Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick to death of hearing about people's cancer

336 replies

MiserableCow2022 · 05/11/2022 17:26

I've name changed for this one because I'm pretty sure I'm going to get massive abuse for it but I'm a regular poster.
What the title says, I am sick to death of everybody and their brothers cancer or other appalling disease being postered up in every magazine and newspaper all of the time with week by week progress of their dying. This morning headline news was another "celeb" and her cancer.
I feel sorry for her, I'm not a monster but that's for her and her family to deal with it isn't headline news.
I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or facebook.
Isn't life just shit enough for everyone now without reading about people's terminal illnesses every single day - it's enough to make you want to just end it all.
I don't find people like bowelbabe inspiring, she is gone and her children are motherless and we all had to watch her dying and shrinking bit by bit, nor do I find Sarah Beany's bald head refreshing or inspiring.
I just wish they could just keep it it to themselves and their families.
Everytime I look at the papers I think it's going to be me next.
When I grew up people with a terminal illness just got on with it and retreated into the bosom of their families to die and I wish they would do that now. That is certainly what I am going to do.
People will be informed of my terminal decline only after I've gone. I have no intention of rubbing their noses in it everyday.
I want to die with dignity away from the public gaze and not drag anyone else down with me.
I think part of the reason people do the public thing is because they are terrified of dying and can't accept it and going public distracts them.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Bunsandtophats · 05/11/2022 18:10

I agree with you OP. It's very much about 'me' culture attention seeking typical celebrity behaviour when most others just get on with it away from the spotlight. Others don't have such a platform or just don't think they're any more important than anyone else!

Waitingfordecember · 05/11/2022 18:10

I think I half agree with you (and definitely see where you’re coming from).

I don’t want to see and hear about lots of peoples’ terminal illnesses. It’s upsetting, brings back awful memories of losing loved ones, and sets off my health anxiety. But equally people deal with things in different ways and I don’t think we can expect people not to share if they find it helpful in some way.

And as much as I hate seeing and hearing about it, raising awareness can help others seek help quicker. That’s got to be a good thing.

It’s tricky.

MadameDe · 05/11/2022 18:10

OP, your post was really well articulated and I kind of agree. However, I think it's fair enough if people want to share their experiences as I know some people find it helpful. Personally, I never got into Deborah James' cancer (I refuse to call her bowel babe). I don't want to see someone dying or read about it. I find it a bit weird and voyeuristic.

MissFancyDay · 05/11/2022 18:10

I agree, I do think that everyone should deal with their illnesses and tragedies in whatever way they have to but I do think accounts like Bowel babes attract a certain amount of ghouls and rubbernecking.

And all the accounts which have jumped on the singing and dancing in the hospital bandwagon. I always feel for the other patients who must just want some peace and quiet.

KiwiInTraining · 05/11/2022 18:09

In the case of Bowelbabe (I don’t know much about other public figures who’ve had cancer) I did find her inspiring because she worked so hard to raise awareness of bowel cancer, and she also raised a huge amount of money for cancer research. She was lucky to have a very privileged life, which meant she could afford treatments that sadly others can’t (this is all in the public domain), but she did acknowledge this, and for that, I find her inspiring. I recently bought the book she wrote just before she died, and it’s helped me a great deal (it’s about how to respond to challenges you face in life, essentially).

Kite22 · 05/11/2022 18:08

ldontWanna · 05/11/2022 17:36

YANBU to want to do it differently yourself.
You're also NU to not want to see it /read it.

However, you can't dictate how others deal with their illnesses or grief. If they choose to publicise it on whatever platform,for whatever reason that is their right and choice. You can choose not to read it.

Other people might be inspired by it, might find comfort ,solace,hope or support in it.

This, and what @Taradiddled and a couple of others said.

I haven't heard of the blog or story you are talking about. I know who Sarah Beeny is but knew nothing of her cancer. etc etc. So, if you don't want to read their stories, you clearly don't have to. Some people do though. You opt in if you want to, so YABU to complain as you don't have to.

viques · 05/11/2022 18:07

1000yellowdaisies · 05/11/2022 17:32

In some ways i do agree with you, it always seems the case that when ever a celebrity is ill they do multiple interviews about it often under the banner of 'raising awareness' what ever that means...
But honestly its not something that bothers me its probably quite therapeutic for some people to talk about their illnesses. I remember when Chadwick Boseman died thinking how sad it was and how sad that he'd kept it secret, but that was obviously his wish.
Everyone handles it differently e.g.. I've had a miscarriage and no one knows in real life only talked about it on mm.

Victoria Wood another one, who kept her illness to herself. There is a huge difference between telling close friends and family and getting their love and support and letting the world and his nosy dog in on your diagnosis and treatment. However I almost understand the feeling that if you are in the public eye your health issues could be outed so getting your story out first might be a tactic, but Victoria and Chadwick showed that it is possible to keep your privacy.

Googlecanthelpme · 05/11/2022 18:06

I think you are both YABU and also YANBU

Probably what others have said but one, it helps to highlight symptoms. It helps to raise awareness of the lack of funding, the failures in our healthcare system. It helps people to feel less alone in their own shit, feel less alone in their dying or their grief at others dying.
Ive never felt more alone than during a period of traumatic grief, it didn’t personally help me seeing others talking about it - but it might help others. I am a bit like you that I keep my emotions and feelings private.
But i don’t see that others sharing is a bad thing.

However I do agree that everywhere you look there is cancer, terminal illness, death, grief. It is trotted out online (instagram mostly) almost to the point you absolutely cannot avoid it.
I made the mistake of reading a post about a child with terminal cancer and now my algorithm is just sending me post after post of the same stuff.
I was sobbing just the other day over a story of a young baby who died following a very rare genetic diagnosis.

Its too much for me sometimes and I imagine I’m not alone in feeling that.

But then I don’t expect them to keep their grief private.

it’s a difficult one.

Mischance · 05/11/2022 18:03

I hear what you are saying. It is difficult, as one bit of me thinks that each individual needs to deal with it in their own way, and some will find comfort in sharing - others won't. And sometimes good comes from these stories as it stimulates donations for research and care. However when it comes to celebrities I do think that the media is often driving the agenda and it might not be entirely what the person wants.

My OH died of PD and people think that I am dying to hear about their relatives who have been diagnosed with the same - they are wrong!

BagOfBollocks · 05/11/2022 18:02

Never has the phrase 'You do you' been more apt.

EsmaCannonball · 05/11/2022 17:58

Yes, I don't think I'll or dying people should be silenced or hidden away but I know people with cancer or life-changing or limiting conditions who would like some mental space and respite from their situation. People want a bit of escape. In general, with the media relying on doom-and-panic clickbait articles and modern popular culture being either censorious, mawkish or consciousness-raising, I think we've forgotten the benefit of cheering people up. I'm not sure that being constantly hammered over the head with issues has been good for the population's mental health.

Taradiddled · 05/11/2022 17:58

ILL people.

Taradiddled · 05/11/2022 17:57

Yanbu to make different choices yourself, obviously, but you don’t get to control other I’ll people’s decisions. Also, shouldn’t you change your media sources if you’re finding celebrity cancer stories distressing? I never come across these stories — I read the Guardian and the Irish Times daily, don’t use FB, watch BBC/RTE/Channel4/ Al Jazeera news — and I’d never heard of bowelbabe. I assume they’re avoidable because I’m clearly avoiding them.

Afterfire · 05/11/2022 17:57

I’m not sure really.

If the increased awareness means more money for research and cancer charities then that’s a good thing.

tickticksnooze · 05/11/2022 17:56

How exactly are people supposed to avoid traumatic stories that are plastered all over the front pages of news outlets? Withdraw from society?

Not just people with cancer but those living with trauma either from surviving it or losing a loved one to it?

Significant numbers of people are living with trauma caused by cancer, they are not fucking collateral damage for bullshit "awareness raising". Those news stories are there to satisfy voyeurism not charitable.

glassfully · 05/11/2022 17:54

I saw a strange one on our work intranet the other week. A colleague in her early 30s who joined a few months posted a selfie and a long message that opened with "I think it's really important that we tackle the stigma around cancer. 15 years ago I was diagnosed with lymphoma". WHAT STIGMA? just post your selfie and announce that you want everyone to know you had cancer before.

Madeintowerhamlets · 05/11/2022 17:53

I do get it OP and I have stage 4 cancer myself. For every Deborah James there is someone like me just quietly getting on with it. I don’t use social media & don’t fundraise for cancer charities. I prefer to switch off from it all! I do appreciate that everyone is different though.

ScreamingBeans · 05/11/2022 17:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

tickticksnooze · 05/11/2022 17:53

I tend to agree.

I find it grossly disrespectful to the vast majority of people with a terminal diagnosis who are distressed and traumatised by it rather than "positive and inspirational".

It's not normal to paint on an upbeat smile about dying and I think the media narrative that the only dying people of value are the fake happy ones is obscene.

I spent one of the COVID lockdowns in hospital on a ward with a woman forced to die alone because of the restrictions - she was no less brave or deserving of compassion for having been unspeakably distressed by the situation. She was loved and her life mattered too.

ReturnOfTheMacdonalds · 05/11/2022 17:52

I get where you are coming from, I have cancer and I hate hearing about cancer constantly on tv. I want to think of other things. However, cancer charities do well from this sort of thing raising awareness etc.

Erictheavocado · 05/11/2022 17:52

I agree. Someone close to me has recently been diagnosed with cancer and their first thought was of the celebrity who had a very public battle with the same cancer and sadly died. They assumed that they would have the same journey. Thankfully, their out one is different, but they assumed the worst because of the daily updates on the celebrity.
I had the greatest admiration for David Bowie, Terry Wogan, Victoria Wood and a few others who kept their final illnesses to themselves and their families.

Prescottdanni123 · 05/11/2022 17:51

You do realize that bowelbabe no doubt saved lives with her efforts to get people talking about poo and other bowel issues. You honestly want people like her to stop talking publicly about cancer? Especially when she is doing amazing work like that in the process?

If you don't like hearing it then that is fine. I get it. When you are already feeling low, depressing topics make it worse. But I don't think the solution is to stop mentioning it. I think you maybe need to stop reading these stories or keep off news sites all together if you are finding it difficult.

PauliesWalnuts · 05/11/2022 17:50

I also felt very uncomfortable with the BowelBabe thing - there’s a lot of cancer in my family, we don’t get better from it, and we just get on with things until we die. But we’re not in the public eye, and I can understand a need to want to control how your image/profile is seen by the public on your terms, rather than being papped when you look and feel like shit, as @Geepee71 posted upthread.

MoominPants · 05/11/2022 17:49

Well written OP. Articles and adverts are very triggering for so many people.

Kleptronic · 05/11/2022 17:49

I think a lot of them are doing it to get money for their families for after they've gone, which I understand. But yes, I cannot be doing with it either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread