Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick to death of hearing about people's cancer

336 replies

MiserableCow2022 · 05/11/2022 17:26

I've name changed for this one because I'm pretty sure I'm going to get massive abuse for it but I'm a regular poster.
What the title says, I am sick to death of everybody and their brothers cancer or other appalling disease being postered up in every magazine and newspaper all of the time with week by week progress of their dying. This morning headline news was another "celeb" and her cancer.
I feel sorry for her, I'm not a monster but that's for her and her family to deal with it isn't headline news.
I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or facebook.
Isn't life just shit enough for everyone now without reading about people's terminal illnesses every single day - it's enough to make you want to just end it all.
I don't find people like bowelbabe inspiring, she is gone and her children are motherless and we all had to watch her dying and shrinking bit by bit, nor do I find Sarah Beany's bald head refreshing or inspiring.
I just wish they could just keep it it to themselves and their families.
Everytime I look at the papers I think it's going to be me next.
When I grew up people with a terminal illness just got on with it and retreated into the bosom of their families to die and I wish they would do that now. That is certainly what I am going to do.
People will be informed of my terminal decline only after I've gone. I have no intention of rubbing their noses in it everyday.
I want to die with dignity away from the public gaze and not drag anyone else down with me.
I think part of the reason people do the public thing is because they are terrified of dying and can't accept it and going public distracts them.
AIBU?

OP posts:
blackheartsgirl · 07/11/2022 17:58

I do get it op to a certain extent.

when dh died from colon cancer last year all that kept popping up was peoples struggles with the same cancer even if they did survive I still found it hard to read and I really just didn’t want to know. I still don’t.

ny mum is pretty I’ll with cancer now and all I can see is more bloody stories popping up.

and they make me worry as well for my own health.

makes me sound silly I know

2bazookas · 07/11/2022 17:42

With your special sensitivity, perhaps you shouldn't focus so much attention on "celebrities" and people you've never met?

Afterfire · 07/11/2022 17:39

augustusglupe · 07/11/2022 16:59

No judgment here OP I know exactly where you're coming from.
I've lost my mum and brother to cancer. My brothers illness was quite obvious and he dealt with it by just being him. Carrying on caring about others and doing his job. He worked until a week before he died I believe. I say that because in the last year before he died he didn't want us, his sisters, to know he was dying. I found out from my nephew one week before he died. He was so quietly brave.
I get pissed off too OP with the 'tell all' brigade.
I admire Vic Wood, Terry and David Bowie for dealing with their illnesses privately. Always thought they were great people when they were here and it turns out, they really were.

That’s a bit unfair. It’s implying they’re better people because they chose to deal with their suffering privately.

BobDear · 07/11/2022 17:38

Social Media has created a Global appetite for over-sharing. What was brave and inspiring 20 year ago - someone with a terminal condition writing a weekly column in a broadsheet - has evolved into a sort of obsession with 'owning your story' and an obligation to share share and share some more.

It's not just cancer - it's all illness.
It's mental health
It's personal tragedy
It's personal stories of abuse

A regular outpouring of things that historically would have been privately discussed between you and a close family member or - at a stretch - a therapist are now public fodder.

It's a bit like Misery Porn/Lit. When the first couple of books were published (I think that 'Child Called It' was one of the early ones) it was considered groundbreaking and seen as something that might help others. Now similar, poorly written books, are being published simply to feed the appetite of people who enjoy reading about misery.

So in many ways, I don't blame the people who are sharing their sad stories, it's become a societal expectation - as though we've all become desensitised and expect mawkish 'no-filter' reports on everything.

OriginalUsername2 · 07/11/2022 17:31

I agree with you. We lost MIL to a very nasty cancer in our home with not enough help. Every time a cancer advert comes on, or yes hearing television employees raising “awareness”, I feel really angry, with a pit of dread in my stomach. I don’t need to be reminded that me and most of the people I know will likely get it and that there’s a magical group of people ready to help.

Mil was one to broadcast her cancer to everyone she met, that was her personality, and it made us very uncomfortable. She didn’t understand “trauma dumping” or “triggering”.

All the talk is geared towards bravery and support. That was not my family’s experience. It was horrific.

Daisychainsx · 07/11/2022 17:20

People deal with things differently, some people keep their illnesses quiet and suffer in silence and some people share it with the world. Neither way is right or wrong or better than the other. If it helps someone in their darkest moments to share their story then... let them?
I get that it's worrying and it's sad, but some of these people are absolute warriors and heroes and have saved multiple lives and raised invaluable research money via their high profile campaigns for cancers and MND. I know if it wasn't for Jade Goody and her campaigns I wouldn't have gone for my smear test when I did.
YABU for being selfish and thinking how their illness makes you feel.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 17:18

Mercurial123 · 07/11/2022 16:46

So we don't talk about it? I live with cancer and a rare gene mutation. That's my life. People in the public talking about their situation doesn't bother me. I can't talk for anyone else.

If appropriate then yes, if it comes up or somebody asks. It isn’t NEVER mention it, but equally it depresses the public to have a never ending stream of awful stories imposed upon them.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 17:16

Shaaameless · 07/11/2022 16:53

‘I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or Facebook’.

You just did OP.

No, that’s not fair. She’s making the point that she isn’t saying what she’s saying from a place of zero suffering. It’s relevant to her point.

augustusglupe · 07/11/2022 16:59

No judgment here OP I know exactly where you're coming from.
I've lost my mum and brother to cancer. My brothers illness was quite obvious and he dealt with it by just being him. Carrying on caring about others and doing his job. He worked until a week before he died I believe. I say that because in the last year before he died he didn't want us, his sisters, to know he was dying. I found out from my nephew one week before he died. He was so quietly brave.
I get pissed off too OP with the 'tell all' brigade.
I admire Vic Wood, Terry and David Bowie for dealing with their illnesses privately. Always thought they were great people when they were here and it turns out, they really were.

Shaaameless · 07/11/2022 16:53

‘I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or Facebook’.

You just did OP.

Mercurial123 · 07/11/2022 16:46

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 14:49

@Mercurial123 but to what extent? Awareness can easily become anxiety if we go on about it too much.

So we don't talk about it? I live with cancer and a rare gene mutation. That's my life. People in the public talking about their situation doesn't bother me. I can't talk for anyone else.

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 16:38

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 16:26

Er, no if you read my post you'll see that I do think it op has the right to express her thoughts. Which I find incredibly selfish. Got it?

Then if she has a right to express it, why the name calling?

Why is it ‘abhorrent’?

Saying ‘someone can say something, but I will name call and bully into silence’ isn’t accepting someone may have a different view from you and should be able to express it.

You can disagree without that. That’s what I was saying. Name calling because you don’t like someone’s opinion, is the same traits you slated the op for having.

Have you got it?

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 16:37

CandyPiglet · 07/11/2022 15:51

Lots of casual ableism on this thread. Lots of people who think the very existence of disabled and sick people is distasteful, and they shouldn't be allowed to be visibly present in their own lives, lest their very existence hurt the feelings of the well.

Remember that scene in The Beach, where Tilda Swindon puts the dying man in a shed outside because his dying is putting a dampener on the party? It's like a whole thread of that.

I am a young person living with cancer. I feel that I have no choice but to keep the information as quiet as possible, because I have young children and my priority has to be controlling the spread of information in case they hear something that they aren't ready to from someone else. It's incredibly lonely, and I cry most days.

That's truly shit Candy. I'm very sorry that you haven't had the real life support you deserve.

I can't speak for OP, but I'll say that I have zero objection to "real" people sharing whatever they want about their health with other "real" people, and have been supportive to friends and family members when they have been ill (as of course is right).

I'm talking about media coverage and social media algorithms I guess. I've posted above about having a family member with cancer at the same time as Jade Goody and the issues that caused us. Similarly, I get a lot of "Local City News Live: Local Dad With Stage 4 Cancer Shares..." something, and it's a terrible story that will be devastating for his family but, well, bad things happening to good people isn't exactly news is it.

Like most people I've been bereaved by cancer, including a parent whose cancer was hereditary. I've only recently tested negative so have spent most of my life expecting to get cancer multiple times from a relatively young age. I don't think cancer or any other illness should be hushed or stigmatized. But what many of us are talking about goes far beyond that.

I'm struggling to express myself here, so I hope you can take my posts in good faith.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 07/11/2022 16:37

You have made some really valid points.
It took my smear test results no less than three months to come back. Thankfully, all clear. However I remember reading an article about how a radio DJ has been diagnosed with CC and she put off her smear and it ended up being 5 years between tests and now she has it. I didn't get mine for 5 years due to lockdowns and back log (it was due v early lockdown) and during that same lost three babies (sb and 2 mcs) and I started to really panic about what my poor DH will do without me. I know that's a leap, but I get where you're coming from re too much hearing about illness and death.

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 16:26

Ekátn · 07/11/2022 15:40

And yet you believe because you think one way everyone else should also. That Op and others shouldn’t be allowed to express something because you feel they shouldn’t. Isn’t that self absorbed and entitled? You feel entitled to not see and read a view like the ops? You are expecting not to be touched by something (the ops opinion) you find unpleasant and retaliate by name calling.

The vast majority of people are not expecting to never see anything. But the amount of it can be overwhelming. In the thread there has been examples amid all the places people have been confronted by it. And it’s difficult for some.

Like I said, I don’t agree with the Op that we should go back to hiding death, but I think there could be a better happy medium. I can understand how someone in ops position, being bombarded by certain things ends up feeling at the end of their tether with it.

My mum died last year. not of cancer, though (as I said at the beginning) my aunt did die of cancer. What my mum died of pops up every so often. Not very much so it’s easy to navigate away from. But certain illnesses are not that easy to navigate away from. It’s been an awful year, I can imagine if it was everywhere I looked, I might be feeling pretty angry about it.

Er, no if you read my post you'll see that I do think it op has the right to express her thoughts. Which I find incredibly selfish. Got it?

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 16:23

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 16:12

But to try to shame people who are suffering into silence is completely unacceptable.

But Hello magazine and Instagram aren’t really therapy are there? There are specific support groups, online forums, friends and family for that. Nobody’s asking anyone to suffer in silence, maybe just to seek that support from the right places.

So now people with cancer can't speak about it unless it's in a therapy context? They don't have free speech where they can talk just because they want to because they're just seeking support?! Did it ever occur to you that everyone speaks to be heard and we don't suggest they save all their words for the therapist?

If that's the state of play, why didn't the op tell her therapist about this instead of staying a thread about it.

Even if they were expressing themselves and finding a response to be of therapeutic value, why would that be 'the wrong place' to speak, exactly? Do you think humans exist in a vacuum? Would you prefer we only heard from other human beings if they confine their remarks to lip gloss and the cost of living? Or is the cost of living too heavy and only suitable for a therapy session too? Where do you draw the line?

Shall we make it de rigor to mention babies in public because some of us can't have children?

MissyB1 · 07/11/2022 16:17

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 16:12

But to try to shame people who are suffering into silence is completely unacceptable.

But Hello magazine and Instagram aren’t really therapy are there? There are specific support groups, online forums, friends and family for that. Nobody’s asking anyone to suffer in silence, maybe just to seek that support from the right places.

Who are you to say where people with cancer are allowed to seek support?

Handy tip, don't buy magazines if you don't ike whats in them, and there's no law saying you have to be on instagram.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/11/2022 16:12

But to try to shame people who are suffering into silence is completely unacceptable.

But Hello magazine and Instagram aren’t really therapy are there? There are specific support groups, online forums, friends and family for that. Nobody’s asking anyone to suffer in silence, maybe just to seek that support from the right places.

T1mumtobe · 07/11/2022 16:08

CandyPiglet · 07/11/2022 15:51

Lots of casual ableism on this thread. Lots of people who think the very existence of disabled and sick people is distasteful, and they shouldn't be allowed to be visibly present in their own lives, lest their very existence hurt the feelings of the well.

Remember that scene in The Beach, where Tilda Swindon puts the dying man in a shed outside because his dying is putting a dampener on the party? It's like a whole thread of that.

I am a young person living with cancer. I feel that I have no choice but to keep the information as quiet as possible, because I have young children and my priority has to be controlling the spread of information in case they hear something that they aren't ready to from someone else. It's incredibly lonely, and I cry most days.

You have summed up this thread perfectly. And I am so sorry about what you are going through and that it is so isolating.

TerraNostra · 07/11/2022 16:07

My work internet browser defaulted to a horrendous clickbaity Microsoft 365 "news" page that was full of stories about cancer (Deborah James featured heavily), murders, violence etc. It took a formal complaint to HR for them to change the central settings so it was not shoved in everyone's faces every time they had to use the internet for work.

I don't mind people talking publicly about their illnesses, but I do mind when I am not given the option to avoid that sort of content. I can do it easily enough in my private life. For me this is self-preservation due to my own family history and associated health anxiety.

T1mumtobe · 07/11/2022 16:04

Mummbles · 05/11/2022 19:33

You don't think that people who are terminally ill should be allowed to talk about it because you, a complete stranger, might get upset? And somehow people are actually agreeing with you?!

YABU. This is one of the most unbelievably unreasonably things I have ever read. I cannot believe a single person has agreed with you let alone the majority. I'm undergoing investigations for cancer right now and I am absolutely devastated that MAJORITY of people on this forum think I shouldn't talk about it publicly because they might get sad that cancer exists!! What the actual fuck?!

If you don't like it then don't do it yourself. Other people are entitled to try and make their own terminal illness slightly better to deal with without putting you, a complete and total (utterly self-absorbed) stranger as their highest priority. The whole world doesn't revolve around you OP.

Not to mention, talking about it actually raises awareness for people to get checked and money for research so more people are cured and/or live longer. So, it literally saves lives but you'd rather people die because it makes you sad otherwise? Absolutely insane!

Again, completely agree with Mumbles.

How unbelievably ableist to want people who are suffering to do so silently so that you don't have to hear/think about it! You have the option to turn away, the person living with it doesn't.

And I hate this commonly held attitude of anyone sharing their difficulties online is 'attention-seeking'. So what it they are - maybe they have noone in their life that they can open up to? When people say they never saw it coming after someone committed suicide, or how sad that they felt they couldn't open up, it always enrages me because so often when people do ask for help or talk about their pain, they are met with judgemental responses about how attention-seeking they are being.

There is nothing wrong with not being the one to support when someone is suffering, compassion fatigue is really hard and you deserve to put yourself first. But to try to shame people who are suffering into silence is completely unacceptable.

FlorenceOrTheMachine · 07/11/2022 15:58

@CandyPiglet That's really awful. When I became ill (but not diagnosed) I quickly realised that most people don't want to know if you're not well, and in some cases effectively ghosted me. I don't bother telling anyone now, and have no idea how to answer the "how are you" queries. Your comment about it being lonely is so true.

SandAndSea · 07/11/2022 15:58

I think we're all expected to be terrified of life these days. Best to turn the TV etc off.

BagOfBollocks · 07/11/2022 15:57

CandyPiglet · 07/11/2022 15:51

Lots of casual ableism on this thread. Lots of people who think the very existence of disabled and sick people is distasteful, and they shouldn't be allowed to be visibly present in their own lives, lest their very existence hurt the feelings of the well.

Remember that scene in The Beach, where Tilda Swindon puts the dying man in a shed outside because his dying is putting a dampener on the party? It's like a whole thread of that.

I am a young person living with cancer. I feel that I have no choice but to keep the information as quiet as possible, because I have young children and my priority has to be controlling the spread of information in case they hear something that they aren't ready to from someone else. It's incredibly lonely, and I cry most days.

Lots of people who think the very existence of disabled and sick people is distasteful, and they shouldn't be allowed to be visibly present in their own lives, lest their very existence hurt the feelings of the well.

Can you quote any of these posts? I'll admit it's a long thread so it's possible I missed some but I really don't think there's anything like that here?

CandyPiglet · 07/11/2022 15:51

Lots of casual ableism on this thread. Lots of people who think the very existence of disabled and sick people is distasteful, and they shouldn't be allowed to be visibly present in their own lives, lest their very existence hurt the feelings of the well.

Remember that scene in The Beach, where Tilda Swindon puts the dying man in a shed outside because his dying is putting a dampener on the party? It's like a whole thread of that.

I am a young person living with cancer. I feel that I have no choice but to keep the information as quiet as possible, because I have young children and my priority has to be controlling the spread of information in case they hear something that they aren't ready to from someone else. It's incredibly lonely, and I cry most days.