Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to argue with secondary school over sons refusal to go on PGL? Year 8

114 replies

CatLover122 · 05/11/2022 22:30

For context he has ADHD and this can mean he can be impulsive, not watching roads etc still is dropped off and collected by me or DH as lots of roads and trial runs led to us having to stop them.

He has never liked being away from home for too long, it’s okay we all go on holiday but when DH has tried to take him away on fishing trips he wants to come back and when I’ve taken him to visit my parents without DH he also wants to come back.

He is a real homebody and whilst he has made a few friends at secondary school, nothing massively substantial despite me taking them out here there and everywhere - Son doesn’t always want to meet up out of school as happy at home or doing activities with us

He didn’t go on the year 5 or 6 school residential and school were very reasonable but a pretty big secondary now where residentials are “ compulsory “

Son is crying and really adamant he is NOT going - WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NumberTheory · 10/11/2022 21:12

@CatLover122 Did the email work for you? Have they accepted that your son won’t be going?

CatLover122 · 06/11/2022 20:57

That’s more polite than the email I was planning on sending so I’ll steal that - thank you!

OP posts:
FaazoHuyzeoSix · 06/11/2022 20:54

Dear HOY

Your dismissive and glib email of 6th November amounts to discrimination against (DC Name) on grounds of disability as you are refusing to recognise that his specific needs due to his neurodiversity mean that he cannot be forced into a one-size-fits-all plan. It is not in his best interests to be forced into an activity which will trigger serious anxiety issues, and if the school continues to badger and harass him to join the trip I will be taking my complaints about this discriminatory and unprofessional conduct to the highest levels. I will most certainly not be paying any fee and you do not have my consent to take him on this trip, and will not at any point have such consent."

CatLover122 · 06/11/2022 20:49

I actually am not sure why they’re so welcoming of offering financial assistance as it’s a really affluent school - I doubt money would be an issue for many there.

It would actually be a stretch for us at £600 for 5 days but it’s the emotional trauma I won’t inflict by forcing something that’s not necessary.

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 06/11/2022 20:36

I wouldn't trust a HOY who sent that email with my child's welfare away from home. At heat they are totally clueless, at worst they are deliberately dismissive of parental concerns.

whatdoesthisallmean · 06/11/2022 20:24

The fact that the email from the head of year is so dismissive would just make more worried about him going. No attempt to reassure you or him or to discuss how any adjustments might help support him. Terrible email.

2bazookas · 06/11/2022 20:06

I 'm betting every year, the school encounters parents who exclude their children from residential courses for assorted physical/medical/ dietary /religious reasons. You won't be the only one so just politely tell them NO.

It's ridiculous to present such courses as "compulsory"

cansu · 06/11/2022 19:59

Why don't you talk to them about making adjustments so he can go? Could he go for the day time only? Is it close enough for you to collect him if he is unhappy? A school that is willing to help with finances for everyone to go is being pretty generous. They obviously feel it is a good opportunity. Discuss it first.

Invisibleeye · 06/11/2022 19:55

As a teacher I am absolutely disgusted by that HOY’s response. I would be making a formal complaint.

alexdgr8 · 06/11/2022 19:50

having read that last email, i would be moving him to another school.
their attitude is all wrong.
they can't all be that bad.
all the best to you and yours.

Mamarsupial · 06/11/2022 19:49

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 19:45

Well thinking about my DDs trip where her bully pulled her into a pool and held her under the water with her teacher looking on I suppose if another parent hadn't been there and intervened the worst that could have happened was her coming home in a bodybag. Wouldn't I have felt the fool for encouraging her to try it.

Yes I read your post and am sorry your daughter had such a horrible experience. It’s not something you can generalise to all school trips though. Sounds like a lack of proper supervision.
I had a horrible experience as a child getting lost in a supermarket. Doesn’t mean it’s dangerous for all children in Tesco. Just hold their hands.

ancientgran · 06/11/2022 19:45

Mamarsupial · 06/11/2022 19:26

I mean you wouldn’t be unreasonable not to send him, but children need encouragement to be brave and try new things. What’s the worst / best that could happen? He might surprise you. Having skipped 2 trips already he might be anxious - but it’s good to face our anxieties. He may have fun! School seem confident he can handle it. I’d give it serious consideration.

Well thinking about my DDs trip where her bully pulled her into a pool and held her under the water with her teacher looking on I suppose if another parent hadn't been there and intervened the worst that could have happened was her coming home in a bodybag. Wouldn't I have felt the fool for encouraging her to try it.

Mamarsupial · 06/11/2022 19:26

I mean you wouldn’t be unreasonable not to send him, but children need encouragement to be brave and try new things. What’s the worst / best that could happen? He might surprise you. Having skipped 2 trips already he might be anxious - but it’s good to face our anxieties. He may have fun! School seem confident he can handle it. I’d give it serious consideration.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 06/11/2022 19:25

As for a friend making thing.

Many people - children and adults - are happy as fuck with having a few close friends rather than having loads of friends for the sake of it.

SpentDandelion · 06/11/2022 19:24

I went away on a Girl Guides weekend when l was a young girl. l was absolutely dreading it for weeks before and only went to please my mum. I hated every single minute of it, felt very homesick and like a fish out of water throughout. I cried with relief when l got back home.
Even though l am now 54 just the thought of it makes me feel terrible. My mum and the Girl Guide leaders thought l enjoyed it, it was one of the worst experiences of my life, even though l was very much an outdoorsy child.
Can we please agree that these kind of forced activities are not for everyone and there's nothing wrong with that.

Merlott · 06/11/2022 19:19

Fgs what a ridiculous response from hoy.

I forced myself to go on 2x secondary residentials at 12 and 17... both traumatising. Not using that word lightly.

I would have been better off not going to either. In the end it won't make a lick of difference to a child's education to go on a res

OppsUpsSide · 06/11/2022 19:18

I would reply

‘Thank you for your email, I can assure you I will not be paying the deposit for a trip my son will not be attending. If you wish to discuss this further, please ensure any discussions are had with me rather than my son, you can reach me on __ .’

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 06/11/2022 19:14

I wouldn’t and didn’t send youngest with sn. Anyone who knew him were well aware that he would absolutely detest it.
His comfort zone was going away for 2 nights with his eldest siblings. Thankfully the hoy had his head screwed on and knew these trips aren’t the making of all. Probably helped that he, like many others was forced to endure a week away with his bullies including being in the same room.

Years ago school bullies a friend about her dd going, and of course the dd, along with encouraging the class to go on at her about going. It was horrific and the girl would come home in tears every single night for months.

The school paid just in case they got their way which was possibly behind the increased pressure.

She went and was home within 48 hours. Not only did she really hate the whole thing, the teachers couldn’t deal with her behaviour which she’d managed to mask during the school day.

It’s taken a long bloody time undoing all of that through her family, CAHMS and mh teams.

BertieQueen · 06/11/2022 19:12

You know your own child and what they feel comfortable with.

Having worked within schools myself I am shocked at how they are wording their letters/emails to you. It’s not compulsory to attend school trips.

I would email back and repeat that he shall not be attending and that there will be no more discussions on it. If they still keep on take it further to governors/council.

Do not pay a deposit.

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 06/11/2022 19:12

They cannot possibly take your child away without your consent, so they cannot be compulsory.

madnesss · 06/11/2022 19:08

CatLover122 · 06/11/2022 18:16

So head of year has emailed back ( on a Sunday!! ) saying
“ I am sorry to hear that NAME doesn’t want to attend and you as parents don’t feel it is in his best interests however I can assure you all students who attend, thoroughly enjoy it when there.
We will do all we can, and urge you to do the same to encourage NAME to be prepared for the upcoming trip.
Please pay the £95 deposit by the due date 11/11,
Kind regards
HOY 7 NAME “

Ummm…NO

How bizarre, given your child's ADHD, there is no attempt at discussion. This is something I would be taking higher.

Mum2jenny · 06/11/2022 19:06

Agreed with previous posters, just reply and say that your child will not be taking part in the residental trip end of.

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 06/11/2022 18:53

They cannot make you go and they cannot demand money. Just email back saying that as already stated XXX WILL NOT be attending. I would be tempted to contact the local authority and make a complaint about their bullying behaviour. Also for many parents £95 is undoable even at this time of year. If they are making a trip compulsory then they can bloody well pay for it.

FrodisCapering · 06/11/2022 18:49

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

CatLover122 · 06/11/2022 18:16

So head of year has emailed back ( on a Sunday!! ) saying
“ I am sorry to hear that NAME doesn’t want to attend and you as parents don’t feel it is in his best interests however I can assure you all students who attend, thoroughly enjoy it when there.
We will do all we can, and urge you to do the same to encourage NAME to be prepared for the upcoming trip.
Please pay the £95 deposit by the due date 11/11,
Kind regards
HOY 7 NAME “

Ummm…NO

OP posts: