Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse these baby names?

135 replies

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 15:50

My partner wants to use family names for our baby, (think old fashioned Ethel and Edgar) he has a daughter from his previous marriage and his ex wife wouldn’t allow him to use family names for her middle name. He’s got his heart set on naming our baby after his grandmother or grandfather, depending on the gender, he’s very excited and assumed it will happen without asking, but the truth is I hate the names. Regardless of being family names I wouldn’t force a child to live out their life with these awful suggestions. I understand he wants to continue their memory through our children, but he wants 2/3 middle names that won’t flow and will sound ridiculous out loud. He hasn’t even offered if I had names I like or relatives I’d like to name our children after. It’s starting to really upset me and feels hurtful, as I feel pressured to say yes to avoiding hurting his feelings. I don’t know how to broach the subject and be clear it’s a no before it gets to the birth, without offending him or his family who I am very close with. We have different taste in names in general so I knew it would be difficult but I never expected to have this pushed on me as he’d never mentioned it pre pregnancy. Fwiw my dd has a name in the top 10 and so does his dd, which I’d like to continue with, a name straight from the war era will be very unusual together. I know many old names are making a come back, but I’m confident not these ones! Can anyone share their stories how they worked around this situation please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Daisybuttercup12345 · 24/03/2023 21:15

Just seen this is an old thread. What did you call baby?

Daisybuttercup12345 · 24/03/2023 21:14

Caspianberg · 05/11/2022 16:32

I think it’s fine. It’s a middle name. Add two middle names if you like something more ‘modern’. I think an older name with top 10 name works well

ie

Harry Edgar James
Oliver Edgar Arlo
Noah Edgar Theodore

Isla Ethel Rae
Olivia Ethel Aria
Ava Harper Ethel

I think Ethel is the worst one of all.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 24/03/2023 21:11

They are absolutely awful names. I would refuse, just as his ex wife did. Or choose just one as a 3rd name (to be excluded from forms and quietly forgotten.
You cannot saddle your baby with these. Choose a new name for them and put your foot down.

ConsuelaHammock · 24/03/2023 20:36

If they’re taking his surname then you get final say on the first name. Compromise by choosing one middle name each. If he insists on names you don’t like them you insist on a middle name he hates. You can veteo each other.
Sylvia and Edgar or Wilbur are all fine as middle names.

123wentaway · 24/03/2023 20:21

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

No, sorry, just no, they’re awful. And I’m over 60 but I wouldn’t want any of the grandkids to have those. Stick to your guns OP — you choose first name, he can have 2 middle names ( but please not Peggy)

custardbear · 06/11/2022 06:54

Sorry but I agree with you, hideous names!
You've got to tell him today so he doesn't t tell everyone!

Sockwomble · 06/11/2022 06:29

Some of them are ok. Margaret, Sylvia ( or Sylvie) and Edgar aren't names that would get laughed at as middle names.

Aprilx · 06/11/2022 05:47

You should both be able to veto any name you don’t like. I would compromise on middle names though, they really aren’t an extension, they are barely used. I am loving Edgar though, I wouldn’t mind that as a first name even. 😊

k1233 · 06/11/2022 05:42

Sophie and James are nice first names.

Sophie Margaret or Sophie Ethel could work. I think James works with the three names you mentioned - James Edgar would probably be the better one? Hard to tell without knowing your last name. Eg James Edgar Robinson - not a bad fit.

mathanxiety · 06/11/2022 04:42

Why are you tying yourself in knots trying to be kind?

His previous wife was so desperate about this problem that she registered the baby herself.

You need to be very firm and completely blunt.

"I'm sorry if my politeness has been misinterpreted as consent. But now I see that you're not taking my hints, so I'm going to be blunt. Over my cold, dead body will our baby be given any of those names."

And let the chips fall where they may.

mathanxiety · 06/11/2022 04:30

@snazzlealpaca
Yes indeed.
I suspect she's now realising there's another side to whatever she was told about the ex, and if she isn't, she should be.

Saz12 · 05/11/2022 22:33

DC has my (deceased) mother’s name as a middle name. It means nothing at all to to her. It’s not a particularly fashionable or cool name. But it’s part of her history even if she doesn’t get that yet, and nobody actually uses it! IMO middle names are the bit where you can do the family history part (mine is truly comedy awful).

But for a first name you have to choose something you both like, and will suit them just as well when they’re 5 years old and when they’re 75 years old.

CrispyPancakeeater · 05/11/2022 22:27

We both picked a grandparent's name for our daughter's middle names( I had a very realistic dream where I told my recently deceased Grandad that when I had a baby I'd name it after him. I used a female version of his name) but could not agree on a Christian name so it was literally names in a hat. Her name was not my first choice, however, it really suits her. I wonder if you could find a compromise in a similar way. Its not fair that he chooses alone. Hope you resolve it soon.

WellWhoWouldHaveThought · 05/11/2022 22:17

You’ve got to talk to him! You can’t have a baby with someone you can’t communicate with. Parenthood is about being a team.

I don’t like the names btw.

snazzlealpaca · 05/11/2022 22:02

I think the problem here is that the OP has clearly agreed, in past conversations, how awful his ex was, how controlling and unfair it was of her to go and name their child without his agreement. She has vowed never to be like the mad ex wife (as we see frequently on here).

Now you are finding that maybe the mad controlling ex was a bit of a trope, e.g. there were sane reasons for her actions. But you are the perfect new partner, that always agrees with him and his parents.What to do?

As everyone has said, your joint child's name is ideally a joint decision. You need to work together to decide on what the should be. Please don't give the baby his surname, this is the general advice given to unmarried parents on here. I know you think you will be together forever, and it doesn't matter when or if you get married, but sadly many of us have found the opposite. Best of luck with whatever you decide, but do have a good think about what you've been told about his marriage and consider whether there could be a different angle that might reflect more accurately who he really is.

Mummbles · 05/11/2022 21:53

I LOVE HERBERT - little baby Herbie or Bertie. Lots of babies coming through with those names. I think it's super, super, super cute. Wilbur would surely become Will? Lots of Wills out there too. I think both are nice. Edgar isn't to my taste but I think it'll come back into fashion very soon to be honest, it's already on the way up - it's one of the more niche "Ed/Eddie" names.

Sylvia could be shortened to quite a few cool, edgy names which may really suit her. Via, Lyvia, Syl, Sylvi, Sylv etc. Ethel is beautiful but I'd love little Ettie or Etta.

I wouldn't have chosen any for my DCs except Herbert and I only excluded Wilbur on having another Will in the family but they aren't ghastly like other people are pointing out. In my opinion, they're far nicer than James and Sophie which, to be frank, scream "my parent put zero thought into my name at all" (I have a James and a Sophie in my family too).

RedToothBrush · 05/11/2022 21:42

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

I know a Sylvia age 7.
And I know a little girl with the middle name Ethel who is 3.

Both are actually spot on trend. They would not be regarded as old lady or fusty.

Herbert isn't so great. 'He is a right Herbert'. Bertie yes, but not Herbert.

Edgar as a middle name isn't to my taste but E names are in for boys.

So i struggle with boys choice as I don't think it works, but his girls is fine.

I think your choices are too safe and a bit dull, so I can see why he wouldn't like your choices. I think you need to be a bit adventurous and look at what's actually on trend rather than you think is old fashioned.

It doesn't mean you pick his choices, but I do think you need to step a little more out of the corner you have painted yourself into.

Marmitemother · 05/11/2022 21:34

Babynamedramallama · 05/11/2022 16:55

Sylvia Ethel Peggy for a girl and Herbert Edgar Wilbur. No I’m not trolling they are the names he wants after his grandparents. I’ve probably really outed myself now. I like regular names like James and Sophie. I couldn’t then use one or two of those as middle names as I see middle names as an extension, not names that will be forgotten about, just a reminder of shit names my child has been lumbered with (no offence to anyone who likes those names). I’m not a huge fan of naming a child after a relative anyway as I think they deserve their own individual name, but if I demand my name choices I’m just as bad as he is.

You could always abbreviatte all those names to SEP and HEW. 😁

Seriously, who gives their children 3 first names before a surname?

Sylvia is beautiful especially if she may have blonde hair.

Edgar can be shortened to Ed and is also better than the usual run of the mill names doing the round.

I know of a youngster called Primrose...she loves her name and is so glad her parents gave her an individual name that nobody else has.

Embrace individuality. Life is soooo boring having a name in the top ten.

Dallimore · 05/11/2022 21:14

Our neighbours little boy is Herbert, Bertie as a nickname. We were a bit surprised at first but it actually really suits him

StoneofDestiny · 05/11/2022 21:12

The boys one just use initials HEW as a middle name?
Peggy is short for Margaret (was she a Margaret or a Peggy in fact?) if so rearrange the names and use initials EMS as a middle name?

Otherwise - stick to your guns and choose the names you want. There are more effective ways to honour his family heritage than bundling their names into your children.

Crunchingleaf · 05/11/2022 20:56

Middle names is perfect place for family names. Both my DC have family names and we have middle name picked out for our impending arrival. We haven’t found a first name we both like yet. We are very harsh when one of us suggests a name the other doesn’t like, but we will find something we both like.
Talk to your husband before he thinks this is a done deal OP.

AmandaMirandaPanda · 05/11/2022 20:04

Here's what we did - put a pad and pen in a place where both can access it and each add proposed names, one per line, as you thunk of them. He can make a note if there are any he only wants as a middle. Keep adding as either of you think of new names; don't cross anything out. After you have a big list (or the baby is imminent!) each person goes through and eliminates their absolute "nos". Then discuss and pick from what's left.

If nothing's left, brainstorm additional options based on what you both like - for example, Sylvie or Sophia as a compromise to Sophie and Sylvia. (He may only want the family names "as is", different people feel differently about that.) I'd recommend having two middle names if that's OK with you - I have two and the second one almost never gets used except on my birth certificate and passport. And incidentally, one of my middle names is Margaret after my grandmother, although she also went by Peggy. It's nice to have a family name - my siblings each have one too, one from each of our four grandparents - but it's also nice to have something individual and chosen just for the baby.

Keep in mind how the names sound with the surname - whether that's yours, double-barrelled, or his if you're planning to get married before the baby's born. If he's also assumed it will be his surname without your input, that's absolutely back on the table for discussion.

The baby's name is your joint decision with the father, no one else has a vote. If the family names are important to his parents, it's mean of your partner to give them the impression you'll use them when you likely won't be, but that's his mess to clean up. I'd try to agree with him that you'll both stop discussing it outside the family until the baby's born and the final name firmly chosen.

It seems like the problem is less the specific names and more that you're letting him pressure and even bully you (he MUST know it's not acceptable to choose all the names and not even ask you) and it's making you miserable. Even if he somehow doesn't see it that way, that's how you're experiencing it and as is clear from this thread he is being unreasonable and selfish. His wife was also wrong in naming his older child without his input, but that's done and doesn't give him an excuse to act badly. Tell him to stop.

Letthesunshineonin · 05/11/2022 19:42

Bloody awful names with no flow to them whatsoever. No wonder his ex wife sneaked off to register their daughter without him. She was probably put under the same pressure from him and his parents that you are experiencing now. I applaud her!
You shouldn’t be afraid to tell him and his parents it’s a definite no. Speak up now and be firm before it gets too far out of hand.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 05/11/2022 19:34

Peggy i s short for Margaret. If I were you I'd be praying it's a girl: Sylvia Margaret would be fine. NOT Ethel. Of the boys' names, Edgar is the best in my opinion. I'd choose my battles here, OP!

Soubriquet · 05/11/2022 19:28

Oo I love Sylvia. Would you be happy with Sylvie? Instead?

Swipe left for the next trending thread