Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to argue with secondary school over sons refusal to go on PGL? Year 8

114 replies

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:30

For context he has ADHD and this can mean he can be impulsive, not watching roads etc still is dropped off and collected by me or DH as lots of roads and trial runs led to us having to stop them.

He has never liked being away from home for too long, it’s okay we all go on holiday but when DH has tried to take him away on fishing trips he wants to come back and when I’ve taken him to visit my parents without DH he also wants to come back.

He is a real homebody and whilst he has made a few friends at secondary school, nothing massively substantial despite me taking them out here there and everywhere - Son doesn’t always want to meet up out of school as happy at home or doing activities with us

He didn’t go on the year 5 or 6 school residential and school were very reasonable but a pretty big secondary now where residentials are “ compulsory “

Son is crying and really adamant he is NOT going - WWYD?

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 11:37

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:16

Any of them SEN?

Yes, I usually have a couple of children with additional needs in the group as I think it's really important. My own daughter has ADHD and last unit holiday we had a diabetic child and one with moderate learning difficulties and ADHD.

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 11:37

Yes it is all very confidence boosting. My child came back in bits, the girls who had been bullying her for 2 years didn't have some Road to Damascus moment on the school trip. Her form teacher stood and watched when DD was sitting on the edge of the swimming pool and one of her bullies grabbed her ankles and pulled her in. Now she could have fractured her skull if she'd hit her head on the side of the pool but "all" she suffered as being held under the water and choking. A parent who had gone on the trip intervened. We had a meeting with the Head about it when they got back and the teacher claimed she thought "they were having fun" so she didn't intervene. It resulted in my DD self harming for the first time in her life.

Yes it really was a confidence building moment.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/11/2022 11:32

You tell them no and reassure your son that he does not have to go.

hope he’s feeling better today.

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 11:30

TheMorigoul · 05/11/2022 23:26

Odd responses on this thread.

I'd be doing everything I could and working with the school from their end to see what could be done to accommodate him. He will be further left out of friendship circles and will miss the great confidence boosting activities. Imagine how proud he will be of himself when he comes back and he did it. Build him up OP.

Or he might hate it and come back upset and feeling like his parents didn't have his back.

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 11:26

School talked one of mine into going on a trip. I think they realised their mistake when they phoned me at nearly midnight and asked me to have a chat and calm her down as they couldn't do anything to reassure her. I was sad for DD and glad she was home in time for bed the following night.

Going into school the next morning with younger child the receptionist said with a cheery voice that she'd just heard from Miss X and all was going well on the trip. Smug smile as she was letting me know I was wrong to have had reservations about DD going. I told her it wasn't going that well as I'd spoken to DD a few hours ago. She was taken aback, said they never, absolutely never let children phone home. I smiled and moved on.

Hard for professionals to admit it sometimes but we do actually know our own children.

Mariposista · 06/11/2022 11:24

It should not be compulsory but neither should he be allowed a week off.
He should be allowed to stay at school and be set work/join another year group if all his peers are going

GeorgeorRuth · 06/11/2022 11:22

As it is 'compulsory' they should have completed a risk assessment already for your son. I would ask to see it. ADHD is usually one where teachers heave a sigh of relief when DC don't want to go judging on the kids I know with it and their poor parents trying to get them included in activities.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:20

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:45

Sorry I should have said I’ve already emailed the HOY saying he won’t be attending and have reassured DS he won’t have to go - I home educated him when he missed the year 5/6 trips so I’ve offered that if unable to attend school etc

I just have a feeling they’ll argue it with me, a friend was in a similar position pre Covid and they basically bullied her into forcing her DD to go - not the same school but local.
They actually asked her to attend a parenting course as said she lacked boundaries and shouldn’t be dictated to by her own child!

Well more fool her for going.

Please come back and tell us the outcome.

But stick to your guns.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:19

notdaddycool · 06/11/2022 10:42

The post about how children develop on these courses is so true. I’d be looking at what you can do to make it work for your child, even brings them home each night or staying with them in a hotel nearby. Only if it really can’t work say not happening…

You know there's a cost of living crisis now, yes?

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:18

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 10:58

My homebody, not liking being away from home child, always really benefitted from going away with school and taught him resilience and independence.
I think at age 12, you're mollycoddling him and I suspect that's why the school insists they go.

They a) can't insist and b) not all children are the same and c) the OP knows her SEN son better than they do.

Fairislefandango · 06/11/2022 11:17

Parents often don't always make the correct choices for their children.

Neither do schools! And who gets to decide what is 'correct' in this context? Anyway, whether you like it or not, it is the parent's right to make that call.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:16

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 11:13

I also run a brownies group, so I'm taking away 7/8/9 year olds for a couple of nights. I find that the ones who are less keen benefit the most from the experience.

Parents often don't always make the correct choices for their children.

Any of them SEN?

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:16

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:35

The letter says and I quote
“ We are excited to have each and every one of our Year 8 pupils attend the compulsory PGL trip coming up. It’s important they attend regardless of financial pressure so please contact our school secretary if you are under financial stress. “

If it costs you any money (and it will - they won't pay for clothes etc, will they?) you get to decide.

It would be over my dead body if I was you.

Fairislefandango · 06/11/2022 11:14

I suspect that's why the school insists they go.

Do you really think the school has the authority to insist they go? Of course it doesn't. So either the school doesn't realise it can't actually enforce that (unlikely), or the school is lying to the parents. Worrying either way.

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 11:13

BiggerBoat1 · 06/11/2022 11:08

That is very harsh. It is not mollycoddling to understand your child's needs and expect the school to do the same. Not every child is the same.

I also run a brownies group, so I'm taking away 7/8/9 year olds for a couple of nights. I find that the ones who are less keen benefit the most from the experience.

Parents often don't always make the correct choices for their children.

ImAvingOops · 06/11/2022 11:08

@underneaththeash just because your child benefitted, that doesn't mean OPs child will.
And you are missing the point that the school cannot insist they go, since the school have no parental authority and can't just make unilateral decisions for other people's children!

BiggerBoat1 · 06/11/2022 11:08

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 10:58

My homebody, not liking being away from home child, always really benefitted from going away with school and taught him resilience and independence.
I think at age 12, you're mollycoddling him and I suspect that's why the school insists they go.

That is very harsh. It is not mollycoddling to understand your child's needs and expect the school to do the same. Not every child is the same.

BiggerBoat1 · 06/11/2022 11:06

It is not compulsory - they are just bullying you because they want as many to go as possible. Just stick to your guns.

Fairislefandango · 06/11/2022 11:05

I read that message as urging less well-off families to feel confident that money isn't an obstacle to attendance.

Confused It literally says 'compulsory', so I don't know how you read it that way. Yes,it says the 'regardless of financial pressure' bit too, but why on earth say it's compulsory when they have no power to make it compulsory? It's just lying!

madnesss · 06/11/2022 11:03

TheMorigoul · 05/11/2022 23:26

Odd responses on this thread.

I'd be doing everything I could and working with the school from their end to see what could be done to accommodate him. He will be further left out of friendship circles and will miss the great confidence boosting activities. Imagine how proud he will be of himself when he comes back and he did it. Build him up OP.

Great confidence booster my arse.

Listen you your child OP as that will give them more confidence when navigating this world than a forced trip/activity ever will.

LovedFedAndNoonesDead · 06/11/2022 11:00

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:35

The letter says and I quote
“ We are excited to have each and every one of our Year 8 pupils attend the compulsory PGL trip coming up. It’s important they attend regardless of financial pressure so please contact our school secretary if you are under financial stress. “

I would write back to the school stating “as parent of XX, while we appreciate that the school has arranged for every year 8 pupil to attend the residential at PGL, we do not give permission for XX to attend. We will, of course support you in ensuring XX does any school work set for the time the rest of the year are away from school and ensure that he attends school during that time.”

Darbs76 · 06/11/2022 10:59

No way they can make him go. If they try to insist I’d firstly argue it should be an adjustment for his ADHD or secondary tell them he’s unwell on the day!

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 10:58

My homebody, not liking being away from home child, always really benefitted from going away with school and taught him resilience and independence.
I think at age 12, you're mollycoddling him and I suspect that's why the school insists they go.

LIZS · 06/11/2022 10:55

They cannot disguise what is a discretionary spend as a compulsory trip. Shock If they are difficult about him not going ask them for the specific risk assessment and adjustments in relation to your ds needs. Were a day visit possible that might be a compromise but it is up to the school to make it work for your ds.

Dutch1e · 06/11/2022 10:54

I read that message as urging less well-off families to feel confident that money isn't an obstacle to attendance.

Personally I would encourage my DS to take part in some way, working with him and the school to find the right balance between stretching his comfort zone a bit without being overwhelming.