Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick to death of hearing about people's cancer

336 replies

MiserableCow2022 · 05/11/2022 17:26

I've name changed for this one because I'm pretty sure I'm going to get massive abuse for it but I'm a regular poster.
What the title says, I am sick to death of everybody and their brothers cancer or other appalling disease being postered up in every magazine and newspaper all of the time with week by week progress of their dying. This morning headline news was another "celeb" and her cancer.
I feel sorry for her, I'm not a monster but that's for her and her family to deal with it isn't headline news.
I've had a terrible sad life with lots of abuse and illness and I've lost no less than 9 lovely people who were very close to me over the last three years so I've had loads of grief too on top of my own health problems which I choose not to broadcast to the nation or go on about on mumsnet or facebook.
Isn't life just shit enough for everyone now without reading about people's terminal illnesses every single day - it's enough to make you want to just end it all.
I don't find people like bowelbabe inspiring, she is gone and her children are motherless and we all had to watch her dying and shrinking bit by bit, nor do I find Sarah Beany's bald head refreshing or inspiring.
I just wish they could just keep it it to themselves and their families.
Everytime I look at the papers I think it's going to be me next.
When I grew up people with a terminal illness just got on with it and retreated into the bosom of their families to die and I wish they would do that now. That is certainly what I am going to do.
People will be informed of my terminal decline only after I've gone. I have no intention of rubbing their noses in it everyday.
I want to die with dignity away from the public gaze and not drag anyone else down with me.
I think part of the reason people do the public thing is because they are terrified of dying and can't accept it and going public distracts them.
AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 16/12/2022 21:36

PauliesWalnuts · 05/11/2022 17:50

I also felt very uncomfortable with the BowelBabe thing - there’s a lot of cancer in my family, we don’t get better from it, and we just get on with things until we die. But we’re not in the public eye, and I can understand a need to want to control how your image/profile is seen by the public on your terms, rather than being papped when you look and feel like shit, as @Geepee71 posted upthread.

Bowel babe did a huge amount for awareness of ca bowel and also raised miliions for charity.

I'm sure lots of folk are alive today because of her

CharlotteRose90 · 16/12/2022 21:09

If people don’t want to talk about it then that’s up to them. Cancer isn’t going away and needs to be spoken about. It isn’t a bed of roses. My mums had skin cancer twice and I’ve had a blood one . I also have a very high chance of Bowel cancer thanks to the condition i have. Bowel babe and others openly talking about it should be cherished, it’s normal life stuff. You can’t run from it. If it makes you uncomfortable then you need to look into why.

user1497207191 · 16/12/2022 20:40

FlorenceOrTheMachine · 16/12/2022 20:05

That's the thing though - she "kept it quiet over 30 years" - no intentions of dissing her in the slightest, but she didn't keep it quiet (why should she) - it was openly known about. But what I want to focus on is the "30 years bit". At the risk of playing an unseemly game of "cancer top trumps", it might be that a key difference here is those who have (horrible as they are) cancers with "good" prognosis, and those that don't. The latter, with a more immediate need to come to terms with their mortality probably have different needs to the former. In my case I tested the water by confiding to a few friends that I had a potentially serious blood cancer. They clearly felt uncomfortable with that, and have "ghosted" me. I don't necessarily blame them; I might feel the same if I was a healthy person in their shoes.

Since then, I've received results of genetic tests that suggest the course the disease I have might take. The phrase "poor prognosis mutation" isn't one you really want to hear in relation to a blood cancer. I don't have an extensive support network, and have burned through a fair proportion of my few friends with the initial communication of a cancer of any sort I can kind of imagine what the result will be if I break the news to the remaining ones that not only do I have a cancer, but the median survival time is 8 months (I'm well below the average diagnosis age so hope to beat that somewhat). So I'm left either (a) opening up and facing it alone as what few remaining friends abandon me, or (b) pretending to them it's not happening as long as I can. Whichever, it sucks.

I think you've misread my post. I never said she kept it quiet over 30 years!

FlorenceOrTheMachine · 16/12/2022 20:05

user1497207191 · 07/11/2022 22:55

Olivia Newton John was inspirational in the way she handled it over 30 years. She didn’t wallow, she stayed positive and found ways of turning a negative into a positive, particularly by founding and raising tens of millions for her cancer research and wellness centre, which she was heavily involved with. We never got the “pity me” photos in the media - she kept out of the limelight during her treatments and until she was well again.

That's the thing though - she "kept it quiet over 30 years" - no intentions of dissing her in the slightest, but she didn't keep it quiet (why should she) - it was openly known about. But what I want to focus on is the "30 years bit". At the risk of playing an unseemly game of "cancer top trumps", it might be that a key difference here is those who have (horrible as they are) cancers with "good" prognosis, and those that don't. The latter, with a more immediate need to come to terms with their mortality probably have different needs to the former. In my case I tested the water by confiding to a few friends that I had a potentially serious blood cancer. They clearly felt uncomfortable with that, and have "ghosted" me. I don't necessarily blame them; I might feel the same if I was a healthy person in their shoes.

Since then, I've received results of genetic tests that suggest the course the disease I have might take. The phrase "poor prognosis mutation" isn't one you really want to hear in relation to a blood cancer. I don't have an extensive support network, and have burned through a fair proportion of my few friends with the initial communication of a cancer of any sort I can kind of imagine what the result will be if I break the news to the remaining ones that not only do I have a cancer, but the median survival time is 8 months (I'm well below the average diagnosis age so hope to beat that somewhat). So I'm left either (a) opening up and facing it alone as what few remaining friends abandon me, or (b) pretending to them it's not happening as long as I can. Whichever, it sucks.

Friendofdennis · 21/11/2022 21:08

I agree with you. Not everyone has to be brave or inspiring

MissyB1 · 21/11/2022 21:00

@FiscalDragQueen do you resent it when friends/aquiantances/colleagues mention having cancer? Or if they mention they are struggling with a loved one's diagnosis? TV adverts are one thing, but cancer is going to touch all our lives wether we would like to avoid the topic or not. Personally I think it's best to educate our kids about the progress being made in cancer treatment, about the importance of research, and not making the word something to be feared. or hidden from.

FiscalDragQueen · 21/11/2022 20:55

On the one hand, I think that people like Bowelbabe encourage people to look out for the signs and go to the doctor, which could save lives.

On the other though, I hate those adverts that say "one out of two of us will get cancer in our lifetime". This has actually scared my children when they have seen this. Children have enough stress these days without having to sit there and worry about half their family getting cancer.

My mum died of cancer when I was a teen. It was awful. I know that I will have to deal with cancer in my family, or myself, at some point in the future. In the meantime, I'd like to go a day without being triggered.

georgarina · 21/11/2022 20:52

FlorenceOrTheMachine · 21/11/2022 20:10

Since getting my diagnosis of a poor prognosis type of blood cancer some months ago, I'm surprised anyone with cancer talks about their condition (other than with close family). I mentioned to one or two friends that I had a cancer (without specifying the exact type, or seriousness) since which my entire network (which admittedly wasn't extensive) seem to be "ghosting" me. I'd quite like to be open and matter of fact about such things (they're a fact of life (and death) ffs) but they still seem to be a taboo. This thread seems to reflect this.

I'm so sorry Florence. Don't listen to this thread, it seems OP is bitter due to her own experiences so doesn't want anyone else to share or receive empathy. It is absolutely your right to be open about what you're going through. Hope you're ok xxx

Benjispruce4 · 21/11/2022 20:13

Sorry to hear that @FlorenceOrTheMachine . People can be so cruel.

FlorenceOrTheMachine · 21/11/2022 20:10

Since getting my diagnosis of a poor prognosis type of blood cancer some months ago, I'm surprised anyone with cancer talks about their condition (other than with close family). I mentioned to one or two friends that I had a cancer (without specifying the exact type, or seriousness) since which my entire network (which admittedly wasn't extensive) seem to be "ghosting" me. I'd quite like to be open and matter of fact about such things (they're a fact of life (and death) ffs) but they still seem to be a taboo. This thread seems to reflect this.

misssunshine4040 · 15/11/2022 07:55

VivienneDelacroix · 15/11/2022 01:13

What I find hard to swallow with it is that it is always white, middle-class people that share their stories. They control the narrative around cancer (and other issues tbh) because they have the time, money, and connections to be able to do that. Lots of people battle through illness quietly in poverty, without media campaigns, and without getting knighted or damehoods - I find it quite jarring to be honest.

Very well said

Baconking · 15/11/2022 07:44

I had never heard of Bowelbabe until after my mum died from bowel cancer.
It wasn't a cancer I was particularly aware of and yet had we known all the symptoms maybe my mum would have lived longer 😔

MissyB1 · 15/11/2022 07:30

I thought about this nasty little thread yesterday when it was in the news about Jonny Irwin having terminal cancer. No doubt there was posters on here who were rolling their eyes, thinking oh there’s another attention seeker just trying to upset us. I actually said to Dh oh this will piss of the mumsnetters who think cancer should be kept quiet.

Januarcelebration · 15/11/2022 04:04

graceinspace999 · 12/11/2022 10:24

I am reading this and am trying to survive two types of cancer. I said in another post that sadly these attitudes don’t surprise me.

I agree with you and am wondering why there is such openness about a lack of empathy/distaste towards those with cancer.

How did we get to be such delicate little flowers?
How did our feelings take such precedence over the feelings of cancer sufferers that we expect them to go and die in a bunker knowing that the majority of people would prefer not to know them...

I totally see what you are saying.

However, many people who have posted that they (somewhat) agree with the Op or feel similar, do have cancer and/or have lost loved ones as well.

I don’t agree they should hide away, like op feels. But the constant reminders are very difficult for people who are suffering or bereaved. It’s not about prioritising people who haven’t cancers feelings over the feelings of those whose lives have been turned upside down by cancer.

VivienneDelacroix · 15/11/2022 01:13

What I find hard to swallow with it is that it is always white, middle-class people that share their stories. They control the narrative around cancer (and other issues tbh) because they have the time, money, and connections to be able to do that. Lots of people battle through illness quietly in poverty, without media campaigns, and without getting knighted or damehoods - I find it quite jarring to be honest.

BirdyWoof · 15/11/2022 00:57

bloodyplanes · 07/11/2022 22:48

@Ingrainedagainstthegrain what about that childs dignity and rights to privacy?

This.

I find a lot of Instagram accounts incredibly uncomfortable nowadays, especially when there is a sick child involved. Post after post of them looking uncomfortable in a hospital bed with every single detail of their illness disclosed in vast detail.

I get that it may be a comfort but I think there’s other ways of getting that comfort than posting photos and dialogue regarding your child when they are at their most vulnerable and have no ability to say no.

I don’t mind adults posting that sort of content as it’s completely their choice.

AutumnalCrow · 15/11/2022 00:25

Bless you all, @blackheartsgirl. I wish you all lots of peace and love. You’ve been through so much.

blackheartsgirl · 14/11/2022 23:50

My dh died very quickly and painfully from undiagnosed colon cancer that had gone into his liver. We married in hospital and I spent my wedding night on 2 chairs pushed together holding his hand and I cried and cried whilst he was asleep.

i am going through the same thing with my mum who also has cancer and caring for her too.

I am beyond devastated, mine and my children’s lives are shattered, my 12 year old dd is suicidal and I’ve developed a heart condition which could end my life.

inam not some some delicate flower who finds cancer distasteful.
im fucking terrified of getting it and leaving my girls alone because they would have to go into care.

I can’t bear to watch cancer adverts, read about cancer or talk about it to anyone because I just feel so panicky. I’m just taken back to that hospital room with the seagulls screaming (hospital bins were right underneath his window) and holding him whilst we both cried with the helplessness of it all.

he died in my arms 2 days later.

im so sorry for all of you going through cancer yourselves. My husband was so scared and brave too. I miss him.

graceinspace999 · 12/11/2022 10:24

Mummbles · 05/11/2022 19:33

You don't think that people who are terminally ill should be allowed to talk about it because you, a complete stranger, might get upset? And somehow people are actually agreeing with you?!

YABU. This is one of the most unbelievably unreasonably things I have ever read. I cannot believe a single person has agreed with you let alone the majority. I'm undergoing investigations for cancer right now and I am absolutely devastated that MAJORITY of people on this forum think I shouldn't talk about it publicly because they might get sad that cancer exists!! What the actual fuck?!

If you don't like it then don't do it yourself. Other people are entitled to try and make their own terminal illness slightly better to deal with without putting you, a complete and total (utterly self-absorbed) stranger as their highest priority. The whole world doesn't revolve around you OP.

Not to mention, talking about it actually raises awareness for people to get checked and money for research so more people are cured and/or live longer. So, it literally saves lives but you'd rather people die because it makes you sad otherwise? Absolutely insane!

I am reading this and am trying to survive two types of cancer. I said in another post that sadly these attitudes don’t surprise me.

I agree with you and am wondering why there is such openness about a lack of empathy/distaste towards those with cancer.

How did we get to be such delicate little flowers?
How did our feelings take such precedence over the feelings of cancer sufferers that we expect them to go and die in a bunker knowing that the majority of people would prefer not to know them...

gogohmm · 08/11/2022 13:14

I think it depends a lot on the individual. If you are in the public eye, most prefer to want to control what information is spread rather than leaks to the press or photos without hair. Sarah Beeny chose to be photographed bald so she didn't have journalists sniffing around and speculating (she's being treated at the same place as a friend in fact).

Yes some do go overboard on the public information but I choose to avoid reading such magazines or articles, not sure who this bowel person is?

Delatron · 08/11/2022 13:12

I just think we all deal with things differently and there’s no right or wrong way.

I agree with you about all the cancer adverts. Especially the Cancer Research one about ‘fighting cancer’ or something that implied you only died if you didn’t fight hard enough. I’ve had breast cancer. I’m alive because I was lucky- not because I was brave or fought hard!

I personally have huge admiration for bowel babe. There is no way on earth I could have gone out and about in a wheelchair to a public event with all the sympathetic looks/publicity . She raised lots of money too. Maybe she saved some lives as people went to get checked out?

But I do agree that many of us want to deal with cancer/death/grief behind closed doors. Therefore I understand when quite often the first you hear about a celebrity’s cancer is when their death is an announced. We’re all different- there’s no right or wrong.

Ingrainedagainstthegrain · 08/11/2022 13:02

mowly77 · 08/11/2022 12:48

Well I've got breast cancer, stage 4, and I just don't know what to make of this thread.

My own mother died of breast cancer in 1985 & she didn't tell anyone; no-one at work; just one close friend & her brother. It was extremely taboo. I am glad it no longer is. I think if celebrities WANT to take control of the narrative, write & talk about it, & be photographed, more power to them. It's part of the big shift in society to cancer NOT being a dirty, shameful secret and I find that personally, for me, comforting. I wish it had been the same for my mum, and she didn't feel she had to keep it secret for fear of being sacked etc. It must have been intensely lonely for her.

The media outing celebrities is shameful. But those who choose to be private such as Olivia Newton John or David Bowie are not morally superior beings to those who have chosen to be open about their illness, which is very much the subtext of the OP & many PP. What a crazy old-fashioned attitude, one that takes suffering in silence way too far. @Mummbles you've made some great points.

You do not have to read salacious websites/magazines etc that publish stories about celebrities with illnesses if you don't want to, as so many PP have said. I appreciate @MothralovesGojira 's point about accidentally seeing the Sarah Beeney pics when buying something in the supermarket though; I haven't seen them, and I haven't sought them out as yeah I look and feel like shit & don't feel there's much to be gained from seeing her tattooed eyebrows or whatever. But she shouldn't have to hide away if she doesn't want to, and she clearly doesn't.

Personally, I feel quite private about my disease. My close friends and family know the details, but I don't especially feel like sharing it with all and sundry -- apart from on here, which is anonymous, and a great source of support for me. Unfortunately, once you lose your hair, you lose your privacy. People still recoil from you, and don't want to meet your eyes, or chat. At my daughter's school there is no doubt I am Cancer Mum. That's awful, that's lonely.

As for death and dying, we are all going to die. It should not be taboo! We have a very, very odd attitude to death in England specifically, unlike say, Ireland, where open caskets are still a thing etc. I wouldn't choose to go out as publicly as Deborah James for example, photographed until the end at various events, but she wanted to wring every last drop out of life and more power to her. I'm sure there was an element of rubbernecking and grief tourism there, but that doesn't mean she should have stayed home. Yes, she shrunk, yes she looked like she was dying. So fucking what? That's what happens when you die of cancer. NORMALISE THIS. 100% of us will die one day.

Everyone talking about their health anxiety being triggered by coverage of cancer like this — have a word with yourself. Get off the internet. Turn off the TV. I wish that was all I had to worry about!

Spare a thought for those of us actually living this nightmare.

Respect to you and best wishes for your recovery.

mowly77 · 08/11/2022 12:48

Well I've got breast cancer, stage 4, and I just don't know what to make of this thread.

My own mother died of breast cancer in 1985 & she didn't tell anyone; no-one at work; just one close friend & her brother. It was extremely taboo. I am glad it no longer is. I think if celebrities WANT to take control of the narrative, write & talk about it, & be photographed, more power to them. It's part of the big shift in society to cancer NOT being a dirty, shameful secret and I find that personally, for me, comforting. I wish it had been the same for my mum, and she didn't feel she had to keep it secret for fear of being sacked etc. It must have been intensely lonely for her.

The media outing celebrities is shameful. But those who choose to be private such as Olivia Newton John or David Bowie are not morally superior beings to those who have chosen to be open about their illness, which is very much the subtext of the OP & many PP. What a crazy old-fashioned attitude, one that takes suffering in silence way too far. @Mummbles you've made some great points.

You do not have to read salacious websites/magazines etc that publish stories about celebrities with illnesses if you don't want to, as so many PP have said. I appreciate @MothralovesGojira 's point about accidentally seeing the Sarah Beeney pics when buying something in the supermarket though; I haven't seen them, and I haven't sought them out as yeah I look and feel like shit & don't feel there's much to be gained from seeing her tattooed eyebrows or whatever. But she shouldn't have to hide away if she doesn't want to, and she clearly doesn't.

Personally, I feel quite private about my disease. My close friends and family know the details, but I don't especially feel like sharing it with all and sundry -- apart from on here, which is anonymous, and a great source of support for me. Unfortunately, once you lose your hair, you lose your privacy. People still recoil from you, and don't want to meet your eyes, or chat. At my daughter's school there is no doubt I am Cancer Mum. That's awful, that's lonely.

As for death and dying, we are all going to die. It should not be taboo! We have a very, very odd attitude to death in England specifically, unlike say, Ireland, where open caskets are still a thing etc. I wouldn't choose to go out as publicly as Deborah James for example, photographed until the end at various events, but she wanted to wring every last drop out of life and more power to her. I'm sure there was an element of rubbernecking and grief tourism there, but that doesn't mean she should have stayed home. Yes, she shrunk, yes she looked like she was dying. So fucking what? That's what happens when you die of cancer. NORMALISE THIS. 100% of us will die one day.

Everyone talking about their health anxiety being triggered by coverage of cancer like this — have a word with yourself. Get off the internet. Turn off the TV. I wish that was all I had to worry about!

Spare a thought for those of us actually living this nightmare.

MissyB1 · 08/11/2022 12:38

Runningwithoutstopping · 07/11/2022 23:11

It's well known fact that if all cancer sufferers just stayed positive and didn't 'wallow' they would be fine.

Oh yes apparently so. And if they all kept quiet about having cancer, and just pretended they were perfectly well they could avoid offending or “triggering” others. Or perhaps they could just lie and say they have a totally different illness to avoid offence? Oh these pesky people with cancer causing all these problems eh? 🙄

Lentilweaver · 08/11/2022 12:02

Such a thought provoking thread. I still don't know what I think. Best wishes to the posters with cancer.