Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask the driver of the special needs school bus to be quieter?

245 replies

savagegardener · 05/11/2022 13:27

I know I sound like an arse but hear me out. I live on a long cul-de-sac of terraced houses. It's about 25 houses each side so 50 in total. In London, so lots of houses have been converted to flats. Therefore parking is very difficult and cars are parked on both sides of the road.
Most of the time residents with cars either have to do a 30 point turn in whatever sliver of space is available or just reverse down the road to exit. This is tricky as we're off quite a busy road.
Anyway the family in the middle of the road have a severely disabled child and they've recently been offered a place at a special school a long way away. Every morning the bus comes to collect the child at 6.50 am. It's a long process to get them and all their equipment in and as neighbours we have been very supportive- there's constant car moves each evening so that people who leave later are swapping with people who need to leave earlier as otherwise all the cars on half the street are blocked in for 20-25 mins. We've done it willingly and haven't involved the parents at all in case it stresses them. This has been going on for a few months now and all was fine.
There's now a new bigger bus. Frankly it struggles to get down the road at all but the biggest problem is that when stopped and when reversing it beeps. Not quiet beeps. The loudest beeps ever heard. Someone on the next but one street posted on local fb asking what the noise was! The beeping can be up to 10 mins while loading and the another 10 mins or so as the driver gingerly reverses down the road and waits for a gap in London traffic. One morning the beeping was for nearly 30 mins.
I cannot stress how loud it is. It defeats double glazing, ear plugs, moving bedrooms. It wakes an entire street of people every morning before 7.
Yesterday a group of neighbours called round. Apparently one of them had asked the driver yesterday if he could turn the beep off and he said he wasn't allowed to. He refused to give any details of who employed him. The neighbours now want to go and ask the parents. We aren’t blaming the parents at all- we’d just like to know who runs the bus service to take it up with them. The reason they asked me is because I speak the language of the parents whose English isn’t great.
I don’t know if complaining makes us arses. I can’t imagine how hard their life is- but we also have a lot of shift workers from the local hospital and whose sleep is being destroyed every day. My next door neighbour has 3 kids in junior school who are woken an hour before they need to be. EVERY MORNING.
So should we just all suck it up or say something? Any other suggestions?

OP posts:
NamelessNancy · 05/11/2022 22:24

pastabakeonaplate · 05/11/2022 22:22

I don't get why it beeps when it's not reversing.

Anyway speak to the council.

But the beeps when reversing are a safety feature and I'd rather that than have a kid run over

At 6.50am? How many kids are wandering the streets? Later and I absolutely agree with you but surely there's a balance.

NamelessNancy · 05/11/2022 22:22

The one thing I would say re involving the family - it seems ridiculously early as a pick up. My DS is the first pick up at 730 for what is otherwise a ten minute journey to school (8.45 start time). I'm ok with it as he has friends picked up after him and is happy on the minibus but it's a long day for a child with disabilities. I think if the council told me they'd be turning up at 6.50 I'd be pointing out that that would be an excessively long day.

pastabakeonaplate · 05/11/2022 22:22

I don't get why it beeps when it's not reversing.

Anyway speak to the council.

But the beeps when reversing are a safety feature and I'd rather that than have a kid run over

Thatsnotmycar · 05/11/2022 22:18

Facecream · 05/11/2022 22:14

@Thatsnotmycar
that was my second post and I wasn’t merely referring to wheelchair users: this child obviously travels with “a tank of some sort” which as I’ve said is most likely oxygen, suction equipment, possibly feeding equipment and other equipment I don’t even know about.
Im sure the LEA didn’t just chose to piss off the neighbours in trying to get the most inconvenient vehicle imaginable

Yes, I know it was, I have read the thread. I was just pointing out that some black cabs are wheelchair accessible with the correct restraints as your post made it sounds as if black cabs were unsuitable because they lacked the correct restraints for those travelling in their chair. As for your last sentence I don’t think I have posted anything to the contrary, have I?

HRTQueen · 05/11/2022 22:15

It’s unfortunate when living around people their lives can inconvenience you but we all get on with our lives

when a child needs so much support their life their families lives it’s day in day out endless struggles and worries and difficulties that thankfully most of us do not even to even consider

take it up with the LA and leave the family alone

and those recommending a different pick up spot how utterly vile of you just nasty

Facecream · 05/11/2022 22:14

@Thatsnotmycar
that was my second post and I wasn’t merely referring to wheelchair users: this child obviously travels with “a tank of some sort” which as I’ve said is most likely oxygen, suction equipment, possibly feeding equipment and other equipment I don’t even know about.
Im sure the LEA didn’t just chose to piss off the neighbours in trying to get the most inconvenient vehicle imaginable

NamelessNancy · 05/11/2022 22:12

Pgj · 05/11/2022 22:04

Yes. It's a safety feature and the bus driver has already said it can't be turned off. I'm
Not sure what you expect the parents or the bus driver to do. This bus will be picking the child up their whole school life so it's unfortunately something you'll all just have to get used to. If you don't believe the driver you could phone the transport team at the local authority and ask them, their number will be on the local councils page. But I don't think you'll get anywhere.
My little girl gets picked up by school transport. I know they annoy one of our neighbours because the bus blocks the bottom on the street where we live and they try to leave for work at the same time. It's beyond our control and them knowing what time the bus comes means they could just set off 5 minutes earlier if they really can't wait while they wheel her wheel chair on the bus and strap her in, but instead they insist on sitting in their car behind the school bus revving their engine Confused
I'd be absolutely heartbroken finding out that our entire street had been moaning about us behind our backs because they don't like the school bus picking up my disabled child to get her safely to school

I don't think the OP (or the rest of the street according to what she has said) begrudge anything which helps the child or parents. The beeping does not help them. It exists to warn other pedestrians, who are likely in small supply at 6.50 am. Hence the legislation which says they should not disturb residents at this time.

Pgj · 05/11/2022 22:04

Yes. It's a safety feature and the bus driver has already said it can't be turned off. I'm
Not sure what you expect the parents or the bus driver to do. This bus will be picking the child up their whole school life so it's unfortunately something you'll all just have to get used to. If you don't believe the driver you could phone the transport team at the local authority and ask them, their number will be on the local councils page. But I don't think you'll get anywhere.
My little girl gets picked up by school transport. I know they annoy one of our neighbours because the bus blocks the bottom on the street where we live and they try to leave for work at the same time. It's beyond our control and them knowing what time the bus comes means they could just set off 5 minutes earlier if they really can't wait while they wheel her wheel chair on the bus and strap her in, but instead they insist on sitting in their car behind the school bus revving their engine Confused
I'd be absolutely heartbroken finding out that our entire street had been moaning about us behind our backs because they don't like the school bus picking up my disabled child to get her safely to school

Thatsnotmycar · 05/11/2022 22:02

Samcro · 05/11/2022 21:58

Will they fit the child
their equipment
mother children their equipment ??
the answer is no

If you read my post I didn’t comment on what would fit in, did I? I was replying to the poster saying black cabs weren’t suitable for those in a wheelchair because they didn’t have e.g. the correct restraints, when some are suitable and do have the correct restraints. Although, as this is school transport it is unlikely the mother will be travelling too.

Samcro · 05/11/2022 21:58

Thatsnotmycar · 05/11/2022 21:54

There are black cabs that are wheelchair accessible with restraints etc. to allow a wheelchair user to safely travel in their chair. For example, see here.

Will they fit the child
their equipment
mother children their equipment ??
the answer is no

Thatsnotmycar · 05/11/2022 21:54

Facecream · 05/11/2022 21:26

Black cans are completely unsuitable btw.
If the child is in a specialist chair it doesn’t just pop into a cab.
The bus will have special straps to restrain it so it doesn’t tilt etc every time the vehicle changes direction and to protect the users in the event of a crash.
Ever tried taking a buggy in a black cab..?
Now picture something thirty times heavier and with flammable oxygen to boot…

Re the hypothetical emergency vehicles I’m sure the driver knows what to do if that eventually ever transpired.

it’s not nosy neighbours who need to risk assess for the LEA.

And on street parking isn’t a basic right while being safe and being able to access school is.

There are black cabs that are wheelchair accessible with restraints etc. to allow a wheelchair user to safely travel in their chair. For example, see here.

Whinge · 05/11/2022 21:48

Can anyone who has experience of this type of transport explain why the bus needs to beep even when stationary?

Thatsnotmycar · 05/11/2022 21:44

Skiphopbump · 05/11/2022 21:12

@Thatsnotmycar the parents may have been aware of the early
pick up time when the school was chosen. My DS has a longer than recommended journey but that’s because I chose a school that’s 40 miles away on an often busy route.

Many do have journeys longer than the recommended maximum, but if the journey is longer than the recommended journey time because the transport is doing multiple pick ups, as a large bus suggests is the case here, the LA should provide another vehicle to reduce the journey time. This should happen regardless of if the placement was parental preference or not, and if the LA refuse it can be challenged.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 05/11/2022 21:43

Wow what an inconvenience to you 🙄 it’s not as if the child’s parents have enough to worry about every minute of every day with their own child, just get on with it and be grateful you are not up in the early hours getting your disabled child ready for school and you have the time to worry about some beeping.
put a fan on in your room or get up go for a shower.
Stop being selfish.

all if you in your watts app group need to really think about what your are complaining about!

This where reading the whole thread - or at least the OP's posts - before commenting is so important.

You would have seen that OP and other neighbours have never complained about the child's needs in the least. They have thought - and clearly expressed what they are complaining about: lengthy unnecessary beeps, even when the bus is stationary.

The beeps make no difference whatsoever to the child's safety or to their needs being provided for - they are a huge irritant to a whole area of households for no additional benefit whatsoever.

Facecream · 05/11/2022 21:26

Cabs obviously

Facecream · 05/11/2022 21:26

Black cans are completely unsuitable btw.
If the child is in a specialist chair it doesn’t just pop into a cab.
The bus will have special straps to restrain it so it doesn’t tilt etc every time the vehicle changes direction and to protect the users in the event of a crash.
Ever tried taking a buggy in a black cab..?
Now picture something thirty times heavier and with flammable oxygen to boot…

Re the hypothetical emergency vehicles I’m sure the driver knows what to do if that eventually ever transpired.

it’s not nosy neighbours who need to risk assess for the LEA.

And on street parking isn’t a basic right while being safe and being able to access school is.

Paq · 05/11/2022 21:20

The noise is completely unacceptable and avoidable. I used to see several disabled children being picked up in my neighbourhood when walking my dog early in the morning and none of them beeped non-stop for 30 minutes.

Do speak to the council but be aware that they could mangle the message and tell the parents that neighbours have complained behind their back.

Facecream · 05/11/2022 21:15

I have a severely disabled child who is unable to walk. It takes 5-10 minutes to load her and she doesn’t require @a tank of some sort” by which I expect is either an oxygen tank and/or suction equipment which is very heavy and not like a school bag.
My daughter has suction equipment so I do know what that entails.
Whoever is stupid enough to think that someone who requires that level of equipment should wait down the road … no words. Literally none.
id be telling anyone who complained to jog on, if I were the parents.
That poor child and family will hardly relish them leaving the house at 6:50.
The driver was right not to give you details.
Take it up with the LEA.
See how far you get

Skiphopbump · 05/11/2022 21:12

@Thatsnotmycar the parents may have been aware of the early
pick up time when the school was chosen. My DS has a longer than recommended journey but that’s because I chose a school that’s 40 miles away on an often busy route.

x2boys · 05/11/2022 20:52

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/11/2022 20:39

SHould think the bin lorry makes everyone move their bins to where they can easily pick them up from... not an ideal solution.

Black cabs ARE the solution in many places, I didn't pull that idea out my ass, in several places where I have lived and gone to school, the LEA used suitable, adapted black cabs with the right ramps and tie downs and so on (or people carriers) for such collections and yes, it is cheaper for them if they can collect several children in one vehicle, but if the child lives up an inaccessible road for a bus.. then tough shit, they'll need to send a seperate vehicle for them!

My lea mainly use the council mini buses which have a ramp for children in wheelchairs and they also use local mini bus firms,my son isnt in a wheelchair fortunatley hes fully mobile andwhere we live its pedestranised so they pick him up in the carpark infront of our house ,they still get beeped though if they happen to hold people up for the two minutes it takes to get him safely seated on the bus ,ill be damned if people think i should walk him to tje main road and put him at risk for the sake of a coupld of minutes

ProFannyTea · 05/11/2022 20:44

Is this really as traumatic as your daily life gets? You live in a city for crying out loud. You probably complain about dustcarts too.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/11/2022 20:39

SHould think the bin lorry makes everyone move their bins to where they can easily pick them up from... not an ideal solution.

Black cabs ARE the solution in many places, I didn't pull that idea out my ass, in several places where I have lived and gone to school, the LEA used suitable, adapted black cabs with the right ramps and tie downs and so on (or people carriers) for such collections and yes, it is cheaper for them if they can collect several children in one vehicle, but if the child lives up an inaccessible road for a bus.. then tough shit, they'll need to send a seperate vehicle for them!

MMAMPWGHAP · 05/11/2022 20:31

What does the bin lorry do? Does it have to reverse and does it have an alarm too?
Is there a turning circle at the end? Could it be made bigger by a small adjustment to yellow lines?

PrincessArora · 05/11/2022 20:23

while it seems the council may have to look at the provision, I am absolutely disgusted by those posters who have suggested a severely disabled child and their equipment should have an alternative pick up point. You really are despicable. Thank god you don’t have disabled children. I wouldn’t wish the stress, grief and completely overwhelming at all turns life that is parenting a disabled child on anyone. Think yourselves bloody lucky and perhaps have some compassion.

Thatsnotmycar · 05/11/2022 20:18

Depending on what time the school starts you could try a different tact. The maximum recommended travel time for primary aged DC is 45 mins and 1hr15 for secondary DC. If the journey time is longer than that you could help the parents challenge the LA for alternative arrangements. SENTAS can help with transport appeals too.

LAs like to condense transport pick ups on to the least number of vehicles possible because it is cheaper, but if the journey times are longer than the recommended time they should use more vehicles.

It is unacceptable for the solution to the problem to be the parents and child go to the end of the street for pick up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread