Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick to death of hearing about people's cancer

336 replies

MiserableCow2022 · 05/11/2022 17:26

I've name changed for this one because I'm pretty sure I'm going to get massive abuse for it but I'm a regular poster.
What the title says, I am sick to death of everybody and their brothers cancer or other appalling disease being postered up in every magazine and newspaper all of the time with week by week progress of their dying. This morning headline news was another "celeb" and her cancer.
I feel sorry for her, I'm not a monster but that's for her and her family to deal with it isn't headline news.
I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or facebook.
Isn't life just shit enough for everyone now without reading about people's terminal illnesses every single day - it's enough to make you want to just end it all.
I don't find people like bowelbabe inspiring, she is gone and her children are motherless and we all had to watch her dying and shrinking bit by bit, nor do I find Sarah Beany's bald head refreshing or inspiring.
I just wish they could just keep it it to themselves and their families.
Everytime I look at the papers I think it's going to be me next.
When I grew up people with a terminal illness just got on with it and retreated into the bosom of their families to die and I wish they would do that now. That is certainly what I am going to do.
People will be informed of my terminal decline only after I've gone. I have no intention of rubbing their noses in it everyday.
I want to die with dignity away from the public gaze and not drag anyone else down with me.
I think part of the reason people do the public thing is because they are terrified of dying and can't accept it and going public distracts them.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 08/11/2022 10:31

@MothralovesGojira

There are plenty of celebs who do deal with it all quietly (Andy Taylor for one) and I can only applaud them.

Olivia Newton John didn't want people to know - she didn't even tell her own daughter! Unfortunately, a member of staff at the hospital leaked it to the media and ONJ was given an ultimatum to either make it public herself or the media would report it anyway and she'd have no control over what they reported! She ended up giving a press release and then effectively "disappeared" from public life for the duration of her treatment and early stages of recovery. Even after it was all over the media, she still didn't tell her daughter until quite some time afterwards when she moved back to Australia for convalescence and sent her daughter to a local school, where of course, they knew all about it as it had been all over the media there!

The second time she had it, ONJ managed to keep a lid on it and only her very closest friends/family knew about it. It never got widely known, the media never got hold of the story. Her close friends/family respected her decision for privacy and there were no leaks!

She spent her final 30 years campaigning to help reduce the suffering of other cancer sufferers and putting her money where her mouth was with setting up her own cancer centre in Melbourne (her home town).

Throughout those years, she did numerous interviews etc where she explained why she didn't want to be seen as a "sufferer" or having had a "battle" with cancer - she coined the phrase "thriver" rather than survivor, and explained how she changed her mindset to be grateful for what she had rather than obsess about the unfairness of it all. Hence the song she wrote and released herself - "Why me? Why NOT me?" She spent every day being grateful she was still alive and making the most of what she had, rather than allowing negativity into her mind!

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 08/11/2022 09:56

bloodyplanes · 07/11/2022 22:48

@Ingrainedagainstthegrain what about that childs dignity and rights to privacy?

Children have their pictures etc on social media all the time. It's a big thing to you if they look a bit different but really there is nothing shameful or embarrassing that should be hidden away any more than the average child (if you disagree with children on sm as standard that isn't the issue). Their parents do not see what you see. They see what is still there-a beautiful child. Everything I said about why they need to share their journey stands but if you're too self absorbed and lacking in empathy to respect why they might need/wish to do that, it's your life. I personally don't have time to waste on you.

ChristmasisRuined · 08/11/2022 00:12

How disgusting Biscuit

Foxhassmellysocks · 07/11/2022 23:28

MoominPants · 05/11/2022 17:49

Well written OP. Articles and adverts are very triggering for so many people.

Yes, triggering is a good way to put it.

I feel the same way about miscarriage. It's something that women shouldn't be ashamed of or have to hide. And yet, I bloody detest being blindsided by it in films and TV series.

snowspider · 07/11/2022 23:21

MothralovesGojira · 07/11/2022 18:16

@mumboss1984

You are right - you should take yourself off of this thread and indeed off of MN.
Do you and the others who are fervently agreeing with you actually had cancer?
I have also lost many friends and relatives to cancer and now I am undergoing treatment myself. Come on over to our page in General Health and see our struggles and perhaps you can have the decency to remove the stick from your arse and shut up.
I agree with the OP because

  • I want to be able to go to the cinema like a normal person and not be reminded of cancer by having adverts in my face. I want to lose myself in the wonder of cinema and not be reminded that I also have cancer several times when all I want to do is forget about it for just two f*ing hours.
  • I want to open a nice fluffy ladies mag and not have six pages of cancer stories shoved down my throat. Ok, this may be my bad but if I quickly flick through in the shop and don't spot anything obviously about cancer and then find a surprise story in the middle about cancer then is that my fault.
  • I want to be able to watch tv with my DC and not have them burst into tears suddenly because even though the programme isn't aimed at adults, there is a big f*ing cancer advert jumping up unexpectedly.
  • I want to be able stand at the bus stop and not have a big ass cancer advert staring back at me until the bus comes. Yes, I could walk off a distance but I can't run or walk too quickly back to the stop when the bus comes as I've found to my cost when I have done this.
  • I want to be able to go to the Co-op on a Saturday afternoon and not get upset by 'I've got cancer' celebs on a newspaper front page while I'm bending down to get a TV guide. I don't want to have to explain why they look lovely and healthy and I don't want to feel shit about myself because no one I know with cancer looks like Ms Beeny. I look like death warmed up most of the time.
  • With regards to the likes of the Ms Beeny interview: money makes the cancer journey so much easier when you have it (her lovely talk of tattooed eyebrows really rubbed it in because that is super expensive) and celebs can mostly choose whether to work - it just rubs it in. I'm back at work because my sick pay ran out and not through choice and it is killing me and wrecking my health.

So there it is. The OP isn't actually saying that all cancer suffers should shuffle off and die in a corner quietly. What they are saying is that our journey is horrible and undignified and that we shouldn't have this constantly shoved down our throats by advertising for funds and celebs who use the media to keep their profiles up. There are plenty of celebs who do deal with it all quietly (Andy Taylor for one) and I can only applaud them. I and others deal with our cancer reality every day so what should I do? Not leave the house, not watch tv, not read magazines? I do skim/ignore the cancer stories in mags and I do not do any social media but I've not had a single day where I have not been reminded that I have cancer. I have told very few people that I have cancer and have endured/processed in private. Tomorrow I get to find out whether I am dying. If I am then I want to do that quietly and in dignity.

this resonates with me

Taradiddled · 07/11/2022 23:12

Runningwithoutstopping · 07/11/2022 23:11

It's well known fact that if all cancer sufferers just stayed positive and didn't 'wallow' they would be fine.

Indeed. While ‘bravely battling’, obviously.

Taradiddled · 07/11/2022 23:12

user1497207191 · 07/11/2022 22:55

Olivia Newton John was inspirational in the way she handled it over 30 years. She didn’t wallow, she stayed positive and found ways of turning a negative into a positive, particularly by founding and raising tens of millions for her cancer research and wellness centre, which she was heavily involved with. We never got the “pity me” photos in the media - she kept out of the limelight during her treatments and until she was well again.

But why should anyone feel the need to adopt a ‘mustn’t wallow’ and ‘staying out of the public view while visibly ill’ if they don’t want to? If I were dealing with a serious illness, the last thing that would benefit me is behaving according someone else’s idea of ‘staying positive’ and ‘turning a negative into a positive’. It sounds as if you want people to tidy away the unpalatable side of dealing with a bad diagnosis.

Runningwithoutstopping · 07/11/2022 23:11

It's well known fact that if all cancer sufferers just stayed positive and didn't 'wallow' they would be fine.

Runningwithoutstopping · 07/11/2022 23:07

When I received my diagnosis I felt deeply ashamed of my body I hid away from the world and felt guilty about the effect that my illness would have on others. Luckily I found that there were others that had shared their story to help others .
I listened to Deborah James along with Rachel Bland and Lauren Mahon on you, me and the big 'C' who spoke about their illnesses in all its shitty 'glory'. Slowly overtime I learnt that I didn't need to hide away that I wasn't just on a fast track to death and living well with cancer was possible.
I don't see myself as a warrior,a fighter or resilient or any of the other of the labels that get tossed our way but I'm not going to live in silence because it makes others feel awkward if my speaking up helps then I'll keep on talking

user1497207191 · 07/11/2022 22:55

Olivia Newton John was inspirational in the way she handled it over 30 years. She didn’t wallow, she stayed positive and found ways of turning a negative into a positive, particularly by founding and raising tens of millions for her cancer research and wellness centre, which she was heavily involved with. We never got the “pity me” photos in the media - she kept out of the limelight during her treatments and until she was well again.

bloodyplanes · 07/11/2022 22:48

@Ingrainedagainstthegrain what about that childs dignity and rights to privacy?

Towcat15 · 07/11/2022 22:36

Evidence wtf? I knew her you prick she was a friend.

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 22:34

Towcat15 · 07/11/2022 22:28

@Ingrainedagainstthegrain oh I’m sorry did you know her? Because I did.

And what evidence did you have that she felt under pressure to do something she didn't want to do? Or was it just you that found it a bit pathetic and projected?

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 22:32

bloodyplanes · 07/11/2022 21:25

I don't so much mind adults who do this but there is so many fb and insta pages set up by parents about their children who are suffering with cancer! I absolutely detest these! These children can't/ are not old enough to give consent to the whole world seeing how ill they are and the effects treatment has had on them! Its so so narcissistic and attention seeking of the parents!

Whatever they need to do to get them through the day. I can't believe you're criticising a parent sharing their experience of hell. They can do without judgement. Fortunately they gain a lot of support and sometimes much needed practical help. One way in which the internet has made the world a kinder place. If you can't say get well soon, scroll on.

It's like compassion doesn't even occur as a potential response.

When you're losing everything and the light of your life is fading from the world, there is a frantic desire to sing the beauty of your child from the rooftops so everyone will know they lived. It's not hard to understand. The star of catastrophe recently wrote a book explaining this excellently which was quite rightly heralded as an important book. Not everyone can manage a book so a social media post is their way. Your position is grounded in judgement and ignorance.

Towcat15 · 07/11/2022 22:28

@Ingrainedagainstthegrain oh I’m sorry did you know her? Because I did.

bluewanda · 07/11/2022 22:25

Thanks @JenniferBarkley . I personally think it’s a disgraceful decision and still don’t understand why @MNHQ didn’t post that explanation on THIS thread.

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 07/11/2022 22:25

Towcat15 · 07/11/2022 21:52

It’s putting pressure on those diagnosed with a serious/ terminal illness to be publicly brave and be a big popular personality too - a lady in our village got given 6 months to live and instead of spending that time with her family she tried to become a local celebrity, doing a public head shave in the middle of the square and only 4 people turned up, then tried to do a crowd funder to send her kids to Disney world and only raised £150.

for every bowel babe there is someone who fails to take the limelight but has no less of a fight to give.

That's the most ridiculous reason yet. The lady in your village did what she wanted to do. As is her right. I doubt she felt peer pressure, I really do.

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 22:21

bluewanda · 07/11/2022 22:14

I’ve now read the first two and last two pages of this thread, which I find incredibly offensive and upsetting. I still can’t find any explanation why such a nasty thread has been allowed to stand. Perhaps you should post your explanation on THIS thread @MNHQ as opposed to another one? Why should people have to wade through a load of posts that they might not want to read? I didn’t think TAAT were allowed on this site.

Fine, you don't want to click the link I gave you. Here is the explanation, copied and pasted:

"YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · Today 11:54
Hi again @JenniferBarkley thanks for raising this with us. We've had a retrospective look at the moderation decisions here and agree that we were too hasty in removing the thread. Threads that are 'difficult' (for want of a better word) inevitably draw lots of reports but that shouldn't mean we can't have those discussions.
We can also see that lots of posters with personal experience of cancer were in agreement with the OP and it was emerging as an interesting thread. With that in mind, we've reinstated it now and will leave it to stand provided it stays on track.
Obviously, we encourage everyone to report posts you think break our guidelines - and we're thankful to all who do - but if it's a case of just not liking a thread, do bear in mind you have the option to hide it.
Thanks."

Needsomeadvice33 · 07/11/2022 22:15

I 100% agree with you OP. We are all going to have to deal with horrible things its part of life. 1 in 2 people get cancer. I hate the ads on TV. We don't need it shoved down our face at every opportunity. I agree the misery/ grief of cancer is for the person dealing with it and their families. We are all going to have to deal with it at some point either ourselves or close family. We don't need strangers grief rammed down our throats.

bluewanda · 07/11/2022 22:14

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 22:09

They've explained their reasoning in detail on another thread, and that's been both posted and linked here.

I’ve now read the first two and last two pages of this thread, which I find incredibly offensive and upsetting. I still can’t find any explanation why such a nasty thread has been allowed to stand. Perhaps you should post your explanation on THIS thread @MNHQ as opposed to another one? Why should people have to wade through a load of posts that they might not want to read? I didn’t think TAAT were allowed on this site.

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 22:09

bluewanda · 07/11/2022 22:03

Have @MNHQ commented on this thread? Because I can’t see anything? I can’t believe it’s allowed to stand, awful.

They've explained their reasoning in detail on another thread, and that's been both posted and linked here.

A580Hojas · 07/11/2022 22:05

Again bluewanda you only need to read back for a few minutes. The explanation is on this thread. If you are going to participate on a thread it makes sense to read it?

bluewanda · 07/11/2022 22:03

JenniferBarkley · 07/11/2022 19:57

The quote is posted above or you could read this thread in site stuff.

Have @MNHQ commented on this thread? Because I can’t see anything? I can’t believe it’s allowed to stand, awful.

bluewanda · 07/11/2022 21:59

A580Hojas · 07/11/2022 19:51

@bluewanda all you need to do is read through the thread for a few minutes.

I did read a few pages of it yesterday and thought it was utterly vile. I was actually writing a reply yesterday too, expressing something along those lines, but when I posted I was alerted that the thread had been deleted. Why is it back up?

Towcat15 · 07/11/2022 21:52

It’s putting pressure on those diagnosed with a serious/ terminal illness to be publicly brave and be a big popular personality too - a lady in our village got given 6 months to live and instead of spending that time with her family she tried to become a local celebrity, doing a public head shave in the middle of the square and only 4 people turned up, then tried to do a crowd funder to send her kids to Disney world and only raised £150.

for every bowel babe there is someone who fails to take the limelight but has no less of a fight to give.