Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask the driver of the special needs school bus to be quieter?

245 replies

savagegardener · 05/11/2022 13:27

I know I sound like an arse but hear me out. I live on a long cul-de-sac of terraced houses. It's about 25 houses each side so 50 in total. In London, so lots of houses have been converted to flats. Therefore parking is very difficult and cars are parked on both sides of the road.
Most of the time residents with cars either have to do a 30 point turn in whatever sliver of space is available or just reverse down the road to exit. This is tricky as we're off quite a busy road.
Anyway the family in the middle of the road have a severely disabled child and they've recently been offered a place at a special school a long way away. Every morning the bus comes to collect the child at 6.50 am. It's a long process to get them and all their equipment in and as neighbours we have been very supportive- there's constant car moves each evening so that people who leave later are swapping with people who need to leave earlier as otherwise all the cars on half the street are blocked in for 20-25 mins. We've done it willingly and haven't involved the parents at all in case it stresses them. This has been going on for a few months now and all was fine.
There's now a new bigger bus. Frankly it struggles to get down the road at all but the biggest problem is that when stopped and when reversing it beeps. Not quiet beeps. The loudest beeps ever heard. Someone on the next but one street posted on local fb asking what the noise was! The beeping can be up to 10 mins while loading and the another 10 mins or so as the driver gingerly reverses down the road and waits for a gap in London traffic. One morning the beeping was for nearly 30 mins.
I cannot stress how loud it is. It defeats double glazing, ear plugs, moving bedrooms. It wakes an entire street of people every morning before 7.
Yesterday a group of neighbours called round. Apparently one of them had asked the driver yesterday if he could turn the beep off and he said he wasn't allowed to. He refused to give any details of who employed him. The neighbours now want to go and ask the parents. We aren’t blaming the parents at all- we’d just like to know who runs the bus service to take it up with them. The reason they asked me is because I speak the language of the parents whose English isn’t great.
I don’t know if complaining makes us arses. I can’t imagine how hard their life is- but we also have a lot of shift workers from the local hospital and whose sleep is being destroyed every day. My next door neighbour has 3 kids in junior school who are woken an hour before they need to be. EVERY MORNING.
So should we just all suck it up or say something? Any other suggestions?

OP posts:
Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 10:59

I was one of those suggesting speaking to the LA about a different vehicle. Not from the PoV of disturbing the neighbours, but from the PoV a bus doing multiple pick ups is making the journey unnecessarily longer than the recommended maximum travel time.

I am not ignorant to how difficult it is to travel with a disabled child with complex needs, neither am I ignorant to how difficult it is to get the LA to adjust transport arrangements. I never said it would be easy but it should be changed, not for the neighbours’ benefit but for the family’s benefit, the legislation and statutory guidance is clear.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 11:00

Moomieboo · 06/11/2022 10:44

As the parent of a Severely disabled child....... Some children still don't have school transport this year. So they are home full time with parents. So they can't even work and need to live on £68 a week carers allowance!!
You have no idea what goes on behind closed doors....but yep...those beeps must be infuriating 🙄

Those parents need to contact SENTAS for help and write to the Director of Children’s Services threatening judicial review.

Blackheath95 · 06/11/2022 11:07

@Sockwomble then the whole street should be designated no parking for the safety and ease of the bus. Great idea! You should be in town planning! love to see you explain to the street why their parking is being taken away.

Sockwomble · 06/11/2022 11:11

Why would the council care? Double yellows appear all the time. Residents wants aren't the same as a legal duty towards the child.

Sockwomble · 06/11/2022 11:17

The council would say it is because of no safe access for emergency vehicles.

YomAsalYomBasal · 06/11/2022 11:21

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 10:59

I was one of those suggesting speaking to the LA about a different vehicle. Not from the PoV of disturbing the neighbours, but from the PoV a bus doing multiple pick ups is making the journey unnecessarily longer than the recommended maximum travel time.

I am not ignorant to how difficult it is to travel with a disabled child with complex needs, neither am I ignorant to how difficult it is to get the LA to adjust transport arrangements. I never said it would be easy but it should be changed, not for the neighbours’ benefit but for the family’s benefit, the legislation and statutory guidance is clear.

Apparently you are ignorant to the difficulties though. Does it say anywhere in this thread that the bus is picking up multiple children?
My child has to have a full on minibus even if they are the only child travelling. May be the case here too. Contacting the LA is indeed the right thing to do but please stop insisting they just need to change the vehicle.

NamelessNancy · 06/11/2022 11:21

The child has a right to safe transport. The residents have a right to access and to quiet before 7am.

I don't think it's necessarily impossible for the vehicle to be changed. According to op there was a different vehicle used initially which didn't cause these problems. Unless it needed to be swapped to better meet the needs of the child concerned it may be feasible for collection routes to be altered allowing this vehicle to be used again.

Ultimately though I think this has simply highlighted an existing problem re access to larger vehicles/emergency services and however unpopular it may be it sounds like one side if the street really needs to be double-yellow lined for the safety of everyone.

Herejustforthisone · 06/11/2022 11:22

This thread is really bringing out the ableist cunts that lurk on Mumsnet.

Pgj · 06/11/2022 11:31

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 05/11/2022 23:23

Yes. It's a safety feature and the bus driver has already said it can't be turned off.

But why is that bus any less safe when it's stationary than any other vehicle? Or any building, bus shelter, lamp post, phone box, whatever? If it's so dangerous for a vehicle to be parked without beeping, surely every vehicle, building and other obstacle should be beeping nonstop 24/7? If we're going on the apparent necessity for beeping, why is a car reversing at 20mph supposedly less dangerous than a stationary bus?!

Is it really designed that way or is the driver somehow pointlessly leaving it in reverse before putting on the handbrake? Which, if it were the case, would be a lot more dangerous than leaving it in neutral or park, if we're concerned about safety.

I'd be absolutely heartbroken finding out that our entire street had been moaning about us behind our backs because they don't like the school bus picking up my disabled child to get her safely to school

So would anybody, I'm sure; but that's not what's happened here at all - as OP has made abundantly clear. The child's needs are a given and nobody is disputing or begrudging that; what people are complaining about is a completely unnecessary and antisocial decision made by somebody along the chain in providing the service, which in no way helps or benefits the child.

Suppose the bus company had arbitrarily decided to paint an offensive or deeply controversial advertising slogan on the bus that comes to collect a disabled child, would you call people terrible for objecting to the slogan, purely on the grounds that the bus happens to be used to transport a disabled child?

I mean, we're just reaching now aren't we. Why do we need to pretend something offence is painted on the side of the bus.
I honestly believe the time the child is being collected is exaggerated but let's be real, it's almost 7am, not like they're coming at 2am is it.
If it's that much of an issue and they're as concerned about blocking the street as they pretend to be, like others have said they could ask the council to park double yellows so the bus can park rather than blocking the street. But they won't because that inconveniences them more.
I also think how long it takes to get the child in the bus is being exaggerated too. As the parent of a child with a wheelchair and lots of medical equipment, I know how long it takes to get them up on the bus and I doubt very much it's 30 minutes like it's been suggested in the posts

Samcro · 06/11/2022 11:32

Herejustforthisone · 06/11/2022 11:22

This thread is really bringing out the ableist cunts that lurk on Mumsnet.

yep

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 11:34

YomAsalYomBasal · 06/11/2022 11:21

Apparently you are ignorant to the difficulties though. Does it say anywhere in this thread that the bus is picking up multiple children?
My child has to have a full on minibus even if they are the only child travelling. May be the case here too. Contacting the LA is indeed the right thing to do but please stop insisting they just need to change the vehicle.

No I am not ignorant to the difficulties. The fact they pick up at 6.50am suggests there are multiple pick ups.

I didn’t post it needed to be a smaller vehicle, it could be the same size vehicle but doing fewer pick ups or no other pick ups thereby a later collection time - not for the neighbours’ benefit but for the child’s. In this case the OP posted a smaller bus was previously used.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 11:40

The child has a right to safe transport. The residents have a right to access and to quiet before 7am.

Exactly.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/11/2022 11:45

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 11:40

The child has a right to safe transport. The residents have a right to access and to quiet before 7am.

Exactly.

But nobody has a right to parking on their own street. So the obvious solution is double yellow lines on one side of the street, this should cut down the amount of time the transport needs to be on the street as they can just pull up outside the house without needing to reverse down the street so that they can arrive after 7am and will also mean they won’t be beeping for ages as they reverse down the street.

ThreeLeggedCat · 06/11/2022 11:46

Ask the council to provide a vehicle with broadband reversing beeps. This is quite common for delivery vehicles where there might be an impact on local residents because of the noise.

If the Council ignore you over this, go to Environmental Health, also at the Council. Make a noise complaint and be very clear as you have been in your OP that you are looking at a solution to benefit all parties. Ask them to work with the transport department to get this sorted. At the same time you could ask if it’s possible for the community to apply for a disabled space outside the house on the parents behalf (trying to avoid stressing the parents). If this sort of request came into our department (I work in environmental health) we would do our best to try and get all departments to try and work together to sort it in a pragmatic way.

Also tell them that 6.50am it’s still nighttime hours according to the world health organisation guidelines for night time noise. Night time hours are from 11 pm until 7 am.

user29 · 06/11/2022 11:47

x2boys · 05/11/2022 17:19

Thankfully the LEA should put the needs of the disabled child first and take no notice of what random strangers want.

The main issue is that It is putting the safety of 50 households at risk for 2.5 hours a week.I think that definitely needs to be raised with the council.What if someone needed an ambulance?

I am not sure why the beeping sounds whilst the bus is stationary.Why doesnt the driver switch the engine off.

x2boys · 06/11/2022 11:55

user29 · 06/11/2022 11:47

The main issue is that It is putting the safety of 50 households at risk for 2.5 hours a week.I think that definitely needs to be raised with the council.What if someone needed an ambulance?

I am not sure why the beeping sounds whilst the bus is stationary.Why doesnt the driver switch the engine off.

Yes as a pp pointed an imaginary person might need an ambulance so the imginary ambulance s is now blocking the sreet ,what happens if another imaginary person has an imaginary fire ,the imaginary fire truck wont be able to get down the street becsuse the imaginary ambulance is blocking them ,all seems a bit unlikey doesnt it ?just like there might be an emergency at exactly the same time the disabled child is being picked up

YomAsalYomBasal · 06/11/2022 11:59

It's not 2.5 hours a week, that's clearly an exaggeration.
But if an imaginary person needs an imaginary ambulance I'm sure the driver would move out of the way. Just as the refuse collectors and delivery drivers presumably also have to on this awkward road.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 12:00

Yes as a pp pointed an imaginary person might need an ambulance so the imginary ambulance s is now blocking the sreet ,what happens if another imaginary person has an imaginary fire ,the imaginary fire truck wont be able to get down the street becsuse the imaginary ambulance is blocking them ,all seems a bit unlikey doesnt it ?just like there might be an emergency at exactly the same time the disabled child is being picked up

Goodness. You do seem to have issues.

Most posters on this thread, and especially the OP, have been more than reasonable. All agree the child has a right to an education.

But most agree that the beeping at that time of the morning is unreasonable and they want it to stop.

That's all.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 12:03

x2boys · 06/11/2022 11:55

Yes as a pp pointed an imaginary person might need an ambulance so the imginary ambulance s is now blocking the sreet ,what happens if another imaginary person has an imaginary fire ,the imaginary fire truck wont be able to get down the street becsuse the imaginary ambulance is blocking them ,all seems a bit unlikey doesnt it ?just like there might be an emergency at exactly the same time the disabled child is being picked up

Yes and in the unlikely event it was to happen and the transport couldn’t move at that moment in time I am sure the ambulance would park in the middle of the road and walk to the ~12/13 houses on each side of the street further down than the school transport. Just like they would park and walk to the patient if they were in the middle of a shopping centre/work building/inaccessible field…

x2boys · 06/11/2022 12:05

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 12:00

Yes as a pp pointed an imaginary person might need an ambulance so the imginary ambulance s is now blocking the sreet ,what happens if another imaginary person has an imaginary fire ,the imaginary fire truck wont be able to get down the street becsuse the imaginary ambulance is blocking them ,all seems a bit unlikey doesnt it ?just like there might be an emergency at exactly the same time the disabled child is being picked up

Goodness. You do seem to have issues.

Most posters on this thread, and especially the OP, have been more than reasonable. All agree the child has a right to an education.

But most agree that the beeping at that time of the morning is unreasonable and they want it to stop.

That's all.

Maybe you should read the the thread again becsuse lots of peoole havent bern ressonable ,many have been. downright unpleasent.

Breziegrass · 06/11/2022 12:05

NamelessNancy · 05/11/2022 16:58

I might be misinterpreting but I understand this to mean reversing beepers should not be used before 7am.

"Use of audible warning instruments
99.—(1) Subject to the following paragraphs, no person shall sound, or cause or permit to be sounded, any horn, gong, bell or siren fitted to or carried on a vehicle which is—

(a)stationary on a road, at any time, other than at times of danger due to another moving vehicle on or near the road; or
(b)in motion on a restricted road, between 23.30 hours and 07.00 hours in the following morning."

From: www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1986/1078/regulation/99/made

I think the difficulty and safety issues of parents having to take a severely disabled child to a pick up point would also be totally unacceptable. As the road is being blocked for emergency vehicles the only realistic options would be to double yellow a portion of road or change the collecting vehicle.

@NamelessNancy so you deliberately missed out paragraph 2

"2) The provisions of paragraph (1)(a) do not apply in respect of the sounding of a reversing alarm when the vehicle to which it is fitted is about to move backwards and its engine is running." 🙄

Also people who are making shit up about blocking ambulances and fire engines ect. iIn your fantasy world so you think the bus will just refuse to move or work with them? 🙄

Lastly those who say there needs to be a compromise on reversing beeps, how many incidents or deaths caused buy tiring this safety feature is enough of a compromise 1,2 or more.

Seriously some people on here really need to get a grip on reality.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 12:07

Maybe you should read the the thread again becsuse lots of peoole havent bern ressonable ,many have been. downright unpleasant.

Most have been eminently reasonable and extremely sympathetic.

x2boys · 06/11/2022 12:08

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 12:07

Maybe you should read the the thread again becsuse lots of peoole havent bern ressonable ,many have been. downright unpleasant.

Most have been eminently reasonable and extremely sympathetic.

Clearly we are reading different threads .

Icedlatteplease · 06/11/2022 12:17

Another one who doesn't see how the OP are kind and considerate neighbours.

The rearranging of the cars isn't for the disabled child or her parents benefit. It's for other neighbours benefit so they won't be inconvenienced getting to work.

The only thing the OP has done is complain about a transport company doing their job for a disabled service user.

I'm sorry but that to ne really isn't the definition of kind an considrate, I'd call that being an arse.

It's highly unlikely the LEA is going to send alternative transport. Chances are if the LEA are collecting at 6.30, they are already (breaking the law) by sending one bus for all the kids they have to collect for the school. But unless a child's parent takes that to court, for the child's benefit I very much doubt anything will change.

NamelessNancy · 06/11/2022 12:29

Breziegrass · 06/11/2022 12:05

@NamelessNancy so you deliberately missed out paragraph 2

"2) The provisions of paragraph (1)(a) do not apply in respect of the sounding of a reversing alarm when the vehicle to which it is fitted is about to move backwards and its engine is running." 🙄

Also people who are making shit up about blocking ambulances and fire engines ect. iIn your fantasy world so you think the bus will just refuse to move or work with them? 🙄

Lastly those who say there needs to be a compromise on reversing beeps, how many incidents or deaths caused buy tiring this safety feature is enough of a compromise 1,2 or more.

Seriously some people on here really need to get a grip on reality.

I didn't! That refers to 1a not 1b and I did say I may be misinterpreting. Either way the beepers are a nuisance at that hour and are not benefitting the disabled child or family. Such an early collection seems really unfair to them too. It's not unreasonable for the residents to want peace. As I've said elsewhere it seems to me that the street needs double yellow lines.