Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 05/11/2022 20:51

He's channeling Maggie T!

I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand "I have a problem, it is the Government's job to cope with it!" or "I have a problem, I will go and get a grant to cope with it!" "I am homeless, the Government must house me!" and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first. It is our duty to look after ourselves and then also to help look after our neighbour and life is a reciprocal business and people have got the entitlements too much in mind without the obligations.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 20:51

Fluffygreenslippers · 05/11/2022 20:46

Might as well dispose of the overpaid tosspots then and elect an Alderman for each district like the good old days.

Yup

Skodacool · 05/11/2022 20:50

I think OP might have a point if we didn’t have governments that consistently and repeatedly waste our taxes on poor service from private companies. As for meeting every need, MPs don’t go short of much do they. In my 70+ years I have never before experienced such incompetence.

anniegun · 05/11/2022 20:48

The state cannot do anything but there is a lot more it could do. It is a bit of a cop out when he says that but really means: the healthcare system, education, the justice system, affordable housing are all broken and we cannot ensure people will be fed and warm.

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 05/11/2022 20:48

I agree the Government can't be everything to everyone. But it should be there to step in and protect the most vulnerable - people who lose their job through no fault of their own, people who are medically unable to work and anyone who is working full-time who still can't afford a basic standard of living. Basically, I think everyone has a responsibility to improve their circumstances as best as they can, but if they hit the limit of what is reasonable for them and they still can't afford a basic lifestyle, the Government needs to subsidise them. It's about a basic level of respect for other humans.

I don't think everyone should be able to buy a home, but I think everyone who contributes to society should have a roof over their heads and be able to afford to eat and heat without thinking about it. I also think free basic healthcare (dentistry and medical care) should be easily accessible.

I don't think I'm asking a lot, and I don't think the Government is delivering even that.

Fluffygreenslippers · 05/11/2022 20:46

Might as well dispose of the overpaid tosspots then and elect an Alderman for each district like the good old days.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 20:44

notmyrealmoniker · 05/11/2022 20:15

I have to laugh at the 12 years of Tory awfulness. Did we have a glorious time under the Labour government?

YANBU. No government is going to be everything to everyone.

It was a million times better.

We didn’t have three prime ministers in the time it takes to grow my fringe out, for starters. And neither did we have a Labour prime minister who crashed the economy simply by opening their mouth.

wherethewildthingis · 05/11/2022 20:43

Most people- middle to high earners included- are currently scared to put their heating on and wondering how they will afford food. And the message our prime minister chooses to share is that the government cannot do everything for people 🙄
I do believe that a basic standard of living is something that the government should facilitate for people.
Sitting back and doing nothing, while energy companies claim record profits, and people die of cold, is not OK.

Stripyhoglets1 · 05/11/2022 20:42

notmyrealmoniker · 05/11/2022 20:15

I have to laugh at the 12 years of Tory awfulness. Did we have a glorious time under the Labour government?

YANBU. No government is going to be everything to everyone.

It was a damn sight better than it is now that's what I remember.

This government do stuff that makes things worse - then says "but your on your own dealing with it!"

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 20:39

funrunning · 05/11/2022 20:36

0.1% or 0.01%? There is quite a difference and you mention both.

Also not quite sure you understand ‘loopholes’. They are not universal. There is not a global ‘cure’ on account of ~the very complicated~ tax laws being specific to each country.

Countries could collaborate and I am sure that plans were afoot to do that just before Brexit.

georgarina · 05/11/2022 20:38

Sounds a bit like your cheating violent alcoholic husband telling you 'Well, sorry I'm not a PERFECT PERSON.'

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 20:36

Aleaiactaest · 05/11/2022 20:26

The real issue is that Western economies have all been so desperate to attract big business and have had such low corporation taxes. The big economies have been competing amongst each other to attract said corporations. Companies don’t pay that much tax but their workers do. Similarly, governments globally are scared to lose the billionaires who they see us providing jobs etc. Politicians are simply scared of freaking the market out as it quickly spirals out of control. We saw exactly this happening with Truss’ mini budget. So the governments think they can’t actually do that much. Even if Labour comes into power if we are still in recession where are they going to get the money from? It is a fine balance between taxing the rich and the rich leaving. If most of the developed world has gone billionaire/rich person friendly then what can governments actually do?

Governments could work together to counter the power of corporations who actually need stable countries to invest in, otherwise they can kiss goodbye to their profits.
that’s why the EU is so powerful and a driving force behind Brexit which sought to destabilise the EU.

funrunning · 05/11/2022 20:36

ilyx · 05/11/2022 19:52

The top 0.1% don’t pay any tax because loopholes exist to avoid paying them. And if the wealthiest countries all decided to end those loopholes they’d have to pay them. Economist Ha Joon Change who lectures at Cambridge has written about this so it’s not me conjuring up this from thin air. But the top 0.001% are who control the politicians.

0.1% or 0.01%? There is quite a difference and you mention both.

Also not quite sure you understand ‘loopholes’. They are not universal. There is not a global ‘cure’ on account of ~the very complicated~ tax laws being specific to each country.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 20:34

Croque · 05/11/2022 20:23

There was a lag of several years between financial liberalization and people no longer feeling ashamed to max out their credit cards for silly things which they could do without. The feel good era provided one blueprint after another to help normalize financial irresponsibility.

some of that may be true but most people are sensible and try and save.

However wages have stagnated and housing costs have crept up as a proportion which leaves less to save. I came out of university and had to repay tuition fees which left less to save.

Again, you fall into the trap of blaming individuals when they’re trying to work with the hand they’ve been dealt. Plenty of my peers have saved thousands if not tens of thousands and struggle to get on the housing ladder. I only know one person who was irresponsible with credit and their parents bailed them out.

Most people aren’t stupid. Give them credit ffs and stop assuming the worst.

Croque · 05/11/2022 20:27

I am actually furious about the way in which libraries are being unapologetically repurposed. FFS, do it in shopping arcades instead. Outside of educational establishments, we have barely any widely accessible places left which promote our literary and cultural heritage.

Aleaiactaest · 05/11/2022 20:26

The real issue is that Western economies have all been so desperate to attract big business and have had such low corporation taxes. The big economies have been competing amongst each other to attract said corporations. Companies don’t pay that much tax but their workers do. Similarly, governments globally are scared to lose the billionaires who they see us providing jobs etc. Politicians are simply scared of freaking the market out as it quickly spirals out of control. We saw exactly this happening with Truss’ mini budget. So the governments think they can’t actually do that much. Even if Labour comes into power if we are still in recession where are they going to get the money from? It is a fine balance between taxing the rich and the rich leaving. If most of the developed world has gone billionaire/rich person friendly then what can governments actually do?

cakeorwine · 05/11/2022 20:26

Government choices affect people's lives though.
They can't be everything but what they do affects us.
Or what they don't do.

Badbadbunny · 05/11/2022 20:26

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 20:17

Most people do.

Rishi is just finding ways to make you and others think badly of other people while distracting from his shit show.

Exactly in the same way he made out that the 3 million HE excluded from covid support were either rich or tax evaders! Neither are remotely true. He's very good at using lies and slurs to excuse his overt discrimination.

I hope people start to realise who he really is. He mostly got away with the 3 million excluded during covid, mostly because of incompetent opposition who couldn't understand the unfairness/illogical rules, and believed his lies and half truths about why people were excluded.

Croque · 05/11/2022 20:23

There was a lag of several years between financial liberalization and people no longer feeling ashamed to max out their credit cards for silly things which they could do without. The feel good era provided one blueprint after another to help normalize financial irresponsibility.

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 20:23

BTW there is enough money

Badbadbunny · 05/11/2022 20:22

He's right that a govt can't do everything for everyone. But what they do should be fair.

Rishi was completely out of order during covid for excluding 3 million workers from the covid support schemes. I remember him saying then "we can't help everyone", but that's pathetic. If he's handing out thousands in support to some people, then it should have been across the board to everyone HE stopped from operating their businesses and working, rather than him coming up with flimsy and illogical exclusions meaning over 3 million got bugger all!

It's the gross unfairness that gets me, with Rishi being the arbiter of who's worthy and who isn't!

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 20:21

I don't think it's fair that governments can fuck things up for people and then get to walk away with no consequences

Notonthestairs · 05/11/2022 20:21

It's just a line to soften us up before services are cut again. Nobody needs libraries (unless they need somewhere to warm up).

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 20:21

Choppies · 05/11/2022 20:07

If there’s no money for basic human needs how come the rich (Tory donors and voters) keep getting richer??

Where did I say that?

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 05/11/2022 20:20

This is the same Rishi Sunak who was filmed bragging about taking resources and funds from socio-economically deprived communities and using it to further enhance already affluent areas. So when he says "the government can't do everything" what he actually means is they'll do pretty much anything to protect the wealthy, their donors, bankers and tax-dodging corporations but when it comes to everything else "sorry, our hands are tied".