Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 17:27

Ilovemycatalot · 06/11/2022 17:19

The more I hear Rishi talk the more I dislike him. He comes across snobbish and smug. He is so out of touch with reality how could he ever relate to the problems the a vast majority of the uk population are having. He speaks for the millionaires and the top percent earners not every day people.

Have you seen that lovely video of him as a stufent where he laughs about not having any working class friends, "obviously"?

This way before he married a billionnaire.

He has many skills and is clearly bright, but has no clue about how his decisions impact people less well off than him. He has also clearly soent little time studying socio-economic models across time and countries so that he can make sensible choices now.

We don't need to reinvent the wheel. Crises are not new. Difficult choices are not new. There is plenty of evidence from well-managed economies about what works, for social stability and economic success. He will no doubt choose the opposite. So people should question the motivation. Or at least, they should. But based on this thread so far, most will not: they will continue with their "everyone should pay but me" mentality and buy into his propaganda.

Ilovemycatalot · 06/11/2022 17:19

The more I hear Rishi talk the more I dislike him. He comes across snobbish and smug. He is so out of touch with reality how could he ever relate to the problems the a vast majority of the uk population are having. He speaks for the millionaires and the top percent earners not every day people.

spaceshiptrain · 06/11/2022 17:15

Government are there to represent our interests and organise and administer large scale schemes for the benefit of the citizens of that country.

That's it. I don't think they need to solve any problems, just prevent them by settings things up for us and running them and leaving us alone to live our self-determining lives.

The benefits scheme is brilliant too if run haphazardly sometimes, but I've used it many times and it's been a great help to get me back on my feet.

Ultimately we have to take initiative and do things for ourselves.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 17:15

Cuppasoupmonster · 06/11/2022 14:25

@AliensAteMyHomework i agree with what you wrote.

@Blossomtoes right to buy should never have happened.

Thank you. Shame more people haven't read and comprehended it. So we'll carry on as we are I guess with everyone getting poorer year on year.

HoppyHorse · 06/11/2022 17:07

Yanbu. Too many people think they can make whatever life choices they fancy and the government/tax payers should pick up the tab. Such as people who don't bother to work full-time but expect benefits, people who don't turn up to medical appointments because they are 'free', people who think they are entitled to a state funded house with multiple bedrooms without bothering to work for it themselves.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 17:01

Havanananana · 06/11/2022 15:58

"According to this report by HMRC the top 1% of earners contribute about 30% of tax received by the government and I can assure they use less government resources as they are more likely to send their kids to private school, use private medical etc."

Who pays for the training of the teachers at these private schools, or for the medical staff in the private hospitals? Do these taxpayers also use the same roads and railways as everyone else or is there a separate infrastructure that they use? What about the police, armed forces, Border Force? Do they have private binmen, separate dumps and recycling units, and a separate supply of water, gas and electricity?

The argument usually states that "people don't want to pay more tax" - and yet there is a whole segment of the population that is happy to pay more for private healthcare and private education - not for the benefit of the population at large, but so that they can buy what they perceive to be an advantage over everyone else.

The net contributors are the people who pay more than they extract even when all of these services are taken into account. It isn't a difficult concept to grasp.

These people are being bled dry while the majority if the population pay a pittance compared to the services they use.

In any society with welfare some people will not be net contributors. But to narrow the tax base so that only 10% of people are is madness and a recipe for the instability we see now.

Croque · 06/11/2022 16:59

The fat and slack in the public sector is a genuine problem. The civil service is like a giant hunk of fatty meat with a higher proportion of fat than meat. It is counterproductive to honest, hard work. One person makes unreasonable demands, if they are bossy enough they are heard. The bar is then permanently lowered for all of the others in the name of equality. I have heard about it too many times.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 16:56

Hawkins00
As the banks use a fiat currency system, they can pretty much print what is needed.

Every heard of the balance of payments deficit?

It has increased from 2% to 8% GDP post-Brexit. Who do you think funds that? The UK is reliant on foreign investment to stay afloat now. Foreign investors won't continue to do that if you just print money, as KameKwazi discovered. You need a viable economy with decent productivity.

Croque · 06/11/2022 16:55

I can certainly speak for London when I say that right to buy created deep seated social divisions which have now become entrenched. You had people buying £3m houses next door to a RTB who paid £30,000 and openly berating them for being "mugs" and "posh idiots". It never had an aspirational effect on either side. It just fueled suspicion and resentment and encouraged vanishing prejudices to rise to the surface again.

Stripyhoglets1 · 06/11/2022 16:39

Florenz · 06/11/2022 14:44

Too much of what we pay in tax in the UK is pocketed by those working in the public sector in the form of salaries and pensions and hardly any of the money goes to deserving people. It'd be far more efficient for high rate tax payers to go round deprived areas and put a few hundred quid into every letterbox, than to pay sky high taxes of which a small percent goes to the needy.

You do understand that the work we do in the public sector does deliver public services that people want, need and rely on?!

LexMitior · 06/11/2022 16:09

Honestly it means he is going to tax you more to deal with his Government screw ups and you will get less. But his sponsors get more.

Conservatives telling you to take responsibility in these circumstances is an utter pee take.

Still there will be enough well upholstered middle class fools who will like the Victorian morality of it - truthfully it's called "you are going to be poorer, accept it".

Isitsixoclockalready · 06/11/2022 16:02

This guy made sense -he should run for parliament!

www.tiktok.com/@lbc/video/7132825652876741893?_t=8X7odRGBp93&_r=1

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 16:02

Income tax accounts for less than a third of government revenue. The less wealthy pay proportionally much more of their incomes in indirect taxes. The income tax argument is a red herring.

Havanananana · 06/11/2022 15:58

"According to this report by HMRC the top 1% of earners contribute about 30% of tax received by the government and I can assure they use less government resources as they are more likely to send their kids to private school, use private medical etc."

Who pays for the training of the teachers at these private schools, or for the medical staff in the private hospitals? Do these taxpayers also use the same roads and railways as everyone else or is there a separate infrastructure that they use? What about the police, armed forces, Border Force? Do they have private binmen, separate dumps and recycling units, and a separate supply of water, gas and electricity?

The argument usually states that "people don't want to pay more tax" - and yet there is a whole segment of the population that is happy to pay more for private healthcare and private education - not for the benefit of the population at large, but so that they can buy what they perceive to be an advantage over everyone else.

MarshaBradyo · 06/11/2022 15:48

Cantstandbullshit · 06/11/2022 14:17

You know that’s bullshit right?

According to this report by HMRC the top 1% of earners contribute about 30% of tax received by the government and I can assure they use less government resources as they are more likely to send their kids to private school, use private medical etc.

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/income-tax-liabilities-statistics-tax-year-2019-to-2020-to-tax-year-2022-to-2023/summary-statistics

Infact there are many many people in the UK who are negative contributors to tax as they pay little tax and when you consider the resources used eg NHS, schools etc they are actually getting more than they pay in.

Agree with this

Havanananana · 06/11/2022 15:47

"Unfortunately Brown sold our gold."

At the time this seemed like a crazy idea and Brown was roundly criticised, but the money was invested in a sovereign wealth fund that has performed better than gold, so his actions actually improved the UK's economic situation.

Of course, like all investment performance, this might be more down to luck than judgement and is not really a way to run the finances of a country any more than betting a million on the 3.15 horse race at Sandown is.

yogiil · 06/11/2022 15:42

We need to invest in dc & ensure the upcoming generations are highly skilled. That's the best path for a prosperous future. Of course there isn't enough dc as people can't afford them.

People should have to pay a land value tax which contributes to bullring more homes. If they don't like, they downsize. If they can't afford it a charge can go on the home. Most of the countries money is locked up in housing which has fucked everything up.

user1497207191 · 06/11/2022 15:38

Florenz · 06/11/2022 15:04

IMO we should return to the gold standard.

Unfortunately Brown sold our gold.

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 06/11/2022 15:35

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 14:27

As the banks use a fiat currency system, they can pretty much print what is needed.

We keep hearing this, if governments can print any money they want then why do all country's have excellent services and military?

What does printing loads of money do to your currency when needing to import stuff?

sst1234 · 06/11/2022 15:32

Maybe the statistics will help.

on Debt UK government debt is £2.5t. The ‘black hole’ that govt is trying to cover by taxing you all more and cutting more is £60b. The government borrowed £500b to pay for Covid. That’s right 20% of total debt happened in the last two years because the govt chose to lock healthy people at home and throw money around like confetti. And to cover for £60b, they are now telling you that you have to pay more. The rest hasn’t even started to be paid yet.

On inflation, the UK government has printed £1t. Thats £1,000,000,000,000. Half of that was printed in to in the last two years, again to lock up healthy people at home, while the economy was being destroyed right in front of your eyes. This has then led to the double digit inflation we have now.

And the gems just keep coming. Increase in corporation tax at a time when the private sector investment is already faltering. Higher taxes when the economy is going into recession. Cancellation of power plants as we struggle with supplies.

Rishi Sunak is directly responsible for a lot of this. And now he gas lights people into thinking that it happened by accident. Folks, you’ve had all the freebies you were going to get during Covid. Now it’s time to pay.

Havanananana · 06/11/2022 15:31

"Especially when you add in our much higher than average rate of VAT."

UK VAT is 20%. The only countries in Europe with a lower rate are Germany (19%) Cyprus (19%) Malta (18%) Romania (19%) and Luxembourg (17%). All of the other European countries have rates of 20% or higher - in Sweden, Denmark and Croatia VAT is 25%, in Hungary it is 27%.

The UK VAT rate is lower than that of 17 of the EU member states and the EU’s average standard VAT rate of 21%

DrManhattan · 06/11/2022 15:11

@Skidaramink there is enough, it's not distributed in a way that benefits all. Some people in society can't stand on their own two feet. I don't want to live in a world where the disabled and vulnerable are discarded.

Blossomtoes · 06/11/2022 15:04

Florenz · 06/11/2022 14:44

Too much of what we pay in tax in the UK is pocketed by those working in the public sector in the form of salaries and pensions and hardly any of the money goes to deserving people. It'd be far more efficient for high rate tax payers to go round deprived areas and put a few hundred quid into every letterbox, than to pay sky high taxes of which a small percent goes to the needy.

You mean people working in the public sector as nurses, doctors, teachers, police officers, even bin men - those people? How is their work not benefiting everyone in society and not just the better off? This place is bonkers sometimes.

Florenz · 06/11/2022 15:04

IMO we should return to the gold standard.

Believeitornot · 06/11/2022 14:57

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 14:27

As the banks use a fiat currency system, they can pretty much print what is needed.

yes and no, not without unintended consequences. The fiat system means we can operate with a deficit but we couldn’t spend endlessly.