Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask the driver of the special needs school bus to be quieter?

245 replies

savagegardener · 05/11/2022 13:27

I know I sound like an arse but hear me out. I live on a long cul-de-sac of terraced houses. It's about 25 houses each side so 50 in total. In London, so lots of houses have been converted to flats. Therefore parking is very difficult and cars are parked on both sides of the road.
Most of the time residents with cars either have to do a 30 point turn in whatever sliver of space is available or just reverse down the road to exit. This is tricky as we're off quite a busy road.
Anyway the family in the middle of the road have a severely disabled child and they've recently been offered a place at a special school a long way away. Every morning the bus comes to collect the child at 6.50 am. It's a long process to get them and all their equipment in and as neighbours we have been very supportive- there's constant car moves each evening so that people who leave later are swapping with people who need to leave earlier as otherwise all the cars on half the street are blocked in for 20-25 mins. We've done it willingly and haven't involved the parents at all in case it stresses them. This has been going on for a few months now and all was fine.
There's now a new bigger bus. Frankly it struggles to get down the road at all but the biggest problem is that when stopped and when reversing it beeps. Not quiet beeps. The loudest beeps ever heard. Someone on the next but one street posted on local fb asking what the noise was! The beeping can be up to 10 mins while loading and the another 10 mins or so as the driver gingerly reverses down the road and waits for a gap in London traffic. One morning the beeping was for nearly 30 mins.
I cannot stress how loud it is. It defeats double glazing, ear plugs, moving bedrooms. It wakes an entire street of people every morning before 7.
Yesterday a group of neighbours called round. Apparently one of them had asked the driver yesterday if he could turn the beep off and he said he wasn't allowed to. He refused to give any details of who employed him. The neighbours now want to go and ask the parents. We aren’t blaming the parents at all- we’d just like to know who runs the bus service to take it up with them. The reason they asked me is because I speak the language of the parents whose English isn’t great.
I don’t know if complaining makes us arses. I can’t imagine how hard their life is- but we also have a lot of shift workers from the local hospital and whose sleep is being destroyed every day. My next door neighbour has 3 kids in junior school who are woken an hour before they need to be. EVERY MORNING.
So should we just all suck it up or say something? Any other suggestions?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 06/11/2022 22:29

As everything happened all at the same time I'm unlikely to ever find out whether or not the complaints had anything to do with the change of pick up/drop off. I don't really talk to the neighbours anymore especially since they appeared to know things about us before we did iykwim.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 22:25

It may have still been over the recommended travel time but without 4 other pick ups it would have been less which was my point. Even if over the recommended maximum, as many are, it should be as short as possible.

And it may not apply to the situation in the OP, but it is worth mentioning to the family in case the transport is doing multiple pick ups. Not for the neighbours’ sake but for the family.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 06/11/2022 22:15

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 20:38

This is what I mean. What happened to you shouldn’t happen. They LA should provide another transport so that it isn’t doing 6 stops and making the maximum journey time unreasonably long. You shouldn’t have been forced to another pick up point however short lived it was.

If the 6.50am pick up time in the OP is because the bus is doing multiple pick ups the current arrangements are unlawful. Transport should be non-stressful and not be longer than the maximum recommended travel time because of multiple pick ups. The transport arrangements should change for the child and the family, not the neighbours.

You're right ideally it shouldn't have been like that, initially he was picked up at 7 - 7.10 but the multiple pick ups weren't the problem it was the motorway journey that caused the issues, major repairs, reduced lanes and lowered speed limits over an extremely long period of time meant that transport needed to start the pick ups earlier and earlier and the change in pick up point probably had more to do with planned roadworks in our city that was making things even worse as opposed to the neighbours complaining. The journey back from school was just as bad if not worse and DS arrived home vetween 5.30 and 6pm. Even without multiple pick ups/ drop offs the travelling times still exceeded the recommended travel times. Since there was no other suitable alternative provision available the choice was go with the flow or keep him at home.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/11/2022 21:23

For those saying the LA should change it so that the child isn’t sharing with other children, it might be they are already on their own bus. OP states the child has got a place at a school a long way away, in special education that could quite easily outside of their local authority. I work in an independent special school and the journey for some of our day students can be 2+ hours each way as they have Ben placed out of area. Very very few of our students travel in shared minibuses as different LEAs are funding the transport but several of them will be getting on transport before 7am to make it to school before 9:00 in rush hour. Unfortunately they are usually funded places out of area because none of the local special schools can adequately meet their educational (or sometimes health/ behavioural etc) needs so it’s not as easy as finding a closer school.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 20:38

*5 stops

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 20:38

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 06/11/2022 20:34

DS used to get picked up at between 6.40 to 6.50, first of 5 pick ups then on to a horrendous motorway and country road journey, they rarely got to school before 8.30 and there were a number of occasions when they arrived at school after registration. A couple of neighbours did complain about the noise and an alternative pick up point was trialled, that meant that we had to be there before 6.40 outside of somebody else's house in all weathers, needless to say they weren't happy about it either. Pick up was changed back to our house

This is what I mean. What happened to you shouldn’t happen. They LA should provide another transport so that it isn’t doing 6 stops and making the maximum journey time unreasonably long. You shouldn’t have been forced to another pick up point however short lived it was.

If the 6.50am pick up time in the OP is because the bus is doing multiple pick ups the current arrangements are unlawful. Transport should be non-stressful and not be longer than the maximum recommended travel time because of multiple pick ups. The transport arrangements should change for the child and the family, not the neighbours.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 06/11/2022 20:34

DS used to get picked up at between 6.40 to 6.50, first of 5 pick ups then on to a horrendous motorway and country road journey, they rarely got to school before 8.30 and there were a number of occasions when they arrived at school after registration. A couple of neighbours did complain about the noise and an alternative pick up point was trialled, that meant that we had to be there before 6.40 outside of somebody else's house in all weathers, needless to say they weren't happy about it either. Pick up was changed back to our house

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 20:33

I’m not the post police it was what it sounded like!

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 20:31

Sorry post police, it’s because I quoted them. I should have specified that my reply to them was the first part of my post, that last bit was a general comment to anyone who hadn’t realised what some families deal with on a daily basis.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 20:27

Just a little insight there as to how poorly some of these children are and what some families have to deal with!

No, I’m not assuming, ^^ this makes it sound like you felt they needed some “insight” because they disagreed with you.

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 20:22

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 19:04

I know what you were doing but your last sentence assumed because they didn’t agree with you they needed some “insight”.

No, you’re assuming that’s what it meant.

mrshoho · 06/11/2022 20:00

Finding this hard to believe that the child's picked up at 6.50am for a start.

x2boys · 06/11/2022 19:16

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 18:52

I work in an SEN school. The children with the most complex needs tend to come on buses rather than taxis as they may need treatment such as suction or rescue medication while travelling. They have a home chair that they come to school in then they are transferred into their class chairs (also other equipment accessed throughout the day). Some of these children have oxygen tanks and suction machines that have to travel with them.

Just a little insight there as to how poorly some of these children are and what some families have to deal with!

Quite my child goes to such a school fortunatley hes a very healthy child with no mobilty issues just severe autism/ learning disabllities,but there are kids at his school with profound and multiple disabillities ,who are on oxygen and are tube fed etc and people are suggesting such children not be picked up from home ,becsuse the noise upseta the neighbours.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 19:04

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 19:02

I was trying to make the poster that I quoted aware that giving a child rescue medication or suction while in a taxi/smaller vehicle might not be possible. The children at our school with these needs require a bus because they have two carers on board trained to do this rather than just one passenger assistant.

I genuinely wasn’t aware of all this before I worked here so I’m sure many other people aren’t either.

I know what you were doing but your last sentence assumed because they didn’t agree with you they needed some “insight”.

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 19:02

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 18:58

Just because people don’t agree with you doesn’t mean they don’t have any insight into what life is like with a disabled DC with complex needs.

I had a DC with complex needs who travelled in a wheelchair with oxygen/NIV, suction, infusion pump, feed pump... I also have another DC who has a large SN buggy, sometimes with a feed pump, other times he just has overnight feeds.

I was trying to make the poster that I quoted aware that giving a child rescue medication or suction while in a taxi/smaller vehicle might not be possible. The children at our school with these needs require a bus because they have two carers on board trained to do this rather than just one passenger assistant.

I genuinely wasn’t aware of all this before I worked here so I’m sure many other people aren’t either.

SnarkyBag · 06/11/2022 19:00

StrangerOnline · 06/11/2022 15:34

Exactly this - LA need to send a suitable vehicle

Disabled children at a nearby SN unit/school to us that need to bring mobility wheelchairs and other equipment arrive in people carrier sized taxis.

And I did also hear of one child who was provided with a 2nd wheelchair for use on school premises due to difficulties transporting the large electric/motorised one (although I think some fund-raising happened to help with that, so probably not easy to sort)

Well there’s the answer the op and her neighbours can fundraise for the several thousands of pounds a specialist wheelchair costs so there can be a spare one at school! Then they can keep fundraising to replace it once the child outgrows it. I can assure you the chances of the NHS finding anything towards a second wheelchair to keep on school premises is close to zero.

”probably not that easy to sort” is the understatement of the year! Honestly people on here are clueless.

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 18:58

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 18:52

I work in an SEN school. The children with the most complex needs tend to come on buses rather than taxis as they may need treatment such as suction or rescue medication while travelling. They have a home chair that they come to school in then they are transferred into their class chairs (also other equipment accessed throughout the day). Some of these children have oxygen tanks and suction machines that have to travel with them.

Just a little insight there as to how poorly some of these children are and what some families have to deal with!

Just because people don’t agree with you doesn’t mean they don’t have any insight into what life is like with a disabled DC with complex needs.

I had a DC with complex needs who travelled in a wheelchair with oxygen/NIV, suction, infusion pump, feed pump... I also have another DC who has a large SN buggy, sometimes with a feed pump, other times he just has overnight feeds.

Wombatbum · 06/11/2022 18:52

StrangerOnline · 06/11/2022 15:34

Exactly this - LA need to send a suitable vehicle

Disabled children at a nearby SN unit/school to us that need to bring mobility wheelchairs and other equipment arrive in people carrier sized taxis.

And I did also hear of one child who was provided with a 2nd wheelchair for use on school premises due to difficulties transporting the large electric/motorised one (although I think some fund-raising happened to help with that, so probably not easy to sort)

I work in an SEN school. The children with the most complex needs tend to come on buses rather than taxis as they may need treatment such as suction or rescue medication while travelling. They have a home chair that they come to school in then they are transferred into their class chairs (also other equipment accessed throughout the day). Some of these children have oxygen tanks and suction machines that have to travel with them.

Just a little insight there as to how poorly some of these children are and what some families have to deal with!

Thatsnotmycar · 06/11/2022 18:44

I certainly don’t think the LA have “a vast array of vehicles to choose from”, but I do know LAs act unlawfully all the time unless challenged, and if they don’t have enough suitable in house transport to meet demand whilst working within the legislation, statutory guidance and case law meet they should put it out to tender.

You’re right they aren’t going to change it for the neighbours, but they should change the transport arrangements for the child and the family if the pick up time is because the bus is doing multiple pick ups because to have the current arrangements because there are multiple pick ups is unlawful.

Spikeyball · 06/11/2022 18:41

LA transport departments don't do reasonable, only what they absolutely legally have to.

Spikeyball · 06/11/2022 18:32

Some people seem to think the transport department have a vast array of vehicles to choose from so they can just pick another one if a neighbour decides they don't like it.

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/11/2022 18:30

No I suspect they have risk assessed, route planned and costed out the cheapest possible method.

It may not be possible to send individual transport, but if you don't ask, you absolutely don't know - if half a street are inconvenienced and disrupted by it, yes its reasonable for the LEA to look at what they're doing.

x2boys · 06/11/2022 18:27

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/11/2022 18:16

To be clear - my suggestions for contacting the LEA to suggest alternative transport vehicles such as adapted black cabs or people carriers comes from my personal experience travelling with a person in a large power chair, and also from my personal experience travelling in such vehicles in my own extremely large power chair.

If it were the case that the LEA always provides the exact correct, most appropriate transport option for each child, I'd say theres no point speaking to anyone.

But I think any sensible adult knows that is not the case, they will be providing the cheapest workable option - unless those affected by this make it clear it is affecting them, they will continue to do that.

It is possible in many cases, for everyones needs to be met, without affecting the quality of care/service to the disabled child - but if you don't ask, that certainly won't happen!

Do you not think the lea will have risk assessed the most suitable type of transport?
That is literally the job of transport ,to risk assess ,plan routes etc
Do you think they really need randomers phoning them up " advising them"?

Spikeyball · 06/11/2022 18:25

The LA are not going to change the transport they provide because neighbours are complaining.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 06/11/2022 18:21

AND FWIW, to MNHQ - I don’t agree with the trouble-makers upthread saying this is ‘ableist’. The OP had a very genuine and sensitive question to ask for opinions on

Of course it isn’t. This thread really has attracted some posters who seem out for a fight when none is really needed.