Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with the nurses strike?

686 replies

borderterrierr · 05/11/2022 20:10

Guardian reporting that the rcn strike has resulted in a yes vote and we'll be striking before Christmas.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/nov/05/nurses-across-uk-vote-to-strike-in-first-ever-national-action?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Patient's emergency care will be protected but it's a strike vote

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 07/11/2022 01:09

A 17% pay raise would most probably result in hospital closures and staff reshuffled. It won’t mean more staff. The NHS can’t afford the >£6bn to give them that kind of raise.

But the government could afford to scrap the National Insurance rise which was supposed to generate 13 billion for the NHS, yet maintain that level of funding?

It seems that money can be found for political decisions, doesn't it?

lolalouisa84 · 07/11/2022 00:44

@Discovereads

The £1400 was for all staff. The only people who got close to 4% were band 2 staff who were basically on NMW. Nurses at the lowest pay point it was less than 3%

What that article doesn't mention (assuming from your quotes) is that at the same time they increased pension contributions. So in terms of actual take home pay, there was at most £10 per month, but in some cases the uplift bumped them up a pension bracket and it resulted in less take home pay than prior to the uplift. So they were infact worse off.

This uplift and the knock on effect with pensions is what led to strike action being balloted. It negatively affected many many frontline nurse and other HCPs within the NHS.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 00:39

noblegiraffe · 07/11/2022 00:19

So, this strike is only about pay and demanding a 17% pay raise?

Legally, yes. But if nurses were working in fab conditions and hadn't had the piss taken out of them for years by this government then this yet another shitty pay offer might not be the final straw. They have never had a national strike before.

Something has to change in hospitals. Nurses are facing yet another pay cut. Everyone is struggling to pay the bills. If more nurses leave because they can't afford to stay then conditions will get even worse.

Something has to change. A pay increase would help retain staff. Retaining staff would be an improvement over losing even more staff.

Improving pay is linked to improving working conditions.

A 17% pay raise would most probably result in hospital closures and staff reshuffled. It won’t mean more staff. The NHS can’t afford the >£6bn to give them that kind of raise. If this articles figures are correct, they’re asking for an raise of approx. £6k per annum for each nurse, and there are over a million nurses

Nurses are facing yet another pay cut. According to the same article the Government has offered a £1,400 per annum pay raise for each nurse which averages 4%. Scotland nurses have been offered a flat £2,205 per annum pay raise, which averages 7%.

inews.co.uk/news/health/nhs-nurses-strike-december-hospital-delays-1955518

noblegiraffe · 07/11/2022 00:19

So, this strike is only about pay and demanding a 17% pay raise?

Legally, yes. But if nurses were working in fab conditions and hadn't had the piss taken out of them for years by this government then this yet another shitty pay offer might not be the final straw. They have never had a national strike before.

Something has to change in hospitals. Nurses are facing yet another pay cut. Everyone is struggling to pay the bills. If more nurses leave because they can't afford to stay then conditions will get even worse.

Something has to change. A pay increase would help retain staff. Retaining staff would be an improvement over losing even more staff.

Improving pay is linked to improving working conditions.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 00:03

@noblegiraffe
So, this strike is only about pay and demanding a 17% pay raise?
Nothing to do with patient care and understaffing? Why are nurses claiming it is all about the latter and nothing to do with the former?

If they cannot strike about patient care & understaffing because, as you said, it’s not affecting all members nationally, then why even strike if striking won’t affect understaffing & improve patient care?

If the vote & threat to strike was just to raise public awareness, job well done. So why not call off the strike so that patient safety isn’t further jeopardised? What purpose could actually going through with the strike serve?

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 23:42

If you want a national strike, it has to be about something that affects all members nationally. I imagine that individual staffing levels in different hospitals and different departments would be quite difficult to ascertain.

As a teacher, different schools have local strikes about conditions in their schools, but it would be quite difficult to strike nationally about general conditions that weren't considered to be political. The teacher unions, for example, aren't currently balloting members in private schools because the pay dispute doesn't affect them and that wouldn't be allowed.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:34

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 23:32

They're not allowed to strike about the NHS being run into the ground because that's political. So they are striking about pay, which is what they are allowed, legally, to strike about.

Well that’s a bit of a porkie, because you can strike over pay and/or work conditions like dangerous levels of understaffing.

It’s not true you can only strike over pay.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 23:32

They're not allowed to strike about the NHS being run into the ground because that's political. So they are striking about pay, which is what they are allowed, legally, to strike about.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:31

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 23:27

Even if you’re not the best nurse, you can quite easily build up a annual pension income of £80k/yr by working a normal forty year career.

"Easily" and "working a forty year career as a nurse" don't seen to belong in the same sentence.

I was reading that 1 in 9 nurses quit this year so I don't think many of them are lasting 40 years, despite the pension.

Well, I don’t disagree understaffing and stress is a major issue causing nurses to leave. But the pay isn’t appallingly low and the pension is still generous, so it seems disingenuous to claim they are why nurses are leaving and demand a 17% pay raise…

Conditions bad= yes
Pay and benefits bad= no

Iwantcollarbones · 06/11/2022 23:28

@lolalouisa84

Thank you. I have been very lucky with my placements so far (lots of CNS placements) so have been able to get lots signed off but I have also had to be quite strident at times as some nurses simply can’t find the time to sit and sign off the pad. I have been on placements where I have seen nurses start and leave during the time I’ve been there. Staff turnover is truly alarming on the wards and the government doesn’t seem to even ask why. If I wasn’t so disoriented from the workload of theory and placement I might have time to wonder what the hell I am getting myself in to. But seeing how hard qualified nurses work, the skills they have, the effect of the dedication and the skill sets they have has on patients, and yet how they struggle financially is appalling.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 23:27

Even if you’re not the best nurse, you can quite easily build up a annual pension income of £80k/yr by working a normal forty year career.

"Easily" and "working a forty year career as a nurse" don't seen to belong in the same sentence.

I was reading that 1 in 9 nurses quit this year so I don't think many of them are lasting 40 years, despite the pension.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:27

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 23:12

The thing you’ve failed to take into account @Discovereads is that NHS salaries don’t keep up with inflation. NHS staff have effectively had a pay cut over the last ten years. If that continues that pension doesn’t look very rosy.

No, I have actually. I’ve assumed this hypothetical nurse earns only £27k a year for 40yrs, never a promotion, never a pay raise. Which I know is so conservative it’s laughable but was to prove the point the pension is actually still generous.

It’s not the salary that gets increased with inflation + 1.5% in my example, it’s your pension entitlement for every year of work.

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 23:12

The thing you’ve failed to take into account @Discovereads is that NHS salaries don’t keep up with inflation. NHS staff have effectively had a pay cut over the last ten years. If that continues that pension doesn’t look very rosy.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 22:58

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 22:08

NHS pensions are no longer particularly generous. The scheme has just changed again to reduce its generosity further.

They are still generous. Earn 1/54th of salary per year that is then increased by CPI + 1.5% each year until you retire. No cap on how many years you can work and accrue. When it pays out, it is also inflation indexed to increase each year. Plus an ill health/disability early retirement provision.

One year working at £27k, gives you an initial £500/yr defined benefit pension income. After forty years of this being increased by CPI + 1.5%, if we use the 20yr CPI U.K. average of 2.05%, that’s 3.55% annual growth in value. If you retire after forty years work, your first year of work alone gives you a defined pension benefit of £2,018.25 income/ yr that will continue to grow whilst in retirement.

Even if you’re not the best nurse, you can quite easily build up a annual pension income of £80k/yr by working a normal forty year career. Now £80k in forty years will be worth only around £36k today. But still, £36k/yr in todays money worth of guaranteed pension income that increases each year with inflation while retired? That’s still generous and that’s assuming you never get promoted not once your entire career.

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 22:38

Iwantcollarbones · 06/11/2022 22:34

I’ll admit it is an exaggeration as band 7s also practice at a level with experience that can not be taught at uni, but the clinical skills the new band 5’s will be equipped with are at that level. Advanced assessments in cardio, respiratory, neuro and gastro, prescribing and IV drug administration were previously expected to be learnt as you progressed your career as a previous placement supervisor explained to me when she came across them in my pad, skills she was just learning whilst completing her msc.

The uni i attended was a "flagship" for the new curriculum and it can be tough to get them, I know some in my cohort struggled for so many, it was a massive talking point n our cohort chats as placements just weren't aware of the changes before we went in and showed them what was expected! Arranging as many spokes as you can whilst out on placement is definitely beneficial though, then they can liaise with your assessor and get you signed off. Theres defs more than the two I mentioned I struggled to get, but those two were definitely the hardest so stick out!

Good luck with your final year!

Notsofast1 · 06/11/2022 22:34

I'm a pharmacist and we're paid under agenda for change like nursing staff. Totally agree with strike action. I completely understand that the money has to come from somewhere to pay off the huge debts the country has however the pay disparities between the public and private sector now are frankly huge, i massively disagree with Agenda For Change. I've worked 13 years for the NHS, spent 5 years training and done 2 masters degrees and a prescribing qualification to become a specialist within Intensive Care. The high Street pharmacies are paying newly qualified pharmacists 10,000 a year less than I earn as a starting salary excluding bonuses for this years graduates. Frankly that's a disgrace! No where else in the civilised world do we get paid such little to do what we do just because its for the NHS. I am frankly looking to get out now and move to industry. I love my job and took a lower salary initially than my peers working in the private sector because I knew I'd get a decent pension at the end of it. Now I contribute nearly 13% of my pay for it and its not final salary anymore. Frankly that does not make the extra unpaid hours, the phone calls at all hours and the weekends worth it for me. I'm very sad about it but I'm done.

Iwantcollarbones · 06/11/2022 22:34

I’ll admit it is an exaggeration as band 7s also practice at a level with experience that can not be taught at uni, but the clinical skills the new band 5’s will be equipped with are at that level. Advanced assessments in cardio, respiratory, neuro and gastro, prescribing and IV drug administration were previously expected to be learnt as you progressed your career as a previous placement supervisor explained to me when she came across them in my pad, skills she was just learning whilst completing her msc.

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 22:28

Topgub · 06/11/2022 22:24

@lolalouisa84

Did your placement not have a cardiology or respiratory ward?

No icu? Or ED?

I know loads of ward based nurses with those skills. Band 5s too. Lol

My placements were not cardiology resp or ITU (my 3rd year placements were awful in all honesty lol), but i went with the ITU outreach nurses for 2 shifts for ECG interpretation, then my chest ausc I did with the surgical nurse practitioners whilst on a surgical day case placement and managed to chat them into letting me go as I knew some from my previous HCA role in surgical special care.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 22:24

@lolalouisa84

Did your placement not have a cardiology or respiratory ward?

No icu? Or ED?

I know loads of ward based nurses with those skills. Band 5s too. Lol

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 22:20

Topgub · 06/11/2022 22:18

@lolalouisa84

Still not practicing at the level of a band 7 though

No i agree, bit of an exaggeration, but a nightmare to get signed off as a student when no ward level nurses (in my placement areas) could do those skills so a 100+ students need the spokes and exposure to actually do them to get it signed off

Topgub · 06/11/2022 22:18

@lolalouisa84

Still not practicing at the level of a band 7 though

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 22:16

Topgub · 06/11/2022 22:14

@lolalouisa84

I'm aware 3rd year students are now expected to complete venepuncture and cannulstion, and be IV drug trained.

But that is not practicing at the level of a band 7.

Interpret ECGs accurately and Identifying differing chest sounds via auscultation are the two off the top of my head I couldn't do on any placement and had to spoke with specialists to get signed off. Im sure there were more though

Lovemyjobbutstruggling · 06/11/2022 22:14

I’m a nurse and voted yes to striking. I have a BSc, an MSc and a prescribing qualification. I’ve worked as a nurse for 20 years. I lead a service and very much do the same job as the consultants within my specialty. I absolutely love my job but I’m exhausted. I have to work extra shifts whenever I can to have enough money to pay my bills. I rarely have a lunch break, never leave work on time and frequently have to do work at home once I’ve got my children to bed. I do all the extra unpaid hours because I care about my patients but there has to be a point where we say enough is enough and make a stand.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 22:14

@lolalouisa84

I'm aware 3rd year students are now expected to complete venepuncture and cannulstion, and be IV drug trained.

But that is not practicing at the level of a band 7.

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 22:11

@Topgub I think "practice at band 7" is a bit of an exaggeration, but some are definitely not standard ward-based care proffs and are much more specialised.