Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with the nurses strike?

686 replies

borderterrierr · 05/11/2022 20:10

Guardian reporting that the rcn strike has resulted in a yes vote and we'll be striking before Christmas.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/nov/05/nurses-across-uk-vote-to-strike-in-first-ever-national-action?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Patient's emergency care will be protected but it's a strike vote

OP posts:
Badnewsoracle · 06/11/2022 10:52

Absolutely!

Some people see it as placing patients in danger, however what people don't see is that patients are in danger every single day due to the recruitment and staffing crisis.

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 10:50

£12 an hour when you are making clinical decisions that can be life or death, have the responsibility for checking and giving medications that are life or death, caring for 12+ patients on shift with no breaks, not even to use the toilet, going hours and hours without a sip of water, trying to meet the differing needs of all those patients, then having to stay an hour+ late unpaid cos the next shift hasn't arrived and you have no choice, or you have to complete paperwork, or put in a report because a patient has fallen whilst you were in another bay dealing with a possibly septic patients and couldn't get to the other bay to help, getting abused verbally and physically because you cant drop everything to give patients their 2 hourly analgesia, plus the 5000 other things to do to care for the patients you have been allocated which is double what is considered to be safe, with no senior nurses on shift so you also have to find time to update boards and flow and try to arrange cover cos staff haven't turned up or agency have cancelled or people have extended this sick leave by another week and you find out 10 mins before your due to leave, I think £12 and hour is pretty awful.

Mrsherdwick · 06/11/2022 10:46

If nursing was such an attractive career choice there wouldn’t be a 40,000 nurse shortage.
I qualified over 40 years ago. Am now retired thankfully. I support a nurses strike.

Ughnamechange256 · 06/11/2022 10:46

Out of interest, where are all the nurses who are leaving the profession going?
They must be going to other jobs, but what?

LexMitior · 06/11/2022 10:46

Yes, the Government will never listen otherwise. Nurses are highly responsible people with tough jobs - why do you want them exhausted and ill paid.

Likewise police, teachers, railway workers, border force, prison officers, civil service. If you pay people peanuts you get monkeys. If nothing works in the UK, that is because anyone who is any good is leaving public service and getting a job with less responsibility where they can negotiate their own damn pay rise and not be criticized for being greedy.

MichelleScarn · 06/11/2022 10:45

@katypp are people's lives at risk if 'people in every other job take their UNPAID breaks and work to rule?

FacebookPhotos · 06/11/2022 10:43

Most professionals work more than their standard hours but do not get overtime. Teachers for example.

I wouldn’t use “but teachers do it” as a counter to nurses striking about conditions tbh. Because teaching is also facing a crisis in staffing and unions are balloting on strike action.

I fully support the nurses strike. Pay has increased below inflation for over a decade, as well as being below the average increase across the economy as a whole. It appears that during that same time the conditions have got worse too. Not acceptable imo.

MCHammersmutha · 06/11/2022 10:43

For those saying nurses shouldn't get a payrise...any other profession where your roles responsibilities and skills expoentially increase have the right to ask for more money. Nurses have been doing this for my entire nursing career ( nearly 40 years) to NO effect. We worked through the unprecedented pressures of Covid and were offered 1%, an absolute insult. This was on the heels of year on year breaking down our pay eg reduction in mileage and wear and tear on cars for community staff, to the point many nurses find themselves paying to use their car for work due to the mileage allowance limitations, pity the poor rural workers in particular.

We have watched as politicians and many other professions are seen as 'vital' and deserve their pay increases. People complain that nurses are asking for better pay and conditions. So ask yourself if you don't value the nurses who will look after you or your loved ones then you dont value the care you will get when the time comes for you or yours needing that care, because nurses have had enough abuse and exploitation, because it should be a 'vocation'. Nurses arent slaves theyre intelligent professionals with lives.

I am now retired, early due to the current circumstances, I barely made it past 40 k after nearly 40 years. I was a specialist and a prescriber, I had to fight with management to get that recognised, I was doing band 7 work for years on a band 6 wage. I liken it to the investment banker who still gets a tellers wage, noone else would accept this, but then those that object to nurses striking are valuing money over lives. No Nurse should have to work in the environment they do. We have tried the nicey nicey approach for the lifetime of my career and it has got us precisely nowhere. If we dont do this now we will never do it and the nhs will undoubtedly crumble to nothing. Nurses are leaving in their droves and most have an eye to an escape to something else. The lives of patients are already at risk and people are losing their lives due to the current health crisis make no mistake, so if you value having an nhs you need to support the nurses strike.

Katypp · 06/11/2022 10:42

@lolalouisa84 but as a pp has said, this is the same in any job. You describe band 5 nurses as low level. Many, many people start professional jobs and don't progress to senior or management roles. And are paid less than £32k to do so. If we could just stop pretending that nurses are appallingly paid and made realistic comparisons with just about every other job, then we could have a sensible discussion. I don't hate nurses and I don't hate the NHS but I do get tired of the emotive claptrap spoken.

LionsandLambs · 06/11/2022 10:39

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 09:45

A band five clears just shy of £2k pcm without overtime. If the basic hours are 36 what does a nurse clear with an additional 12 hour shift?

Most professionals work more than their standard hours but do not get overtime. Teachers for example.

For someone who (from your many other posts on threads) relies an awful lot on nursing care, you never seem to stop deriding them. The pay clearly isn’t enough as there are tens of thousands of vacancies. This is a skilled profession and it’s pay should not be compared with non skilled non professional jobs.

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 10:39

The problem in and around London is that there are pockets of very poor nursing.

Can band 5's prescribe and make decisions or is that the domain of the band 6s.

The advanced practitioner nurses I have seen in A&E/Minor injuries have been superb. I bet they aren't band 5. They are mostly close to my age and a lady who helped me last summer told me she went into nursing originally as an SEN. Absolutely not via the degree route.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:38

CornishGem1975 · 06/11/2022 10:32

I feel sorry for my friend who is a nurse, who doesn't want to have to strike - she loves her job and her patients, she's pretty much happy (probably because she's on a higher band as a specialist nurse) - but she's now forced into striking, and that's making her feel really uncomfortable.

The option is there to leave the union.

agahah · 06/11/2022 10:38

I think some posters are confusing a graduate degree with a professional graduate qualification it's very different and requires different consideration.
Of the UKs registered professionals nurses are the lowest paid followed by teachers.
As for the unpaid overtime being common to all jobs, it's not the same unless you are considering that this is every single day which week in and week out amounts to around a minimum of 10 hours of unpaid labour (numerous studies back this). In a job that doesn't involve caring for others you chose to work unpaid overtime.
In a job where you can't leave the shift because no one has come to replace you or there is no one trained to give the clinical care or make the clinical decision required you are not making a choice you are bound by your professional registration and body.
The average life span of a nurse is less than the average for the population as a whole, being a nurse is also a risk factor for suicide statistically speaking.
The current average duration of service before leaving nursing is 4 years, one year longer than the training that is required to attain the professional registration and not enough time to reach the top of band 5.
The reason people are mentioning the take home pay is because we pay alot more into pensions etc than other jobs, yes you get that back when you possibly live to 70 at the way things are going but its important that the public know what they are actually paying for and that is an average for the largest majority of nursing staff of about £12 ph.
I care much more about patient care than money but I couldn't continue to work on a ward alone for the most part and be expected to fulfil my professional,legal or ethical obligations to the standard that is required. Working in the community has been much easier personally the pay drop without the antisocial pay was painful but worth it and all things considered and my role is less pressured in many ways.

My main point is really that a graduate job isn't the same as a professionally registered job at all to those who are playing comparison I would advise you look up the nursing code of conduct and see if you can apply it to some graduate marketing post or some equivalent.

Katypp · 06/11/2022 10:37

@lolalouisa84@lolalouisa84

CornishGem1975 · 06/11/2022 10:32

I feel sorry for my friend who is a nurse, who doesn't want to have to strike - she loves her job and her patients, she's pretty much happy (probably because she's on a higher band as a specialist nurse) - but she's now forced into striking, and that's making her feel really uncomfortable.

Mammyloveswine · 06/11/2022 10:27

As a teacher also preparing to strike i support all industrial across my comrades are preparing to take!

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 10:26

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 10:21

@DonnaBanana
Agree with the strike and while anyone who dies as a consequence is unfortunate, sometimes sacrifices have to be made for the greater good

See, I can’t agree with this. The Hippocratic Oath says “first do no harm” no one who is willing to deliberately let several innocent humans die for a 17% pay raise (oh and better staffing levels) should be in a nursing profession. Some of these patients are children btw. Would you be happy for your DC’s life to be a sacrifice for this greater good?

A strike will leave staffing at christmas day levels, Where people who require care will still get exactly the same as any other non striking day.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:23

Nurses aren't allowed to strike about the state of the NHS and the numbers of deaths that is being caused by underfunding. If they were allowed to strike about that, I'm sure they would.

Appuskidu · 06/11/2022 10:23

EightChalk · 06/11/2022 10:20

I think some posters are misunderstanding the idea of "starting salary", "experienced salary" etc. in nursing. You don't just automatically move up the bands - you go up within your band and stop at the top, even if you're very experienced. You have to apply for band 6 and higher roles competitively, and these tend to be clinical management and/or specialist advanced nursing roles, and they involve a massive increase in responsibility. There are also far, far fewer band 6 and 7s needed than band 5s. Don't look at band 5 as a starting salary that all nurses inevitably move up from.

This reminds me off the adverts for teaching a few years back on the telly saying ‘great’ teachers earn £65k. The advert got tonnes of complaints-I think this was listed as the salary scale of a lead practitioner teacher in central London-I’m not sure anyone was actually employed as one!

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 10:22

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 10:13

That’s the same for most degreed professions though. You need a masters to be promoted beyond a certain level. You can’t expect to climb to the top of any professional career ladder on just the strength of a bachelors degree you received at age 21. Most professions you need a doctorate to get to the top, at least in nursing, it’s only a masters.

And promotions only depending upon job availability is not a negative, as for most professions they also depend on being the best performer out of a pool of competitors. It’s actually a silver lining of being short-staffed in that staff will be promoted faster than usual, and in some cases faster than they should be.

And their pay isn’t technically “capped” because there is the NHS annual pay raise for everyone, which last year was 3%. I know annual pay raises were frozen, set at zero for several years by the government but that’s not the same as a cap on pay.

I think a full ride bursary through University coving tuition and accommodation/board would get more nurses into the profession and alleviate the staffing shortages. As well as setting up a commission to look at passporting foreign qualifications as equivalent so nursing staff could immigrate and take up nursing jobs with only a two week induction into specifics of the NHS.

The 3% that didnt actually result in a payrise because they upp'd pesion % contributions at the same time? Nurses haven't seen a real pay rise in many many years.

Short staffed does not = faster promotions, it equals burn out and people quitting because they just can't cope. Being pressured in nursing doesn't just effect you, it effects the patients, who in turn get angry, and often abusive, as people in pain at their most vulnerable are not rationale. Nurses are the ones being abused when they literally cant do more than they are doing.

Im in £75k worth of debt for my degree. I love my job, I was one of the lucky ones who had worked within the hosp as a HCA for many years before I started my degree and knew exactly what I was letting myself in for. Many don't, they don't realise what nursing actually is these days, and many many leave. I think it was around 1/3 of my cohort didn't graduate.

I don't think the starting wage is awful, I agree, although I was somewhat pissed off my band 2 role brought home more than my band 5 role after 3 years of studying, but now I'm not in preceptorship its better. But something does have to change, we need to keep more band 5s, we need more staff on the floor, good experienced knowledgeable caring nurses. As a student every nurse would say "I wouldn't do my training again given the choice, you're crazy for doing it, should have stayed band 2" but I want to progress and further my skills. These are the staff we need to keep.

We also do have programmes recruiting people from abroad, lots of young indian nurses, who come promised these amazing jobs, then they see the reality and don't last very long.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 10:21

@DonnaBanana
Agree with the strike and while anyone who dies as a consequence is unfortunate, sometimes sacrifices have to be made for the greater good

See, I can’t agree with this. The Hippocratic Oath says “first do no harm” no one who is willing to deliberately let several innocent humans die for a 17% pay raise (oh and better staffing levels) should be in a nursing profession. Some of these patients are children btw. Would you be happy for your DC’s life to be a sacrifice for this greater good?

AntlerRose · 06/11/2022 10:21

Katypp · 06/11/2022 08:49

I'm sorry, I know I will get torn to pieces for this, but I will say it anyway.
All those posters stating that nurses are terribly paid - do you actually know the starting salary for a nurse?
I won't comment on the working conditions, other than to say working upaid extra time and antisocial hours is not unique to nursing. I will say that most professions where weekend/night working is expected and is part of a rota do not get paid extra for doing it.
But back to this shocking, dreadful pay - I am not sure that a starting salary of £27k is that awful. It's not a fortune, but it's certainly not shocking, appalling, paltry and all of the other hyperbolic adjectives used to describe it.
And before anyone asks no, I couldn't be a nurse and no, I don't save lives every day. But I didn't choose to be a nurse. I don't suppose many nurses would want to do what I do either.

The problem is not enough people are choosing to be a nurse, and those that did are now choosing to go and do something else. Generally because of the pay and conditions. So it doesnt matter if you think 27k is enough for something you wouldnt do anyway, because the people who would do it have started not to.

EightChalk · 06/11/2022 10:20

I think some posters are misunderstanding the idea of "starting salary", "experienced salary" etc. in nursing. You don't just automatically move up the bands - you go up within your band and stop at the top, even if you're very experienced. You have to apply for band 6 and higher roles competitively, and these tend to be clinical management and/or specialist advanced nursing roles, and they involve a massive increase in responsibility. There are also far, far fewer band 6 and 7s needed than band 5s. Don't look at band 5 as a starting salary that all nurses inevitably move up from.

noblegiraffe · 06/11/2022 10:14

DonnaBanana · 06/11/2022 10:10

Agree with the strike and while anyone who dies as a consequence is unfortunate, sometimes sacrifices have to be made for the greater good (see climate protesters as well). This will affect emergency care btw because emergency care is already being affected by general shortages in other parts of the NHS so it can’t escape the knock on effects.

People are dying unnecessarily because of the state of the NHS. If this strike improves the situation, then it will save lives in the long run.

Any deaths caused will be the fault of the government for deliberately running the system into the ground, not of those trying to save it.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 10:13

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 10:02

those pays only change with ne roles and further study of Masters levels. And experienced nurse does not automatically get that pay. You can work your whole career as a band 5 nurse where the maximum pay is £32k. Promotions depend on job availability. You average ward will have 15 band 5s, 4 or so band 6s, and a band 7 - band 6+7 taking on more management less patient caring roles in a lot of cases. Not all the band 5 can get promoted to 6+ it just doesn't happen that way, so stay band 5 for their career and hit max pay at 4 years, and wards need the band 5 to function, which is what we are missing. Its the low grade, but front line working 12 hour shifts caring for 12 patients literally saving lives daily nurses that we need. Not the band 7's on £55k, we have those roles filled. We need to promote the band 5, retain good staff, and encourage new ones. We don't do that by capping their pay after 4 years of working unless they more onto to a new roles.

That’s the same for most degreed professions though. You need a masters to be promoted beyond a certain level. You can’t expect to climb to the top of any professional career ladder on just the strength of a bachelors degree you received at age 21. Most professions you need a doctorate to get to the top, at least in nursing, it’s only a masters.

And promotions only depending upon job availability is not a negative, as for most professions they also depend on being the best performer out of a pool of competitors. It’s actually a silver lining of being short-staffed in that staff will be promoted faster than usual, and in some cases faster than they should be.

And their pay isn’t technically “capped” because there is the NHS annual pay raise for everyone, which last year was 3%. I know annual pay raises were frozen, set at zero for several years by the government but that’s not the same as a cap on pay.

I think a full ride bursary through University coving tuition and accommodation/board would get more nurses into the profession and alleviate the staffing shortages. As well as setting up a commission to look at passporting foreign qualifications as equivalent so nursing staff could immigrate and take up nursing jobs with only a two week induction into specifics of the NHS.