Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
KnittedCardi · 06/11/2022 12:06

I want no part of a low tax, small state society, but it is the road that the UK has embarked on

But surely the last couple of years have been anything but?

In other news, I must find the recent poll where most people would rather reduce services than pay more tax, and there you have the problem with our population. No-one thinks they should pay more tax.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 12:05

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 12:02

If you mean the poor, its a tiny % but if you mean the very wealthy, then that's a majority, they demand (and get) lower taxes, tax breaks, inside information, access to ministers to formulate policy, access for friends/donorsto distort planning laws (Robert Jenrik) access to Russian money.

Ministers routinely break the law and get away with it, with a code of conduct that in any other walk of life would see you fired and/or criminal investigation - bullying and security breaches being the two most recent.

I mean both

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 12:02

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:37

Wealth inequality and lack of social mobility absolutely has to be tackled but yes we also do need to be realistic about what can be achieved with the money we have.

People do seem to have ridiculous expectations on what the nhs and the state can provide.

Do they? I’d settle for the level of public services we had in 2010. Nobody thought we had ridiculous expectations then.

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 12:02

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:50

@TooBigForMyBoots

People absolutely do think the govt owes them a living.

If you mean the poor, its a tiny % but if you mean the very wealthy, then that's a majority, they demand (and get) lower taxes, tax breaks, inside information, access to ministers to formulate policy, access for friends/donorsto distort planning laws (Robert Jenrik) access to Russian money.

Ministers routinely break the law and get away with it, with a code of conduct that in any other walk of life would see you fired and/or criminal investigation - bullying and security breaches being the two most recent.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 12:01

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:37

This thread is indicative of everything that is wrong with what we expect from government. People here are falling over themselves demanding that government should tax the rich and corporations more. The hammer and sickle crowd are protesting that the government isn’t getting enough taxes.

Rather than demanding to know where the existing taxes are being spent, since we have the highest post war tax burden right now. There is no moral outrage about the fact that the latest round of borrowing is to pay for people’s energy bills because the government failed to build nuclear power 10 years ago. No moral outrage that they printed half a trillion pounds to lock up healthy people at home and destroy the economy. No moral outrage that the tax burden is about to go up because growth has been so weak.

No, just tax people more. Which people? Anyone but us of course.

I agree.

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 06/11/2022 11:57

antelopevalley · 06/11/2022 11:48

So it is all poor peoples fault?

What about the millions of money paid out for PPE that was never useworthy? Or the billions defrauded through the business help scheme?

Frankly if our government had not been utterly corrupt, there would be more money around.

I am in no way defending the government but let's look at PPE first . There was a world wide shortage of PPE in every sector that needed it, the government had to source from every available place including paying over the odds.

Now if your argument was we should have never been in that position in the first place I would agree with you.

Now the COVID loan fraud,. I can remember screams of we must get money out there to help business and people quickly. Putting in the usual checks and balances would have taken months so HMRC missed out a lot of the checks.

Now time should be spent investigating these frauds even if it costs more to find the people just on principal.

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 11:55

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:48

Depends how you look at it.

For current funding and current demands then yeah thats what you'll get.

If you want a reasonable service from the nhs you have to pay for it.

And reduce demand.

Not quite true, there is the funding for more staff but the UK simply doesn't have enough people - we have shortages across all sectors, not least health care.

Leaving the EU ensured more left the UK and cut off an easily accessible supply of semi and skilled Labour.

We are authors of our own misfortune, encourage by Sunak and his ilk.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 11:52

Worriedddd · 05/11/2022 21:16

People are either going to have to accept Nordic style taxes like 50 percent. Or face facts that things will have to be privatised.

Many on higher rate tax - especially those having personal allowances confiscated too - already pay tax at these kinds of rates. Especially when you add in our much higher than average rate of VAT.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:50

@TooBigForMyBoots

People absolutely do think the govt owes them a living.

antelopevalley · 06/11/2022 11:50

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 11:43

Its not unrealistic to not have to wait 1 or 2 years for an operation or 18 hours outside AE.

How much is this all costing us in lost productivity? how many people have had to give up work and/or claim benefits because they are incapacitated with easily treatable conditions?

I agree. We have the highest number ever of working-aged adults on long-term sick. Delays in treatment costs the country money and in some cases means the treatment is more expensive than if it had been done at an earlier stage.

TooBigForMyBoots · 06/11/2022 11:48

Sunak is talking shite and deflecting blame. No one thinks the government should be everything to everyone. We just think that they should be competent, which the Tories are not.

Sunak and his party have wrecked the UK. They should accept responsibility for their massive cock ups, lies and corruption and stop shifting the blame to tax paying citizens.

Tory Bastards.🤬🤬🤬

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:48

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 11:43

Its not unrealistic to not have to wait 1 or 2 years for an operation or 18 hours outside AE.

How much is this all costing us in lost productivity? how many people have had to give up work and/or claim benefits because they are incapacitated with easily treatable conditions?

Depends how you look at it.

For current funding and current demands then yeah thats what you'll get.

If you want a reasonable service from the nhs you have to pay for it.

And reduce demand.

antelopevalley · 06/11/2022 11:48

So it is all poor peoples fault?

What about the millions of money paid out for PPE that was never useworthy? Or the billions defrauded through the business help scheme?

Frankly if our government had not been utterly corrupt, there would be more money around.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 06/11/2022 11:43

I agree that some expect a lot to be provided with no onus on themselves to improve their lot. You only have to look at the number of sad face stories with a couple in a two bed flat demanding a larger home because they have taken the decision to have three or even four kids when they earn very little.

I was raised that you have the children you can afford. We are relatively wealthy and only have two because that is affordable no matter what goes wrong. I would have loved more dc but not at the expense of their quality of living. I simply cannot understand the mindset of people that have multiple dc when there is only one parent working in a minimum wage role.

That being said if the parents won’t take responsibility then it has to be up to the government to provide simply because the children are not responsible for the choices of their parents and they have the right to not be raised in poverty. We are a developed country and we need to start acting like it and supporting these families so the children have the capacity to make better choices. We can’t just leave them to it as we are now, it’s utterly immoral that children are cold and starving in this country. And unfortunately this government is failing massively on that score egged on by those who don’t think we should take care of innocent children who had no say in the circumstances into which they were born.

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 11:43

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:37

Wealth inequality and lack of social mobility absolutely has to be tackled but yes we also do need to be realistic about what can be achieved with the money we have.

People do seem to have ridiculous expectations on what the nhs and the state can provide.

Its not unrealistic to not have to wait 1 or 2 years for an operation or 18 hours outside AE.

How much is this all costing us in lost productivity? how many people have had to give up work and/or claim benefits because they are incapacitated with easily treatable conditions?

user1497207191 · 06/11/2022 11:42

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 11:32

He is gaslighting everyone trying to pretend that this mess is our fault and we should just suck it up, when he won't take the very obvious actions that could improve the situation. Instead he wants to hammer the same people again: those on PAYE who have been hammered with tax rises and real-terms salary cuts too in many cases, for over a decade already.

Yes, he blamed the 3 million he excluded from the covid support schemes!

mynamesnotMa · 06/11/2022 11:38

Yes he's right. He mentioned taxing dividends as a start to stop people earning money without paying tax. I bet he'll forget he said that. Stop errant parents declaring their whole income for child maintenance.
I don't agree we have a 5 star NHS mental health service or state education we have had 12 years of public services being utterly annihilated.

Topgub · 06/11/2022 11:37

Wealth inequality and lack of social mobility absolutely has to be tackled but yes we also do need to be realistic about what can be achieved with the money we have.

People do seem to have ridiculous expectations on what the nhs and the state can provide.

Mardyface · 06/11/2022 11:35

Fleetheart · 05/11/2022 19:41

we elect the government to do the things we cannot do as individuals. The govt can’t do everything but they should use the power they have for the food of every member of society; not just those who support them. this is where they have been going wrong and continue to go wrong in so many areas.

This, and this again.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 11:35

Don't forget that as the third PM since an election was held he is claiming a mandate on the basis of their last manifesto while simultaneously claiming he can break all of its pledges because circumstances have changed. Cognitive dissonance much? Can't have it both ways. Either the mandate based on that manifesto exists still, or it does not.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 11:32

Croque · 05/11/2022 19:58

He has been delivering that clever line for a while. The problem is that it sounds lazy. If he does not aspire to deliver much then he is arguably letting himself off the hook for subsequently failing to perform.
Aspirational leadership has always been important, never more so in bleak times like this. I would have thought that the Tories are aware.
Perhaps he is starting to steer us towards the American model. Help only for the extremely vulnerable (which is also part of his spin).

He is gaslighting everyone trying to pretend that this mess is our fault and we should just suck it up, when he won't take the very obvious actions that could improve the situation. Instead he wants to hammer the same people again: those on PAYE who have been hammered with tax rises and real-terms salary cuts too in many cases, for over a decade already.

Truthseeker456 · 06/11/2022 11:31

My response to him is this, fine but can you tell us in detail where our money has gone over tha last 10 years . Seems reasonable to me , they would never do it , why ? Because there would be uproar .

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 11:30

Well. People are trying to look after themselves but Government actions are making this harder.

£30bn of headroom in July has now become a £50bn deficit. Why? Was this the public's fault?

Are the recent sharp rises in mortgage rates the public's fault or were they vastly accelerated by a totally unnecessary Trussterfuck?

The BoE then had to prop up markets by £60bn in the following days, underwritten by the Treasury. Why should we pay more tax for that when the Government caused the panic that made it necessary?

Brexit is costing the country £120bn per year in GDP which equates to £40bn tax revenue. Rejoining the single market would plug almost the entire deficit and cost us nothing. It would also reduce inflation (by removing artificial trade barriers and import costs) and improve the value of GBP limiting the need for further rate rises. Why is Mr Sunak "I am being honest with the public" refusing to mention this elephant in the room? Why should we all have our standard of living decimated just so that he doesn't have to admit he was wrong about it?

I don't expect the state to fix my problems. I expect it to run the economy competently and fix the problems it has created. What I do not expect is being told that because of politicians' incompetence - as a lone parent - I should pay yet more tax when we cannot access any services that we need anyway. Oh and rumours today that they want to also screw over my pension to pay for the mess they've made. On what planet would that be acceptable?

supertato32 · 06/11/2022 11:29

@ethelredonagoodday this is so depressing to read. I really despise the hatred a lot of civil servants receive (when Mogg was relishing in the fact he was going to make so many hardworking CS redundant)! They are easy scape goats, when all eyes are on the government! If the MPs in power actually knew how to run a business let alone a company, we'd be in a much better place

supertato32 · 06/11/2022 11:27

@Cuppasoupmonster sorry no, haha! Just get on my soap box and know a lot of people try and sympathise with the government! The rant wasn't aimed directly at you! Sorry