Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with the nurses strike?

686 replies

borderterrierr · 05/11/2022 20:10

Guardian reporting that the rcn strike has resulted in a yes vote and we'll be striking before Christmas.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/nov/05/nurses-across-uk-vote-to-strike-in-first-ever-national-action?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Patient's emergency care will be protected but it's a strike vote

OP posts:
walkinginsunshinekat · 07/11/2022 17:31

@Cherryblossoms85 Bankers are probably for another thread?

But on a funding model, as an EU comparison, UK scores well BUT we are then comparing ourselves with Latvia and other small states too, when comparisons made with Germany France Italy and Spain, we do not do anything like as well, consistently 1 to 3% of GDP less than these larger economies.

Personally (and you might be surprised) we have to spend more and as much as i don't like Sunak, i'd be happy to see charges for all NHS appointments & charges for missed appointments, with money ring fenced for the NHS and GP practices - detail would need to be looked at and exemptions as we do for prescriptions.

Many other EU countries do this and i think it would help people value the NHS a bit more and stop taking it and the staff for granted.

The caveat is that services would have to improve first.

kitcat15 · 07/11/2022 17:30

TheForests · 07/11/2022 08:35

I earn £25k I work for a charity doing work that is stressful and life changing for the clients. I just feel like all this moaning about pay is a bit insensitive to people who actually have a low wage.

🙄 and?

CrazyCatLover · 07/11/2022 17:27

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 09:42

I think nurses already have a decent wage and an excellent pension.
Theyre not low paid. 🤷‍♀️

Yew the current retired nurses do have an excellent pension (alot of which retired @ 55). Which younger nurses have no chance of getting now. Total age discrimination, born in a different year and have totally different retirement opportunities in the NHS.

lolalouisa84 · 07/11/2022 17:02

TheForests · 07/11/2022 16:53

Sorry because I feel like I'm usually behind strikes, I go on marches, I believe in social justice.
But I earn 27k. I work with rough sleepers and substance misusers who often have complex mental health issues. It's a hard job, funding has been cut by half since I started the role.
I do it because I believe in it, I want to make a difference, more fool me perhaps.
It just sounds like they get quite a good deal.

My sister works in community mental health and addiction services and I 100% couldn't do her job for all the money in the world. Its impossible, but she loves it and the people she works with.

Nursing absolutely is underpaid and undervalued. But its not alone in that, there's many services within the UK that need to be looked at both funding wise and the pay given to essential staff. Nurses are just the ones who currently have been given a platform to shout from. I hope one day soon MH services get their chance too.

Topgub · 07/11/2022 16:59

@TheForests

Rather than being pissed off at nurses trying to improve their wages to what they should be, you should be doing the same.

mumof2many1943 · 07/11/2022 16:58

@ TheForests you too need a pay rise, thanks for all you do for unfortunate people.

PomRuns · 07/11/2022 16:58

@TheForests thst sounds like a really tough and difficult job, I’m sure I couldn’t do it. I don’t think it’s comparable to nursing issues highlighted.
I do think you should be paid more though.

prescribingmum · 07/11/2022 16:58

TheForests · 07/11/2022 16:47

I'm sorry but I agree with all this.

Ok, so what’s your solution to fix the current staff crisis and poor working conditions nurses are facing?

TheForests · 07/11/2022 16:53

Sorry because I feel like I'm usually behind strikes, I go on marches, I believe in social justice.
But I earn 27k. I work with rough sleepers and substance misusers who often have complex mental health issues. It's a hard job, funding has been cut by half since I started the role.
I do it because I believe in it, I want to make a difference, more fool me perhaps.
It just sounds like they get quite a good deal.

mumof2many1943 · 07/11/2022 16:51

Trained in the 1960’s, yes pay was appalling and yes we worked many more hours, however the respect and love we got from patients was amazing!
I am not sure I could work for the NHS today, (and we were paid whilst training).
Go for it nurses, HCPs I will be on the picket line with you❤️

Topgub · 07/11/2022 16:49

@TheForests

Why are you sorry?

PomRuns · 07/11/2022 16:49

No need to be sorry, that’s your opinion. It won’t however, help staff the nhs.

TheForests · 07/11/2022 16:47

Katypp · 07/11/2022 16:17

I must be living in a parallel universe when £27k starting salary is considered a shockingly low wage.
As usual, this thread has become an echo chamber of indignant nurses and sycophantic supporters.
Unless you agree that:
A. No profession works harder than nurses
B. No profession has any worth apart from nursing
C. Every other profession allows you to work from home and not do very much of worth
D. A salary range of £27-47k for a ward nurse is pitiful
E. No other profession ever works unpaid overtime or misses breaks, ever
F. All nurses are beyond criticism
And G. Apparently nurses are unique in having to pay back student loans, not being able to afford housing and having to pay to park their car at work.

No criticism or critical thought allowed. Move on.

I'm sorry but I agree with all this.

prescribingmum · 07/11/2022 16:46

@Katypp noone is claiming any of those things.

The point you’re spectacularly missing is that nurses are absolutely essential to our health service and there is a huge shortage of nurses at the moment which is causing a downwards spiral in working conditions and staffing levels. Unless they are paid better, we won’t be able to attract more into the profession or convince those in the profession to stay. What then?!

Comparing their pay to other professions is meaningless as are all of the other points you have made. We can’t have an NHS without nurses so either we get behind them and pay them an amount that retains them or they continue to leave and our health service disintegrates

PomRuns · 07/11/2022 16:41
  • dislike even !
PomRuns · 07/11/2022 16:32

@Katypp noone has claimed those things. You’re dyskinesia of the nhs/ nurses is clouding what you see.

Topgub · 07/11/2022 16:28

@Katypp

It's helpful if your criticisms are based in fact to start with

Cherryblossoms85 · 07/11/2022 16:22

@walkinginsunshinekat My understanding is that the pay structure will change completely, so they will lose the existing base pay offer and have their employment contracts redrawn.
I think what we're really missing is competent politicians capable of drafting good legislation that does not have unintended consequences, and able to govern without endless kneejerk reactions and random u-turns. I have absolutely no idea what the funding model for the NHS should be, or how we can afford it, but there hasn't been a coherent plan from the government in at least 5 years, and it shows. Not sure Hunt's "reforms" did anything noticeably positive either.

Katypp · 07/11/2022 16:17

I must be living in a parallel universe when £27k starting salary is considered a shockingly low wage.
As usual, this thread has become an echo chamber of indignant nurses and sycophantic supporters.
Unless you agree that:
A. No profession works harder than nurses
B. No profession has any worth apart from nursing
C. Every other profession allows you to work from home and not do very much of worth
D. A salary range of £27-47k for a ward nurse is pitiful
E. No other profession ever works unpaid overtime or misses breaks, ever
F. All nurses are beyond criticism
And G. Apparently nurses are unique in having to pay back student loans, not being able to afford housing and having to pay to park their car at work.

No criticism or critical thought allowed. Move on.

walkinginsunshinekat · 07/11/2022 16:09

@Cherryblossoms85 Fair enough.

Yes i get foreign workers but surely UK based top people would have had a salary increase to compensate loss of bonus? thats what i understood happened.
They wouldn't lose that unless non consolidated, though i guess in a shrinking sector, they may well lose their jobs.

Yes 100% on Brexit, terrible for the 'city, FS, LS and UK plc, not to mention a strong Europe, able to stand up & compete with US China.

btw i'm a firm believer in capitalism but with a social heart i.e very good regulation & social protection other wise we just go back to the 19th C.

Which is why i support whatever action nurses and AHPs take.

Cherryblossoms85 · 07/11/2022 15:42

@walkinginsunshinekat Sorry maybe I misunderstood. Yes, we all globally paid for the GFC. A lot of people were also massively overleveraged particularly in the US, as a result of very poor regulation that allowed the market to spiral like it did, and to create tranches of debt etc. It also turned governments into the underwriters of private businesses, which only accelerated with the Covid situation, and that will continue. As a result, we can indeed expect governments (i.e. taxpayers) to take a much greater interest in business activities they're basically insuring. There is an interesting research paper I went to the talk on suggesting that central banks will be increasingly toothless, as they cannot raise interest rates all that much before governments have to step in to prevent mass bankruptcies and the political fallout from them (I'm a trading process expert, not a banker, so I struggled to fully understand how we don't still run out of taxpayer money).

Perhaps I didn't explain the bonus issue well. Before the bonus cap, bankers usually earned 200%+ of their salary in bonuses on top. Actually getting that bonus relied on closing an IPO, delisting, merger etc. on the FTSE. Now, they cannot earn more than 100% of their base pay in bonuses. The effect is that mediocre bankers show up from NY, earn 400k basic plus 300k bonus (let's say) for showing up and doing a mediocre job. BUT with the cap removed, they're down to 200k basic and potentially about 100k bonus because they cannot close any deals in a shrinking market. My heart doesn't exactly bleed, but it's a worry for the public purse.

All the deal-making is leaving London. We have a hugely undiversified economy with a huge tax take (both corp, stamp duty and individual taxes) from financial services, and yet we've utterly fucked it over during Brexit by not even bothering with passporting rules. That fucks us all over. Removing the cap may incentivise more US banks to move dealmakers to London, as it reduces fixed costs compared to the EU. Still doesn't solve the fact we keep losing tech IPOs to other markets, but gives some hope of more tax to support public services.

noblegiraffe · 07/11/2022 15:19

Still a lot of money, obviously, but it'll mean they have to sell up and take their kids out of Wycombe Abbey etc. It'll also mean a lot less for the public purse, but I realise you just think rich = bad.

Actually that would be great, wouldn’t it, because apparently higher wages ‘fuel inflation’ so if they have to sell and downgrade, that’s a positive for everyone.

Or is it only a positive when nurses can’t afford things?

walkinginsunshinekat · 07/11/2022 15:11

@Cherryblossoms85 I couldn't give a stuff about banker bonuses or how much they earn BUT i do take issue with people who say its a private businesses and we aren't paying for it, when thats incorrect.

Presumably salary increases they had when the cap was in place were consolidated? and they'll keep them going forward? as per any other wage increase, other wise they were just bonuses?
Tax take should there fore stay the same.

There is nothing wrong with people being rich, people can be bad whether they are rich or poor.

There is no equation (from me) that says Rich = Bad, you ve got the wrong end of the stick if you re trying to beat me with that.

Cherryblossoms85 · 07/11/2022 14:55

@walkinginsunshinekat Actually it may please you to learn that the removal of the bonus cap on bankers means they'll be earning far less this year and probably next. The effect of the cap was that base pay was hugely inflated, and bonuses accounted for a much smaller proportion of overall pay. As a result of very poor results on the FTSE and a lack of IPOs in London, the people you refer to as bankers (you really mean the tiny number of deal-heading people in the square mile) will drop their base pay back to maybe 200k and will earn absolutely diddly squat on top. Still a lot of money, obviously, but it'll mean they have to sell up and take their kids out of Wycombe Abbey etc. It'll also mean a lot less for the public purse, but I realise you just think rich = bad.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 07/11/2022 14:53

Absolutely.

Quite simply, I believe in every worker having the right to strike and exercising that right as a last resort. Going on strike costs the worker loss of earnings so it is not something they do for shits and giggles. If an employer does not want their workforce out on strike then they have a simple solution to that - negotiate a fair settlement.