’t want to.

This👆.
I genuinely don't and can't see how that happened/happens.
Parents make decisions. He is 12 not 18.

PhotoDad · 06/11/2022 06:59

It's entirely normal for a teen (or nearly) DC to want to spend time away from home. Try not to take it personally!

We have never limited screen time. DD spent hours on her laptop doing art, and is now at art school. DS (now 15) has always filled all his "spare time" with gaming or watching anime, but that's alongside two instruments, a choir, clubs, a sport at national level and just enough schoolwork to be at grade 7+ in all subjects. Obviously it's horses for courses, but for most kids I know, screen-time isn't a problem.

LolaSmiles · 06/11/2022 06:58

Puddywoodycat

But it's parents who decide where their children are sleeping and whether sleepovers happen. If a parent, for whatever reason, doesn't want their child staying over somewhere all the time then that's their right.

If course 12 year olds like the fun house with no boundaries, endless junk food, and endless screen time. It's also not surprising that the fun house has all the sleepovers, and all the friends wanting to be round there, not is it surprising that the friend with all the freedoms doesn't seem to want to go to other people's houses.

I've agreed OP could do with relaxing screen time a bit, but to be honest she's always going to be on the back foot if her child's friend has the cool parents with few boundaries.

smileandsing · 06/11/2022 06:54

You sound like a good parent, but quite judgemental of your son's friend's parents and what they allow their son to do and have. You don't really know what rules or boundaries they have, only what your son has told you. Also what's with the only child comment? Jealousy is a terrible thing, as is insecurity.
I'd have said no last night to the sleepover as you had plans. But you didn't say no, presumably because your son would have been unhappy, so I think perhaps you don't have the strong boundaries you think you do. Just an idea but you could invite the boy to sleepover at yours more often, maybe his parents are fed up of all the kids hanging out at theirs all the time, but don't want to cut their son off from his friends, especially as he's an only child.

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 06:49

Lola

I think doing that would cause massive deep seated resentment.

By 12 our children should know who they are and have formed good habits.
Being exposed to some freedom shouldn't affect a 12 year old.

I would not cut down on sleepovers without op relaxing her rules at home and it sounds like her DC share a room. Nothing wrong with that but unless she is flexible she will drive her son away..

I can't believe at this age she thinks he would want to sit in a super strict controlled environment with someone who seeks to control him.to this degree rather than be free at his friends.

BatsAtHome · 06/11/2022 06:47

Flippingnora100 · 06/11/2022 03:48

We live abroad in a tropical place. My son does after school activities like art and swimming that he loves. Also surf lessons on weekends. When he’s at home he loves reading, playing Lego with his brother and just relaxing. We have a pool. Last summer he cycled around with his friends and they went from house to house, which I thought was great. Trust me, this child does not have a bad life! It’s just that we have some boundaries instead of none.

This is an amazing life. OP - you are not a bad parent for limiting junk food and screen time, quite the opposite. At 12 your son is still very much a kid.
Screen time and technology is always going to be a contentious subject -
I would suggest being less regimented about it. If its a quiet or low energy day then yes, more time playing with tech is ok. Some days it doesn't feature at all.
Trust yourself - you're the parent and you sound like a great one.
Your son is separating from you a little which is of course natural but you need to keep the family ties strong and stable too.
You could suggest that sleepovers need to be an equal amount - split between sleepovers out and sleepovers at home. Maybe one sleepover every fortnight during term and a lot more in the holidays.
I think it's ok to say no to surprise sleepovers too, if it doesn't work for the family.
Kids need sleep and healthy food as well as fun.
You might enjoy reading "Hold on to your kids" by the fantastic Gabor Mate.

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 06:45

@Thelongnights that's not usual though, my sons would sit there all day (and all night) if allowed. My eldest also needed snacks moderating when younger as he puts on weight really easily - he's got the hang of it better now that he's older.

I would rather parent properly and then lift restrictions when they no longer need them.

itwasntmetho · 06/11/2022 06:44

I’d have taken him back tonight, you had plans.

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 06:43

Op 15 mins is too short what would anyone watch in that time?
Unfortunately what such strict boundaries show at age 12 is a lack of trust.

You don't trust your son and of course he will want to "escape" to a free environment!
It's one thing restricting screen times at younger ages but age 12! He would feel hugely embarrassed to invite people back.

Respect and trust is a two way street and if he works hard and is a good student you need to relax with him and have " age appropriate" boundaries.
Otherwise you will simply turn into those "strict" parents who no one can relax around and no one wants to he around.

Remember his friends, some will be getting the exact same grade's, possibly better and yet be allowed loads of freedom. Maybe not basketball hall boy but certainly others and he will start to wonder what the point of these rules are?

Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 06:42

And not a chance I would turn up to collect my son and then just turn around and accept him sleeping over there. That is plain rude for a start

Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 06:40

Junk food, sweets, fizzy drinks, no screen time limits, big house, lots of fun stuff eg basketball court, sleepovers all the time with lots of friends etc.

quite simply - I would not want my 12 year old regularly in this environment. So would heavily limit sleepovers

Ladybug14 · 06/11/2022 06:40

bumblingbovine49 · 06/11/2022 06:34

Those are very strict screen times for a 12 year old. Do you impose them when friends are over, even at the weekend? If so I imagine his friends won't want to come over when they have a better ( to them) option.

This

Your restrictions are ludicrous imo BUT if these restrictions are in place during sleepovers too, then it's no wonder your easy going son is choosing to go elsewhere. I expect he's embarrassed but wouldn't dream of upsetting you by telling you.

Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 06:39

And thankfully sleepovers aren’t remotely a “thing” in his group of friends.

Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 06:38

I have DS same age.
One tv programme during the week but ONLY after all homework done, showered and in PJs and all laid out for school next day. No gaming during the week.

Weekends 3 hours of gaming on Saturday (I have control on app So it cuts off after 3 hours). And 2 hours on Sunday but only after showered after rugby, and done homework. Then a film with family on evening.

LolaSmiles · 06/11/2022 06:37

15 minutes sounds a bit harsh, but it sounds like you've got a lovely lifestyle out there where there's no need for children to be glued to screens for hours a day. Increasing the time a bit wouldn't be the end of the world.
It's not personal that he wants to go to his friend's house. He's 12 and the freedom is a novelty.

You seem to have a good handle on boundaries and expectations, so why are you allowing a child to decide if he's sleeping over Vs being at home? I might have got the wrong end of the stick, but you can set limits and say no to sleepovers all the time.

Ohyoucutie · 06/11/2022 06:35

He is 12 Op

not 17

assert some authority and restrict all the sleepovers. One every other weekend.

bumblingbovine49 · 06/11/2022 06:34

Flippingnora100 · 06/11/2022 03:30

15 mins in the week and 1 hour on weekends. We usually watch a tv show together at the end of the day too before they go to bed. Some of his friends have no limits. We are definitely on the stricter end. If friends come over, we aren’t too strict on the screens though.

Those are very strict screen times for a 12 year old. Do you impose them when friends are over, even at the weekend? If so I imagine his friends won't want to come over when they have a better ( to them) option.

Oblomov22 · 06/11/2022 06:32

What? Only 15 minutes? Good grief woman ease up! No wonder he wants to go to this friends house. You sound unnecessarily strict.

Cmsquestions · 06/11/2022 06:28

I’d be rejecting you too op 😉 unclench! X

Backstreets · 06/11/2022 06:23

Wish I was allowed just 15 minutes a day honestly! Though I suppose it would make my job a lot harder. Agree op’s son sounds like he has a dream life but YABU for feeling rejected by a 12 year old having fun with friends.