Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse these baby names?

135 replies

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 15:50

My partner wants to use family names for our baby, (think old fashioned Ethel and Edgar) he has a daughter from his previous marriage and his ex wife wouldn’t allow him to use family names for her middle name. He’s got his heart set on naming our baby after his grandmother or grandfather, depending on the gender, he’s very excited and assumed it will happen without asking, but the truth is I hate the names. Regardless of being family names I wouldn’t force a child to live out their life with these awful suggestions. I understand he wants to continue their memory through our children, but he wants 2/3 middle names that won’t flow and will sound ridiculous out loud. He hasn’t even offered if I had names I like or relatives I’d like to name our children after. It’s starting to really upset me and feels hurtful, as I feel pressured to say yes to avoiding hurting his feelings. I don’t know how to broach the subject and be clear it’s a no before it gets to the birth, without offending him or his family who I am very close with. We have different taste in names in general so I knew it would be difficult but I never expected to have this pushed on me as he’d never mentioned it pre pregnancy. Fwiw my dd has a name in the top 10 and so does his dd, which I’d like to continue with, a name straight from the war era will be very unusual together. I know many old names are making a come back, but I’m confident not these ones! Can anyone share their stories how they worked around this situation please?

OP posts:
Notthetoothfairy · 05/11/2022 19:26

You’re the one going through the pregnancy and giving birth and you’re not even married to him. I would give him Peggy or Wilbur as a second middle name, and that’s it.

JaneAustensHeroine · 05/11/2022 19:18

Sylvie and Ed would be my only compromise.

Other than that, no.

Musti · 05/11/2022 19:18

I quite like the names but you’ve both got to like the names. I would have liked to have named one of my kids after my grandmother but it is a marmite name so we didn’t. All my kids’ middle names are family members names. I prefer that.

Abraxan · 05/11/2022 19:16

He doesn't get to chose all three names. You need to put your foot down on that.

If having 3 names, then one compromise could be:
first name - you both like equally
middle names - one name chosen each

So he gets to chose one from his choices for each sex, as one of the middle names:
Sylvia or Ethel or Peggy
Herbert or Edgar or Wilbur

For what its worth - Herbert is my least favourite. The rest I don't mind.
I teach infant age children - in recent years I have taught: Sylvia, Peggy, Edgar and Wilbur on more than one occasion. So not that unusual now either.

Shinyandnew1 · 05/11/2022 19:15

Is the baby having his surname, @Babynamedramallama ?

Abraxan · 05/11/2022 19:09

First name - needs to one you both chose and like

Middle names - these are rarely used day to day, so ideal for older family names. They don't need to 'flow' initially. As time goes on and you say them they will start to 'flow' more to you anyway - most do.

Unless the names are really really awful (and Edgar/Ethel aren't imo) then I can't see the issue of honouring his family with one of the child's middle names. Even more so if the child will be having more than one middle name.

AssumingDirectControl · 05/11/2022 19:06

Herbert The Pervert springs to mind…

Why is he assuming he will get to choose all three names? I’d say that he can have one as the middle name, you could add a second middle name of your choice, but the first name needs to be something you both agree on.

Sylvie or Will any use as compromises?

W0tnow · 05/11/2022 19:06

All of my children have meaningful middle names from my family. I was adamant. Fair enough, as they all got his surname. I think if kids get the man’s surname the mother’s opinion should carry more weight.

TiaraBoo · 05/11/2022 19:05

Sophie Sylvia and James Edgar aren’t too bad.
I think I personally would compromise with 1 of the GP names if I was choosing their first name and could make sure it flowed nicely.

2 or 3 GP names I’d say a concrete no to. But my priority would be your child and their potential feelings about the name rather than just honouring a GP.

Lannielou · 05/11/2022 19:05

Put your foot down. Please don't saddle your child with those names

EsmeSusanOgg · 05/11/2022 19:02

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

So he wants all the names!? Nope.

We settled on choosing a first name together, then I got one middle name and my husband the other middle name. Your husband wants to have the first name, both middle names and the surname? That's utterly selfish.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 05/11/2022 18:59

SemperIdem · 05/11/2022 16:59

Put your foot down. His ex did so he must be expecting you to as well, deep down.

And maybe that's why she is now his Ex? Edgar isn't so bad, and Ethel might make a comeback. Let them have middle names and you pick any modern name you want for the first - Pixie Ethel Smith' and Thor Edgar Smith. Whatever.

Shinyandnew1 · 05/11/2022 18:51

Hmmm, you need to speak up now and ask him why he thinks he will get to choose all of your baby’s names?! Say now-this evening-you don’t like any of them.

He has been through naming a child with someone before who clearly thought his suggestions were nuts-this won’t be a shock to him! What did you say when he told you how he wasn’t allowed to name his older children these names?

Is he able to compromise on other things in your relationship? I’d be asking him what he understands by the word compromise!?

Stravaig · 05/11/2022 18:45

I'd just have said 'I don't like any of those' there and then. If his family joined in with their suggestions, I'd have invited them all to notice where the unborn babe was at that very moment, and who was going to have final say on names, and everything else!

Honestly, OP, use your words - and start trying out names aloud, with your surname, not his. That should take the wind out of his sails.

AliceMcK · 05/11/2022 18:45

I was very lucky, there was no discussion on names, I made it clear a girl would be named after my grandmother, DH was happy and her middle name is his grandmothers. #2 named similar & #3 we agreed to give baby the name my DF liked, my DH and I loved the boy name and girl we were happy for a middle name, yes it’s a very old fashioned MN cringe name but we like it and she suits her name.

I have both my maternal and paternal grandmothers names as middle names, but my parents choose my first name, well my mum picked one name, think Emma Jane and my DF registered me with what he wanted Alice Jane, then the grandmothers names. (Before anyone says anything about my DF, my mother was a narcissistic controlling bitch, this was one of my DFs few wins and I definitely prefer his name choice, I’d have been one of 8 Emma’s in my class at school otherwise). It’s long, 4 forenames but I’ve always liked it. I’ve met lot of other people with several middle names.

I think you both definitely need to agree on the first name, but would it really be that big of a deal to let him have one or even 2 middle names. My DDs love they are named after family, each of their names has a meaning and story behind it. My oldest named after my grandmother, I was very close to her, she was someone I could turn to when home was extremely toxic, my DH spent a lot of time with his grandmother when he was young, she did all the childcare while his parents worked. They both meant so much to us, they were strong fierce women that we loved and admired, which is why we wanted to name out daughter after them.

Also there is a Herbie in my 8yos class, so it’s not that old fashioned.

PeeJayDay · 05/11/2022 18:45

You can't call a kid Herbert.

BreatheAndFocus · 05/11/2022 18:42

Those names are awful - and why does he think all the ‘name gaps’ are going to be filled by his relatives?? What about your grandparents and great-grandparents, etc?

IMO he’s being very pushy, and I bet he mentioned it at his parents to try to guilt you and make out it’s a done deal. Put a very firm stop to that crap. Importantly, I also advise you to give the baby your surname. Don’t be railroaded into giving baby his name. There’s nothing to stop you changing it to his name in the future but I bet he’d never agree to change it to yours if you separated.

As for name choices, both make a list of names and then work together to eliminate one’s the other person dislikes; see if any choices coincide; mark each other’s names to make compromise easier; and always keep yourself and baby in mind. You do not have to pushed around like this, even if your partner is excited or whatever. He is not in charge, and you are not a mere vessel for his children.

Noodlesmumm · 05/11/2022 18:42

Definitely don't do it

I had a middle name that was awful (Violet) and had the micky taken even as an adult. My mum had recently lost her sister, who by all accounts was a marvellous lady. Didn't make me feel any better though

I'm in my 60s and still cringe

DPotter · 05/11/2022 18:32

I think I'm right in saying an unmarried father cannot register the birth of his child - only a married father. An unmarried father can only be named on the birth certificate if present with the mother and gives his consent to be named.

I agree with everyone else - this is no time to let him ride rough shod over your feelings. Time to speak up and take his 'suggestions' as opening up the discussions, not cast in stone. I would also suggest you very seriously re-think using his surname. You can change it if you marry and take his name. Oh and don't hold these discussions in public - this is between you and your partner - no one else gets a say at all. If he tries to involve his family shut down the conversation - he either agrees to discuss maturely and reach a mutually acceptable decision between the 2 of you, or you will decide alone and he gets no say at all. See para 1.

BellePeppa · 05/11/2022 18:31

Terrible names although Sylvia would be quite nice as a middle name. This would be an area I’d be quite assertive about and would be giving a flat no to and to hang with ‘hurt’ feelings. He can name a dog Herbert.

itsthefinalcountdown1 · 05/11/2022 18:23

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur.

Say, that's nice, but you do remember that this child is half mine, don't you? 🙄 I don't know why he's assumed he'd get to full name the baby, but you clearly need to work on being more assertive if he's ever been able to take that assumption on board.

SummerWhisper · 05/11/2022 18:22

Sophie Sylvie Rose
James Edward instead of Edgar

Please don't let him register the birth...I think he'll sneak in what he wants.

bewarethetides · 05/11/2022 18:18

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

Those would be a definite 'no' from me.

You need to say no, you won't be naming a child any of those names. Your children will have 'similar' era names to your existing child (and his existing child) so he needs to sit down with you and draw up a realistic list of names you can both agree on to choose from.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 05/11/2022 18:17

Well this is one of many reasons not to have a baby with someone you barely know. Two years is nothing.

But stand your ground. No more babies should be saddled with these horrible old names.

Itsabitnotcold · 05/11/2022 18:16

Is there middle names or nicknames you can use instead?
I wanted to include my grandparents. Both had old first names so I went with grandads middle name, it's a classic like James, and the pet name he had for my nana for a girl.

I don't think he gets ALL the names either. A child deserves their own name. Not just a miss mash of other people's names.