Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to argue with secondary school over sons refusal to go on PGL? Year 8

114 replies

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:30

For context he has ADHD and this can mean he can be impulsive, not watching roads etc still is dropped off and collected by me or DH as lots of roads and trial runs led to us having to stop them.

He has never liked being away from home for too long, it’s okay we all go on holiday but when DH has tried to take him away on fishing trips he wants to come back and when I’ve taken him to visit my parents without DH he also wants to come back.

He is a real homebody and whilst he has made a few friends at secondary school, nothing massively substantial despite me taking them out here there and everywhere - Son doesn’t always want to meet up out of school as happy at home or doing activities with us

He didn’t go on the year 5 or 6 school residential and school were very reasonable but a pretty big secondary now where residentials are “ compulsory “

Son is crying and really adamant he is NOT going - WWYD?

OP posts:
LBFseBrom · 06/11/2022 17:32

School is being ridiculous. Nobody has the right to force your son to go away if he cannot bear the thought of it. Just say he cannot go and avoid contact with the school until it's over.

TestingTesting123456 · 06/11/2022 17:07

@underneaththeash
Don't be silly. Parents know their children and can absolutely predict in lots of cases how they'll react to different situations. Some children are initially nervous and eventually have a nice time or at least tolerate it and feel proud of having managed. Others would be absolutely terrified and find it traumatising. The parent is the best person to gauge what would happen with her son. An anxious child does need to be pushed outside their comfort zone with plenty of support. They do not need to be pushed into a situation beyond which they can cope with. This would be massively detrimental.

I also wouldn't trust, well meaning teachers who say 'the kids always enjoy it'. My school said that and I happen to know a one child who went in the past and absolutely hated the residential and it put them off being away from home, even with family, for a long time. The teacher who said this is lovely and the trip was amazing for 99% of children (mine absolutely loved it and came back much more independent and self confident) so I don't think she was deliberately being misleading it's just not always obvious when kids mask well.

neverbeenskiing · 06/11/2022 16:30

They absolutely cannot force your DS to go. I say that as someone who works in a secondary school. What they should be doing, not just with your DS but any child with SEND, is working with the child and parents to find solutions, make adjustments and have support in place so that he might want to go.

We don't pressure kids into going on residentials, but the vast majority do go and every year we take kids with a very high level of SEN. Some kids will inevitably be anxious in the run up to the trip, so a lot of work goes into preparing them for it and making sure they know what to expect. We have had parents choose to stay in a B&B nearby in case of any issues, which turned out not to be necessary but made them feel more comfortable about it all.

Every year there are anxious kids who are adamant they aren't going (they cry at the thought of it etc) but then they realise it's all anyone will be talking about for weeks afterwards so they push themselves to do it, and they end up having a fantastic time. It is not unusual for kids who are quite socially isolated to come back from the Y8 and 9 residential with a whole new friendship group. It is really lovely to see what it can do for their confidence. All that said, you know your child best. We would never try to force you into sending him and we certainly wouldn't be so disingenuous as to claim a trip was "compulsory" when we simply don't have that authority.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 14:38

mycatisannoying · 06/11/2022 13:33

Couldn't you drop him off for a day or two? In all my years in Education, I've never come across a child who didn't love school camp ... and this includes children with significant needs.
There's surely a compromise between making him go and allowing him to stay in his comfort zone forever.

Why do some people not realise that all children are different so it's not beyond the realms of possibility that the OP's DC will hate it?

And if a kid is crying at the thought, it's not for them. It's supposed to be FUN!

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 14:36

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 13:53

You have no way of knowing that, as they haven't tried.

I know my own DGD and she would be overwhelmed and would hate it.
So not unreasonable to thing others might be the same

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 14:13

mycatisannoying · 06/11/2022 13:33

Couldn't you drop him off for a day or two? In all my years in Education, I've never come across a child who didn't love school camp ... and this includes children with significant needs.
There's surely a compromise between making him go and allowing him to stay in his comfort zone forever.

Maybe I could introduce you to my DD.

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 13:53

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 13:09

But all individuals and for some it really wouldn't work

You have no way of knowing that, as they haven't tried.

Irridescantshimmmer · 06/11/2022 13:50

He's got ADHD, the school have to make reasonbable adjustments which means your son should be exempt from compulsary residential trips.

Check with Ofsted.

mycatisannoying · 06/11/2022 13:33

Couldn't you drop him off for a day or two? In all my years in Education, I've never come across a child who didn't love school camp ... and this includes children with significant needs.
There's surely a compromise between making him go and allowing him to stay in his comfort zone forever.

Zofloraeverywhere · 06/11/2022 13:33

@CatLover122 you know your child better than anyone else and if he isn’t going to benefit from this school trip, there is absolutely no point in him going. It’s supposed to be something joyful, not an endurance test for young people!

Does your son have a particular educational interest or subject that he really likes? The week of the trip could be a good time for you to devote some time to planning activities around his favourite subject.

bewarethetides · 06/11/2022 13:29

Under the circumstances, just stand firm. Tell the school you will not be paying for the trip and he won't be going end of.

Refuse to pay for it.

Betty000 · 06/11/2022 13:24

Residential are not compulsory. Poor kid, tell the school in writing why he will not be attending and that you will tolerate no further coercive behaviour on the subject. He and you have both clearly declined and there is nothing they can do it about it. Absolute arseholes, ive had this twice with my youngest, makes me so cross.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/11/2022 13:19

Saying it's compulsory could be the wording they need to be legally able to pay for everybody who says they can't afford it.

Which would mean that the OP can quite happily keep him at home with her or send him in to be put into lower years' classes/inclusion/wherever they find a place for him for the week.

StillMedusa · 06/11/2022 13:18

Fuck that.
It's not compulsory, no matter what they say... what are they going to do, drag your son and pack him a suitcase?

I still remember the residential trip I went on and it was miserable. I was bullied the whole time and consequently never forced my own children. Two went and loved it, one hated the idea and didn't. One went from an early age as at a Special School where they did it to give parents a break, but there I knew he was so well looked after I didn't hesitate.

Stick to your guns... one trip isn't going to magically make him find it all so much fun of he doesn't want to go.

Ocampa · 06/11/2022 13:16

I hated every school trip and residential. It was bad for my confidence and since I need some down time everyday, actually made me more vulnerable to bullying because I was different. I can't function unless I'm left alone each day. Other kids don't understand that.

Schools should fuck off with all kinds of compulsory trips and gym classes. And I say that as an adult who loves travelling and exercises almost daily. Both trips and gym classes in school make kids who are even slightly different, targets for bullying.

My mum later told me that she also hated each trip because it was "just too loud and busy" for her. So I'm guessing the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

Stand by your child, you know them best.

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 13:09

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 11:37

Yes, I usually have a couple of children with additional needs in the group as I think it's really important. My own daughter has ADHD and last unit holiday we had a diabetic child and one with moderate learning difficulties and ADHD.

But all individuals and for some it really wouldn't work

Fairislefandango · 06/11/2022 12:54

It should not be compulsory but neither should he be allowed a week off.
He should be allowed to stay at school and be set work/join another year group if all his peers are going

That sounds like you think he should be punished for not going. Yes he might join another class, but the OP getting him to do school work at home would be just as educationally valid.

WhatFreshHel1 · 06/11/2022 12:22

Another secondary school worker who says bollocks to them and their compulsory trip. Honestly, argue like hell. I would support you if you were one of my students' parents.

madnesss · 06/11/2022 12:20

ImAvingOops · 06/11/2022 12:19

Tbh I think it's perfectly okay for a child to just decide they don't want to go and got that to be respected, even without having additional needs.
Sone kids just absolutely hate this stuff and are homebodies. This is absolutely fine and not a character flaw that they need to be forced out of!
Schools need to recognise that not all children are the same. Like adults, they have their own preferences. There are plenty of adults for whom an enforced week with work colleagues, doing activities that their employer deemed worthy, would be hellish too.

Spot on

ImAvingOops · 06/11/2022 12:19

Tbh I think it's perfectly okay for a child to just decide they don't want to go and got that to be respected, even without having additional needs.
Sone kids just absolutely hate this stuff and are homebodies. This is absolutely fine and not a character flaw that they need to be forced out of!
Schools need to recognise that not all children are the same. Like adults, they have their own preferences. There are plenty of adults for whom an enforced week with work colleagues, doing activities that their employer deemed worthy, would be hellish too.

HuwsInTheHouse · 06/11/2022 12:17

I would be refusing.

My recently diagnosed ASD child was definitely traumatised by all the times I encouraged them to go to parties, clubs or events that they clearly didn't want to go to but I listened to peer pressure.

Brownies trips are a ridiculous comparison because, as another poster said, they are already happy to go to Brownies!

MummyGummy · 06/11/2022 12:03

Nanny0gg · 06/11/2022 11:19

You know there's a cost of living crisis now, yes?

You don’t know the OP’s financial situation, it’s helpful to have alternative suggestions.

Another option could be a parent going along on the trip to assist, or if it isn’t that far from home they could go for at least one day as a day trip.

It depends what the barriers are preventing them from wanting to go, do they not want to be away from home, are they worried about the activities or food, do they not have a friendship group. The school has to make reasonable adjustments to make the trip inclusive for your child.

If all these ideas have been explored then it’s perfectly ok for them not to go, reassure them there will be other opportunities when they are older and they might feel able to go then.

GnomeDePlume · 06/11/2022 11:48

underneaththeash · 06/11/2022 11:37

Yes, I usually have a couple of children with additional needs in the group as I think it's really important. My own daughter has ADHD and last unit holiday we had a diabetic child and one with moderate learning difficulties and ADHD.

Brownies is different because they are already going because they want to go.

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 11:40

Fairislefandango · 06/11/2022 11:05

I read that message as urging less well-off families to feel confident that money isn't an obstacle to attendance.

Confused It literally says 'compulsory', so I don't know how you read it that way. Yes,it says the 'regardless of financial pressure' bit too, but why on earth say it's compulsory when they have no power to make it compulsory? It's just lying!

Exactly right. How do they expect to have a good relationship with parents or guardians if they bare faced lie to them? How are we expected to respect them?

2reefsin30knots · 06/11/2022 11:38

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:45

Sorry I should have said I’ve already emailed the HOY saying he won’t be attending and have reassured DS he won’t have to go - I home educated him when he missed the year 5/6 trips so I’ve offered that if unable to attend school etc

I just have a feeling they’ll argue it with me, a friend was in a similar position pre Covid and they basically bullied her into forcing her DD to go - not the same school but local.
They actually asked her to attend a parenting course as said she lacked boundaries and shouldn’t be dictated to by her own child!

If he's in Y8 I'm very surprised he had a Y5 or 6 residential to miss. Both years were hit by covid and residentials were pretty much the first to go and last to return.

Swipe left for the next trending thread