Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mexican-themed NYE party - racist, right?

491 replies

BobLobla · 05/11/2022 13:20

Just been invited by very good friends to their NYE party which promises to have a Mexican theme and everyone must wear a long droopy moustache and a sombrero. Already I am cringing as I think this is pretty racist. Don't think I’ll go… but do I say something privately to my friends about the fact that this seems really off? Do I just dip out and not say anything to avoid awkwardness?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
Hellsmovie · 07/11/2022 09:54

Arayes · 06/11/2022 22:14

Christ. "I meat well" isn't an excuse. If you wear blackface but honestly thought you were just "expressing appreciation", would that be just fine?
I think you know it would not.

I think there is a 0.01% time where it's ok to to do it. But you would have to explain it every 5 minutes . So I wouldnt based on that

FrippEnos · 07/11/2022 07:01

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:21

I was paraphrasing as you well know. I note the definition you posted doesn’t list clothing though? 🤔

The poster also doesn't acknowledge the flaw in their own argument, in that their definition says unacknowledged or inappropriate adoption so intention is important in their deffinition.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 03:56

Coyoacan · 07/11/2022 01:07

I’m being serious. General Zapata is a national hero in Mexico

So, you've upped the ante. You are not just in favour of poking fun at generic Mexicans, you have to aim the insult at one of our national heroes.

And no, @falllakes, Mexicans do not dress up as Zapata or as anyone else on Independence day

I’m not in favour of poking fun at anyone nor insulting any national hero. That’s why I reacted the way I did to that posters laughing emoji saying I was serious.

falllakes · 07/11/2022 01:16

They absolutely did in the area of Mexico I lived in, or specifically the dc did
Or to be ultra specific they wore the same costume.
Every year the dc went into school in traditional costumes. For the boys this meant having sombreros, drawn on or fake mustaches, etc.

Then people put up Facebook posts on their dc in their costumes.
I'm not stating that this is universal but it was what happened where I lived.
We actually lived close to the center of the uprising for independence so it was a big celebration.
So I'm absolutely fine with people stating that doesn't happen in their part of Mexico, it is a very large country but it absolutely happens where we were. That is why I mentioned it.

Coyoacan · 07/11/2022 01:07

I’m being serious. General Zapata is a national hero in Mexico

So, you've upped the ante. You are not just in favour of poking fun at generic Mexicans, you have to aim the insult at one of our national heroes.

And no, @falllakes, Mexicans do not dress up as Zapata or as anyone else on Independence day

falllakes · 07/11/2022 00:52

He is and that is why Mexican dc dress in that way on Independence Day.
It doesn't mean Brits should do it but it is absolutely part of Mexican culture.

Discovereads · 07/11/2022 00:46

NormaTheWife · 07/11/2022 00:38

who has a sombrero and a droopy moustache 😂😂😂😂

I’m being serious. General Zapata is a national hero in Mexico.

MangyInseam · 07/11/2022 00:43

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:51

Not really, blackface is far worse because it’s not cultural, and so it is always offensive. There is no such thing as appreciative blackface is there?

And a Sioux Chieftains bonnet is more than a headdress, which is why it’s always offensive to wear one. It would be offensive for even a Sioux to wear one if they hadn’t earned it.

Can’t really compare either of those to wearing a sombrero 🤨

I think that really depends on how you define blackface. It once had a pretty limited and specific sense, you could argue that it was always intended to be rude/mocking - though it's not as cut and dried always as people think.

But if you are talking about an actor in a village theater in 1950 playing Othello, that's quite a different scenario, no one considered actors acting in serious roles the same thing. Actors in the theater often use all kinds of physical modifications to play roles and skin colour was not seen as different. It now gets classed as blackface but it comes from a very different tradition.

NormaTheWife · 07/11/2022 00:38

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:38

See, the costume requested could be in homage to Emilio Zapata, a true revolutionary.

who has a sombrero and a droopy moustache 😂😂😂😂

MangyInseam · 07/11/2022 00:37

Coyoacan · 06/11/2022 22:21

If the intention is to mock and denigrate or take and make money off it, then it’s cultural appropriation. If the intention is to express appreciation and do a homage, then it’s cultural appreciation which is not only acceptable but encouraged

Well there you have me. I still haven't voted as I'm not certain how much a party in suburban England would affect Mexicans, but using your own definition, the intention in this case is obviously mocking, because it's been well over a hundred years since Mexicans have gone around with sombreros and moustaches.

I would argue the opposite, it makes it more like a toga party, or one where people dress up as Socrates, or cowboys.

It's not mocking, it's silly, and that silliness reflects on the wearers, not Romans or Mexicans or cowboys.

One of the problems with CTR is it only has one tool for analysis, and so it thinks everything is a nail. There are only hierarchies of oppression and only race or its analogues.

HRTQueen · 07/11/2022 00:15

I’m not suggesting blackface isn’t more offensive

the point I was making is that some are still of the opinion of I can not see what is so offensive it’s all just fun when it’s been discussed and raised by people from Mexico

it wasn’t that long ago that it was argued on here that blackface isn’t so bad thankfully many people listen and learn from other peoples opinions and change theirs

im sure quite a few on here wore a bindi in the 90’s
as it was fashionable I doubt many of their daughters would be wearing one now

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:51

Arayes · 06/11/2022 23:41

It's all part of the same thing. Blackface, wearing a Native American headdress, dressing up as a stereotypical Mexican, it's all the same bullshit.

images.app.goo.gl/LdHARFbAeVeTMYy77

Not really, blackface is far worse because it’s not cultural, and so it is always offensive. There is no such thing as appreciative blackface is there?

And a Sioux Chieftains bonnet is more than a headdress, which is why it’s always offensive to wear one. It would be offensive for even a Sioux to wear one if they hadn’t earned it.

Can’t really compare either of those to wearing a sombrero 🤨

Arayes · 06/11/2022 23:42

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:41

Must be a grey area then.

Only to an idiot.

Arayes · 06/11/2022 23:41

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:22

Blackface isn’t Cultural though is it? It’s biology, that’s what makes it offensive. Cultural face paint would be like putting blue woad or red ochre on your face.

It's all part of the same thing. Blackface, wearing a Native American headdress, dressing up as a stereotypical Mexican, it's all the same bullshit.

images.app.goo.gl/LdHARFbAeVeTMYy77

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:41

Arayes · 06/11/2022 23:36

ETC

Must be a grey area then.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:38

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:19

Unless it’s celebrating their rich history and the costume is actually that of their freedom fighters when they fought for independence from Spain?

See, the costume requested could be in homage to Emilio Zapata, a true revolutionary.

Mexican-themed NYE party - racist, right?
Mexican-themed NYE party - racist, right?
Arayes · 06/11/2022 23:36

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:21

I was paraphrasing as you well know. I note the definition you posted doesn’t list clothing though? 🤔

ETC

Hagpie · 06/11/2022 23:34

Imagine being so racist you would willingly risk your job in this economy to stereotype people. That’s the thing I don’t get! You’ve heard how people on benefits are going hungry and you want to upset people more than you want to avoid that for you and your family. “Can’t say nothing these days haha” will not pay for Christmas. Your gen z neighbour won’t care you’re too stupid to know why people are upset, they will post you online and I’ve seen Twitter find people within 48 hours! Party on a Saturday and find out getting fired means a 3 month benefit sanction by Friday. Even racists have a sense of self-preservation no???

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:22

Arayes · 06/11/2022 22:14

Christ. "I meat well" isn't an excuse. If you wear blackface but honestly thought you were just "expressing appreciation", would that be just fine?
I think you know it would not.

Blackface isn’t Cultural though is it? It’s biology, that’s what makes it offensive. Cultural face paint would be like putting blue woad or red ochre on your face.

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:21

Arayes · 06/11/2022 22:24

Might help if you actually got the definition right...

Oxford Dictionaries defines cultural appropriation as “the unacknowledged or inappropriate adoption of the customs, practices, ideas, etc. of one people or society by members of another and typically more dominant people or society.

I was paraphrasing as you well know. I note the definition you posted doesn’t list clothing though? 🤔

Discovereads · 06/11/2022 23:19

Coyoacan · 06/11/2022 22:21

If the intention is to mock and denigrate or take and make money off it, then it’s cultural appropriation. If the intention is to express appreciation and do a homage, then it’s cultural appreciation which is not only acceptable but encouraged

Well there you have me. I still haven't voted as I'm not certain how much a party in suburban England would affect Mexicans, but using your own definition, the intention in this case is obviously mocking, because it's been well over a hundred years since Mexicans have gone around with sombreros and moustaches.

Unless it’s celebrating their rich history and the costume is actually that of their freedom fighters when they fought for independence from Spain?

FlamencoDance · 06/11/2022 23:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster’s request.

HRTQueen · 06/11/2022 22:49

There are still areas in the uk where you do not see many if any Asian or black people

im quite sure of someone posted on here I’m invited to the local village party we have been told to wear saris, a bindi and brown up or we have been told it’s black face make sure you black up we are all white so no one will be offended the vast majority would say that is offensive

but let’s face it some still would support it because it’s just for a laugh and it’s not there problem if people take offence to a bit of fun

Arayes · 06/11/2022 22:47

Was your point that you don;t know what the discussion is about and you're terribly confused? Because I definitely proved that.

Scianel · 06/11/2022 22:37

I am, yes. Did your have a point?

You just proved it.