Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel rejected by my son?

133 replies

Flippingnora100 · 06/11/2022 02:41

DS is 12 and a lovely, kind, gentle, easygoing kid. We get along really well. I love our family time together. Lately he’s been hanging out at his friend’s house a lot and is always going on sleepovers there. The friend is a nice kid, but is quite indulged (I’m not sure if it’s because he’s an only child). Junk food, sweets, fizzy drinks, no screen time limits, big house, lots of fun stuff eg basketball court, sleepovers all the time with lots of friends etc. The mum is really nice but definitely less strict than me. My son never invites his friends to our house and jumps at any chance to go to his friends’ houses-especially this friend. Plans that start off being at our house seem to always end up at this other kid’s house instead. Today we planned a family pizza movie night and when we arrived to pick DS up, he had just been invited to sleep over and was all excited. I said yes but left feeling a little hurt. I’m happy that he has friends and gets invited to things. I don’t want to guilt trip him, but we had planned to all hang out together tonight. Do I need to let go and accept that this is how it is when kids get closer to their teenage years? Should I talk to him about evening things out and inviting friends here more often?

OP posts:
Chickmad · 06/11/2022 08:07

You may find if you insist that you alternate sleepovers that he will stop doing them altogether as he will be embarrassed for your screen time restrictions to become known by his peers.

Kids that age can be vicious and will single out any "oddities". I suspect that he makes a million excuses as to why he can't game with his mates or rarely gets back to them on messenger etc rather than admit to your 15 minute rule.

Out of interest, if school work requires working on screens how does that fit into your screen time rules?
Our schools are virtually paperless these days. Everything from source material to text books is now delivered via a screen. And all work is submitted electronically.

blippi123 · 06/11/2022 08:03

Of course he wants to go to his friend's house whenever possible

He's able to do all the things there that he's not allowed to do at home

MintJulia · 06/11/2022 08:01

Greenqueen40 · 06/11/2022 03:34

15 mins a day? At 12?? No wonder he wants to be at his friends house😬

This. He's 12, not 2.

OP, this is the beginning of your ds choosing his own life and what he wants to do. As he progresses into his teens, this builds up, he'll want to spend time with his friends, develop his own society, do sports or travel and eventually leave home.

I was like your ds, our home life was 'rigid' and by 12 I grabbed any chance to be elsewhere, quite simply because it was more fun. More freedoms, new experiences, different foods, etc. It's natural that your ds should want that. I left home at 18 and never went home.

Maybe you need to loosen the leash !

Kidsandcat · 06/11/2022 08:01

I have noticed that at secondary school age kids seem to favour the house with less restrictions for sleepovers or just hanging out. It's not personal. For sleepovers we felt we were easy going but we would go in and tell them to go to sleep if they were up too late. This was embarrassing apparently as other parents were more relaxed!! When my oldest was 16 he never wanted friends over as they always went to houses where parents were cool about drinking alcohol!!!

ikeawardrobe · 06/11/2022 08:01

OP, it has taken me more than 15 minutes to read all of the posts to here. Can you imagine what your son feels when his 15 minutes are up? You can’t do anything from beginning to end in 15 minutes.

we are the other end of your rules. DS has no restrictions on screen or gaming time as long as the jobs in the house he needs to do are done and homework is done and his room is relatively tidy. He can spend a while gaming and chatting to his friends but similarly, he will often come off and just say he’s had enough and switch Netflix on or come and watch a film with me and his dad.

Its the same with food. Nothing is restricted in the house. This works well as he will usually go for fruit and water even though he has free access to chocolate and crisps etc.

He is 14 and self regulates. I think if you restrict too much you are setting yourself up for difficult times ahead.

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 07:57

*ourselves
Absolutely

FuckabethFuckor · 06/11/2022 07:56

He’s 12, this is normal. This is when they start pushing for independence. It’s not only normal, it’s biologically necessary.

And you have to let it happen, unless you want to end up as the parent of Buster from Arrested Development.

Wait till he’s 16. You’ll never see him.

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 07:56

@Tigofigo

Sorry to intrude, my dd struggled to read etc and it was a slog but we got her going.. unfortunately she won't read as much as her D's but she has now read two thick novels which is a huge milestone for her.

But we had to do it all oirse etc the school was absorbed clue less.

Sellorkeep · 06/11/2022 07:56

If you let him spend so much time in places that have different boundaries to those you want, then what’s the point really of your boundaries?
It sounds like he’s a good age for you to revisit some things.

Melonapplepear · 06/11/2022 07:55

Im not really seeing the issue tbh? He's 12 he's going to be spending time with other people, his world is opening up. That this other woman is less 'strict' than you is neither here nor there. Unless the environment is unsafe, which doesn't seem to be the case, you are being v U.

strawberry2017 · 06/11/2022 07:54

Of course he wants to be elsewhere your rules are ridiculously OTT.
I wouldn't want to live in your house
You need to chill out more. Screen time is fine. I agree not all day but 1 hour at a weekend and 15 mins during the week.
That's ridiculous. Let your kid be a kid

Tigofigo · 06/11/2022 07:54

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 07:52

@Tigofigo

how old and why won't read, usually some sort of barrier causes this..

10 and 7. Probably dyslexic and visual processing disorder.

Tigofigo · 06/11/2022 07:53

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 07:27

Exactly.
If you have plans and your ds knows about them then no he can’t sleepover.
He needs to learn that sometimes he has to stay at home.

This.

Friends are important at that age but so is family. You should have stuck to your plans.

Puddywoodycat · 06/11/2022 07:52

@Tigofigo

how old and why won't read, usually some sort of barrier causes this..

ErinAndTonic · 06/11/2022 07:52

Maybe if you weren't so OTT on screen time and other things that bring him joy he might want to spend a bit more time at home...

Tigofigo · 06/11/2022 07:50

Thelongnights · 06/11/2022 04:49

I don't have restrictions 🤷‍♀️ not on junk or screen time, I have a rule of no junk/snacks until after lunch but that's about it. My kids don't gorge on junk or veg out in front of the TV all day either though, I find that without restrictions/ withholding certain foods etc. my children don't see those things as special, case in point I literally found their last year Halloween sweets in back of storage press when taking out Halloween decorations, completely abandoned and forgotten, this year's stuff is sitting in a big bowl on counter in kitchen and hasn't been looked at since Halloween night, it'll likely all end up in the bin just like most of ther easter chocolate and so on, was my daughters 13th bday today we all went out for dinner at a very nice restaurant and both kids passed up on dessert as they weren't in the mood and were full, we went bowling afterwards and they were offered snacks etc but didn't touch them, they didn't even have cake when offered... TV is apparently boring and they spend most days doing crafts, out swinging in the garden or reading, my 7 y/o has a massive dogman collection while 13 y/o practically inhales books. Both girls have consoles, 7 y/o has switch and 13 y/o has an xbox, they play them in the morning for maybe an hour at weekend, or if its a particularly dreary wet evening we all play Mario kart as a family, only extended period my kids are in front of a screen is if we do Mario night or a movie night. My 13 y/o is in all honor levels in secondary school. Both girls are very well behaved and I'm always complimented on their manners/politeness. I don't have to force or bribe or "encourage" then to eat their veg and I don't need to wrestle TV remotes or controllers from them. I have never had any issues with bed times, kids are always up early and I've never had a single tantrum in a shop for sweets or whatever. Neither are overweight, their both very active. Most importantly my children aren't motivated by the promise of a screen or sugar, these things do not have any weight or power over my kids and if that makes me a shit parent then so be it but I'm proud to say I'm raising children who I'm hoping become adults without food related issues such as binging on "bad/restricted food". Children should be allowed to self moderate, in fact its a skilled parents should be actively teaching... some kids literally grow up to young adults with no idea how set their own limits with devastating consequences

Doesn't this massively depend on your child though?

One of mine wine will eat and eat until he has stomach ache and has been this way since infancy. They won't read books, despite us reading to them every day, and are closer to bottom than top of class. The other one would stay on tablet all day every day given the chance and will only eat three kinds of veg despite us never forcing and continually serving a wide variety up.

Is it anything you did, or is it just your DC, because I'd wager that I work harder at parenting than most.

Violettaa · 06/11/2022 07:45

Your dig at only children is really unkind.

More generally, as your son gets older he will naturally want to spend more time with friends and less with family. That’s a good thing!

And also naturally, teens gravitate to the most fun and welcoming houses.

I can see how the suddenness of this has come as a shock to you. But whether your house is a teen ‘hub’ is in large part up to you.

Itslookinggood · 06/11/2022 07:40

I sympathise, op.

It is very hard when they start to assert their independence and want to be around friends rather than parents. If their friends’ place is a bit more of a free for all, then that’s part of the attraction too.

as time goes on, this will increase. Our task as parents is to let them go. It’s difficult to not take it personally, when we have been out child’s everything until now, but we do have to step back.

smile, say you hope your son enjoys his night, and do family night another time. And relax a bit about the screen time, as others have said.

12 is hard, it’s still very childlike in many ways but also the cusp of adolescence. But the patterns you put in place now will stick.

Doingmybest12 · 06/11/2022 07:35

The friends mum may be pleased if you say 'sorry not today it is our turn to host before you go there again'. I would try and just put a bit of a curb on things if it is too much and too onesided .but talk to your child about what he'd like to do to have friends back at yours. One of my children never had friends home although the others did. I think the one that didn't found us embarrassing or that we'd judge his friends.

Snoken · 06/11/2022 07:33

I too think you are being over the top strict with your son, which will drive him away of course. You have no trust in him and you treat him like he's much younger than he is. He needs to have freedom, and if you do want him and his friends over at your house you need to let go of most of these rules and just let them enjoy themselves even if that means occasional junk food, screen time or whatever. You sound very jealous of his friends family dynamic, but you are still adamant that you should not be a fun house because of rules, which needs to be followed.

Sushi7 · 06/11/2022 07:29

Flippingnora100 · 06/11/2022 03:30

15 mins in the week and 1 hour on weekends. We usually watch a tv show together at the end of the day too before they go to bed. Some of his friends have no limits. We are definitely on the stricter end. If friends come over, we aren’t too strict on the screens though.

Do you only spend 15 minutes a day on your phone? He can’t even play one match on an online game with his friend or text his friends for a while. When your ds is at home he can’t contact his friends because you don’t allow him to. No wonder he always goes to his friend’s house to hang out.

Fireballxl5 · 06/11/2022 07:27

Theunamedcat · 06/11/2022 07:22

You claim this other child is overindulged yet your son gets to decide where he sleeps without a murmer from you?

Exactly.
If you have plans and your ds knows about them then no he can’t sleepover.
He needs to learn that sometimes he has to stay at home.

Twiglets1 · 06/11/2022 07:25

I haven’t read the whole thread but my impression is YABU.
Family pizza night is not a big deal, it can be swapped if anyone gets a better offer. I would just rearrange it and say to your son, we’ve changed it for you so we won’t want you to change it again.
Maybe ask him casually if he would like to invite his friend to yours for a change. Ask what you could do to make the evening more fun for the boys.

tulips27 · 06/11/2022 07:22

My personal opinion is that I'd limit passive streaming (Netflix, films) but allow socially active communication (Whatsapp, possibly Instagram but that can be fraught, gaming with a group).

Theunamedcat · 06/11/2022 07:22

You claim this other child is overindulged yet your son gets to decide where he sleeps without a murmer from you?