Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Rishi is right - the government cannot be everything to everyone?

306 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 05/11/2022 19:39

Don’t get me wrong, the Tory government hasn’t tried to be anything let alone everything.

But I think he was right when he said there’s too much reliance on the state to provide for each and every issue the public face.

We could free up a lot of funds by taxing big corporations properly, cracking down on non doms etc. But even then, I’m not convinced the socialist utopia of generous benefits, a five star NHS, cheap and available high quality public housing, instant mental health support etc that is often discussed on here could ever be financially viable.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AliensAteMyHomework · 07/11/2022 03:25

Thank you for admitting that.

Hawkins001 · 07/11/2022 00:29

AliensAteMyHomework · 07/11/2022 00:07

In what way does that imply everyone should believe all MPs? How does that even make any sense when the entire point that I was making is that they contradicted each other in public repeatedly, so by definition it was impossible for all of them to be telling the truth? Hence Clavinova's posts (as always) were misleading.

How did you get from that to believing I am saying MPs tell the truth? I'm honestly baffled. Confused Unless you got confused and meant to direct your post at Clavinova?

Selective analysis and ended up confusing myself based on not fully analysing both of your perspectives

AliensAteMyHomework · 07/11/2022 00:16

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 23:56

AliensAteMyHomework
Which directly contradicted what many, many other MPs said in public repeatedly and widely publicised in televised interviews etc. As you well know.

No point quoting MPs from 2011, 2012, 2013 etc. if the referendum vote is 2016 - or is Keir Starmer sticking with Jeremy Corbyn's 2019 manifesto in the next general election?

people have debunked over and over again

Nonsense.

As everyone has repeatedly told you when you repost your spam over and over again for the last 6 years

For a start I didn't take much interest in Brexit until the summer of 2018 and I certainly didn't post any Brexit related stuff until mid 2018.

You are right, it is indeed nonsense that you post. Your nonsense been debunked so many times that I'm amazed you're not embarrassed to continue with it. That's why nobody can be bothered to go through your arguments one by one and disprove them to you yet again for the 1,000,000th time because you still don't seem to be able to understand facts.

I shall not respond to you again on this thread or any other.

AliensAteMyHomework · 07/11/2022 00:07

In what way does that imply everyone should believe all MPs? How does that even make any sense when the entire point that I was making is that they contradicted each other in public repeatedly, so by definition it was impossible for all of them to be telling the truth? Hence Clavinova's posts (as always) were misleading.

How did you get from that to believing I am saying MPs tell the truth? I'm honestly baffled. Confused Unless you got confused and meant to direct your post at Clavinova?

Hawkins001 · 07/11/2022 00:02

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:49

So are we to believe all mps, are honest and factually correct ?

Where on Earth did you get this from? ConfusedConfused

"Which directly contradicted what many, many other MPs said in public repeatedly and widely publicised in televised interviews etc."

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 23:56

AliensAteMyHomework
Which directly contradicted what many, many other MPs said in public repeatedly and widely publicised in televised interviews etc. As you well know.

No point quoting MPs from 2011, 2012, 2013 etc. if the referendum vote is 2016 - or is Keir Starmer sticking with Jeremy Corbyn's 2019 manifesto in the next general election?

people have debunked over and over again

Nonsense.

As everyone has repeatedly told you when you repost your spam over and over again for the last 6 years

For a start I didn't take much interest in Brexit until the summer of 2018 and I certainly didn't post any Brexit related stuff until mid 2018.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:49

So are we to believe all mps, are honest and factually correct ?

Where on Earth did you get this from? ConfusedConfused

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:48

I believe the theory is, all the main trading blocks will eventually unite as one

Is it? Whose theory is that then? 🤔🙄

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 23:46

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:33

Which directly contradicted what many, many other MPs said in public repeatedly and eidely publicised in televised interviews etc. As you well know. As everyone has repeatedly told you when you repost your spam over and over again for the last 6 years. Same old crap over and over again which people have debunked over and over again. It's boring, and nobody believes your nonsense because everybody has already disproved all of your selective quotes and can't be bothered to keep repeating why you're wrong because you already know that, anyway. You're just trying to mislead yet more gullible people, again. 🥱🥱

So are we to believe all mps, are honest and factually correct ?

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 23:44

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:25

Name one other large economy which instead of joining the trade block on its doorstep has joined another in another continent, with totally different legal systems, business norms, and much more limiting physical ability to trade plus higher shipping costs, etc?

Clue: none.

I believe the theory is, all the main trading blocks will eventually unite as one,

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:33

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 22:49

AliensAteMyHomework
Indeed. It didn't have to involve leaving the single market, for example. In fact many prominent Brexiteers were very vocal in saying that of course nobody was suggesting any such thing because that would be madness.

8 May 2016 — Britain will quit Europe's single market if the country votes to leave the EU, [says] Michael Gove, the Leave campaign's most senior figure...

22 Feb 2016
Leader of the UK Independence Party Nigel Farage has said that he doesn't want the United Kingdom to be a part of the the European Single Market

www.cityam.com/eu-referendum-ukip-leader-nigel-farage-says-he-doesnt-want-to-be-part-of-the-european-single-market/

Owen Paterson: 'Dear Jeremy, please stop misquoting me'

www.shropshirestar.com/news/politics/2019/03/14/owen-paterson-dear-jeremy-please-stop-misquoting-me/

Hansard (Pre) Referendum Debate Wednesday 15 June 2016

Nigel Adams
(Selby and Ainsty) (Con)
Q14. I congratulate my right hon. Friend on honouring our manifesto pledge and delivering this historic referendum. Unfortunately, however, we have heard some hysterical scaremongering during the debate, and there are those in this House and the other place who believe that if the British people decide to leave the EU, there should be a second referendum. Will he assure the House and the country that, whatever the result on 24 June, his Government will carry out the wishes of the British people—if the vote is to remain, we remain, but if it is to leave, which I hope it is, we leave?

The Prime Minister [David Cameron]

I am very happy to agree with my hon. Friend. “In” means we remain in a reformed EU; “out” means we come out. As the leave campaigners and others have said, “out” means out of the EU, out of the European single market, out of the Council of Ministers—out of all those things...

Quite a few MPs obviously suffered some memory loss after the vote -Theresa May didn't get her 'red lines' out of nowhere.

Which directly contradicted what many, many other MPs said in public repeatedly and eidely publicised in televised interviews etc. As you well know. As everyone has repeatedly told you when you repost your spam over and over again for the last 6 years. Same old crap over and over again which people have debunked over and over again. It's boring, and nobody believes your nonsense because everybody has already disproved all of your selective quotes and can't be bothered to keep repeating why you're wrong because you already know that, anyway. You're just trying to mislead yet more gullible people, again. 🥱🥱

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 23:32

Havanananana
The Japan deal that was the same as the EU-Japan deal (except for some cheese

Not the same deal for financial services;

www.cityam.com/finance-not-fish-the-trade-deal-with-japan-focuses-on-what-matters-for-the-city/
www.gov.uk/government/publications/inaugural-uk-japan-financial-regulatory-forum/uk-japan-financial-regulatory-forum-2022-joint-statement

6 Nov 2022
Japan and Britain are expected to agree to a major new defence pact in December, a report said Sunday, as the two countries look to boost cooperation with mutual ally the U.S. amid concerns over China’s growing assertiveness

www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2022/11/06/national/britain-japan-defense-pact/

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:28

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 23:15

JohnStuartMill
The UK will have the slowest growth of the G7 economies next year

That was July's forecast - currently it's Germany and Italy;

www.dw.com/en/imf-says-germany-and-italy-to-slip-into-recession-in-2023/a-63405441

In July the UK apparently had £30bn of headroom and now it has a £50bn deficit per October. £80bn (annual and compounding) additional fuckup in the space of 3 months. Care to ask your beloved Tories why?

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:25

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 23:00

I guess to achieve the goals of one world government, if such a feat can be achieved, I guess we will have to rejoin one block or another etc

Name one other large economy which instead of joining the trade block on its doorstep has joined another in another continent, with totally different legal systems, business norms, and much more limiting physical ability to trade plus higher shipping costs, etc?

Clue: none.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 23:23

Isn't that the same with most main stream newspapers and commentators, as it's all mostly analysis, = their perspectives, with more knowledge than me, but still basically educated analysis on what ifs ?

Economic data exists. It is possible to track effects from different causes and analyse them. This is what many people do as a profession. It isn't just someone's opinion. Forecasts are to a certain extent "what ifs". Analysis of what has actually happened is not.

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 23:15

JohnStuartMill
The UK will have the slowest growth of the G7 economies next year

That was July's forecast - currently it's Germany and Italy;

www.dw.com/en/imf-says-germany-and-italy-to-slip-into-recession-in-2023/a-63405441

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 23:11

Havanananana
Even with this decline in trade, the German economy is in a far better state than the UK

14 Oct 2022
Economists say Germany is poised for recession next year. The International Monetary Fund predicts it could suffer the worst hit among major economies other than Russia.

www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/14/germany-economy-recession-energy-exports/

24 Oct 2022
In order to tackle rising energy prices, a quarter of German companies revealed in a new survey that they planned to cut jobs, among other cost saving measures.

www.thelocal.de/20221024/energy-crisis-quarter-of-german-companies-plan-to-cut-jobs/

JohnStuartMill · 06/11/2022 23:04

Dramatic rise in child poverty in the last five years:
www.lboro.ac.uk/news-events/news/2021/may/dramatic-rise-in-child-poverty/

Poverty rate among working households in UK is highest ever:
www.theguardian.com/society/2021/may/26/poverty-rate-among-working-households-in-uk-is-highest-ever

UK is only G7 country with smaller economy than before Covid-19
www.ft.com/content/4edae69b-c82d-49fb-ae5a-03d14ca8caa6

The UK will have the slowest growth of the G7 economies next year:
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-26/uk-economy-will-have-slowest-growth-in-g7-next-year-imf-says

No matter what, Clavinova is still trying to convince us all that we have never had it so good.

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 23:00

I guess to achieve the goals of one world government, if such a feat can be achieved, I guess we will have to rejoin one block or another etc

Hawkins001 · 06/11/2022 22:51

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 21:42

If that's the case you could start a much better thread admitting that, asking for help and links. Then people could help you to learn. Posting comments on a thread like this defending indefensible and damaging policies and pretending you know things you don't is not ok, and risks spreads misinformation.

Isn't that the same with most main stream newspapers and commentators, as it's all mostly analysis, = their perspectives, with more knowledge than me, but still basically educated analysis on what ifs ?

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 22:49

AliensAteMyHomework
Indeed. It didn't have to involve leaving the single market, for example. In fact many prominent Brexiteers were very vocal in saying that of course nobody was suggesting any such thing because that would be madness.

8 May 2016 — Britain will quit Europe's single market if the country votes to leave the EU, [says] Michael Gove, the Leave campaign's most senior figure...

22 Feb 2016
Leader of the UK Independence Party Nigel Farage has said that he doesn't want the United Kingdom to be a part of the the European Single Market

www.cityam.com/eu-referendum-ukip-leader-nigel-farage-says-he-doesnt-want-to-be-part-of-the-european-single-market/

Owen Paterson: 'Dear Jeremy, please stop misquoting me'

www.shropshirestar.com/news/politics/2019/03/14/owen-paterson-dear-jeremy-please-stop-misquoting-me/

Hansard (Pre) Referendum Debate Wednesday 15 June 2016

Nigel Adams
(Selby and Ainsty) (Con)
Q14. I congratulate my right hon. Friend on honouring our manifesto pledge and delivering this historic referendum. Unfortunately, however, we have heard some hysterical scaremongering during the debate, and there are those in this House and the other place who believe that if the British people decide to leave the EU, there should be a second referendum. Will he assure the House and the country that, whatever the result on 24 June, his Government will carry out the wishes of the British people—if the vote is to remain, we remain, but if it is to leave, which I hope it is, we leave?

The Prime Minister [David Cameron]

I am very happy to agree with my hon. Friend. “In” means we remain in a reformed EU; “out” means we come out. As the leave campaigners and others have said, “out” means out of the EU, out of the European single market, out of the Council of Ministers—out of all those things...

Quite a few MPs obviously suffered some memory loss after the vote -Theresa May didn't get her 'red lines' out of nowhere.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 22:21

NCFT0922 · 06/11/2022 22:18

@AliensAteMyHomework why did you have to? Did you tell him all this while ordering his free school meal?

And no, he does not get free school meals. 🙄

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 22:21

NCFT0922 · 06/11/2022 22:18

@AliensAteMyHomework why did you have to? Did you tell him all this while ordering his free school meal?

Because he is curious about the world and how everything works and he asks me questions and I answer them honestly (in an age appropriate way). I don't believe he should be denied honest answers to his questions.

AliensAteMyHomework · 06/11/2022 22:19

Clavinova · 06/11/2022 22:18

AliensAteMyHomework
Oh God you again with your spam. Will you just bore off? Everyone's bored of it, and has been for years

Bad luck.
Did you intend to copy all of my post - not really necessary was it?

I didn't copy it. I used the quote function.

As usual, as you know, it was nonsense.

NCFT0922 · 06/11/2022 22:18

@AliensAteMyHomework why did you have to? Did you tell him all this while ordering his free school meal?

Swipe left for the next trending thread