Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse these baby names?

135 replies

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 15:50

My partner wants to use family names for our baby, (think old fashioned Ethel and Edgar) he has a daughter from his previous marriage and his ex wife wouldn’t allow him to use family names for her middle name. He’s got his heart set on naming our baby after his grandmother or grandfather, depending on the gender, he’s very excited and assumed it will happen without asking, but the truth is I hate the names. Regardless of being family names I wouldn’t force a child to live out their life with these awful suggestions. I understand he wants to continue their memory through our children, but he wants 2/3 middle names that won’t flow and will sound ridiculous out loud. He hasn’t even offered if I had names I like or relatives I’d like to name our children after. It’s starting to really upset me and feels hurtful, as I feel pressured to say yes to avoiding hurting his feelings. I don’t know how to broach the subject and be clear it’s a no before it gets to the birth, without offending him or his family who I am very close with. We have different taste in names in general so I knew it would be difficult but I never expected to have this pushed on me as he’d never mentioned it pre pregnancy. Fwiw my dd has a name in the top 10 and so does his dd, which I’d like to continue with, a name straight from the war era will be very unusual together. I know many old names are making a come back, but I’m confident not these ones! Can anyone share their stories how they worked around this situation please?

OP posts:
InFiveMins · 05/11/2022 17:23

You need to compromise. You don't like those names, so don't agree to them. Surely if you discuss together you can come up with a list of names you can both agree on?!

MalagaNights · 05/11/2022 17:22

Sophie Sylvia and James Edgar sound lovely.

emptythelitterbox · 05/11/2022 17:22

You're right. They are hideous to lumber a child with.

You mentioned he's a partner. Have you been together long?

mathanxiety · 05/11/2022 17:22

Compromise suggestions-

Something Sylvia Margaret (Peggy is a nickname, not a given name)
Something Edgar Herbert (Wilbur is godawful)

Frostine · 05/11/2022 17:22

Sylvia is nice but I agree the boy name not so much. What is your husband's middle name ? Could you have that as a first name and then pick one of the families name as the middle name ?

WhereYouLeftIt · 05/11/2022 17:21

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:11

The names are not to my taste at all, I know older names are making a come back but I just can’t picture them on a baby, particularly my own. I think it comes from a good place as he is excited to be involved more with this pregnancy than his ex wife allowed with his daughter. She named and registered her without him present, so I can understand he wants to chose names for our baby, just not these ones! I’m happy to compromise of course, but compromise on names we both like not his choices alone.

Just because his ex overrode him does not make it OK for him to override you!

I am seriously not getting this 'excitement' over names being an acceptable reason for him ignoring your naming preferences or, as it sounds, his totally ignoring that you might wish to have any input into the naming of your child!

To compare - DH and I sat (in the back garden of a pub IIRC) and discussed what we wanted from a name - it boiled down to

  • 'normal'
  • not so popular that there'd be multiples in the same class
  • multiple short versions he could choose from
All very non-exciting/excitable!
HappyHoppyHippo · 05/11/2022 17:21

Please speak up! You will hurt his feeling less in the long run.

APurpleSquirrel · 05/11/2022 17:20

You need to have a conversation & say you don't like those names.
My DC have two middle names - both from our families (one name each from each family) & then we choose the first names together.
The middle names are of course rarely used, but they have sentimental meaning for us & our families especially as some of the people have now died.
I'd say choose the first together; then you each pick one middle name (of course you need to agree to it so try & find a name you're ok with).

RuthW · 05/11/2022 17:20

Sylvia, Wilbur, Herbert are gorgeous names. If you really don't like them, use as one of the middle names.

DisforDarkChocolate · 05/11/2022 17:19

I have heard much worse!

Sylvia is lovely (but I prefer Sylvie).

Edgar is very lovely.

I would be happy with using one family name, picking all three is too much.

MalagaNights · 05/11/2022 17:17

Why on earth haven't you just said what you think? Why are you being weirdly passive? You should have immediately corrected his presumption and had a real conversation.

I'd agree to use a family name as a middle name. Middle names are never used so are a nice way of honouring someone.

Kids also enjoy having a middle name with a story or a reason, rather than the bland: my parents just thought Grace sounded nice with Sophie explanation.

But most importantly talk to your husband.

mathanxiety · 05/11/2022 17:17

I see the ex wife named and registered their daughter without your H present.

Gee, I wonder if he had been wanging on about Ethel and Peggy and Wilbur and Herbert while she was pregnant?

GoldenSpiral · 05/11/2022 17:17

I like the idea of Sylvie and I don't mind Wilbur, but perhaps William could work as a compromise?

I don't understand how you haven't said anything up until this point to be honest.

YouCanSpeakWhenYoureMakingSense · 05/11/2022 17:17

What about Sylvie as a compromise? I think that’s so pretty.

Sandysandwich · 05/11/2022 17:16

Does he want all three? Because they are way too much in one name.
Would a co.promise work like you mutally agree on a first name that you both like and isn't a family name and then you each put a middle name in?
Two middle names isnt bad and could make his name blend in more.
Like Sophie Alice Sylvia Jones
Or Sophie Freya Peggy Jones or
James Alec Wilbur Jones ect?

RishisProudMum · 05/11/2022 17:16

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:13

Because the conversation happened today and I’m still trying to process it and how to handle it maturely

Nothing you’ve described sounds like a conversation. It sounds like you being told things and just accepting them.

The mature way to handle it is to speak up about your desired names for the child you are carrying. There is no alternative way.

CanYouFeelMyHeart · 05/11/2022 17:15

Herbert is fucking awful.

Really OP you must stop being a drip about this! Speak up for goodness' sake.

Gazelda · 05/11/2022 17:14

Why on earth can't you start a conversation about this? Surely you chat about baby stuff - when shall we go pram shopping, do you need my MATB1 so you can organise paternity leave, don't forget the scan next Tuesday, can we talk about names ...

mathanxiety · 05/11/2022 17:14

I'm speaking as someone who used family names for my DCs, but with exH's full approval.

And there were names that weren't even considered - not 'Hephzibah' but similarly gobsmacking and unusual. I'd put Herbert in that category.

The names your H wants were the fashion for their times. They're not traditional and timeless names like Catherine, Margaret, Elizabeth, Mary, Anne, William, Edward, John, James, Peter, etc. If there was no long family tradition of using those names generation after generation, why should you commemorate what was basically a whim of the parents of the people he wants to honour?

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:13

Because the conversation happened today and I’m still trying to process it and how to handle it maturely

OP posts:
Naunet · 05/11/2022 17:11

I’d start saying the names out loud to yourself but with your last name (assuming you don't share a last name) and ignore his reaction, but probably far more sensible just to pull him up on his arrogance!

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:11

The names are not to my taste at all, I know older names are making a come back but I just can’t picture them on a baby, particularly my own. I think it comes from a good place as he is excited to be involved more with this pregnancy than his ex wife allowed with his daughter. She named and registered her without him present, so I can understand he wants to chose names for our baby, just not these ones! I’m happy to compromise of course, but compromise on names we both like not his choices alone.

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 05/11/2022 17:11

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 17:05

His mother thinks herbie as a nickname is cute, so even she thinks it’s a given. No one has asked how I feel or if I even agree, which I obviously don’t. I couldn’t even agree to them as a middle name. Yes baby will have his surname too, it’ll be a very long name overall if I did use them. He hasn’t turned down my name choices, he’s just thrust his preferred choices on me first. I pulled a face insinuating I didn’t like them, but he was so excited I don’t know if he noticed or chose to ignore it.

"Yes baby will have his surname too"

I find myself wondering how 'excited' he would be to use those first names, if you were then to say 'Well if you get to choose the first names I get to choose the family name, and our child will be carrying MY surname.'

You should raise that and see what he says.

Scrambledeggsontoasted · 05/11/2022 17:11

How can you have sex with someone but not be honest with them about how your feeling?

I love you, I love your family but I am not naming our children after them. Now what names would you like that aren't from your family?

PinkSyCo · 05/11/2022 17:10

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

Ooh I quite like some of those names. They are definitely not as bad as I expected anyway. Surely you can let him chose one as a middle name?