Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 05/11/2022 21:35

Did we have a glorious time under the Labour government?

Comparatively yes.

MangyInseam · 05/11/2022 21:35

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:24

He rolled out financial support in such a way (via businesses, including furlough) which meant the scope for fraud was huge. Fake companies were set up in their thousands to claims loans etc.

Other countries did it differently. We locked down too late and it cost us dear.

And if I hear “it’s just the flu” one more time, I’ll scream.

There is a difficult line to walk between ease of access and the possibility of fraud. Can you imagine the fall out if people could not get approved?

Other countries did have some of those same problems, or issues where people claimed and it was later clawed back. I know someone here in Canada, a person who is fairly close to being indigent, who claimed income supplement, and was then dinged with a $30.000 bill when tax time came. They garnished his welfare payment which made it far too tiny to live on. He wasn't being fraudulent, they encouraged people who thought they should qualify to apply.

I'm not sure why you think an earlier lockdown would have made any difference, it didn't anywhere else.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:32

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:25

Unless you think there’s an infinite supply of money, then yes it matters if companies make huge profits because it takes money from
elsewhere

unless you believe in the magic money tree….

What do you mean take money for elsewhere? Where is this elsewhere? They sell services and goods and are paid for doing so? They’re not taking it from under people’s mattresses.

And your magic money tree analogy really doesn’t work here. Private sector actually creates wealth. The magic money tree is the government printing press that’s printing away for 14 years, causing this inflation.

RosaGallica · 05/11/2022 21:31

Privatisation was a big mistake, as was PFI, as was right to buy. The government has spent too long being everything to the private sector. Somehow though it’s always working people at fault, never the rich ones who have been ripping off the public purse for years. They need to stop giving public money away and use it to build infrastructure everyone can use

Zilla1 · 05/11/2022 21:29

NHRTT but perhaps OP might have a look where anyone recently has asked the government 'to do everything' that might make this response reasonable instead of being a cynical media management exercise. Just repeating the same unreasonable statement Liz or Boris said a few months ago?

Perhaps what people wanted was the bare minimum government competence instead of the lowest economic growth and productivity amongst comparable nations, highest inflation and 12 years of deliberate decisions that has led to the relative impoverishment of the majority (c 33% cut in real incomes) while enabling the richest 1% to accrue an additional £2.5tn in wealth.

All features rather than side effects of a series of policy decisions.

Where it will now get interesting is that the absence of competence has impacted on the wealth of the richest by a reduction in asset prices and pensions and because the recession is impacting on the larger corporates who used to be the primary focus of government priorities but now are second order stakeholders but still important enough to shake the government tree.

The government's preference will be more austerity and erosion of incomes of the majority but their stakeholders are perhaps thinking what the effects of this on consumer spending might lead to in corporate turnover and profits.

Perhaps people might look at the per capita GDP and relative spending power in comparable economies to wonder whether austerity the return will improve the UK economy? Just remember we can't pay what we can't afford, there's no such thing as a magic money tree, the government can't do absolutely everything and all the other apparently reasonable marketing statements dreamt up to hide monumental incompetence.

What was the Daily Mail;s headlines the day of/the day following Liz's fiscal event statement before even the rich realised the adverse effects on their wealth?....... Bonanza.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:28

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:22

Why do you only think of the wealth individuals? What about about corporations?

There will be sectors out there making huge profits at the moment - you only know what’s reported in the media but plenty will be.

What about corporations? You can only tax corporations who are based in the UK. Corporations are footloose. It’s not hard for them to up and base themselves anywhere and route all profits through low tax jurisdictions.

By the way, oil and gas sector already pays 30% in tax, more than any another sector. And also the windfall tax.

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 21:27

@sst1234 I think you missed the bit when I wrote that the government needs to step in.
Last time I checked I didn't live in North Korea but sounds like you know best.

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:25

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:24

Why does it need to be stopped? It’s business. Who says that you or anyone can also stop businesses from making profit. Do we live in North Korea?

Don’t give into lazy sound bites. The problem is not that BP is making profits legitimately. The problem is that our government has failed to be energy self sufficient. Failed to take the decision 10 years ago to build nuclear power. Just this week it was announced that sizewell C will likely be cancelled. Is that BP’s fault?

Unless you think there’s an infinite supply of money, then yes it matters if companies make huge profits because it takes money from
elsewhere

unless you believe in the magic money tree….

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:24

MangyInseam · 05/11/2022 21:22

I don't think covid policy was up to him.

But once the decision was made - and remember that "the science" was screaming all over that these were the only options, at least according to all the media - there was really no option other than rolling out financial support.

He rolled out financial support in such a way (via businesses, including furlough) which meant the scope for fraud was huge. Fake companies were set up in their thousands to claims loans etc.

Other countries did it differently. We locked down too late and it cost us dear.

And if I hear “it’s just the flu” one more time, I’ll scream.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:24

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 21:19

@sst1234 look at the profits the energy companies are making - its in the billions, that is our money that we are paying that is pure profit. It needs to be stopped. The government need to step in in circumstances like this. Same with other huge companies not paying any tax etc.

Why does it need to be stopped? It’s business. Who says that you or anyone can also stop businesses from making profit. Do we live in North Korea?

Don’t give into lazy sound bites. The problem is not that BP is making profits legitimately. The problem is that our government has failed to be energy self sufficient. Failed to take the decision 10 years ago to build nuclear power. Just this week it was announced that sizewell C will likely be cancelled. Is that BP’s fault?

Believeitornot · 05/11/2022 21:22

Capri3 · 05/11/2022 21:21

I agree, a higher rate of tax still wouldn’t raise as much as many people think.

Who are these “very wealthy” people who apparently need to pay more tax? Most really wealthy people have several houses all over the world. They may not officially directly pay much in tax, but will employ many people in each country (housekeepers, cleaners, gardeners, chauffeurs etc) and spend a huge amount on services such as restaurants, designer clothing, hairdressers, beauty treatments, florists, hotels etc etc, but wouldn’t use the NHS, or state schooling for example, so are already paying in way more money than they take out. If you try to tax them on salary earnt and already taxed abroad, they’ll just leave.

Why do you only think of the wealth individuals? What about about corporations?

There will be sectors out there making huge profits at the moment - you only know what’s reported in the media but plenty will be.

MangyInseam · 05/11/2022 21:22

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:10

He would be right. If we didn’t have the highest tax burden since the war right now.

This is the guy that badly mismanaged the economy by wasting public funds during Covid. And printed half a trillion pounds to pay for lockdown largesse. He’s stupid and incompetent. Hardly in a place to be lecturing.

I don't think covid policy was up to him.

But once the decision was made - and remember that "the science" was screaming all over that these were the only options, at least according to all the media - there was really no option other than rolling out financial support.

Capri3 · 05/11/2022 21:21

Butchyrestingface · 05/11/2022 21:06

But my point is even if the very wealthy did pay a much higher rate of tax, I’m not convinced it would be enough for everything posters on here seem to expect.

How's about we start taxing them properly and put your theory to the test?

I agree, a higher rate of tax still wouldn’t raise as much as many people think.

Who are these “very wealthy” people who apparently need to pay more tax? Most really wealthy people have several houses all over the world. They may not officially directly pay much in tax, but will employ many people in each country (housekeepers, cleaners, gardeners, chauffeurs etc) and spend a huge amount on services such as restaurants, designer clothing, hairdressers, beauty treatments, florists, hotels etc etc, but wouldn’t use the NHS, or state schooling for example, so are already paying in way more money than they take out. If you try to tax them on salary earnt and already taxed abroad, they’ll just leave.

miceonabranch · 05/11/2022 21:20

Tut, those pesky people demanding they have access to housing, healthcare, reliable transport and education, where will it end? 🙄

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:20

Basically he wants more of you money for less responsibility. He wants to tax everyone more and more by stealth, yet the state cannot do everything, sorry anything.

To all those people saying they Tories bad, boo. This is not conservatism. Not even remotely. This is corrupt socialism dressed up with a few sound bites give the illusion of conservatism. These charlatans realized a long time ago there is no fun or personal gain in pursuing economic growth for the country, in looking after the public finances, in keeping taxes low. The real fun is in taking people’s money and throwing it around like confetti. And actually even if Rishi and co wanted to pursue conservative policies, they don’t possess the intellect or skill to do so.

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 21:19

@sst1234 look at the profits the energy companies are making - its in the billions, that is our money that we are paying that is pure profit. It needs to be stopped. The government need to step in in circumstances like this. Same with other huge companies not paying any tax etc.

Worriedddd · 05/11/2022 21:16

People are either going to have to accept Nordic style taxes like 50 percent. Or face facts that things will have to be privatised.

MangyInseam · 05/11/2022 21:14

I think he's right in the sense that there are people who would like the state to do everything they imagine, and they can imagine a lot.

But it's also true in some other ways. I don't think the state is able to do a good job at certain things, no matter how much money it has. You can have a great welfare state, but it's impersonal, people are doing their job, it's never going to effectively replace having a close knit community or family nearby who can knock on your door or drive you to the shops when you have a broken foot or babysit in an emergency.

You could also make an argument around whether it is really a good thing for the state to do things that other types of citizen groups or individuals can do. There are communities that have historically become dependent upon a state body for some reason, and when that happens down several generations it doesn't create good healthy empowered individuals or communities.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:14

DrManhattan · 05/11/2022 20:23

BTW there is enough money

No there really isn’t. Our debt burden and weak economy is there for all to see. The money has been well and truly spent. Makes you wonder where the sky high taxes go.

Stripyhoglets1 · 05/11/2022 21:13

Jjones8 · 05/11/2022 20:59

I agree with you. Sadly there is no magic money tree and the number simply cannot add up just now.

I think it is quite clear that there is when they want money for their backers!

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:11

Hugasauras · 05/11/2022 20:51

He's channeling Maggie T!

I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand "I have a problem, it is the Government's job to cope with it!" or "I have a problem, I will go and get a grant to cope with it!" "I am homeless, the Government must house me!" and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first. It is our duty to look after ourselves and then also to help look after our neighbour and life is a reciprocal business and people have got the entitlements too much in mind without the obligations.

Channeling Maggie?

If he had half the intellect and backbone that Maggie had, we wouldn’t be in this mess.

sst1234 · 05/11/2022 21:10

He would be right. If we didn’t have the highest tax burden since the war right now.

This is the guy that badly mismanaged the economy by wasting public funds during Covid. And printed half a trillion pounds to pay for lockdown largesse. He’s stupid and incompetent. Hardly in a place to be lecturing.

antelopevalley · 05/11/2022 21:07

You are setting up a strawman. No one is expecting utopia. A functioning and competent government who can deliver on at least some of their manifesto pledges would be a massive step up from what we have had.

Butchyrestingface · 05/11/2022 21:06

But my point is even if the very wealthy did pay a much higher rate of tax, I’m not convinced it would be enough for everything posters on here seem to expect.

How's about we start taxing them properly and put your theory to the test?

Jjones8 · 05/11/2022 20:59

I agree with you. Sadly there is no magic money tree and the number simply cannot add up just now.