Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mexican-themed NYE party - racist, right?

491 replies

BobLobla · 05/11/2022 13:20

Just been invited by very good friends to their NYE party which promises to have a Mexican theme and everyone must wear a long droopy moustache and a sombrero. Already I am cringing as I think this is pretty racist. Don't think I’ll go… but do I say something privately to my friends about the fact that this seems really off? Do I just dip out and not say anything to avoid awkwardness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Scianel · 06/11/2022 15:39

You honestly cannot see how fucked up it would be to dress up as a bad stereotype?!

Meh. I'm in Scotland where, as previously mentioned, the See You Jimmy hats are sold to tourists. I don't see the difference in particular.

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 15:38

Again how does it impact anyone not to wear a fancy dress outfit or doesn’t does it

are you telling me that Mexicans who don’t care are actively encouraging people to wear this outfit ? No they just don’t care or find it offensive

we used to dress up in what we called Red Indian outfits having no knowledge of what was considered offensive now I know different

I used to use the term oriental I was pulled up and I apologised I asked my friend who is from Vietnam if she was offended by it she never heard of this and liked the term but I still stopped using it

I can remember the called debates about p*ki not being offence as it’s just shortening the word for Pakistani and of that is offence then so is Brit 🙄 this was on MN

do we not learn more and take more information on and make decisions then ? That seems to be what many people do

Schroedingersimmigrant · 06/11/2022 15:30

Well this thread just ended literally any dress up 😁

PBSam · 06/11/2022 15:28

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 15:26

It’s dressing up for one night

yes I think it’s better to listen to those that expressed why it’s offensive and take that on it doesn’t impact my life to not dress up in a fancy dress outfit that many find offensive does it you PBSam ?

But many Mexicans don't care and seem to like it. Why do they not matter?

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 15:26

It’s dressing up for one night

yes I think it’s better to listen to those that expressed why it’s offensive and take that on it doesn’t impact my life to not dress up in a fancy dress outfit that many find offensive does it you PBSam ?

Schroedingersimmigrant · 06/11/2022 15:24

PBSam · 06/11/2022 15:20

Someone will always be offended so shall we all just do nothing to be on the safe side?

Tbh this would be the only solution if we should follow only one side. However hyperbolic that may sound

PBSam · 06/11/2022 15:20

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 15:18

and how does it impact anyone not being able to dress up in a costume for one night

its doesn’t at all

regardless of how split Mexican people are on this or even if they have an opinion on the matter some find it offensive

but if you don’t care about mocking someone then go ahead

Someone will always be offended so shall we all just do nothing to be on the safe side?

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 15:18

and how does it impact anyone not being able to dress up in a costume for one night

its doesn’t at all

regardless of how split Mexican people are on this or even if they have an opinion on the matter some find it offensive

but if you don’t care about mocking someone then go ahead

elp30 · 06/11/2022 15:18

NameChanger001500 · 05/11/2022 13:55

I wouldnt see it as racist, its fancy dress 🤷‍♀️ and its Mexican themed. If I was invited to a Mexican themed fancy dress party I would 100% wear a moustache, one of the poncho things and a hat.

Honestly, I think most people just like to be offended over things these days

Are you for fucking real?!

I am Mexican-American.
My father and all four of my grandparents were Mexican Citizens.

You honestly cannot see how fucked up it would be to dress up as a bad stereotype?!

NormaTheWife · 06/11/2022 15:16

Sandra1984 · 06/11/2022 11:27

So Frida Kahlo represents Mexican culture but the sombrero and moustache doesn’t ? I’m lost here. A party host asking everyone to come dressed as Frida Kahlo is as weird as asking everyone to come dressed in a sombrero and moustache.

That would be a drag party then?

Schroedingersimmigrant · 06/11/2022 15:14

You are listening to only one side though. lots of Mexicans also spoke for it and joke about it themselves. Not so long ago stood up for Speedy Gonzales.

No group will ever wholly agree, but both could be discussed

NormaTheWife · 06/11/2022 15:13

pewtypie · 06/11/2022 07:12

@NutellaEllaElla it’s harmful peddling stereotypes of minorities. It may just be silliness for you but stereotypes harm minorities.

Does that mean that all those people who come to Scotland and buy tartan clothing/kilts/shawls etc and Hey Jimmy hats are peddling a stereotype of a minority?

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 15:05

How can you compare a dressing up outfit with debates over such issues as rape or Brexit this impacts people lives hugely

Mexican people have spoken out on why they find dressing up as the stereotypical Mexican as offence and a mockery why isn’t they enough to think well it seemed fun but I don’t wish to cause offence so I won’t

how does it impact anyones life not to wear this fancy dress to a party for one night it simply doesn’t if in doubt just don’t

want to discuss discrimination and debate the subject of the impact of discrimination listen first to those who are discriminated against have ti say before making up your mind on what you think is discrimination

LargeHadronCollidHER · 06/11/2022 15:05

YANBU and I’d feel the same as you and refuse to go

But this is one of those MN threads that highlights how far we need to go around racism and cultural appropriation, it’s easy to forget how bigoted some on here are

Schroedingersimmigrant · 06/11/2022 15:01

Arayes · 06/11/2022 14:38

Everything should be up for debate? Next up, lets debate "the Holocaust, did it really happen? MN weighs in" followed by "Rape, when is it a good thing?"

No, not everything is up for debate, ffs. We don't move forward as a society by pretending we need your opinion on things everyone with half a brain already knows for sure. Your thoughts on such things are not needed or wanted.

Well yeha probably for english speaking ones with the history.... Yeah.

Just an fyi, other societies may have different opinions and practices and allowances.

So you know, discussing things usually leads to share of information and opinions and development.

SandAndSea · 06/11/2022 14:54

Arayes · 06/11/2022 13:53

Your kind of comedy being Jim Davidson and Roy Chubby Brown, one can only assume.
Comedy moustaches and sombreros went out with the fucking ark.

Not at all but I think it's interesting that you went straight to insulting me. It's not the best argument really, is it?!

falllakes · 06/11/2022 14:48

Not debating things properly is how you end up with decisions like Brexit.
Everything should be up for debate, otherwise ideas just grow unchecked in dark corners.
Challenging people, assessing evidence and listening to what others are saying is really vital in functioning democracy.

FrippEnos · 06/11/2022 14:44

Arayes

The holocaust should be debated if only to show the stupidity of those that don't believe that it happened.

Rape should be debated so that the myths surrounding it can be challenged.

Racism needs debating as various people are trying to change the meaning to exclude an entire group of people.

Your thoughts on such things are not needed or wanted.

and this ^ is just censorship and oppression.

Guiltycat · 06/11/2022 14:44

@Arayes did you never experience a debate club?

Yes, absolutely. I would welcome open debate on ANY of those topics you mentioned, and more.

Because by using facts and evidence you can expose ignorance. If done in a respectful enough way and you can actually change peoples minds.

Sticking your fingers in your ears and screaming ‘lalala I don’t want to hear you because you are wrong’ only entrenches polarised views further. It also makes it look like you are arguing from a position of ignorance, that you don’t really understand why you hold your own opinion, or that your opinion cannot stand up to any argument at all.

It helps no one. Least if all the people who are supposedly being ‘protected’ by such a method.

Arayes · 06/11/2022 14:38

Guiltycat · 06/11/2022 14:33

We don't need to debate it

Poisonous attitude. Everything, and I mean everything, should always be up for debate. Differing opinion is extremely valuable, not something to be scorned. Closing your mind to any other way than the current ‘right’ way is ignorant and dangerous.

Even things found offensive, distasteful, disgusting should always be open to debate.

Because that’s how we move forward as a society. Not one idea or current social norm should be cast in stone because there could always be improvement, revision or reinforcement of why something is good/bad.

Everything should be up for debate? Next up, lets debate "the Holocaust, did it really happen? MN weighs in" followed by "Rape, when is it a good thing?"

No, not everything is up for debate, ffs. We don't move forward as a society by pretending we need your opinion on things everyone with half a brain already knows for sure. Your thoughts on such things are not needed or wanted.

Hellsmovie · 06/11/2022 14:37

Guiltycat · 06/11/2022 14:25

The first time a group of Asian men decides little girls can be their sex slaves because they are only white and therefore disposable trash - that is racism.

Couldn’t agree more. I avoid a particular section of this forum. The section is ‘for’ me, but some of the posts are infuriatingly hypocritical, as full of hate and prejudice as those they supposedly despise.

But it is ok. Because it is against white people.

There are many white peoples who have also been oppressed and discriminated against. CRT and the divisiveness/racism it in itself has sown has a lot to answer for. In the 90’s I actually like we were making more progression towards harmony and that we’ve since gone backwards.

I take a plod across to that section occasionally.There are a couple posters who only start a discussion on certain themes with purposefully goady titles. Thankfully a majority in that section dont.

Guiltycat · 06/11/2022 14:33

We don't need to debate it

Poisonous attitude. Everything, and I mean everything, should always be up for debate. Differing opinion is extremely valuable, not something to be scorned. Closing your mind to any other way than the current ‘right’ way is ignorant and dangerous.

Even things found offensive, distasteful, disgusting should always be open to debate.

Because that’s how we move forward as a society. Not one idea or current social norm should be cast in stone because there could always be improvement, revision or reinforcement of why something is good/bad.

millio · 06/11/2022 14:32

Would the people who think it's fine be happy to attend a Jewish-themed party where the dress code is mock-Orthodox Jewish garb including fake facial hair? Or an Indian-themed party with stereotypical Indian outfits? If not, then why is a Mexican-themed party any different? There may be some Mexicans who are fine with it, sure, but I doubt all Mexicans are happy to see their culture portrayed as a sombrero-and-moustache stereotype.

Also, if the pictures end up on social media forever you might find yourself being accused of racism down the line (like Justin Trudeau with his teenage blackface photos).

Arayes · 06/11/2022 14:29

Schroedingersimmigrant · 06/11/2022 14:22

The good question is "who will it be causing offense to?".
Because most talks of "i would find x offensive" don't come from x culture but from certain white people.
What if they and the x culture disagree on what's offensive? Who should people listen to then?

We don't need to debate it. Most of the world already gets that wearing other peoples history and culture as a costume is not ok. Clearly plenty of MNers have yet to get there, but no-one needs your debate on it.

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 14:27

some Mexicans have spoken about finding dressing up as a stereotype offence it’s doesn’t matter how many

isnt that enough

No one is going to loose out on not dressing up are they