Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse these baby names?

135 replies

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 15:50

My partner wants to use family names for our baby, (think old fashioned Ethel and Edgar) he has a daughter from his previous marriage and his ex wife wouldn’t allow him to use family names for her middle name. He’s got his heart set on naming our baby after his grandmother or grandfather, depending on the gender, he’s very excited and assumed it will happen without asking, but the truth is I hate the names. Regardless of being family names I wouldn’t force a child to live out their life with these awful suggestions. I understand he wants to continue their memory through our children, but he wants 2/3 middle names that won’t flow and will sound ridiculous out loud. He hasn’t even offered if I had names I like or relatives I’d like to name our children after. It’s starting to really upset me and feels hurtful, as I feel pressured to say yes to avoiding hurting his feelings. I don’t know how to broach the subject and be clear it’s a no before it gets to the birth, without offending him or his family who I am very close with. We have different taste in names in general so I knew it would be difficult but I never expected to have this pushed on me as he’d never mentioned it pre pregnancy. Fwiw my dd has a name in the top 10 and so does his dd, which I’d like to continue with, a name straight from the war era will be very unusual together. I know many old names are making a come back, but I’m confident not these ones! Can anyone share their stories how they worked around this situation please?

OP posts:
RishisProudMum · 05/11/2022 17:08

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:05

His mother thinks herbie as a nickname is cute, so even she thinks it’s a given. No one has asked how I feel or if I even agree, which I obviously don’t. I couldn’t even agree to them as a middle name. Yes baby will have his surname too, it’ll be a very long name overall if I did use them. He hasn’t turned down my name choices, he’s just thrust his preferred choices on me first. I pulled a face insinuating I didn’t like them, but he was so excited I don’t know if he noticed or chose to ignore it.

Stop ‘insinuating’. You’re an adult, you’re having a child and you have equal say in said child’s name. Speak up.

dodobookends · 05/11/2022 17:07

Edgar is growing on me, actually.

mathanxiety · 05/11/2022 17:07

You're now seeing the sort of personality traits that made him a single dad with an ex wife...

Knock this right on the head. And forget about avoiding hurt feelings. He has no qualms about upsetting you while you're pregnant. Look around at his extended family - did anyone else use the dreadful family names?

You can each come up with a list of 20 names you like. You get to strike out ten names from each other's lists. Then you narrow down the twenty you're left with, for first and middle names.

This is fair. What he's doing is not fair.

Saltywalruss · 05/11/2022 17:07

The names he wants were "regular" names when his grandparents were babies and they probably will be again :-) I like his name suggestions, but I can see why you don't. It doesn't seem fair that he gets to decide on three names for the child and you don't get a say at all.

Pebblebeach15 · 05/11/2022 17:06

My ds has a middle name after his dad’s dad . It is old fashioned and I did not like it at all but is was really important to Dh and made grandad so happy before he passed away . Ds is now 7 and loves his middle name and proudly announces it .

Rockingcloggs · 05/11/2022 17:05

I like Sylvie and I like Bertie - would he compromise for a play on those names? Well, actually he/she is coming out of you so more to the point are you willing to compromise?

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:05

His mother thinks herbie as a nickname is cute, so even she thinks it’s a given. No one has asked how I feel or if I even agree, which I obviously don’t. I couldn’t even agree to them as a middle name. Yes baby will have his surname too, it’ll be a very long name overall if I did use them. He hasn’t turned down my name choices, he’s just thrust his preferred choices on me first. I pulled a face insinuating I didn’t like them, but he was so excited I don’t know if he noticed or chose to ignore it.

OP posts:
EndlessMagpies · 05/11/2022 17:05

Peggy isn't a proper name anyway, certainly not from their generation, it is short for Margaret.

Howlongtillwegetthere · 05/11/2022 17:03

Sylvie and Herbie are ok - have heard them used on kids recently. May be compromise on the shortened versions?

Caspianberg · 05/11/2022 17:03

I love Sylvia, and Wilbur

surely it’s a comprise. Something you like and he does?

Sylvia Ethel Peggy and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. Maybe:

Peggy is from Margaret. So Margarita, Margaret, Margot, Maggie, Pearl are also the same.

Ethel : Etta, Ettie

Sylvia : Sophia is similar. Sylvester, Sullivan for boy?

Herbert: Albert, Bertie, Herbie, Alberta for girl?

Sophia Etta Pearl

Albert Edwin Wilbur

Merrymumoftwo · 05/11/2022 17:03

Is there an option to compromise and have one or two but as middle names?

if there are family names you like, mutually agreed first name, then you and he add a family middle name each?

MrsCarson · 05/11/2022 17:01

God no, they are awful names. Go with whatever you like for a first and pick the best of a bad bunch for a middle if you want to compromise.

Naunet · 05/11/2022 17:01

So is the baby already getting his family name by way of last name? If so expecting to also use an additional 2 or 3 family names is really taking the piss.

FluffyYucca · 05/11/2022 17:00

You need to find names you both agree on, really. Surely there’s something that you could both accept, even if it’s not the names you’d have as first choices.

(I like some of those names, but not others, but that’s irrelevant)

I do tend to think the mother has the casting vote, though, as you’re the one who has done all the hard work!

SemperIdem · 05/11/2022 16:59

Put your foot down. His ex did so he must be expecting you to as well, deep down.

ofwarren · 05/11/2022 16:57

I love them Grin

5yearplan · 05/11/2022 16:57

Oh no I don’t like a single one of them. He can’t be serious surely.

LearnerCook · 05/11/2022 16:55

You don't want to hurt his feelings but he's clearly hurt yours and made decisions without consulting you. You really must let him know how you feel. And soon.

Would you be prepared to allow a name you don't like to be a second of 2 middle names, sling the lines of Catherine Anna Ethel? And make sure it is used as little as possible? It'd something of a compromise, I guess.

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

OP posts:
HeraldicBlazoning · 05/11/2022 16:47

Seriously. You might name your child - for example - Elizabeth Beatrice Evangeline Smith. You will tie yourself into knots wondering what sounds better, Elizabeth Beatrice Evangeline, or Elizabeth Evangeline Beatrice. Or whether two "E" names are too much, and whether Elizabeth Agatha Beatrice would be better? Or maybe Margaret or Olive as a middle name?

Whereas in 99.99% of situations, the child will be known as Beth Smith. Using a family surname or given name as a child's middle name is a centuries old tradition which marks the links between the generations. This is obviously something which is important to your partner.

Minimalme · 05/11/2022 16:41

You need to speak up op - he sounds overbearing. I worry that finding a name you both like will be the least of your problems with this guy.

Starryskiesinthesky · 05/11/2022 16:40

Are you married? Is the baby going to have his surname? If it is then no way would I be letting him choose all these names.

PinkSyCo · 05/11/2022 16:36

WheresMyDodo · 05/11/2022 16:25

I think this is the time when you need to worry less about your partner's feelings and more about the feelings of your unborn child if they are lumbered with a terrible name their whole life. This is absolutely worth putting your foot down over. They can be middle names or none at all.
Stand up for your baby! 😊

How do you know that the baby won’t grow up wishing it had an old fashioned name with history, rather than having the same name as every other person they meet though?

Caspianberg · 05/11/2022 16:32

I think it’s fine. It’s a middle name. Add two middle names if you like something more ‘modern’. I think an older name with top 10 name works well

ie

Harry Edgar James
Oliver Edgar Arlo
Noah Edgar Theodore

Isla Ethel Rae
Olivia Ethel Aria
Ava Harper Ethel

blurer · 05/11/2022 16:27

Tbh I'd be more annoyed that he expects to dictate baby names without any discussion. Why do his family names trump your family names anyway?

Swipe left for the next trending thread