Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Havanananana · 05/11/2022 22:27

"I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable."

I see that the phrase "socialist utopia" sneaked in when describing the basics that should be available to everyone. Socialised benefits are those that are better and more affordably provided by governments than by profit-making organisations, be that education, healthcare, infrastructure etc. or are benefits that can be incentivised by government action to be provided for the population as a whole and not just to provide profit and incomes for a few corporations. For example, this could be through user-owned co-operatives rather than through government-controlled organisations or private companies.

Financial viability? Some European countries already have many of the "generous benefits" in the OP. Where I live there is five-star health provision (paid for through employer and employee contributions, just as in the UK, but ringfenced for healthcare and not administered by the government or used as a political football). There is high quality housing - either private, public or co-operative - with strict enforcement of building regulations and housing laws to avoid slums and stop rip-off landlords, but also to balance the supply of housing with the demand. Utilities are largely public-owned or co-operatively owned, so the "profits" generated go back to the customers rather than being creamed off by investors (which in the case of the UK are very often overseas investors, so money pours out of the UK economy). Education, whether academic or practical, is not the preserve of the rich or the well-connected.

It can be done, but decades of mismanagement by all of the British political parties and a refusal to acknowledge that the UK's problems are not the fault of "the EU, foreigners, experts, doomsters, scientists and cyclists" and all of the other scapegoats that are trotted out but have been caused by a rotten political system populated with rotten politicians (all of the parties have them) that makes it easy to manipulate the population and misuse Parliament.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 22:20

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 22:03

I don’t think you’d have to have all countries actually.

I don’t think it’s beyond the wit of man to come up with a better answer than what we have. There’s just no will from those who could do it.

So we’ve moved into fantasy economics now.

Has everyone picked a country yet. Wonder what Ireland has to say about that.

Chippy1234 · 05/11/2022 22:12

I hear the Amazon name lots of times. If there is so much disapproval why not refuse to buy from them? Any taxes that are added to Amazon will be paid by us in the end anyway. 1% of the richest pay nearly 30% of overall income tax.

VestaTilley · 05/11/2022 22:04

Nobody’s asking it to be all things to all people, or solve all problems.

We’re just asking them to not create new ones, and to run the country and public services competently.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 22:03

DdraigGoch · 05/11/2022 21:59

You'd need all countries to cooperate to achieve that. No exceptions. You'd have to persuade Switzerland to become more transparent, coerce various Caribbean islands (not to mention Monaco, Liechtenstein etc.) into giving up the perks of having more millionaires paying peanuts than actual houses.

Good luck.

I don’t think you’d have to have all countries actually.

I don’t think it’s beyond the wit of man to come up with a better answer than what we have. There’s just no will from those who could do it.

DdraigGoch · 05/11/2022 21:59

ilyx · 05/11/2022 19:52

The top 0.1% don’t pay any tax because loopholes exist to avoid paying them. And if the wealthiest countries all decided to end those loopholes they’d have to pay them. Economist Ha Joon Change who lectures at Cambridge has written about this so it’s not me conjuring up this from thin air. But the top 0.001% are who control the politicians.

You'd need all countries to cooperate to achieve that. No exceptions. You'd have to persuade Switzerland to become more transparent, coerce various Caribbean islands (not to mention Monaco, Liechtenstein etc.) into giving up the perks of having more millionaires paying peanuts than actual houses.

Good luck.

Jedsnewstar · 05/11/2022 21:57

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable

Yeah much better to keep everyone sick and sad, better for everyone. 🥱

Charley50 · 05/11/2022 21:55

Government took taxpayer's money, or borrowed money that taxpayers will have to pay back, and handed it to their friends, e.g. failed Test and Trace, PPI, Serco given billions old pounds for covid testing contracts which could have stayed within NHS (although most of that is run by private providers now anyway). Completely careless and just spunking money away.

Rishi stupidly stopped stamp duty during covid, giving more money away and making house prices rise in a time of economic uncertainty, when they should have stagnated or gone down a bit.

Basically this country is being stripped bare by the Conservatives and they have money for their rich friends, and make decisions that fuck up the majority of the population.

rainingsnoring · 05/11/2022 21:55

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:52

Neo-liberalism is the answer to many of those failures. A misguided belief that private is better for everything.

Agreed. Neoliberalism has clearly been a huge failure.

roarfeckingroarr · 05/11/2022 21:54

YANBU at all

chipshopElvis · 05/11/2022 21:54

I don't want the state to do everything. I want them to sort out the health service and help people at the bottom of society and I certainly feel that food banks are a fairly recent development, bloody madness. Life wasn't a Utopia under Labour but waiting times were going down, Sure Start centres were bloody brilliant and quite frankly I'd rather be in the 90s than the 2020's.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:52

rainingsnoring · 05/11/2022 21:51

Rishi is just trying to get everyone prepared for all the tax rises and austerity that are about to land on 17th November.

The government are, rather tragically, trying to portray themselves as the responsible saviours after the Truss/ Kwarteng disaster. This is jolly far from the truth as Rishi was the chancellor who presided over ridiculous levels of money printing during the pandemic. The Tory party has been in power for 13 years and made countless major errors which are also entirely glossed over (not that other governments before them were that much better). Why has there been no energy planning? Why was the money from the N Sea oil used on tax cuts for the city boys? Why was council housing sold off and the stock not replenished? Why was UK manufacturing closed down? Why was their grand plan for the UK economy to sell off all our assets to foreigners and put rockets under the housing market? Why was there so much 'temporary' QE and ZIRP?
So much greed and dishonesty and utter incompetence.

Neo-liberalism is the answer to many of those failures. A misguided belief that private is better for everything.

rainingsnoring · 05/11/2022 21:51

Rishi is just trying to get everyone prepared for all the tax rises and austerity that are about to land on 17th November.

The government are, rather tragically, trying to portray themselves as the responsible saviours after the Truss/ Kwarteng disaster. This is jolly far from the truth as Rishi was the chancellor who presided over ridiculous levels of money printing during the pandemic. The Tory party has been in power for 13 years and made countless major errors which are also entirely glossed over (not that other governments before them were that much better). Why has there been no energy planning? Why was the money from the N Sea oil used on tax cuts for the city boys? Why was council housing sold off and the stock not replenished? Why was UK manufacturing closed down? Why was their grand plan for the UK economy to sell off all our assets to foreigners and put rockets under the housing market? Why was there so much 'temporary' QE and ZIRP?
So much greed and dishonesty and utter incompetence.

TooBigForMyBoots · 05/11/2022 21:50

georgarina · 05/11/2022 20:38

Sounds a bit like your cheating violent alcoholic husband telling you 'Well, sorry I'm not a PERFECT PERSON.'

I was thinking the bit where he shouts: "WELL YOU'RE NOT PERFECT YOUSELF".

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:49

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:48

If the cap fits….

It demonstrates a base/misguided understanding of politics. Like calling a Tory a Fascist.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:48

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:46

Tax me more.

it’s funny how the best you’ve got is to make stupid references to communism.

says a lot.

If the cap fits….

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:46

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:37

This thread is indicative of everything that is wrong with what we expect from government. People here are falling over themselves demanding that government should tax the rich and corporations more. The hammer and sickle crowd are protesting that the government isn’t getting enough taxes.

Rather than demanding to know where the existing taxes are being spent, since we have the highest post war tax burden right now. There is no moral outrage about the fact that the latest round of borrowing is to pay for people’s energy bills because the government failed to build nuclear power 10 years ago. No moral outrage that they printed half a trillion pounds to lock up healthy people at home and destroy the economy. No moral outrage that the tax burden is about to go up because growth has been so weak.

No, just tax people more. Which people? Anyone but us of course.

Tax me more.

it’s funny how the best you’ve got is to make stupid references to communism.

says a lot.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:45

onlythreenow · 05/11/2022 21:42

It is not about expecting the Government to provide everything - nobody expects that.

Actually rather a lot do expect that, and I think that is what the OP is getting at. Everyone thinks that whatever need/want it is that they are passionate about should be funded by the government, but the reality is that there is not an endless source of money for everything.

Most people do not expect that. It’s a minority - a tiny one.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:45

Capri3 · 05/11/2022 21:37

The only way to fix the issue with companies who earn huge amounts, but don’t pay their staff enough, is to alter or stop tax credits/UC. Many companies get away with only offering part-time hours, but equally, many employees refuse to work over the minimum hours too. I’m pretty sure that was suggested a while ago by the government, but quickly u-turned due to the outrage. Realistically though, a couple who are both able bodied adults only being required to work 16 hours between them per week is pretty ridiculous.

Altering UC will do fuck all to makes companies pay more.

And do you have any idea how expensive childcare is? It’s easy to see why people work 16 hours a week. When my dc were preschool age, childcare exceeded my mortgage. And that’s before we get to the huge levels of hidden unpaid care.

Skodacool · 05/11/2022 21:45

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 21:07

You are setting up a strawman. No one is expecting utopia. A functioning and competent government who can deliver on at least some of their manifesto pledges would be a massive step up from what we have had.

Agreed!

TokyoSushi · 05/11/2022 21:45

Not RTFT but I don't for one second expect the government to bail me out/prop me up.

I do expect the government to not make my financial situation worse through their actions and to fix any issues that they might have caused.

onlythreenow · 05/11/2022 21:42

It is not about expecting the Government to provide everything - nobody expects that.

Actually rather a lot do expect that, and I think that is what the OP is getting at. Everyone thinks that whatever need/want it is that they are passionate about should be funded by the government, but the reality is that there is not an endless source of money for everything.

VisitingThem · 05/11/2022 21:39

I think its just a lazy copout. From a government who are nothing to anyone who isn't one of their rich mates.

Capri3 · 05/11/2022 21:37

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:22

Why do you only think of the wealth individuals? What about about corporations?

There will be sectors out there making huge profits at the moment - you only know what’s reported in the media but plenty will be.

The only way to fix the issue with companies who earn huge amounts, but don’t pay their staff enough, is to alter or stop tax credits/UC. Many companies get away with only offering part-time hours, but equally, many employees refuse to work over the minimum hours too. I’m pretty sure that was suggested a while ago by the government, but quickly u-turned due to the outrage. Realistically though, a couple who are both able bodied adults only being required to work 16 hours between them per week is pretty ridiculous.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:37

This thread is indicative of everything that is wrong with what we expect from government. People here are falling over themselves demanding that government should tax the rich and corporations more. The hammer and sickle crowd are protesting that the government isn’t getting enough taxes.

Rather than demanding to know where the existing taxes are being spent, since we have the highest post war tax burden right now. There is no moral outrage about the fact that the latest round of borrowing is to pay for people’s energy bills because the government failed to build nuclear power 10 years ago. No moral outrage that they printed half a trillion pounds to lock up healthy people at home and destroy the economy. No moral outrage that the tax burden is about to go up because growth has been so weak.

No, just tax people more. Which people? Anyone but us of course.