Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with the nurses strike?

686 replies

borderterrierr · 05/11/2022 20:10

Guardian reporting that the rcn strike has resulted in a yes vote and we'll be striking before Christmas.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/nov/05/nurses-across-uk-vote-to-strike-in-first-ever-national-action?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Patient's emergency care will be protected but it's a strike vote

OP posts:
DonnaBanana · 06/11/2022 10:10

Agree with the strike and while anyone who dies as a consequence is unfortunate, sometimes sacrifices have to be made for the greater good (see climate protesters as well). This will affect emergency care btw because emergency care is already being affected by general shortages in other parts of the NHS so it can’t escape the knock on effects.

MCHammersmutha · 06/11/2022 10:06

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 09:45

A band five clears just shy of £2k pcm without overtime. If the basic hours are 36 what does a nurse clear with an additional 12 hour shift?

Most professionals work more than their standard hours but do not get overtime. Teachers for example.

They already do significant overtime with no pay, or time in lieu, it is actually expected now because it is so ingrained.

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 10:02

those pays only change with ne roles and further study of Masters levels. And experienced nurse does not automatically get that pay. You can work your whole career as a band 5 nurse where the maximum pay is £32k. Promotions depend on job availability. You average ward will have 15 band 5s, 4 or so band 6s, and a band 7 - band 6+7 taking on more management less patient caring roles in a lot of cases. Not all the band 5 can get promoted to 6+ it just doesn't happen that way, so stay band 5 for their career and hit max pay at 4 years, and wards need the band 5 to function, which is what we are missing. Its the low grade, but front line working 12 hour shifts caring for 12 patients literally saving lives daily nurses that we need. Not the band 7's on £55k, we have those roles filled. We need to promote the band 5, retain good staff, and encourage new ones. We don't do that by capping their pay after 4 years of working unless they more onto to a new roles.

BeesAndBirds · 06/11/2022 09:55

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 09:53

I don’t think nurses should strike at all because it hurts and risks the lives of current patients who are innocent in all this. Its all well and good for those of us not currently receiving nursing care- as in not in hospital or hospice at this moment. But there are seriously ill and injured patients that rely on nurses.

I was a bit conflicted because I knew staffing was short, but after reading about how short it is, I don’t think that’s enough of a reason to risk patient lives. I know short staffing, having lived through extremely challenging years of short staffing in the military where lives also depended on our work. We didn’t throw the towel in.

It’s also a bit of an oxymoron to refuse to work to “stand up for patient care” when by doing so you’re taking patient care down to zero and risking their innocent lives. There has to be another way. All the management has to do is sit and wait until enough people die and public opinion turns against the nurses strike.

Im not sure if the BBC is accurate in their report but if it is, this are two more reasons why I don’t support the strike. It said an entry level nurse earns £27k/Yr which is quite good for a degreed graduate in any profession starting out. An established nurse, earns £32k and pay is around £55k for the most experienced nurses. This isn’t abysmal pay. This is decent pay imho. No one is going to work in Tesco or Aldi to “make more”. No is going to make more as a self-employed cleaner- not for the same hours.

The BBC also reported that the nurses are demanding a pay raise of inflation + 5%, which based on inflation % as of this month is a pay raise of 17%. They had a 3% raise last year.

Frankly, the demand for a 17% pay raise, and future inflation + 5% pay raises is a ridiculous demand.

If the real reason were understaffing, then sure a petition to Parliament? Or a call for a public inquiry into excess patients deaths due to understaffing? There have to be other things you can do instead of using patients as hostages and sacrificial lambs for a 17% pay raise demand!

These are the stats quoted by the article PP mentioned, and I linked previously.

Do you agree with the nurses strike?
Discovereads · 06/11/2022 09:53

I don’t think nurses should strike at all because it hurts and risks the lives of current patients who are innocent in all this. Its all well and good for those of us not currently receiving nursing care- as in not in hospital or hospice at this moment. But there are seriously ill and injured patients that rely on nurses.

I was a bit conflicted because I knew staffing was short, but after reading about how short it is, I don’t think that’s enough of a reason to risk patient lives. I know short staffing, having lived through extremely challenging years of short staffing in the military where lives also depended on our work. We didn’t throw the towel in.

It’s also a bit of an oxymoron to refuse to work to “stand up for patient care” when by doing so you’re taking patient care down to zero and risking their innocent lives. There has to be another way. All the management has to do is sit and wait until enough people die and public opinion turns against the nurses strike.

Im not sure if the BBC is accurate in their report but if it is, this are two more reasons why I don’t support the strike. It said an entry level nurse earns £27k/Yr which is quite good for a degreed graduate in any profession starting out. An established nurse, earns £32k and pay is around £55k for the most experienced nurses. This isn’t abysmal pay. This is decent pay imho. No one is going to work in Tesco or Aldi to “make more”. No is going to make more as a self-employed cleaner- not for the same hours.

The BBC also reported that the nurses are demanding a pay raise of inflation + 5%, which based on inflation % as of this month is a pay raise of 17%. They had a 3% raise last year.

Frankly, the demand for a 17% pay raise, and future inflation + 5% pay raises is a ridiculous demand.

If the real reason were understaffing, then sure a petition to Parliament? Or a call for a public inquiry into excess patients deaths due to understaffing? There have to be other things you can do instead of using patients as hostages and sacrificial lambs for a 17% pay raise demand!

icanhearapindrop · 06/11/2022 09:52

Yes, 100%. As an ex-nurse, who quit due to poor pay and working conditions, something needs to be done to retain those still there. Nursing is a shitty career in a lot of ways, and expectations on them are so high, and there needs to be recompense for that.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 06/11/2022 09:45

Yes. 100%

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 09:45

A band five clears just shy of £2k pcm without overtime. If the basic hours are 36 what does a nurse clear with an additional 12 hour shift?

Most professionals work more than their standard hours but do not get overtime. Teachers for example.

LionsandLambs · 06/11/2022 09:44

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:31

@tiggergoesbounce I do agree with you, but I think my main problem is that people just blindly belive nurses should be paid more without, in most cases I belive, actually knowing what nurses are paid. We have been brainwashed into thinking it's 'not enough' without most people actually knowing how much the actual figure is. It's not helped by the nurses pay scale starting at level 1, when nurses salaries don't start til level 5, so some people assume nurses are paid a lot less (level 1) than they are. The RCN is happy to let this misunderstanding continue.

There are tens of thousands of unfilled vacancies. It will get much worse as a large proportion of the workforce retire over the next decade. People starting are not staying, as the conditions are so awful. It’s a profession requiring high level training and ongoing training requirements. In any other sector the pay would rise to match demand. People will work all sorts of horrible jobs for the right pay. You can be a supervisor at Aldi for the same pay as a qualified nurse so why would you expect someone to choose nursing?

TimBoothseyes · 06/11/2022 09:42

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:26

@TimBoothseyes but the strike is for better pay and conditions. It's moving the goalposts to say we should not focus on pay, as that's exactly what the union IS focusing on.

But without better pay there will be more loss of staff, leading to further shortages and even lower morale and more pressure on those that are left. You said it yourself better pay and conditions, the two things go hand in hand.

Bobbybobbins · 06/11/2022 09:39

Yes 💯

And hope we will have similar support if we strike (teacher)

Sloth66 · 06/11/2022 09:35

Over 40,000 nurses quit last year. Obviously for various reasons including retirement. I was one of them, not renewing my registration. Nurses are voting with their feet now and simply quitting . It’s an undervalued profession and sadly I don’t feel conditions will ever really improve.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 06/11/2022 09:33

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:26

@TimBoothseyes but the strike is for better pay and conditions. It's moving the goalposts to say we should not focus on pay, as that's exactly what the union IS focusing on.

Unions can't strike over anything else, though.

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:31

@tiggergoesbounce I do agree with you, but I think my main problem is that people just blindly belive nurses should be paid more without, in most cases I belive, actually knowing what nurses are paid. We have been brainwashed into thinking it's 'not enough' without most people actually knowing how much the actual figure is. It's not helped by the nurses pay scale starting at level 1, when nurses salaries don't start til level 5, so some people assume nurses are paid a lot less (level 1) than they are. The RCN is happy to let this misunderstanding continue.

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:26

@TimBoothseyes but the strike is for better pay and conditions. It's moving the goalposts to say we should not focus on pay, as that's exactly what the union IS focusing on.

oldbrownjug · 06/11/2022 09:21

Yes - reluctantly - but yes.

tiggergoesbounce · 06/11/2022 09:19

Yes, absolutely.
It shouldn't be a race to the bottom. Anyone doing a decent days work should not have to be struggling, we need to fight for better pay and conditions for those who need it.
Sadly if striking is the only way to achieve this, yes do it !

TimBoothseyes · 06/11/2022 09:15

People need to stop focusing solely on how much nurses earn and look at what they go through to earn it.

ChildSalad · 06/11/2022 09:14

Katypp · 06/11/2022 08:55

@PomRuns yes I imagine you mean me.
Don't hate the NHS just don't get the complete refusal to accept that nurses not badly paid. They were in the past, but they are not now. It's like some weired brainwashing going on

What we are fighting for is the recognition of the professional and skilled nature of the work we do. On the face of it a band 5 (registered nurse) wage looks ok, but when you factor in the training, skill and responsibility that is needed to fulfil that role, then yes, it's lacking.

Increasingly the role of nurses is taking over what junior doctors used to do. Triaging patients, making clinical decisions, minor surgery, giving cytotoxic drugs, invasive procedures, being a specialist in your field.... I could keep going. Nursing as a profession isn't just about caring, it's a whole lot more than that.

Added to all that, retention is the worst it's ever been. There is a severe lack of nurses, for a number of reasons including retirement, brexit and the withdrawal of the nursing bursary a few years ago. Nursing is not a tempting profession any more, and people cannot afford to take a career because "it's a vocation" they want adequate remuneration for the blood sweat and tears to go into doing the job. This means that patients are at risk, spend a day on a ward, you'll see what I mean. Patient/nurse ratios are disgusting: when my mum was a patient recently on an acute ward, there was one trained nurse running the whole ward of 19 patients. One. They had a physio helping out doing washes. It's dire, it's critical and we need to attract more nurses to the profession.

I could also go on about the amount of money that is wasted on agency staff that costs the NHS so much cost.

Lots of nurses find this hard, we do not want to walk out on our patients, we CARE about them and don't want them to come to harm. But something has to change to make sure that patients are kept safe.

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:14

@Untitledsquatboulder to a point I see what you're saying but everyone wants more pay, everyone thinks they are overworked, underrewarded, have less than perfect working conditions etc.
In absolute terms, a starting salary of £27k is not terrible, it really isn't

Katypp · 06/11/2022 09:10

@RosaGallica the first two point you make are completely irrelevant because they affect everyone, not just nurses. Some graduates never earn enough to start paying back their loan.
Conditions I feel less able to comment on as they are not as black and white as pay, but I would say you will struggle to find anyone who never puts in unpaid time, myself included. As I stated above, unpaid overtime is not unique to nurses and I don't understand why we persist in pretending it is.

Untitledsquatboulder · 06/11/2022 09:09

@Katypp at the end of the day it doesn't matter whether you or I consider current rates of pay adequate or generous or whatever. The fact is that a lot of nurses find them inadequate and are voting with their feet. The tougher and more stressful the conditions we expect nurses to operate under, the more we will need to compensate them. The hospital ds2 was recently in have nurses working 12 hour shifts. No idea if that's typical but that's a long shift.

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 06/11/2022 09:08

Yes, I support it. However I am a senior manager in the NHS and have cold dread thinking about how we will get through the coming months

RosaGallica · 06/11/2022 09:02

soundsystem · 06/11/2022 08:59

Yep support nurses 💯 with this. And I think it's shocking the government and (elements of the press) are trying the "but think of the patients!". If anything goes badly wrong (and of course I sincerely hope it doesn't!) blames lies solely with the government for 12 years of underfunding and not with the nurses!

Yeah, as if the government has ever cared about the patients.

RosaGallica · 06/11/2022 09:02

Now take the student debt of that amount … and compare it to the U.K. average house price, pushing £300k…

I think the conditions are the major problem. Not long ago there was part-time work available and regular shifts. Now they are asking students to work unpaid in order to get that piece of paper. Would you work unpaid? In 12 hr shifts that turn into 14 because there’s no cover, and then feel bullied to get up the next morning?

The public sector generally has had enough of declining real wages and conditions with increased demands. We are not public slaves. If you value the services, pay for them. Or you will end up paying far more for them privately.