Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask the driver of the special needs school bus to be quieter?

245 replies

savagegardener · 05/11/2022 13:27

I know I sound like an arse but hear me out. I live on a long cul-de-sac of terraced houses. It's about 25 houses each side so 50 in total. In London, so lots of houses have been converted to flats. Therefore parking is very difficult and cars are parked on both sides of the road.
Most of the time residents with cars either have to do a 30 point turn in whatever sliver of space is available or just reverse down the road to exit. This is tricky as we're off quite a busy road.
Anyway the family in the middle of the road have a severely disabled child and they've recently been offered a place at a special school a long way away. Every morning the bus comes to collect the child at 6.50 am. It's a long process to get them and all their equipment in and as neighbours we have been very supportive- there's constant car moves each evening so that people who leave later are swapping with people who need to leave earlier as otherwise all the cars on half the street are blocked in for 20-25 mins. We've done it willingly and haven't involved the parents at all in case it stresses them. This has been going on for a few months now and all was fine.
There's now a new bigger bus. Frankly it struggles to get down the road at all but the biggest problem is that when stopped and when reversing it beeps. Not quiet beeps. The loudest beeps ever heard. Someone on the next but one street posted on local fb asking what the noise was! The beeping can be up to 10 mins while loading and the another 10 mins or so as the driver gingerly reverses down the road and waits for a gap in London traffic. One morning the beeping was for nearly 30 mins.
I cannot stress how loud it is. It defeats double glazing, ear plugs, moving bedrooms. It wakes an entire street of people every morning before 7.
Yesterday a group of neighbours called round. Apparently one of them had asked the driver yesterday if he could turn the beep off and he said he wasn't allowed to. He refused to give any details of who employed him. The neighbours now want to go and ask the parents. We aren’t blaming the parents at all- we’d just like to know who runs the bus service to take it up with them. The reason they asked me is because I speak the language of the parents whose English isn’t great.
I don’t know if complaining makes us arses. I can’t imagine how hard their life is- but we also have a lot of shift workers from the local hospital and whose sleep is being destroyed every day. My next door neighbour has 3 kids in junior school who are woken an hour before they need to be. EVERY MORNING.
So should we just all suck it up or say something? Any other suggestions?

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 06/11/2022 18:16

To be clear - my suggestions for contacting the LEA to suggest alternative transport vehicles such as adapted black cabs or people carriers comes from my personal experience travelling with a person in a large power chair, and also from my personal experience travelling in such vehicles in my own extremely large power chair.

If it were the case that the LEA always provides the exact correct, most appropriate transport option for each child, I'd say theres no point speaking to anyone.

But I think any sensible adult knows that is not the case, they will be providing the cheapest workable option - unless those affected by this make it clear it is affecting them, they will continue to do that.

It is possible in many cases, for everyones needs to be met, without affecting the quality of care/service to the disabled child - but if you don't ask, that certainly won't happen!

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 16:57

Transport routes are also often designed to be as cheap as possible for the LA even at the expense of following the legislation, statutory guidance and case law.

If the current bus arrangement does multiple pick ups rather than changing the type of vehicle the suitable vehicle could be the same/similar type, but one that doesn’t do multiple pick up so doesn’t have as long a journey time and a 6.50am pick up. Not for the neighbours’ benefit though but for the child and their family.

Sometimes LAs do send large buses (actual buses as per the OP not minibus) that do multiple pick ups when they could, and should, send several smaller (smaller not small) vehicles due to journey times and individual needs, because sending one large bus is easier/cheaper for the LA than following the law.

YomAsalYomBasal · 06/11/2022 16:42

@StrangerOnline so??
Some children near you travel in adapted taxis. That must be very convenient for all concerned.
It does not mean that all disabled children can. My child cannot.
You have no idea why the previous vehicle has been changed to this minibus. It's ridiculous for you to conclude that because the LA used to send a smaller vehicle that they can do that now. They're unlikely to be sending a big one just for the hell of it!
This thread has opened my eyes to just how ignorant people are to life with a disabled child.

savagegardener · 06/11/2022 16:42

Samcro · 06/11/2022 12:35

the whole thing is imaginary.

Just come back and seen that things have .... devolved.

I cannot imagine why people think this is invented. It's a thread about a beeping school bus and a narrow road. I was expecting 20 responses!

Hopefully there have been enough posters with actual lived experience of transporting children in buses which beep when stationary and when reversing to help people to understand that this is a real situation.

Also not my first post as a few people have said. I name change a lot and am happy for MN to look into me. Been here for 16 years.

I am getting very anxious about this hence the post. Most of the people on the road are nice but some are less nice (and getting very frustrated) and I'm really hoping to keep things civil and not stress the parents.

I can't say enough times that I won't be talking to the parents and have strongly suggested that the other neighbours don't either.

I'll investigate some of the saner solutions suggested tomorrow. Thank you to the people who shared their experiences and who made sensible kind suggestions.

Definitely leaving the thread now though.

OP posts:
StrangerOnline · 06/11/2022 16:12

StrangerOnline · 06/11/2022 15:34

Exactly this - LA need to send a suitable vehicle

Disabled children at a nearby SN unit/school to us that need to bring mobility wheelchairs and other equipment arrive in people carrier sized taxis.

And I did also hear of one child who was provided with a 2nd wheelchair for use on school premises due to difficulties transporting the large electric/motorised one (although I think some fund-raising happened to help with that, so probably not easy to sort)

And sorry - I should have clarified here - the taxis/minibuses have been specifically adapted. They are not just normal people-carrier taxis.

Underhisi · 06/11/2022 16:11

"Exactly this - LA need to send a suitable vehicle"

My son travels on his own in a minibus because this is what his risk assessment says is suitable for his needs. Vehicles are designated by the child's needs not by what neighbours would like.

StrangerOnline · 06/11/2022 16:09

@MolkosTeenageAngst thank you for explaining why the beeping needs to happen when the vehicle is stationary

This kind of explanation might help local people being inconvenienced to have more patience for the situation.

BUT @savagegardener I agree with those PP who said you and your neighbours are trying to be thoughtful and accommodating to this family, by not stressing them out.
Thank you for not speaking to them directly so far. But please do consider a gentle conversation at some point, try and reassure them that their neighbours are understanding and trying to come up with a solution. But I do think they
might be told at some point that complaints have been raised and will be hurt if they are not explained well.

I wish you luck working with LEA to resolve this. Remember the previous vehicle did not have this issue so it IS definitely possible to send suitable transport that doesn’t disturb so many people.

AND FWIW, to MNHQ - I don’t agree with the trouble-makers upthread saying this is ‘ableist’. The OP had a very genuine and sensitive question to ask for opinions on

StrangerOnline · 06/11/2022 15:34

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/11/2022 18:15

This is not about the safety of the disabled child this is about the LEA sending out an unsuitable vehicle, and they will continue to do so until they're stopped!

There are alternatives, a bus that doesn't have a stupidly loud warning beep, a black cab - both very common alternatives too though the black cab probably costs the LEA more.

I should think a complaint to the LEA about the size/loudness of the bus and suggestion of a black cab is the appropriate route to go. No need to compromise on safety, but also, absolutely no need to inconvenience and wake up an entire street to get one kid to school!

Exactly this - LA need to send a suitable vehicle

Disabled children at a nearby SN unit/school to us that need to bring mobility wheelchairs and other equipment arrive in people carrier sized taxis.

And I did also hear of one child who was provided with a 2nd wheelchair for use on school premises due to difficulties transporting the large electric/motorised one (although I think some fund-raising happened to help with that, so probably not easy to sort)

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 15:17

My suggestion of contacting the Director of Children’s Services wasn’t in relation to the OP, it was in response to the poster I quoted who said they know multiple parents where the LA are unlawfully failing to provide transport and thus failing to provide education and the provision in s.F of the EHCP.

Emailing the Director of Children’s Services and threatening to begin judicial review proceedings is what is recommended by education legal experts, including IPSEA and SOSSEN, in order for the child and family to receive the support and services they are legally entitled to. My suggestion had nothing to do with the neighbours.

Facecream · 06/11/2022 14:55

Oh this thread is still going…
Its weird how the people who think the neighbours are lovely and caring and suggesting the family write to children’s Services .. for the sake of the neighbours 🙄🙄🙄🙄.

They don’t speak English properly ffs

wombat1a · 06/11/2022 14:25

CraftyGin · 05/11/2022 20:05

It would be reasonable for them to ask for the beeps to be turned off given the early hour.

To someone who said they can't be turned off, that's not true.

When I was doing my minibus test, they turned the beeps off so they would not annoy the same neighbours several times a day.

I think you can be very certain that your examiner was keeping a (2nd) very close eye out behind for people who didn't realise you were reversing. Something most LEA bus drivers don't have. A different situation to the one described here.

organisedmother · 06/11/2022 14:17

👏

MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/11/2022 14:02

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/11/2022 12:36

It will beep when it reverses, but also as the rear lift is being operated up and down.

But why? Large vehicles beep when they're reversing, as the back will be in the driver's blind spot; but presumably there is somebody there loading/unloading the equipment on, who could warn anybody about to walk into it, so why the need for a third-party beep as well?

I mean, we're just reaching now aren't we. Why do we need to pretend something offence is painted on the side of the bus.

It was an analogy - not a great one but the best I could think of as so many people on this thread really cannot seem to separate the proper provision of the required service for the disabled child from an arbitrary anti-social measure enacted by the provider of the service that in no way makes any difference whatsoever to the child.

The needs of the disabled child are paramount.
The needs of the other residents are also highly important.
The need for a bus provider to arbitrarily cause a wholly unnecessary early-morning anti-social nuisance is non-existent.

The tail-lift beeping when it is in use is a safety feature because vulnerable people (wheelchair users) are being placed onto the lift and manoeuvred up and down. There are no safety clamps on these lifts so there is a risk of injury were the wheelchair to move and fall on/ off and not all wheelchair users will have the capacity to keep themselves safe, for example some could remove their own brakes or try to self-propel off the lift or try to operate the switches to the lift themselves. The beeping starts whenever the lift is ejected from the back of the vehicle, so it will also alert the driver should they fail to store it correctly after use so they don’t start driving with the lift sticking out from the vehicle or it will alert should the lift become dislodged and self-eject during transit so that the driver can pull over and secure it. It would obviously be dangerous for the lift to be ejected when driving which can happen due to either user error storing it or due to a sudden fault with the lift or vehicle.

The beeping as a safety feature alerts anybody around the vehicle to the fact that the lift is ejected and in motion so that if it is being operated unsafely or unexpectedly it is more likely the driver (who typically will be the person responsible for ensuring it is being operated safely) is aware. To turn off this safety feature could therefore be dangerous if it meant that the lift was ejected from the back of the vehicle during transit and the driver was unaware or if somebody without the training was to start operating the lift with a wheelchair user on it unsafely without the driver being aware.

Often on such vehicles the beeping can also occur even when the lift is not in motion if the back doors are open or have not been shut correctly. Wheelchair users are often clamped into the back of such vehicles whilst still in their wheelchairs and the back doors flinging open during transit could obviously be dangerous so as a safety feature the doors will beep whenever open to reduce the risk of driving off without the doors properly closed. The problem with turning off these safety features even temporarily is that humans are fallible and if every day the feature is being turned off sooner or later somebody will forget to turn it back on and an incident where the doors are open or the lift is partially ejected etc could occur and cause an accident which is likely to result in a far worse injury than just a bit of noise disruption.

Underhisi · 06/11/2022 13:50

It's an interesting first post.

PrincessArora · 06/11/2022 13:46

Still allowing this one to run then MN? Unbelievable that the clear nastiness and selfishness of those commenting on families who are clearly in a much less fortunate position than they is allowed. Ableism at its worst and it’s being tolerated? All of you commenting, particularly those around alternative pickup spots or making assumptions about what a child may or may not need when you know nothing about them (and nor does the OP), is nothing short of behaviour which is abhorrent and obviously representative of society. I thought we had moved past Victorian beliefs but clearly not all are entitled to the same opportunities in life such as education eh. Thank god your only concern in life is a bit of noise ffs.

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 13:33

Come on MN pull this thread

some nasty posters are being allowed to spread their spitefulness this isn’t what mn is about

there was a similar thread about two weeks ago how people were being inconvenienced

ChimneyPot · 06/11/2022 13:07

My neighbours child is picked up by a minibus. There is an electronic wheelchair and equipment lift that comes out the back and it beeps continuously while these are operating.
The council have put a very long wheelchair parking spot outside the house and I have never seen anyone else park in it but if that became an issue presumably they could just put in more spots.
It solves the blocking the road issue but not the noise one.
But bin lorries operate noisily in the street early most mornings and we have all become accustomed to the noise. It is part of urban living.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/11/2022 12:39

the whole thing is imaginary.

If you're omnipresent and have insider knowledge that this is the case, then report it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 06/11/2022 12:36

It will beep when it reverses, but also as the rear lift is being operated up and down.

But why? Large vehicles beep when they're reversing, as the back will be in the driver's blind spot; but presumably there is somebody there loading/unloading the equipment on, who could warn anybody about to walk into it, so why the need for a third-party beep as well?

I mean, we're just reaching now aren't we. Why do we need to pretend something offence is painted on the side of the bus.

It was an analogy - not a great one but the best I could think of as so many people on this thread really cannot seem to separate the proper provision of the required service for the disabled child from an arbitrary anti-social measure enacted by the provider of the service that in no way makes any difference whatsoever to the child.

The needs of the disabled child are paramount.
The needs of the other residents are also highly important.
The need for a bus provider to arbitrarily cause a wholly unnecessary early-morning anti-social nuisance is non-existent.

Samcro · 06/11/2022 12:35

the whole thing is imaginary.

NamelessNancy · 06/11/2022 12:29

Breziegrass · 06/11/2022 12:05

@NamelessNancy so you deliberately missed out paragraph 2

"2) The provisions of paragraph (1)(a) do not apply in respect of the sounding of a reversing alarm when the vehicle to which it is fitted is about to move backwards and its engine is running." 🙄

Also people who are making shit up about blocking ambulances and fire engines ect. iIn your fantasy world so you think the bus will just refuse to move or work with them? 🙄

Lastly those who say there needs to be a compromise on reversing beeps, how many incidents or deaths caused buy tiring this safety feature is enough of a compromise 1,2 or more.

Seriously some people on here really need to get a grip on reality.

I didn't! That refers to 1a not 1b and I did say I may be misinterpreting. Either way the beepers are a nuisance at that hour and are not benefitting the disabled child or family. Such an early collection seems really unfair to them too. It's not unreasonable for the residents to want peace. As I've said elsewhere it seems to me that the street needs double yellow lines.

Icedlatteplease · 06/11/2022 12:17

Another one who doesn't see how the OP are kind and considerate neighbours.

The rearranging of the cars isn't for the disabled child or her parents benefit. It's for other neighbours benefit so they won't be inconvenienced getting to work.

The only thing the OP has done is complain about a transport company doing their job for a disabled service user.

I'm sorry but that to ne really isn't the definition of kind an considrate, I'd call that being an arse.

It's highly unlikely the LEA is going to send alternative transport. Chances are if the LEA are collecting at 6.30, they are already (breaking the law) by sending one bus for all the kids they have to collect for the school. But unless a child's parent takes that to court, for the child's benefit I very much doubt anything will change.

x2boys · 06/11/2022 12:08

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 12:07

Maybe you should read the the thread again becsuse lots of peoole havent bern ressonable ,many have been. downright unpleasant.

Most have been eminently reasonable and extremely sympathetic.

Clearly we are reading different threads .

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 12:07

Maybe you should read the the thread again becsuse lots of peoole havent bern ressonable ,many have been. downright unpleasant.

Most have been eminently reasonable and extremely sympathetic.

Breziegrass · 06/11/2022 12:05

NamelessNancy · 05/11/2022 16:58

I might be misinterpreting but I understand this to mean reversing beepers should not be used before 7am.

"Use of audible warning instruments
99.—(1) Subject to the following paragraphs, no person shall sound, or cause or permit to be sounded, any horn, gong, bell or siren fitted to or carried on a vehicle which is—

(a)stationary on a road, at any time, other than at times of danger due to another moving vehicle on or near the road; or
(b)in motion on a restricted road, between 23.30 hours and 07.00 hours in the following morning."

From: www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1986/1078/regulation/99/made

I think the difficulty and safety issues of parents having to take a severely disabled child to a pick up point would also be totally unacceptable. As the road is being blocked for emergency vehicles the only realistic options would be to double yellow a portion of road or change the collecting vehicle.

@NamelessNancy so you deliberately missed out paragraph 2

"2) The provisions of paragraph (1)(a) do not apply in respect of the sounding of a reversing alarm when the vehicle to which it is fitted is about to move backwards and its engine is running." 🙄

Also people who are making shit up about blocking ambulances and fire engines ect. iIn your fantasy world so you think the bus will just refuse to move or work with them? 🙄

Lastly those who say there needs to be a compromise on reversing beeps, how many incidents or deaths caused buy tiring this safety feature is enough of a compromise 1,2 or more.

Seriously some people on here really need to get a grip on reality.