Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick to death of hearing about people's cancer

336 replies

MiserableCow2022 · 05/11/2022 17:26

I've name changed for this one because I'm pretty sure I'm going to get massive abuse for it but I'm a regular poster.
What the title says, I am sick to death of everybody and their brothers cancer or other appalling disease being postered up in every magazine and newspaper all of the time with week by week progress of their dying. This morning headline news was another "celeb" and her cancer.
I feel sorry for her, I'm not a monster but that's for her and her family to deal with it isn't headline news.
I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or facebook.
Isn't life just shit enough for everyone now without reading about people's terminal illnesses every single day - it's enough to make you want to just end it all.
I don't find people like bowelbabe inspiring, she is gone and her children are motherless and we all had to watch her dying and shrinking bit by bit, nor do I find Sarah Beany's bald head refreshing or inspiring.
I just wish they could just keep it it to themselves and their families.
Everytime I look at the papers I think it's going to be me next.
When I grew up people with a terminal illness just got on with it and retreated into the bosom of their families to die and I wish they would do that now. That is certainly what I am going to do.
People will be informed of my terminal decline only after I've gone. I have no intention of rubbing their noses in it everyday.
I want to die with dignity away from the public gaze and not drag anyone else down with me.
I think part of the reason people do the public thing is because they are terrified of dying and can't accept it and going public distracts them.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Ekátn · 07/11/2022 15:40

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 15:23

There are many things in life that we feel and might even express but it doesn't make it morally acceptable. I am lucky enough not to have cancer. I remind myself of that and how precious life is when I see such headlines. I do also feel unease but there are many things that make me feel uneasy that I don't think should be altered or silenced just to suit me. An example being pictures of starving children. I don't expect to be spared from seeing those pictures. As much as I find it upsetting I also have a responsibility to respond with empathy or, if I can't manage that, no response at all.

We can expect others to refrain from hurting us out of malice but trying to create a world where you're not even touched by the misfortunes of others, and even expect them to keep those misfortunes out of your way so you won't have the unease of hearing about them, is incredibly controlling and entitled. It's like telling shielding people that not only should they stay at home, they should also not distress us by telling us about their isolation.

The op was able to display great empathy for herself and none for the people she was describing in rather unpleasant ways. As much as I understand her reaction and feel a sense of fellow feeling about the unease, I find the choices she has made in response to that feeling incredibly self absorbed and entitled. The definition of snowflake. Yet there is a feeling from the tone of her post that she is actually trying to imply that people who don't shut up about their cancer are a bit snowflakey and entitled. The reality is, we can all learn from people who haven't got much time left, whether they are old or young. They don't tend to be whinging for a start.

And yet you believe because you think one way everyone else should also. That Op and others shouldn’t be allowed to express something because you feel they shouldn’t. Isn’t that self absorbed and entitled? You feel entitled to not see and read a view like the ops? You are expecting not to be touched by something (the ops opinion) you find unpleasant and retaliate by name calling.

The vast majority of people are not expecting to never see anything. But the amount of it can be overwhelming. In the thread there has been examples amid all the places people have been confronted by it. And it’s difficult for some.

Like I said, I don’t agree with the Op that we should go back to hiding death, but I think there could be a better happy medium. I can understand how someone in ops position, being bombarded by certain things ends up feeling at the end of their tether with it.

My mum died last year. not of cancer, though (as I said at the beginning) my aunt did die of cancer. What my mum died of pops up every so often. Not very much so it’s easy to navigate away from. But certain illnesses are not that easy to navigate away from. It’s been an awful year, I can imagine if it was everywhere I looked, I might be feeling pretty angry about it.

BagOfBollocks · 07/11/2022 15:34

Madeintowerhamlets · 07/11/2022 15:23

There’s actually an advert coming up for me on this page about ‘How not to die of cancer’ by Dr Greger 🤦🏻‍♀️. Perfect illustration!

Blimey, that must be very upsetting for MNetters who are actually dying of cancer.

FlorenceOrTheMachine · 07/11/2022 15:30

It's an interesting point, and difficult to answer. At the risk of raising your ire, last week I was diagnosed with early stages of leukaemia, of a sort that could turn terminal quite quickly. Must admit I feel that ignoring it's existence is my goto coping strategy (this is first time I've mentioned it to anyone, and wouldn't now if it weren't anonymous). Probably won't stop me dying, but one can but hope. I don't know - pretend it doesn't exist? Possibly not healthy.

Madeintowerhamlets · 07/11/2022 15:23

There’s actually an advert coming up for me on this page about ‘How not to die of cancer’ by Dr Greger 🤦🏻‍♀️. Perfect illustration!

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 15:23

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 15:06

But surely you can understand that many people, feel similar (not the same) as the Op and sharing it may be upsetting to some.

I don’t believe that means your mother shouldn’t write about it. But surely she accepts it’s a double edged sword. People feel different ways about it throughout their diagnosis and outcome as do families. So some people may feel like this at certain points and not at others.

I do agree people should feel the need to hide away. But also understand it’s difficult when you are going through it when it’s multiple news stories every single day.

Don’t think there was any need for the snowflake comment though to an op who is clearly struggling.

There are many things in life that we feel and might even express but it doesn't make it morally acceptable. I am lucky enough not to have cancer. I remind myself of that and how precious life is when I see such headlines. I do also feel unease but there are many things that make me feel uneasy that I don't think should be altered or silenced just to suit me. An example being pictures of starving children. I don't expect to be spared from seeing those pictures. As much as I find it upsetting I also have a responsibility to respond with empathy or, if I can't manage that, no response at all.

We can expect others to refrain from hurting us out of malice but trying to create a world where you're not even touched by the misfortunes of others, and even expect them to keep those misfortunes out of your way so you won't have the unease of hearing about them, is incredibly controlling and entitled. It's like telling shielding people that not only should they stay at home, they should also not distress us by telling us about their isolation.

The op was able to display great empathy for herself and none for the people she was describing in rather unpleasant ways. As much as I understand her reaction and feel a sense of fellow feeling about the unease, I find the choices she has made in response to that feeling incredibly self absorbed and entitled. The definition of snowflake. Yet there is a feeling from the tone of her post that she is actually trying to imply that people who don't shut up about their cancer are a bit snowflakey and entitled. The reality is, we can all learn from people who haven't got much time left, whether they are old or young. They don't tend to be whinging for a start.

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 15:10

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 15:07

I think that’s the issue. That it’s everywhere. There is no avoiding it and it can be really upsetting for some.

Exactly, as I said above it was a real struggle to find magazines for a friend with terminal cancer at the same time as Jade Goody. Sometimes it feels like even the light fluffy stuff you turn to for light relief is filled with tales of woe. And these days, those resources tend to be online and so the algorithm means that once you click one story (intentionally or by mistake) you will see ten more.

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 15:07

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 15:04

It isn’t just about ‘switching off the news’ though. Everywhere you go, there’s gofundme pages and charity walks and head shaving. We get office-wide emails at work telling sad stories and asking for sponsorship, links to gofundme pages all over Facebook, people rattling donation tins in town. It’s not just newspapers/magazines either, there seems to be lots of people with sad causes popping up on breakfast television, radio shows, basically everywhere.

Everyone thinks their cause is the most important one, but it’s lost in a sea of other sad causes. I would rather live in ignorance to be honest and approach problems when I cross them, rather than live in an anxious state of heightened anticipation because it seems like these tragic events are always just around the corner.

I think that’s the issue. That it’s everywhere. There is no avoiding it and it can be really upsetting for some.

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 15:06

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 14:54

I find the sentiments expressed in the op abhorrent. No problem with her saying them if she must but equally bowelbabe or whoever we are talking about can say whatever they like without the op trying to whinge them into a compliant silent end of life.

There's no bizarre moral virtue in hiding yourself away to die just in case others find it a bit distasteful. This is yet another form of discrimination and the self absorption/entitlement of the op is mind boggling. No, snowflake, my mother with cancer will write about it and publish all she wants. Thank fuck there are people kind enough to be interested and let her feel heard, just like you wanted to feel heard when you started this thread without giving a toss about anyone with cancer who might be reading it and feel unaccepted and silenced.

But surely you can understand that many people, feel similar (not the same) as the Op and sharing it may be upsetting to some.

I don’t believe that means your mother shouldn’t write about it. But surely she accepts it’s a double edged sword. People feel different ways about it throughout their diagnosis and outcome as do families. So some people may feel like this at certain points and not at others.

I do agree people should feel the need to hide away. But also understand it’s difficult when you are going through it when it’s multiple news stories every single day.

Don’t think there was any need for the snowflake comment though to an op who is clearly struggling.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 15:04

It isn’t just about ‘switching off the news’ though. Everywhere you go, there’s gofundme pages and charity walks and head shaving. We get office-wide emails at work telling sad stories and asking for sponsorship, links to gofundme pages all over Facebook, people rattling donation tins in town. It’s not just newspapers/magazines either, there seems to be lots of people with sad causes popping up on breakfast television, radio shows, basically everywhere.

Everyone thinks their cause is the most important one, but it’s lost in a sea of other sad causes. I would rather live in ignorance to be honest and approach problems when I cross them, rather than live in an anxious state of heightened anticipation because it seems like these tragic events are always just around the corner.

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 14:54

I find the sentiments expressed in the op abhorrent. No problem with her saying them if she must but equally bowelbabe or whoever we are talking about can say whatever they like without the op trying to whinge them into a compliant silent end of life.

There's no bizarre moral virtue in hiding yourself away to die just in case others find it a bit distasteful. This is yet another form of discrimination and the self absorption/entitlement of the op is mind boggling. No, snowflake, my mother with cancer will write about it and publish all she wants. Thank fuck there are people kind enough to be interested and let her feel heard, just like you wanted to feel heard when you started this thread without giving a toss about anyone with cancer who might be reading it and feel unaccepted and silenced.

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/11/2022 14:50

Yabu. Greater awareness saves lives.

If you dont like it don't read/listen to it but you don't get to decide for other people.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 14:49

@Mercurial123 but to what extent? Awareness can easily become anxiety if we go on about it too much.

Mercurial123 · 07/11/2022 14:47

As someone who has had cancer and 13 years in remission I totally disagree with you. When my mother had cancer 30 years ago nobody talked about it and she felt isolated. Awareness can only be a good thing.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 14:31

I think YANBU but as part of a wider picture where every negative thing that happens to anyone - MH problems, physical health problems etc - has to be rammed down the public’s throat in order to ‘raise awareness’ of it. I understand it’s a big deal for the person going through it, but honestly isn’t life shit enough without an acute awareness of 10494774 illnesses? I panic when DD gets ill because I’ve read so much about sepsis/meningitis etc despite it being relatively rare. Sometimes I wonder if ignorance really is bliss. Whether it was better when dr google and ‘inspirational’ celebs didn’t exist, and people just phoned a doctor if they were really worried but didn’t fall into anxiety spirals before then.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 07/11/2022 14:24

One reason is most of the media in the UK are utter scum who will 'out you' if you don't publicly say it yourself.

mumboss1984 · 07/11/2022 14:20

I am appalled and will be deleting my account now.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 07/11/2022 14:15

If someone is diagnosed with a serious illness it’s entirely up to them how they deal with it.

A close relative has just been diagnosed with cancer. She only wants her close family to know. I think that’s admirable and we will of course respect her wishes. I hope it never happens but I think I would likely be the same.

I don’t think that makes my relative any better or worse than Deborah James, Sarah Beeny or anyone else who chooses to share their illness. Their actions have undoubtedly raised awareness and helped others. I’m certainly not prepared to criticise someone who is suffering for doing anything to get them through.

I actually really dislike the judgement placed on those who choose to be open about these things. If you want to keep it yourself that’s fine, if you want to rant and rave and cry that’s that’s fine, but there is nothing wrong with talking about an illness in an open and dignified way either if it helps.

CornishGem1975 · 07/11/2022 14:14

I totally get that @Madeintowerhamlets ·I hate the narrative around 'they won their hard-fought battle', like those that unfortunately lose their lives to cancer don't fight hard enough?

Taillighttoobright · 07/11/2022 14:13

Another cancer survivor (hopefully) here - and I used to see people’s eyes glaze over. Absolutely agree with you, OP. I now don’t talk about it - it’s just everywhere, yet this gravitas is expected. Yes, it’s sad and is going to fuck up people’s lives, but it’s ubiquitous. There are some really sad cases, though, like the bone cancer that hits young men, and, of course, anything affecting children, but over 50 and with breast cancer? It happens, and it happens a lot.
I think one of the issues is staging. Ductal carcinoma in situ for example - not in the same league as metastasised cancer, but the word “cancer” is still applicable, with all of its potent overtones of tragedy and death. I’ve had people try to “join” me in my journey with survival rates much, much higher than mine, and I just didn’t want to know.
Wanting to shut this thread down is an example of the evocative nature of the word - which is why it sells news, I suppose. People don’t want to accept the reality that many of us find it tedious.

strawberryandcreams · 07/11/2022 14:04

Dame Deborah's campaign has saved my life. I've been taken seriously by doctors even though I'm mid thirties.

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 13:51

BagOfBollocks · 07/11/2022 13:42

It should have been allowed, that's why MNHQ have reflected upon their decision and reinstated it.

For every person this thread doesn't help, there are plenty for whom it will.

Exactly, not everyone will like every thread. Not everyone will find a thread good for them. People may find some threads quite upsetting, but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be here and allowed to stand.

They do help many others.

BagOfBollocks · 07/11/2022 13:42

mumboss1984 · 07/11/2022 13:21

@BagOfBollocks Because I had an email from mumsnet stating it had been taken down because of the amount of complaints. Why should I have to hide something that shouldn’t have been allowed in the first place?

It should have been allowed, that's why MNHQ have reflected upon their decision and reinstated it.

For every person this thread doesn't help, there are plenty for whom it will.

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 13:35

Thanks for posting the explanation @A580Hojas . I think Becky said it well - just because a conversation is difficult doesn't mean it shouldn't be had. I think most people on this thread have tried to express themselves in a considered way.

Madeintowerhamlets · 07/11/2022 13:33

Thanks for reinstating the thread @MNHQ. As @MistressoftheDarkSide said its ironic that people are trying to silence people from voicing their opinion about the narrative around cancer. I have cancer myself & so do many others on this thread so stop telling me that this thread is offensive to me- it isn’t. What’s offensive is a lot of the narrative in the media around cancer- winning/ losing the battle/ being brave & inspirational etc.

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 13:32

A580Hojas · 07/11/2022 13:30

@mumboss1984 this is what HQ said about it on the Site Stuff thread. They advise people to hide the thread if they don't want to read it:

"YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · Today 11:54

Hi again @JenniferBarkley thanks for raising this with us. We've had a retrospective look at the moderation decisions here and agree that we were too hasty in removing the thread. Threads that are 'difficult' (for want of a better word) inevitably draw lots of reports but that shouldn't mean we can't have those discussions.

We can also see that lots of posters with personal experience of cancer were in agreement with the OP and it was emerging as an interesting thread. With that in mind, we've reinstated it now and will leave it to stand provided it stays on track.

Obviously, we encourage everyone to report posts you think break our guidelines - and we're thankful to all who do - but if it's a case of just not liking a thread, do bear in mind you have the option to hide it.

Thanks."

Thank you for sharing that.