Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Havanananana · 06/11/2022 14:53

"Infact there are many many people in the UK who are negative contributors to tax as they pay little tax and when you consider the resources used eg NHS, schools etc they are actually getting more than they pay in."

Yes! - that is the whole point of a socialised system. Everyone benefits - as individuals and society as a whole - and there is a safety net to catch those who for whatever reason cannot provide sufficiently for themselves. The cost is borne by those with the broader shoulders, or who have had the good fortune to prosper.

How does society benefit from supporting those who are "getting more than they pay in"? Quite apart from the moral issue (there still seem to be people who are quite happy that the 6th wealthiest country on the planet has millions of people struggling to pay for heating, food and adequate housing and who are waiting months for hospital treatment) there is a longer-term benefit to improving the lot of everyone.

Better education, healthcare, housing and infrastructure results in a healthier population and a healthier economy. If the children of those who are struggling today are not supported and given better opportunities, then they become the people who need even more support in the future when they become adults. Look at this at community level too - the destruction of the old industries has left entire communities with little or no employment, no internal investment and no prospects. The young have moved away - and in turn they put more pressure on the housing markets in the cities that they have moved to. There is a reason why a terraced house in the north of England can be bought for peanuts while a similar house in North London costs hundreds of thousands.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 14:50

Notonthestairs · 06/11/2022 14:43

"The government should be there for things like infrastructure, the police force, defence, education, and making sure every child in the country has a decent start in life. "

And yet...

"And @TheIFS projects spending per pupil in 2024 will be the same level as in 2010. By the next election, we will have had 15 years with no overall growth in spending on our state schools. That’s a squeeze that IFS says is “effectively without precedent in post-war UK history”.

twitter.com/paulwaugh/status/1585173776291201024?s=46&t=ZLpGgKEYmDOxbjSVp3zXVg

Which means per-pupil fundind has fallen 30-35%.

Disgusting, while we are all being taxed more.

People should ask themselves what Government priorities are if they are not investing in education. It's a no-brainer considering our productivity crisis.

So why is that, do you think?

Where is the highest tax burden ever outside war times being spent? And do you genuinely believe in that context that taxing more would be spent on better services?

If so, heads need examining.

Florenz · 06/11/2022 14:44

Too much of what we pay in tax in the UK is pocketed by those working in the public sector in the form of salaries and pensions and hardly any of the money goes to deserving people. It'd be far more efficient for high rate tax payers to go round deprived areas and put a few hundred quid into every letterbox, than to pay sky high taxes of which a small percent goes to the needy.

Notonthestairs · 06/11/2022 14:43

"The government should be there for things like infrastructure, the police force, defence, education, and making sure every child in the country has a decent start in life. "

And yet...

"And @TheIFS projects spending per pupil in 2024 will be the same level as in 2010. By the next election, we will have had 15 years with no overall growth in spending on our state schools. That’s a squeeze that IFS says is “effectively without precedent in post-war UK history”.

twitter.com/paulwaugh/status/1585173776291201024?s=46&t=ZLpGgKEYmDOxbjSVp3zXVg

FrippEnos · 06/11/2022 14:40

The government should be a lot more to a lot more people and a lot less to their friends.

Skidaramink · 06/11/2022 14:36

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 20:23

BTW there is enough money

No, there isn’t. Not enough people are net contributors to afford what everyone else seems to feel entitled to be provided by the state.

The government should be there for things like infrastructure, the police force, defence, education, and making sure every child in the country has a decent start in life. It shouldn’t be there to re-distribute wealth. Everyone needs to learn to stand on their own two feet and provide for themselves.

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 14:33

Absolutely agree. Right to buy was a cynical exercise in buying votes and it should have been stopped by the Blair government. It’s scandalous that it’s still happening.

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 14:27

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:25

Unless you think there’s an infinite supply of money, then yes it matters if companies make huge profits because it takes money from
elsewhere

unless you believe in the magic money tree….

As the banks use a fiat currency system, they can pretty much print what is needed.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/11/2022 14:25

@AliensAteMyHomework i agree with what you wrote.

@Blossomtoes right to buy should never have happened.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 14:24

Aleaiactaest · 05/11/2022 20:26

The real issue is that Western economies have all been so desperate to attract big business and have had such low corporation taxes. The big economies have been competing amongst each other to attract said corporations. Companies don’t pay that much tax but their workers do. Similarly, governments globally are scared to lose the billionaires who they see us providing jobs etc. Politicians are simply scared of freaking the market out as it quickly spirals out of control. We saw exactly this happening with Truss’ mini budget. So the governments think they can’t actually do that much. Even if Labour comes into power if we are still in recession where are they going to get the money from? It is a fine balance between taxing the rich and the rich leaving. If most of the developed world has gone billionaire/rich person friendly then what can governments actually do?

During the financial crisis 2008, hank Paulson was throwing up or dry heaving as they called it, but it was kept secret at the time as it was said that if it was known that the Secretary of the treasury was throwing up, at that moment it would spook the economic markets.

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 14:23

Yes, we have a shrinking tax base, although paying tax doesn’t end with claiming the state pension. Successive governments have had 50+ years to prepare for this and have failed dismally.

Housing is the real issue. There will be a big rise in the number of houses sold over the next 20 odd years. Increase in supply should damp down prices but it won’t be enough. We need a huge building programme of social housing with right to buy removed, unfortunately that’s going to be difficult when the country’s bankrupt.

JoWawa · 06/11/2022 14:21

I don't think this is true: see

ifs.org.uk/publications/characteristics-and-incomes-top-1

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 14:20

The lack of engagement with my posts here is depressing. We can all moan about the issues but when the wider picture is described and the options set out, nobody wants to know.

What, of the options set out, do people want to choose?

What are they doing about it? Have they pressured their MPs?

(I am an economist).

Cantstandbullshit · 06/11/2022 14:20

JohnStuartMill · 06/11/2022 12:12

The gap between the wealthiest and poorest in the UK is far wider than in comparable neighbouring economies.

In the UK the richest 10 per cent take home six times more than the bottom 10 per cent. In most of Europe that figure is typically about a factor of three.

In 2018, typical households in the UK, France and Germany have remarkably similar incomes – around €34,000. But those similarities hide big differences.

The rich in the UK are richer. The rich here in the UK have incomes 17% higher than their equivalents in France.

In 2018, the poorest households have to survive on incomes 20% lower than those in France (£14,700 v £18,500). That meant higher poverty, lower living standards and no margin when things go wrong.

In the last four years, things have gone very wrong indeed and the UK economy is performing poorly. All the Tories are concentrating on is reducing the burden on the wealthy in the form of tax cuts for the rich. The situation for the poor here is quickly becoming catastrophic.

Part of the issue is many in the UK no longer have the drive and will to increase their income and are content staying at or close to minimum wage and chugging along. The UK is not innovating or growing at the level it should and we’re all focused on taxing the rich more so we can continue to remain mediocre.

Cantstandbullshit · 06/11/2022 14:17

ilyx · 05/11/2022 19:52

The top 0.1% don’t pay any tax because loopholes exist to avoid paying them. And if the wealthiest countries all decided to end those loopholes they’d have to pay them. Economist Ha Joon Change who lectures at Cambridge has written about this so it’s not me conjuring up this from thin air. But the top 0.001% are who control the politicians.

You know that’s bullshit right?

According to this report by HMRC the top 1% of earners contribute about 30% of tax received by the government and I can assure they use less government resources as they are more likely to send their kids to private school, use private medical etc.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/income-tax-liabilities-statistics-tax-year-2019-to-2020-to-tax-year-2022-to-2023/summary-statistics

Infact there are many many people in the UK who are negative contributors to tax as they pay little tax and when you consider the resources used eg NHS, schools etc they are actually getting more than they pay in.

yogiil · 06/11/2022 14:15

We need to tax wealth far more heavily.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/11/2022 14:14

Sandinmyknickers · 06/11/2022 13:27

So we shouldn't aspire to provide better services and help close the wealth gap in case we fall a tiny bit short of perfection? It's either perfection and creating utopia, or no bother trying? Yep, sounds like a classic lazy Tory approach to not have to actually do anything

To me it's all about what kind of society we want to aspire to, even if you fall a bit short of it. And I would rather aspire to a more nordic/Scandinavian approach to society which values community than an American individualistic one

Yes that’s exactly what I said 🙄

OP posts:
AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 14:14

Effectively, this is all just part of the Brexit/ unicorns spiral. Someone else should pay.

It doesn't work like that.

Hold your Government to account. Tell your MP that they need to fix their own fuckups and rejoin the single market. No sympathy for anyone struggling who hasn't emailed their MP about this.

And then if you want a different society: everyone has to pay and everyone has to benefit.

Getoff · 06/11/2022 14:11

Or are you just generalising , let’s be real, because your laundry list of “socialist utopia” (?!) things, are needs which you and others you know have already have privately met for yourself , and so you don’t like the idea of higher taxation so others get it for “free”?

Why do you assume the "problem" caused by high taxation is other people getting things, rather than taxpayers not getting things?

For example, if we abolished free GP services, there would be a group of people who are better off, because the reduction in their taxes is more than enough for them to pay private GP fees.

Similarly, there are relatively well-off people who cannot currently afford private education for their children, but who, if they weren't paying through their taxes for other people's children to be educated, could pay for something better than a state education for their own children.

There will be people on above-average incomes whose funding of other peoples state pensions means might have to work maybe ten years longer than they would if everyone was responsible for themselves.

To suggest no one suffers real personal disadvantages from state-mandated redistribution makes you come across as a bit of a propagandist.

user29 · 06/11/2022 14:10

Cheerleaderdave · 05/11/2022 19:51

I agree OP anything wrong nowadays its the government's fault.

But it wasn't private citizens who spaffed all that lockdown money up the wall or more precisely into their friends pockets for - Test & trace, Nightingale hospitals , unsuitable PPE etc etc
It wasn't private citizens who allowed the energy wholesalers to make megaprofits at their expenses
It wasn't private citizens who printed money with gay abandon and put interest rates up 3%
It isn't private citizens who are responsible for the porous uk borders

user1497207191 · 06/11/2022 14:09

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 13:53

Demands that people in the middle on PAYE pay even more yet again are not realistic. They have propped up the economy and everyone else for over a decade now with real terms pay decreases every year and higher taxes every year.

Target the super rich: yes. But this won't be enough to fix it.

If you want a reset of the way society works then yes everyone will have to pay more tax. Much more. Not this "tax someone marginally better off than me" nonsense. That isn't how a collective system works i.e. Scandinavia.

But certain wealthier groups should pay more than they do, i.e. OAPs with hefty pensions, buy to let properties, share portfolios etc are paying less than workers with similar incomes as they don’t pay NIC etc

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 14:08

Like all this "why should those with private pensions get state pension?" nonsense.

How long do you think a state pension that's not for the incredibly old or sick (as it was when introduced) will persist if the people who find it get nothing?

Many people say "I paid for 40 years" but don't add up what they paid. £10,000 of contribution buys you ~£500 per year of income. If you're paying a couple of hundred pounds a month of NI to fund NHS and pensions, you haven't paid anything like what is required to fund your state pension. Others are subsidising it for you, hugely.

And many don't mind that. But to then suggesting confiscating theirs, which is worth a fraction of what they have paid in because they are subsidising yours... how long do you think they would do that for before there is the political pressure to scrap it entirely?

Same issue if you start taxing higher rate taxpayers who pay for just about all services for everyone else on their pension contributions. At the moment it is fair: everyone pays in tax free and is taxed on withdrawal. You start to tax them when they pay in and pay out? Really?

This is how divisions in society are created. Either you can have a system where everyone pays in a fair amount per their salary and everyone gets universal benefits so everyone buys in.

Or you can have a system of everyone for themselves.

Purportedly we have the former but it has been pushed to its limit deliverately for over a decade now with a small proportion of people funding everyone else and getting less and less back.

I believe this is on purpose, so that public services and benefits lost support from those funding them and can be scrapped. I do not agree with this. And unfortunately those proposing to hammer the people currently paying for them is playing into the hands of those trying to engineer this.

To fix it, in our situation now, you need everyone working/ with unearned income through shareholdings etc paying higher tax and benefits/ services being staunchly defended/ reinstated as universal. If they are not then they will vanish entirely within a decade or two, having been repeatedly downgraded in the meantime.

People need to wake up to the game being played. Spite directed at those with even slightly more when they are not causing the problems.

If you want to move towards a social democratic system them means testing state benefits or child support and taxing only the group in the middle who have been paying the bulk of everything for years is the exact opposite of what you need to do.

user1497207191 · 06/11/2022 14:04

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/11/2022 14:00

That’s essentially my issue. We could hike taxes to what Mn see as an acceptable level, and still not have enough cash for what we need because of factors beyond our control - ageing population, general decline of the west. I don’t know what the answer to the housing crisis is, I don’t want houses built on greenfield land only to need to build more in years to come and destroying the countryside.

The answer re building is to knock down huge swathes of semi derelict housing/industrial areas and repurpose the brownfield sites for housing.

user1497207191 · 06/11/2022 14:02

walkinginsunshinekat · 06/11/2022 12:59

But you are not a civil engineer, so you re guessing these things could be built for half or less the cost - You simply don't know.

My point still stands, had this money been borrowed and on the books, we'd not have been able to borrow for subsequent crisis, not a Blair plan but a handy consequence.

Why shouldn't NHS staff have decent working conditions? they have to compete with organisations that do have shiny new buildings to work in.

High quality administrators/managers are vital for efficient running of the NHS.

You don’t need to be an engineer. Just watch Grand Designs to see the huge costs of large glass expanses. 200/300k for a 2/3 story height wall of glass. That’s fine if you can afford it, but public money shouldn’t be spent on what are effectively art works.

As for staff, yes to safe and decent work places, but there’s no place for luxury when it’s public money.

There’s a middle ground between Dickensian squalor and billionaire luxury.

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/11/2022 14:00

yogiil · 06/11/2022 13:56

The issue is housing costs & an ageing population. We have a shrinking tax paying base, it's not enough.

That’s essentially my issue. We could hike taxes to what Mn see as an acceptable level, and still not have enough cash for what we need because of factors beyond our control - ageing population, general decline of the west. I don’t know what the answer to the housing crisis is, I don’t want houses built on greenfield land only to need to build more in years to come and destroying the countryside.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread