Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with the nurses strike?

686 replies

borderterrierr · 05/11/2022 20:10

Guardian reporting that the rcn strike has resulted in a yes vote and we'll be striking before Christmas.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/nov/05/nurses-across-uk-vote-to-strike-in-first-ever-national-action?CMP=ShareiOSAppp_Other

Patient's emergency care will be protected but it's a strike vote

OP posts:
lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 17:04

According to the analysis for the RCN, international recruitment costs 2.4 times as much as a pay rise of 5% above inflation for a typical nurse.
Currently, each international nurse recruited costs the government £16,900, compared to the £7,100 that it would cost to give a pay rise to a nurse considering leaving the workforce.
The report comes one month after it was announced that health service trusts in England would be given additional funding to recruit nurses from overseas to help with staff shortages.
Under the plans, NHS England is set to pay trusts £7,000 per overseas nurse recruited between 1 January and 31 March 2023.

Add to that the cost of using agency nurses has...

New data released by NHS England reveals the NHS is being forced to pay private firms nearly £1 billion per year.
According to information shared by Labour’s Shadow Health Secretary Wes Streeting, the government has forked out a massive £4.3 billion on agency nursing staff in just the last five years.
In a tweet, Mr Streeting said, “taxpayers are paying the price for the Conservatives’ failure to train enough nurses over the past 12 years”.

Now consider the fact that agency staff and mostly international recruits, that come to the NHS with massive costs, see how much they actually earn, leave the NHS and go agency nursing, reduce their contract with NHS to the minimum and supplement with agency nursing, or leave for a different country.

The cost of retaining current nurses, and training them here, is much lower than the current schemes of recruiting internationally.

The NHS would absolutely cease to function without internationally trained nurses, they are absolutely amazing and often have received better training than we have here in all honesty. However, the cost of attempting to solve staffing by recruiting from overseas isn't cost-effective.

LexMitior · 06/11/2022 17:02

I don't think that many higher earners have any idea of what nurses do or the stress of the job. Many high earning jobs can be demanding, but actually, it gets easier the higher you go. You delegate more, and life is easier. Ignore the "but my City job is tough" brigade. It's nothing like the stress of providing healthcare to vulnerable people.

Untitledsquatboulder · 06/11/2022 16:59

@Topgub isn't it just? Hmm

danmthatonestakentryanotheer · 06/11/2022 16:58

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 14:38

@lolalouisa84 and if they do a 4th shift that's time and a half, double on Sundays and weekends? Many local.solicitors and accountants and civil servants work more than 48 hour weeks for the same money on that basis.

But whilst doing that overtime can those solicitors, accountants etc, take breaks, have time for a pee, eat? You're comparing apples to oranges.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 16:57

On any higher earner thread we're always told that we have to pay higher earners their very high wages because the jobs are so so stressful and the higher earners work so so hard. (Aye right)

But when it comes to nurses its just part of the job they need to accept?

Hilarious

mrshoho · 06/11/2022 16:55

100% behind the nurses and hcas.

Lannielou · 06/11/2022 16:54

I'm a nurse, and my daughter is. We are both going to strike

mackthepony · 06/11/2022 16:54

but I'm not sure they should be paid a premium for that per se. Nurses have ALWAYS dealt with that.

^^
Ah well. Just keep on as is, eh?

Nurses wipe arses and deal with people dying. Not the same as a desk job let's face it.

kitcat15 · 06/11/2022 16:54

Yes

Topgub · 06/11/2022 16:53

Oh and other health care systems have lots more staff. Who are better paid.

So if thats the system you want, that involves big pay rises for staff

mackthepony · 06/11/2022 16:52

LakieLady · 06/11/2022 16:49

I certainly would.

Not just NHS, either, but teachers, social workers, all sorts of public sector jobs have had below-inflation pay rises for years.

Re. Paying more tax to cover nurses wages. Yes, but the Toryoverlords won't allow it.

So nurses, teachers, HCP's are perpetually screwed.

And given the recent long awaited wake up regarding the extortionate cost of nurseries I'm not sure what kind of a pickle were gonna be in.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 16:52

@CurlyhairedAssassin

but I'm not sure they should be paid a premium for that per se.

Why not?

It's part of the role. Its exactly why saying other graduate roles get x is useless

CurlyhairedAssassin · 06/11/2022 16:49

I'm not sure what the answer is. I'm sure that pay doesn't match the conditions at the moment. But part of the reason for that is so many wards and other NHS areas don't seem to be fully staffed, or even if they are on paper, it doesn't translate into the staffing levesl that are ACTUALLY needed, given the knock on effect that shortages elsewhere is having on the pressures that hospitals are under eg social services.

But if we increase pay, surely there will be even LESS money to go around and staffing issues will never be fixed. I don't believe that ANY increase in pay will attract more people into the profession if conditions are as bad as nurses say they are. The main issue is the unsafe levels of staffing and the stress levels as far as I can see. If we were to fix those, and ensure that they would get their full breaks, and leave on time etc, would nurses be then happy with the salary? I don't actually think the starting salary for nurses is terrible, on paper, compared with many many other professional jobs, which also demand particular skill sets etc. The fact that graduate salaries generally are no longer enough to buy a house or rent somewhere decent in this day and age is disgusting, but that applies to wider society, not just nurses.

Some people are arguing that they have to witness very upsetting things as a nurse. People should go into nursing with the full knowledge that they are going to have to deal with upsetting and stressful stuff like patients dying, but I'm not sure they should be paid a premium for that per se. Nurses have ALWAYS dealt with that. What should not be happening is nurses having to be with patients who are dying purely as a result of low staffing levels or inadequate resources etc. No-one could argue that that's incredibly stressful and upsetting to be a part of, yet nurses are telling us this is what's happening, so we should listen to them.

The problem is that a fully publicly funded national healthcare system is NEVER going to be properly funded, is it? There just isn't the money available for a population that is ever increasing in age, along with the double whammy of fewer tax payers in the generations to come. If we want to make sure that our most vulnerable people have free healthcare then we are going to have to look at other ways of funding it for those people. It's a political hot potato but a nurses' strike will hopefully mean that it HAS to be looked at seriously now. I don't want a US model but something similar to France is worth looking at.

mackthepony · 06/11/2022 16:49

No doubt it's been mentioned already, but a teachers strike and early educators strike will be in the pipeline too.

These professions that have always been viewed as 'caring' and 'giving' aka an excuse to pay WOMEN less are due a huge shake up.

And we can no longer hire cheap foreign labour to fill shortages Brexit. Shot ourselves totally in the foot.

LakieLady · 06/11/2022 16:49

Overthebow · 06/11/2022 12:38

Can I ask would everyone be willing to pay higher taxes if it meant that nurses and other NHS staff could have better pay and more staff to enable better working conditions?

I certainly would.

Not just NHS, either, but teachers, social workers, all sorts of public sector jobs have had below-inflation pay rises for years.

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 16:46

You also only get night enhancement for 9.5 hours of a 12-hour night shift in our trust.

Mrsherdwick · 06/11/2022 16:44

@RosesAndHellebores if you do an extra shift you don’t get time and a half. It’s done through the bank. So if you are a top band 5 and do an extra shift you may get less than your normal hourly rate - bank rate is mid point band 5.
You also don’t get double time at the weekends.

Iamboredandgoingforatwix · 06/11/2022 16:44

noblegiraffe · 05/11/2022 20:32

If only there were some way of getting more money in that pot. Like a windfall tax or something.

😂

lolalouisa84 · 06/11/2022 16:40

@MCHammersmutha

That must vary between trusts as absolutely 0 of our shifts are paid at double time. Extra or not. +30% nights and Saturdays, +60% Sundays and bank hols. Nothing at double pay.

MCHammersmutha · 06/11/2022 16:36

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 14:38

@lolalouisa84 and if they do a 4th shift that's time and a half, double on Sundays and weekends? Many local.solicitors and accountants and civil servants work more than 48 hour weeks for the same money on that basis.

Without nurses doing extra shifts the nhs would be an even worse state. Overtime is about time and a half or double time for bank Holidays. FYI Sundays are a weekend. Solicitors, civil servants and accountants arent responsible for the lives and wellbeing of patients. Often they can set their own hours, or have flexitime and can control who they speak to and when. Nurses are bombarded from the minute they walk into work it isnt an appointment system. Nothing is controlled.

SauvignonBlanche · 06/11/2022 16:01

I’m a senior NHS nurse qualified for 31 years, I’m an Band 8a Matron, not because I’ve been round a long time but because I’ve done a myriad of additional qualifications and applied for senior roles.

To put my job in context there are only 3 of us in the hospital, the majority of qualified nurses are employed at Band 5, the majority of HCAs are Band 2.

The current recruitment and retention problems are the worst I have ever seen, we have one ward running at 45% of RN posts vacant. We are absolutely reliant on agency staff whose availability and reliability is hit and miss.

Often there are shifts with only 1 of our own permanent nurses on duty and rest agency staff who may never have worked there before. We often only achieve this by moving nurses round from ward to ward to ensure there are not 2 agency nurses on together, there will only be 2 registered nurses on a ward for a night shift.

Anyone who thinks that a newly qualified Band 5 nurse will not be relied upon for clinical decision-making and supervisory skills is just displaying their ignorance.

The number of staff leaving is unsurprising, we are working hard to recruit from abroad but this is complex and not without its problems. Internationally trained nurses may find the starting salary of a Band 5 nurse sound attractive until they experience the cost of living in the UK, we have had more leave than stay.

Senior managers have been looking into how to support staff experiencing hardship but without the ability in increase their salaries.

The recent paltry ‘pay rise’ caused some such as myself to actually experience a pay cut due to the government fuckwits who organised this as we experienced a pension % contribution increase, I thought this just affected people like me on Band 8a so did not worry about it too much until I heard that staff on Band 3 had been similarly affected 😡

Patients will be kept safe during the strike, we shall see to that though some routine appointments may have to be cancelled to accommodate this.

Senior staff will ensure that all areas are safe and if they are I hope I will then join my colleagues on the picket line. I never imagined myself saying such a thing but I never imagined the mess we are currently in.

firesideglow · 06/11/2022 15:59

RosesAndHellebores · 06/11/2022 14:38

@lolalouisa84 and if they do a 4th shift that's time and a half, double on Sundays and weekends? Many local.solicitors and accountants and civil servants work more than 48 hour weeks for the same money on that basis.

Christ I'm owed about 15 years of back pay if it's double time on Sundays then! I wonder if payroll realises they've been underpaying us all this time! 🤔

NCFT0922 · 06/11/2022 15:50

@miceonabranch of course they will be. They are now and that’s without strikes. It’s appalling

SauvignonBlanche · 06/11/2022 15:38

MyLovelyPen · 06/11/2022 15:34

I’m loving all these posters who think they understand the stresses of nursing because “they work long hours too” 🙄.

I’m not a nurse but many of my family and friends are and you truly have no fucking idea.

Nurses I salute you and will do all I can to support you. I hold out zero hope that this government will cave because this is all part of their grand sell off plan and you guys are collateral damage 😢.

Thank you 🙏

MyLovelyPen · 06/11/2022 15:34

I’m loving all these posters who think they understand the stresses of nursing because “they work long hours too” 🙄.

I’m not a nurse but many of my family and friends are and you truly have no fucking idea.

Nurses I salute you and will do all I can to support you. I hold out zero hope that this government will cave because this is all part of their grand sell off plan and you guys are collateral damage 😢.